Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 13:48, 2 December 2021

Harry Pollitt has been listed as one of the Social sciences and society good articles under the good article criteria. If you can improve it further, please do so. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can reassess it. Review: October 16, 2021. (Reviewed version).

This article has not yet been rated on Misplaced Pages's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects:

Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details. Politics of the United Kingdom Mid‑importance This article is within the scope of WikiProject Politics of the United Kingdom, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of Politics of the United Kingdom on Misplaced Pages. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.Politics of the United KingdomWikipedia:WikiProject Politics of the United KingdomTemplate:WikiProject Politics of the United KingdomPolitics of the United Kingdom Mid This article has been rated as Mid-importance on the project's importance scale. Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details. Biography This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography, a collaborative effort to create, develop and organize Misplaced Pages's articles about people. All interested editors are invited to join the project and contribute to the discussion. For instructions on how to use this banner, please refer to the documentation.BiographyWikipedia:WikiProject BiographyTemplate:WikiProject Biographybiography Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details. Organized Labour Mid‑importance This article is within the scope of WikiProject Organized Labour, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of articles related to Organized Labour on Misplaced Pages. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.Organized LabourWikipedia:WikiProject Organized LabourTemplate:WikiProject Organized Labourorganized labour Mid This article has been rated as Mid-importance on the project's importance scale. Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details. Socialism Mid‑importance This article is within the scope of WikiProject Socialism, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of socialism on Misplaced Pages. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.SocialismWikipedia:WikiProject SocialismTemplate:WikiProject Socialismsocialism Mid This article has been rated as Mid-importance on the project's importance scale.

Untitled

Sadly, the cited version of the Ballad of Harry Pollitt is so poorly recollected that it does not scan and would be impossible to sing; it is also poorly punctuated. The actual words for the first three stanzas, as sung on numerous occasions, are:

Now, Harry was a Bolshie, and one of Lenin's lads, Till he was foully murdered by reactionary cads, By reactionary cads, by reactionary cads, Till he was foully murdered by reactionary cads.

He came before St Peter, trembling at the knees: 'Oh, may I speak to comrade God, I'm Harry Pollitt, please? I'm Harry Pollitt, please; I'm Harry Pollitt, please; Oh, may I speak to comrade God, I'm Harry Pollitt, please?'

'Very well', said Peter, 'if you're humble and contrite And a friend of Lady Astor, then OK, you'll be alright; OK, you'll be alright; OK, you'll be alright; And a friend of Lady Astor, then OK, you'll be alright'.

Mountdrayton (talk) 23:23, 4 November 2008 (UTC)

Cutting this song. It's obviously WP:UNDUE to give over a whole paragraph to the lyrics of it and there's no evidence of popularity. Moreover its lyrics appear to state that Harry Pollitt was murdered which is obvious untrue. FOARP (talk) 11:31, 15 September 2021 (UTC)

NPOV edits

I've edited the article to be less of a hagiography than it previously was, and closer to a neutral position. Particularly:

• Harry Pollitt supported the war in September 1939 but reversed this position in November 1939.
• There is no evidence that Harry Pollitt was a "strong supporter of the international brigades". He was a communist who lived in the 1930's, but this appears to have been it.
• Harry Pollitt's criticism of the Malayan counter-insurgency appears to have been primarily (according to the sources I can find) from the position that it was a "capitalist war" fought in the interests of rubber-planters. Anyone wanting to say otherwise needs to find sources supporting that position.
• A lot of the changes in CPGB positions appear to have been on direct instructions from Moscow. Pollitt was in direct, secret communication with Moscow.
• Harry Pollitt's electoral performances extend beyond his near-win in 1945, and encompass a lot of other quite heavy defeats. FOARP (talk) 12:39, 23 March 2021 (UTC)

incomplete ref

The three citations of Monty Johnstone added by FOARP are incomplete in the JSTOR source: "1930–194". Spicemix (talk) 20:09, 5 September 2021 (UTC)

Fixed. WP:DIY is a great rule. FOARP (talk) 15:17, 14 September 2021 (UTC)

"Red lives" is not a reliable, independent source

I've deleted the information sourced only to the book "Red Lives" as it appears to have been written by members of the Communist Party of Britain's anniversary team as part of a centenary celebration. This source also attributes the authorship/publication of the book to CPB. WP:RS requires that sourcing been independent of the subject-matter, and this case, the membership of the political party that claims to be the successor to that led by Pollitt is clearly not independent of the subject. Even if it were independent of the subject matter, the publisher does not appear to be a well-established one with a reputation for fact-checking.

