| Revision as of 13:42, 5 October 2008 editJaakobou (talk | contribs)15,880 edits undo non consensus revert. convince the community on the talk page or use WP:RD. -- Talk:I'm_a_PC#MS_scrubbing_the_images_-_in_the_lead← Previous edit | Revision as of 18:04, 5 October 2008 edit undoArcayne (talk | contribs)Rollbackers26,574 edits please see talk. Cited information will NEVER be removed from the article, esp. when removing it represents a pov editNext edit → | ||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
| The $300 million dollar advertising campaign was designed to challenge what critics call Apple's "elitist Mac user vibe" "]" campaign by showing everyday PC users, such as scientists and teachers, noting the virtues of their platform of choice.<ref name="smh.com1"/> It also featured prominent and popular individuals saying "I'm a PC" and had appearances by personalities such as medical doctor and writer ], actor ], photographer ] and singer ]. | The $300 million dollar advertising campaign was designed to challenge what critics call Apple's "elitist Mac user vibe" "]" campaign by showing everyday PC users, such as scientists and teachers, noting the virtues of their platform of choice.<ref name="smh.com1"/> It also featured prominent and popular individuals saying "I'm a PC" and had appearances by personalities such as medical doctor and writer ], actor ], photographer ] and singer ]. | ||
| The campaign has been criticized for having used notable supporters of various Apple products as well as it's commercials being revealed to have been created largely on Apple computers.<ref name="computerworld.com1"/> | The campaign has been criticized for having used notable supporters of various Apple products as well as it's commercials being revealed to have been created largely on Apple computers.<ref name="computerworld.com1"/>, and Microsoft's subsequent ] the Apple-specific "]" from the images of the ads.<ref name="informationweek.com1">, by Dave Methvin, ] blog, September 21, 2008</ref><ref name="smh.com1"/> | ||
| ==Campaign== | ==Campaign== | ||
Revision as of 18:04, 5 October 2008
"I'm a PC" is the title for a television advertising campaign created for Microsoft by ad agency Crispin Porter + Bogusky (CPB) in mid-September, 2008 in order to "revamp" the reputation of the Windows Vista computer operating system. The new series of commercials replace those that featured the pairing of Jerry Seinfeld and Bill Gates, which failed to find an audience.
The $300 million dollar advertising campaign was designed to challenge what critics call Apple's "elitist Mac user vibe" "Mac Vs. PC" campaign by showing everyday PC users, such as scientists and teachers, noting the virtues of their platform of choice. It also featured prominent and popular individuals saying "I'm a PC" and had appearances by personalities such as medical doctor and writer Deepak Chopra, actor Eva Longoria, photographer Geoff Green and singer Pharrell Williams.
The campaign has been criticized for having used notable supporters of various Apple products as well as it's commercials being revealed to have been created largely on Apple computers., and Microsoft's subsequent scrubbing the Apple-specific "metadata" from the images of the ads.
Campaign
The "I'm a PC" advertising campaign was created by the CPB advertising agency and exhibited normal PC users to be found everywhere. It was the second phase of Microsoft's 2008 efforts to displace the ubiquity of Apple's "Mac Vs. PC" ads, which portrayed the Mac as "cool and intuitive" and the PC as "boring and clunky". The Microsoft spots typically opened with an image of Sean Siler, a Microsoft employee claiming "I'm a PC, and I've been made into a stereotype".
The composition was made to be initially resemble that of the Apple campaign, as Siler bears a resemblance to John Hodgman, the "PC" counterpart to Justin Long as a Mac in the Apple commercials. The series of commercials also feature common international users as well as noted celebrities like Deepak Chopra, Geoff Green, Eva Longoria and Pharrell Williams, all noting "I'm a PC".
The advertisements are also interspersed with various non-famous users who proclaim "I'm a PC" from a variety of places and in a number of methods. One such is user "Meaghan", displaying the words written on a whiteboard while underwater in a shark cage. When the shark bumps the cage, Meaghan flips the whiteboard over to display the additional, humorous message, "and I'm afraid". The intent is to demonstrate how PC users are ordinary people, contrasting the "Mac Vs. PC" campaign's negative portrayal of Windows users.
Criticism
Departing from what has been negatively deemed "enigmatic teaser" commercials featuring comedian Jerry Seinfeld and Microsoft founder Bill Gates, the new advertisements directly challenge the "Mac Vs. PC" campaign by Apple in what New York Times reporter Stuart Elliott notes as a typical CPB counterstrike campaign.
