| Revision as of 17:50, 18 October 2007 view sourceNishidani (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users99,541 edits →Criticism← Previous edit | Revision as of 01:32, 19 October 2007 view source Jaakobou (talk | contribs)15,880 edits returning most of the blanketed material (and references) - rewrite (shorten) the letter part.Next edit → | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| '''Gideon Levy''' is an ]i journalist |
'''Gideon Levy''' is an ]i journalist and left wing ]<ref></ref> on ] newspaper, where he's also an editorial board member. He was also a former spokesman for ] between 1978 and 1982.<ref></ref> | ||
| ⚫ | |||
| == Background == | == Background == | ||
| Levy was born in 1955 in ], the son of European immigrants. From 1978 to 1982 he served, together with ] as an aide to ]. Since 1982 he has written for the Israeli daily ], |
Levy was born in 1955 in ], the son of European immigrants. From 1978 to 1982 he served, together with ] as an aide to ]. Since 1982 he has written for the Israeli daily ], in which, from 1986, he has written extensively on 'the occupation and Palestinian life under the occupation'.<ref>{{fr icon}}</ref> In 1996 he was awarded the ] by the ]. | ||
| == Political views == | |||
| ⚫ | A recurring theme of his articles is what he calls the 'moral blindness' of Israeli society to the effects of its acts of ] and ], an attitude which he attributes to a systematic ] of Israel's neighbors. During the ], he joined a distinct minority of Israeli commentators in rejecting the view that it was a ']' in which ] casualties were inevitable and acceptable. | ||
| ===Anti-Zionism=== | |||
| While working in Gaza in early 2007 with a French film crew that was making a documentary about him, Levy declared on camera that the Gazans' plight made him ashamed to be an Israeli.<ref></ref> | |||
| == Criticism == | == Criticism == | ||
| Gideon Levi, never shying away from publicly stating his beliefs, has seen many criticisms for his views. | |||
| In a widely circulated {{fact|date=October 2007}} letter canceling her subscription to ''Haaretz'', Israeli novelist ] cited Levy's articles as one of the reasons for her decision. She described him as heading the newspaper's 'Palestinian department,' and alleged that he blocked publication of negative reports on Palestinians. She took him to task for not knowing Arabic, suggesting that his reliance on interpreters indicated his amateurishness.<ref> {{he icon}}</ref> Haaretz 's publisher expressed bemusement at the outburst. He described his newspaper as Zionist and Levy's reports as simply 'a description of the effect of the Israeli occupation on the lives of the Palestinians in the territories.'<ref> {{he icon}}</ref> Levy has also been accused by the controversial polemicist ], of 'celebrating the victory of Hamas'<ref> Steven Plaut</ref>. Former deputy ], ], suggested that Levy be put under surveillance by the ].<ref> Israel Democracy Institute {{he icon}}</ref> | |||
| For example Professor ] of the ] has called Levy an "] ] ]"<ref></ref> and in an interview with Daniel Ben Simon on ], Ben Simon stated that even Levi's friends from Haaretz, known for it's left wing ideology, consider him an extremist. ], when filling the position of Vice to the ], suggested that he'd be watched by the ] to supervise his reports and stated that Levi is treading on the borderline of someone having anti-Israeli interests.<sup></sup> | |||
| === Irit Linur public letter to Haaretz === | |||
| ], a novelist, radio broadcaster, and fellow Israeli journalist, wrote a letter, which gained wide circulation, explaining the reason for her decision to cancel her long time subscription to ]. In the letter, she attacked Haaretz for not only being radical leftist and ] but that it's anti-Zionism had reached the point where its journalism had become silly and mean. | |||
| In the same letter, Linur included a direct attack on Gideon Levy. Noting that, in a personal conversation, he confessed to her he would not drive 100m to save a settler and that she suspected Levy's reporting have long been tainted by his ideological perspective; as his pro-Palestinian tendencies are the most glaring and consistent part of them. | |||
| Levi's entire career was, she asserted, tainted by 'shoddy work' ({{lang-he|חלטוריזם}}) and amateurish journalism, in that he's an Arab matters reporter with no knowledge of Arabic. She dubbed Levy's reports as narrow minded, shallow, and journalistically and morally impaired, suggesting that Levi and his Haaretz colleague ], not only always hold Israel responsible but they also intentionally refrain from reporting on ] violence among the Palestinians. In addition she charged that the two ''"never seem to meet Palestinians who are ], ], corrupt or who clap at the news of suicide bombings"''.<ref> {{he icon}}</ref> | |||
| Amos Schocken, Haaretz's publisher, responded publicly to Linur's letter, stating that Linur's description of himself, Levi and Hass as 'radical leftist' and his paper as anti-Zionist confused him, as he had never thought of himself as a radical leftist. He stateed his pelief that Haaretz is and always had been a highly Zionist newspaper. Schocken noted that Amira Hass had reported on a Palestinian ] execution, and that she had also written both about Palestinian corruption and celebrations of suicide attacks. | |||
| He added that he believes Gideon Levy’s reports should be read as a description of the effect on the lives of the Palestinians by the Israeli occupation in the territories, and that he found nothing radical or anti-Zionist in Levi's writings.<ref> {{he icon}}</ref> | |||
| ==References== | ==References== | ||
| Line 26: | Line 44: | ||
| ] | ] | ||
| ] | ] | ||
| {{Journalism-stub}} | |||
Revision as of 01:32, 19 October 2007
Gideon Levy is an Israeli journalist and left wing advocant on Haaretz newspaper, where he's also an editorial board member. He was also a former spokesman for Shimon Peres between 1978 and 1982.