Additionally, the following statements based on this source are not supported by other sources. Particularly:

- Pollitt did not appear to play a key role in forming the British battalion. Instead this was set up by Wintringham and others. Our page on the battalion does not even mention Pollitt.

- Pollitt was not a "life-long anti-fascist". He clearly was not anti-fascist during the period of the Hitler-Stalin pact. He was 30 years old before fascism even existed.

- Pollitt was not a "leading trade unionist". He never led a real trade-union.

- Pollitt was not a "revolutionary". He did not lead any revolutions.

- Pollitt does not appear to have consistently opposed imperialism/colonialism when the USSR was doing the imperialism/colonialism. He appears to have written on the subject of India and Malaya so it appears that he did oppose at least some instances of British imperialism/colonialism and this is the most that the sources support at present. Additionally, according to Kevin Morgan's biography of Pollitt, during WW2 Pollitt urged Indian independence leaders like Nehru essentially not to press their claim, so "life-long opponent of British colonialism" probably over-states things.

- Pollitt's financial support for German and Indian communists is not mentioned by other sources and needs better support for inclusion in the article. Particularly, that fact that members of CPGB did these things does not mean it was ordered by Pollitt. FOARP (talk) 15:58, 14 September 2021 (UTC)

With respect, I can't make sense of this gibberish you wrote. Claiming that Pollitt no longer opposed fascism because he took a strategic decision during the Molotov-Ribbentrop paact (there's no such thing as the "Hitler-Stalin pact"), trying to argue that Pollitt no longer believed in independence for British colonies because he recognised Japanese fascism as a threat? I don't know how to argue with this Ben Shapiro type logic. BulgeUwU (talk) 03:48, 25 September 2021 (UTC)

Also why are you deleting any reference to how Lenin influenced his political beliefs. ? BulgeUwU (talk) 03:51, 25 September 2021 (UTC)

If you want to put something in the article it needs to be sourced to a reliable, independent source. This means that CPGB's own publications can't be used for potentially controversial statements as they are obviously not independent of the subject. We definitely should not be saying things when reliable sources actually say the opposite. Particularly:

• Pollitt obviously was not a "life-long anti-fascist" since he was 30 years old before fascism even existed.
• The sources are clear that Pollitt did not publicly support the war against Nazi Germany during the period November 1939-June 1941, and indeed followed publicly CPGB's "imperialist war" line, so it is obviously inaccurate to describe him as a "leading"/"life-long" or whatever anti-Nazi/fascist. He led a minor British party that opposed the war against Nazi Germany for more than a year during WW2.
• Pollitt also wasn't anti-imperialism/colonialism when it was the USSR that was doing it (see his support for the the Czech coup and repression in Eastern Germany/Poland/Hungary) and the sources state that he supported this. He did criticise British imperialism/colonialism and this is the extent of what can be said, though this too was modified by the war.
• As for being particularly inspired by Lenin's ideas, this also requires a source - the sources show him following Stalin in every particular, but those showing him adhering to Lenin are less common, and he was anyway on the far left even before 1917 so was Lenin really his inspiration?

Finally, please note that civility is one of the five pillars of Misplaced Pages. Insulting language is not likely to get you far. FOARP (talk) 07:10, 26 September 2021 (UTC)

Hagiography in the lead section

Tothebarricades.tk and I have both reverted you on this BulgeUwU, could you please stop trying to edit-war hagiographic and un/badly-sourced content into the article, or at least explain why you're doing what you're doing here? To put it simply, an pamphlet written by Pollitt himself about Malaya is not in any meaningful sense a decent source for the statements you are trying to use it for (i.e., that Pollitt "smuggl funds to anti-fascist Germans to resist the Nazis and organis monetary support to Indian republicans" and was "a leading against both fascism and colonialism"). FOARP (talk) 12:34, 23 September 2021 (UTC)

GA Review

This review is transcluded from Talk:Harry Pollitt/GA1. The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.