Advertising industry insiders noted how the aggressive new effort is reminiscent of the response by Hertz to Avis' "We're Number 2" ad spots with the "Not Exactly" commercials that responded to the challenger brand by pointing out that while Avis was proud of being in second place, Hertz wanted to point out why it was number one.
It was soon revealed that the entire series of "I'm a PC" commercials were created on Apple's Macintosh computers, using the Adobe graphics editing program, Photoshop CS3. Initially discovered by a Flickr user who noted traces of Apple's operating system and Adobe's CS3 graphics program embedded within press-released images of the commercials. Computerworld magazine concurs, noting that when the file properties of those images, made available on the Microsoft press site, are examined, the designation "Adobe Photoshop C3 Macintosh" can be seen. After the discovery began circulating, Microsoft responded overnight by digitally scrubbing the Apple-related metadata from the images.
In an official press release, Microsoft stated "As is common in almost all campaign workflow, agencies and production houses use a wide variety of software and hardware to create, edit and distribute content, including both Macs and PCs." John Paczkowski of Digital Daily notes that "(t)he irony is enough to make your head explode. The latest evolution of Microsoft’s (MSFT) new ad campaign–the one designed to seize back control of the Windows PC image that Apple has so mercilessly tarred and feathered–wasn’t even made on a PC."
Though considering the statement a "non-denial denial", Tim Beyers of Motley Fool notes that the new ads appear to have initially achieved its goals. Conversely, Jack Loftus of Gizmodo noted that if Apple were smart, they would have another Hodgman/Long spot making fun of this oversight "produced and in the can yesterday". Zach Epstein of BoyGenius Report also points out that the irony of the discovery is detrimental to Microsoft's efforts.
Further criticism notes the choice of spokespeople used in the "I'm a PC" campaign. Jerry Seinfeld, Deepak Chopra, Eva Longoria and Pharrell Williams are all notably vocal Macintosh owners and fans. Seinfeld's eponymous character from Seinfeld uses a Macintosh, and Longoria personally uses a MacBook Pro. Chopra uses one as well, and Williams uses a Macintosh in his recording studio.
References
- Carlson, Nicholas (19 Sept. 2008). "Microsoft's new "I'm a PC" commercials want you to "Think Different"". Vallywag. Retrieved 2008-09-30.
{{cite web}}: Check|authorlink=value (help); Check date values in:|date=(help); Cite has empty unknown parameter:|coauthors=(help); External link in|authorlink= - ^ Microsoft's 'I'm a PC' ad images made on Macs, By Gregg Keizer, Computerworld (Republished on PC World, Spetember 20, 2008)
- ^ 'I'm a PC' made on a Mac, by Asher Moses, The Sydney Morning Herald, September 24, 2008 (duplicate on thevine.com.au)
- Were images in Microsoft's 'I'm a PC' campaign made with Macs?, by Jacqueline Emigh, Betanews, September 22, 2008
- Microsoft Says: No Seinfeld For You!, by Mark Hopkins (mashable.com)
- ^ 'I'm A PC' Made On A Mac, by Dave Methvin, InformationWeek blog, September 21, 2008
- So What's Up With That New 'I'm a PC' Guy, Anyway?, By Mark Wilson, Gizmodo, September 19, 2008
- Magazine: Microsoft ad uses Mac software, United Press International
- 'I'm a PC' ad pictures made on a Mac, (MacNN.com)
- ^ Echoing the Campaign of a Rival, Microsoft Aims to Redefine ‘I’m a PC’, by Stuart Elliott, The New York Times, September 17, 2008
- Eva Longoria, John Hodgman clone lead Seinfeld replacements at Microsoft, (valleywag.com)
- How to ... punch above your weight, By Vincent Heeringa, Idealog, Originally published in Idealog #6, page 110
- ^ I'm a PC, Made on a Mac, by Tim Beyers, Motley Fool, September 22, 2008
- Microsoft’s ‘I’m a PC’ Ads Created On Macs, by Daniel Eran Dilger (RoughlyDrafted.com), September 19th, 2008
- ^ Microsoft 'I'm a PC' Ads Were Created Using a Mac, Gizmodo
- Mac-Loving Seinfeld Endorsing Microsoft For $10 Million, (gawker.com)
- "I'm a PC", but use a Mac, by Chris Tangora (macmod.com), September 20, 2008
- New PC Commercial Parodies Mac Commercial Making Fun of PC, by David Hauslaib (jossip.com)
External links
- Microsoft's PressPass gallery, displaying the images
- Flickr page noting the Apple OS and Adobe CS3 metadata