Background
Levy was born in 1955 in Tel Aviv, the son of European immigrants. From 1978 to 1982 he served, together with Yossi Beilin as an aide to Shimon Peres. Since 1982 he has written for the Israeli daily Haaretz, in which, from 1986, he has written extensively on 'the occupation and Palestinian life under the occupation'. In 1996 he was awarded the Emil Grunzweig Human Rights Award by the Association for Civil Rights in Israel.
Political views
A recurring theme of his articles is what he calls the 'moral blindness' of Israeli society to the effects of its acts of war and occupation, an attitude which he attributes to a systematic dehumanization of Israel's neighbors. During the 2006 Israel-Lebanon conflict, he joined a distinct minority of Israeli commentators in rejecting the view that it was a 'just war' in which civilian casualties were inevitable and acceptable.
Anti-Zionism
While working in Gaza in early 2007 with a French film crew that was making a documentary about him, Levy declared on camera that the Gazans' plight made him ashamed to be an Israeli.
Criticism
Gideon Levi, never shying away from publicly stating his beliefs, has seen many criticisms for his views.
For example Professor Steven Plaut of the Haifa University has called Levy an "anti-Israel leftist fanatic" and in an interview with Daniel Ben Simon on The Knesset Channel, Ben Simon stated that even Levi's friends from Haaretz, known for it's left wing ideology, consider him an extremist. Gideon Ezra, when filling the position of Vice to the Minister of Internal Security, suggested that he'd be watched by the General Security Services to supervise his reports and stated that Levi is treading on the borderline of someone having anti-Israeli interests.
Irit Linur public letter to Haaretz
Irit Linur, a novelist, radio broadcaster, and fellow Israeli journalist, wrote a letter, which gained wide circulation, explaining the reason for her decision to cancel her long time subscription to Haaretz. In the letter, she attacked Haaretz for not only being radical leftist and anti-Zionist but that it's anti-Zionism had reached the point where its journalism had become silly and mean.
In the same letter, Linur included a direct attack on Gideon Levy. Noting that, in a personal conversation, he confessed to her he would not drive 100m to save a settler and that she suspected Levy's reporting have long been tainted by his ideological perspective; as his pro-Palestinian tendencies are the most glaring and consistent part of them.
Levi's entire career was, she asserted, tainted by 'shoddy work' (Template:Lang-he) and amateurish journalism, in that he's an Arab matters reporter with no knowledge of Arabic. She dubbed Levy's reports as narrow minded, shallow, and journalistically and morally impaired, suggesting that Levi and his Haaretz colleague Amira Hass, not only always hold Israel responsible but they also intentionally refrain from reporting on fratricidal violence among the Palestinians. In addition she charged that the two "never seem to meet Palestinians who are Anti-semitic, Chauvinistic, corrupt or who clap at the news of suicide bombings".
Amos Schocken, Haaretz's publisher, responded publicly to Linur's letter, stating that Linur's description of himself, Levi and Hass as 'radical leftist' and his paper as anti-Zionist confused him, as he had never thought of himself as a radical leftist. He stateed his pelief that Haaretz is and always had been a highly Zionist newspaper. Schocken noted that Amira Hass had reported on a Palestinian extrajudicial execution, and that she had also written both about Palestinian corruption and celebrations of suicide attacks.
He added that he believes Gideon Levy’s reports should be read as a description of the effect on the lives of the Palestinians by the Israeli occupation in the territories, and that he found nothing radical or anti-Zionist in Levi's writings.
References
- Articles on Iran: 'Days of darkness' by Gideon Levi
- The Israel Speakers Center: Gideon Levi's page
- Le Monde September 5, 2006Template:Fr icon
- "'Ha'aretz,' Israel's Liberal Beacon" by Stephen Glazin
- WOOING THE HAMAS, by Prof. Steven Plaut
- News First Class (NFC) Template:He icon
- News First Class (NFC) Template:He icon
External links
- Interview with Levy on PBS (2003)
- Selection of articles by Levy
- Article about Levy in the French daily Le Monde September 2006
- Gideon Levy's Official Lecturer Page