Reviewer: GhostRiver (talk · contribs) 16:18, 11 October 2021 (UTC)

I will be reviewing this! — GhostRiver 16:18, 11 October 2021 (UTC)

Good Article review progress box Criteria: 1a. prose () 1b. MoS () 2a. ref layout () 2b. cites WP:RS () 2c. no WP:OR () 2d. no WP:CV () 3a. broadness () 3b. focus () 4. neutral () 5. stable () 6a. free or tagged images () 6b. pics relevant () Note: this represents where the article stands relative to the Good Article criteria. Criteria marked are unassessed

Infobox and lede

• Per Template:Infobox person, the "cause of death" parameter should only be included when the cause of death has significance for the subject's notability, e.g. murder or assassination
• Per MOS:INFONAT, use of the "nationality" and "citizenship" templates should be avoided when the country to which the subject belongs can be inferred from the country of birth. Since he was born in England and was an English politician, that he was of English nationality and British citizenship can be easily inferred.
• Link Marjorie Brewer in the infobox and add the year of their marriage using Template:Marriage
• Add links to Nikita Khrushchev, Russian Civil War, Polish–Soviet War, Republican faction (Spanish Civil War), and Spanish Civil War, and include capital letters for proper nouns accordingly.

Early life

Childhood and early career

• "and joined the Communist party" → "before joining the Communist party"
• Link Communist Party of Great Britain
• Delink "died in infancy" per MOS:OVERLINK
• "little sister" → "younger sister"
• "working alongside his mother"
• Comma after "also particularly affected Pollitt"
• "first world war" → "First World War"
• "Pollitt gain experience of leading strikes during the war." Outside of the poor grammar (gained experience of leading strikes), this area needs some more explanation
• Comma after "1917 October Revolution"
• "workers like me...had defeated the boss class" → "workers like me ... had defeated the boss class" per MOS:ELLIPSIS
• Link Sylvia Pankhurst and Workers' Socialist Federation
• "had gain experience of public speaking." → "had gained experience with public speaking"
• Combine last two paragraphs

Communist campaigner

• Comma after "In September 1919"
• "Soviet Russia" → "the Soviet Union"
• "Russo-Polish war" → "Polish–Soviet War"
• Introduce CPGB acronym after first mention of the full title
• "WSF membership, and as such Pollitt was a founding member of the party, and attended their founding "Utility Convention"." → "WSF membership. Pollitt, thus a founding member of the party, attended the CPGB's founding "Utility Convention"."
• "In 1921" → "The following year,"
• "during his visit he shook hands with Vladimir Lenin, he was later to describe the day of his meeting with Lenin as the greatest of his life." → "During his visit, he met and shook hands with Vladimir Lenin, an experience later described as the greatest day of his life."
• Is it Marjorie or Marjory Brewer?
• Link libel
• Glading was the best man at the wedding? If so, that should be the second sentence of the paragraph
• Comma after "During the same visit"
• Link and use full names for first instances of Joseph Stalin and Nikolai Bukharin
• "'United Front' policy" → ""United Front" policy" per MOS:DOUBLE
• "candidate allowing the Conservatives to win" → "candidate, thus allowing the Conservatives to win"
• No comma needed after "This policy of attacking other left-wing organisations"
• WL trade unions

Leadership of the CPGB

Pre-war and the Stalinist terror

• "Stalinist terror" feels somewhat POV – suggest replacement with "Great Purge", since that's detailed more heavily
• "elected him" → "elected Pollitt"
• "On his appointment Stalin told him" → "On his appointment, Stalin told him,"
• "In his public statements, Pollitt was loyal to" → "Pollitt made clear in his public statements his loyalties to"
• Delink Joseph Stalin in the second paragraph
• Comma after "He was a defender of the Moscow Trials"
• Comma after "12 March 1936" per MOS:DATECOMMA
• "himself shortly to vanish and his photographs airbrushed from history by NKVD archivists." → "whose likeness would be retouched out of the photograph following his 1940 fall from favour and subsequent execution"
• "Tom Mann (who was then treasurer of the NUWM)" → "Tom Mann, then-treasurer of the National Unemployed Workers' Movement (NUWM)"
• This section falls into proseline a bit with the two short paragraphs beginning "In 1932" and "In 1935"
• Comma after The Citizen and His Government
• Make Cohen's connection to Pollitt clearer in the caption, and right-align the image per MOS:IMAGELOCATION
• Pipe "conscription in Britain" to Conscription in the United Kingdom
• Comma after "French communist party"

