Misplaced Pages

Book of Joshua: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 19:24, 7 October 2010 view sourceJohn J. Bulten (talk | contribs)12,763 editsm Historicity of the conquest of Canaan: OK (fixing ref), but rolling my eyes← Previous edit Revision as of 01:06, 8 October 2010 view source PiCo (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers44,429 edits Authorship: this makes for a more comprehensive coverage of authorshipNext edit →
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 7: Line 7:


==Authorship== ==Authorship==
While the book is ascribed by tradition dating from the Babylonian Talmud (] 15a) to Joshua, it never names its author. Most scholars in the second half of the 20th century have viewed the book as part of the series which includes ], ], ] and ], making up the "Deuteronomistic History" of Israel.<REF> p.1</REF> In the view of ], who articulated the thoery in 1943, the partition of the History into books such as Joshua was a later development.<REF> p.1</REF> The prevailing view in modern scholarship is that the author, or authors, of the History worked in the time of ] or the ] or both.<REF> p.159</REF> Nevertheless, the Deuteronomistic hypothesis has always encountered difficulties with Joshua, and large proportions of its text are ascribed to a post-Exilic ] revision.<REF> p.159</REF> There are also signs of a modern trend towards stressing the independent development of the books that make up the series, which allows for the preservation within of ancient material within a "Joshua" tradition with its own special (non-Deuteronomistic) themes and concerns.<REF> p.160</REF>
While the book is ascribed by tradition dating from the Babylonian Talmud (] 15a) to Joshua, it never names its author. "Some recent studies possibly point to the period of ]".<REF></REF>


==Structure== ==Structure==
Line 13: Line 13:


# The history of the conquest of the land (1-12). # The history of the conquest of the land (1-12).
# The allotment of the land to the different tribes, with the appointment of cities of refuge, the provision for the Levites (13-22), and the dismissal of the eastern tribes to their homes. This section has been compared to the ] of the ] (though significantly shorter and not the work of one man). # The allotment of the land to the different tribes, with the appointment of cities of refuge, the provision for the Levites (13-22), and the dismissal of the eastern tribes to their homes.
# The farewell addresses of Joshua, with an account of his death (23, 24). # The farewell addresses of Joshua, with an account of his death (23, 24).


Line 43: Line 43:
==Historicity of the conquest of Canaan== ==Historicity of the conquest of Canaan==
{{seealso|Battle of Jericho}} {{seealso|Battle of Jericho}}
Archaeologist Ann Killebrew says: "Recent research on the emergence of Israel points unequivocally to the conclusion that biblical Israel's roots lie in the final century of Bronze Age Canaan."<ref>, p. 149.</ref> The first record of the name Israel occurs in the ], erected for Egyptian Pharaoh ] c. 1209 BCE, "Israel is laid waste and his seed is not"<ref>, in , p. 91.</ref><ref>{{cite book|last=McDermott|first=John J.|title=What are they saying about the formation of Israel?|year=1998|publisher=Paulist Press|isbn=0-8091-3838-7|url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=_XWTW-21NMwC&pg=PA17&dq=merneptah+stele+first+written&hl=en&ei=IxWjTOK0NaqU4gbN7dy7Aw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CC8Q6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=merneptah%20stele%20first%20written&f=false|page=17}}</ref> (the ] narratives are ascribed to the eras they depict by '']'' 14b ff. (]) and early ]). This Israel is widely identified as a people already settled at that time in the central highlands of Palestine.<ref></ref> Some 300 new villages appeared in the highland area, mostly in the northern part, in Iron Age I (1200-1000 BCE), their population growing from 20,000 in the 12th century to double that number in the 11th.<ref></ref> One interesting feature of these villages is an absence of pig bones,<REF>p.157</REF> and collared-rim jars and four-room houses have been given serious consideration as being distinctively Israelite, but have also been found unusable for isolating particular sites, areas or periods as "Israelite".<REF> p.72</REF> Archaeologist Ann Killebrew says: "Recent research on the emergence of Israel points unequivocally to the conclusion that biblical Israel's roots lie in the final century of Bronze Age Canaan."<ref>, p. 149.</ref> The first record of the name Israel occurs in the ], erected for Egyptian Pharaoh ] c. 1209 BCE, "Israel is laid waste and his seed is not"<ref>, in , p. 91.</ref><ref>{{cite book|last=McDermott|first=John J.|title=What are they saying about the formation of Israel?|year=1998|publisher=Paulist Press|isbn=0-8091-3838-7|url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=_XWTW-21NMwC&pg=PA17&dq=merneptah+stele+first+written&hl=en&ei=IxWjTOK0NaqU4gbN7dy7Aw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CC8Q6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=merneptah%20stele%20first%20written&f=false|page=17}}</ref> (the ] narratives are ascribed to the eras they depict by '']'' 14b ff. (]) and early ]). This Israel is widely identified as a people already settled at that time in the central highlands of Palestine.<ref></ref> Some 300 new villages appeared in the highland area, mostly in the northern part, in Iron Age I (1200-1000 BCE), their population growing from 20,000 in the 12th century to double that number in the 11th.<ref></ref> One interesting feature of these villages is an absence of pig bones, but the reasons behind this are unclear.<REF>p.157</REF>