Spanish civil war

• Capitalize "Civil War" in the subhead
• "1936-39" → "1936–39"
• Comma after "During the 1936–39 Spanish Civil War"
• Pipe "Republican" to Republican faction (Spanish Civil War)
• " Pollitt also played a role in approving applications from British volunteers to join the International Brigades, and vetoed George Orwell's application to join them. Pollitt's veto was based on what he believed to be Orwell's political unreliability." → "Pollitt also played a role in approving or vetoing applications from British volunteers to join the International Brigades. One such veto went to George Orwell, who Pollitt believed to be politically unreliable."
• "Pollitt also wrote many of the letter of condolence" → "Pollitt was also tasked with writing letters of condolence"
• Comma after "In August 1937"

Secret communications etc.

• This subhead is very long; how can it be shrunk while retaining the spirit of the content?
• Comma after "From 1933 until November 1939"
• Don't need to repeat "in November 1939" in the second sentence
• 'having difficulties' → "having difficulties" per MOS:DOUBLE
• ""Such treatment as I received in Paris is a scandal"." → ""Such treatment as I received in Paris is a scandal."" per MOS:LQ
• Commas around "including Harry Pollitt"
• "were the subject of" → "were subject to"
• Are there any other examples of these monitoring efforts besides the one?

World War II

• "he welcomed the British declaration" → "Pollitt welcomed the British declaration"
• Comma after "By November 1939"
• Comma after "disavowed his previous pro-war position"
• Comma after "During 1940"
• Comma after "For his part"
• Link and add comma after "Operation Barbarossa"

Post-war defence of Stalinism

• ""millions of lads" who were "led by their Shop Stewards""
• "for the sacking of Ernest Bevin" → "for Ernest Bevin to be fired"
• More proseline concerns with the paragraphs beginning "In 1951" and "In 1952"
• "independence form Moscow" → "independence from Moscow"
• Comma after "and stating that"
• Link death and state funeral of Joseph Stalin
• "neutralist government in Yugoslavia, however when Krushchev visited Belgrade in 1955 CPGB was forced to recant" → "neutralist government in Yugoslavia; however, when Kruschev visited Belgrade in 1955, CPGB was forced to recant"
• "resigned as General Secretary in May 1956 and was appointed CP Chairman, with John Gollan succeeding him as General Secretary." → "resigned as General Secretary in May 1956, with John Gollan succeeding him, and was appointed CP Chairman."
• "was formally made public in June 1956" → "was formally made public the following month"
• Comma after "that hung in his living room"
• "the crisis in the party worse, particularly as CPGB" → "the CPGB crisis worse, particularly as the party"
• "Eastern Block" → "Eastern Bloc"
• Comma after "Soviet invasion of Hungary"
• "Most of its intellectual figures (including Doris Lessing and E. P. Thompson)" → "Most of the party's intellectual figures, including Doris Lessing and E. P. Thompson,"
• Comma after "In 1959"

Electoral record

• "he lost by 8,433 vote, with 38.2% of the vote compared to the Labour candidate who had 61.8% of the vote." → "he lost to the Labour candidate 61.8% to 38.2%, with a margin of 8,433 votes."
• "Labour candidate's 16,733 vote" → "Labour candidate's 16,733 votes"

Death and legacy

• "Harry Pollitt died, aged 69, of a cerebral haemorrhage, after years of worsening health, while returning on the SS Orion from a speaking tour of Australia on 27 June 1960." → "After years of worsening health, Pollitt died at age 69 of a cerebral haemorrhage while returning on the SS Orion from a speaking tour of Australia on 27 June 1960."
• "and scrapped in 1997" → "and was scrapped the next year."
• "(and hence inaccurately refers to him being murdered)" → "and hence inaccurately describes his murder"
• Commas for parentheses around "the official journal of CPGB"

References

• "THE LIMELITERS HARRY POLLITT LYRICS" should be brought down to title case per MOS:ALLCAPS

General comments

• All images are relevant and properly licensed
• Per MOS:IMGSIZE, you should refrain from using a fixed pixel size without very good reason, and the two smaller images especially need to be bumped back up to their normal thumbnail size
• No stability concerns in the revision history
• Earwig turns up a mirror site but no other copyright concerns

Putting on hold to allow nominator to address comments. Feel free to ping me with questions. — GhostRiver 18:55, 11 October 2021 (UTC)

Many thanks for the very detailed review GhostRiver. All edits accepted except Soviet Union for the Polish-Soviet war since the USSR didn't officially exist until 1922, but to clarify this I've added a link to Soviet Russia. Also I need to research the other instances of Pollitt being spied on beyond MI5 infiltrating CPGB, tapping his communications with Moscow, and planting bugs in the CPGB offices. Let me know if what's been done is sufficient for the GA pass - I'll work on other instances of surveillance involving Pollitt specifically (from memory the archives have verbatim conversations he had but only guesses from the author as to how these were obtained). FOARP (talk) 10:50, 15 October 2021 (UTC)

I have made a handful of small MOS fixes to address my remaining comments. I trust you to find other instances of this surveillance. In the meantime, I'll mark this article down as a pass. Thank you for addressing my comments! — GhostRiver 16:23, 16 October 2021 (UTC)

JR Campbell? Or Albert Inkpin?

All the sources I've looked at show that Albert Inkpin was directly succeeded by Pollitt as general secretary, however that's not what the infobox says (or said until I changed it). JR Campbell's article says nothing about him ever having led CPGB and I can't find anything saying he ever led it. Inkpin's article says he was succeeded by Pollitt. So where does the idea that JR Campbell was CPGB leader come from? It seems an odd mistake to have made. FOARP (talk) 14:45, 20 October 2021 (UTC)

Douglas Hyde quote

This quote is OK to use because:

1) It is cited in a reliable source as an explanation of what "revolutionary defeatism" actually mean in the context of CPGB in 1939-41.

2) The description aligns entirely with the way that other sources describe this policy. It is not at all a WP:FRINGE view of CPGB's policies during that time.

3) Douglas Hyde is cited as the source and the reader can easily go and read his article to weigh him as a source.

In contrast we should not be relying on CPGB's publications, including those from Lawrence & Wishart (which CPGB owned), to support statements about Pollitt's acts as they are clearly not independent, and tend to be inaccurate (e.g., the SS Jolly George is typically described in these publications as being bound with armaments for the Whites, when it is very well documented that it was bound with arms for Poland, and they often hype Pollitt's role in blocking the shipment whilst ignoring e.g., Bevan's role). FOARP (talk) 13:37, 2 December 2021 (UTC)

You rightfully point out that publication houses such as Lawrence and Wishart aren't independent, yet you want to back your arguments with statements made by a man whose works were backed by the British secret service? Seems very contradictory. Also a brief look at Douglas Hyde shows that most of these beliefs stem from his miraculous religious conversion which caused him to did a 180 turn on almost everything, and that he was strong supporter of British propaganda which falsly claiming that Malayan revolutionaries were sponsored by foreign governments. He sounds like a nutjob with a proven record of dishonesty at best, and a government spook at worst. I don't think he should be treated as though he were an impartial expert. --BulgeUwU (talk) 13:48, 2 December 2021 (UTC)

• Misplaced Pages good articles
• Social sciences and society good articles
• All unassessed articles
• GA-Class Politics of the United Kingdom articles
• Mid-importance Politics of the United Kingdom articles
• GA-Class biography articles
• WikiProject Biography articles
• GA-Class organized labour articles
• Mid-importance organized labour articles
• WikiProject Organized Labour articles
• GA-Class socialism articles
• Mid-importance socialism articles
• WikiProject Socialism articles