Many scholars are tempted to attribute widespread Late Bronze city destructions west of the Jordan to invading Hebrews. Miller and Hayes list three problems with this use of archaeological evidence: "it is not clear ... that these cities were destroyed simultaneously", or by a single enemy, or by military action; Miller and Hayes also believe that with a few exceptions (Hazor, Lachish), the cities where destructions are indicated are not the ones the Bible associates with Joshua's conquest; and they believe that those cities that are associated with the Biblical account usually have little or no sign of even being occupied or destroyed at the time.<REF> pp.71-72</REF> Many scholars are tempted to attribute widespread Late Bronze city destructions west of the Jordan to invading Hebrews. Miller and Hayes list three problems with this use of archaeological evidence: "it is not clear ... that these cities were destroyed simultaneously", or by a single enemy, or by military action; Miller and Hayes also believe that with a few exceptions (Hazor, Lachish), the cities where destructions are indicated are not the ones the Bible associates with Joshua's conquest; and they believe that those cities that are associated with the Biblical account usually have little or no sign of even being occupied or destroyed at the time.<REF> pp.71-72</REF>

Revision as of 01:06, 8 October 2010

This article is about the canonical book of the Hebrew Bible. For information on the Samaritan version, see Book of Joshua (Samaritan).
Joshua 1:1 as recorded in the Aleppo Codex
Tanakh (Judaism)
Torah (Instruction)
GenesisBereshit
ExodusShemot
LeviticusWayiqra
NumbersBemidbar
DeuteronomyDevarim
Nevi'im (Prophets)
Former
JoshuaYehoshua
JudgesShofetim
SamuelShemuel
KingsMelakhim
Latter
IsaiahYeshayahu
JeremiahYirmeyahu
EzekielYekhezqel
Minor
Ketuvim (Writings)
Poetic
PsalmsTehillim
ProverbsMishlei
JobIyov
Five Megillot (Scrolls)
Song of SongsShir Hashirim
RuthRut
LamentationsEikhah
EcclesiastesQohelet
EstherEster
Historical
DanielDaniyyel
Ezra–NehemiahEzra
ChroniclesDivre Hayyamim
Old Testament (Christianity)
Pentateuch
Historical
Wisdom
Prophetic
Major prophets
Minor prophets
Deuterocanonical
Orthodox only
Orthodox Tewahedo
Bible portal

Template:Books of the Old Testament

The Book of Joshua (Template:Lang-he) is the sixth book in the Hebrew Bible and the first in the Former (or First) Prophets, covering the history of Israel from the possession of the Promised Land to the Babylonian Captivity. It tells the story of the conquest of the land of Canaan from the death of Moses to that of Joshua.

Authorship

While the book is ascribed by tradition dating from the Babylonian Talmud (Bava Batra 15a) to Joshua, it never names its author. Most scholars in the second half of the 20th century have viewed the book as part of the series which includes Deuteronomy, Judges, Samuel and Kings, making up the "Deuteronomistic History" of Israel. In the view of Martin Noth, who articulated the thoery in 1943, the partition of the History into books such as Joshua was a later development. The prevailing view in modern scholarship is that the author, or authors, of the History worked in the time of Josiah or the Babylonian exile or both. Nevertheless, the Deuteronomistic hypothesis has always encountered difficulties with Joshua, and large proportions of its text are ascribed to a post-Exilic Priestly revision. There are also signs of a modern trend towards stressing the independent development of the books that make up the series, which allows for the preservation within of ancient material within a "Joshua" tradition with its own special (non-Deuteronomistic) themes and concerns.

Structure

The book essentially consists of three parts:

  1. The history of the conquest of the land (1-12).
  2. The allotment of the land to the different tribes, with the appointment of cities of refuge, the provision for the Levites (13-22), and the dismissal of the eastern tribes to their homes.
  3. The farewell addresses of Joshua, with an account of his death (23, 24).

Summary of contents

Moses sends out twelve spies from Shittim to explore the city of Jericho. when they return only Caleb and Joshua give good reports, the other ten say the opposite. The Israelites disobeyed God and choose to listen to the ten other spies. They all took rocks and began to stone Caleb and Joshua. For Israel's punishment God made the whole generation who were born in Egypt wander in the wilderness for 40 years. Those born after the Exodus from Egypt could live and go into the Promised Land. The unfaithful Israelites who had come from Egypt would die before entering the Promised Land.

After Moses' death, Joshua, by virtue of his previous appointment as Moses' successor, received from God the command to cross the Jordan River. In execution of this order Joshua issues the requisite instructions to the stewards of the people for the crossing of the Jordan; and he reminds the Reubenites, Gadites, and the half of Manasseh of their pledge given to Moses to help their brethren.

Having re-iterated the duty to follow the mitzvah, Joshua orders the Israelites to set forth, and they leave Shittim. When they reach the Jordan River, Joshua states that the Ark will miraculously cross the Jordan. As soon as the Ark reaches the river, a miracle duly occurs, and the river stops flowing and rapidly dries up, so the priests carrying it halt, allowing the rest of the Israelites to cross as well. In commemoration of the event, Joshua orders two monuments to be erected: one in the river-bed; the other on the western bank, where the Israelites encamp.

Joshua and the Israelites crossing the Jordan

The Israelites are circumcised at Gibeath-Haaraloth (translating as hill of foreskins). Those who had been born in the desert had not been circumcised. The people are therefore circumcised, and the area is named Gilgal in memory (Gilgal sounds like Gallothi - I have removed, but is more likely to translate as circle of standing stones).

The Israelites then commence with the Battle of Jericho. Placing Jericho under siege, the Israelites circle it once a day for six days, and on the seventh make seven circuits, each time loudly blowing horns and shouting. On the final circuit, the walls cave in, and the inhabitants, except Rahab and her family, are slaughtered. A curse is pronounced against rebuilding the city.

Ai is surveyed and pronounced weak, so the Israelite army sends only a small group to attack them. However they are defeated, causing Joshua and the people to despair. But God announces that the people have sinned: someone has stolen some of the spoils from Jericho which are meant to be for the temple. Consequently the Israelites set out to discover the sinner by casting lots, whittling them down first by tribe (Judah), then clan (Zarhites), then sept (Zabdi), then finally detecting it as Achan. Achan admits having taken a costly Babylonian garment, besides silver and gold, and his confession is verified by the finding of the treasure buried in his tent, so Achan is taken into the valley of Achor, where he and his household are stoned and burned to death.

Afterwards, 30,000 Israelites set an ambush of Ai overnight, and in the morning another Israelite force attack and then feign retreat, drawing the forces of Ai far away from the city. When Joshua raises his lance, the 30,000 men preparing the ambush strike, while Joshua starts attacking again, thus surrounding Ai's forces. The entire city is burned and its inhabitants slaughtered. The king of Ai, however, is taken alive and delivered to Joshua. He is then impaled on a stake for public display before being buried outside the city gates, following Hebrew guidelines for the guilty. (see Deuteronomy 21.23).

Joshua erects an altar on Mount Ebal and makes offerings upon it and carves into it the law of Moses. The people are arranged into two sections, with one facing Ebal and the other facing Gerizim. They each read the blessings and curses specified in Deuteronomy as appropriate.

The Hivites fool the Israelites into thinking them foreigners and gain a non-aggression treaty from the Israelites. Even after its detection, the fraud is not abrogated, though the Hivites are punished by being treated as the lowest social class (referred to via the Hebrew idiom "hewers of wood and drawers of water for the altar of Yhwh").

An 1883 depiction of Joshua commanding the sun to stand still in the sky.

Adonizedek, king of Jerusalem, brings about an alliance of the "five kings of the Amorites" (the kings of Hebron, Jarmuth, Lachish, and Eglon, and himself), and they besiege the Hivites in Gibeon, whom they perceive as traitors. The Hivites implore Joshua's help, and so he launches a surprise attack following a night march, causing the Amorites to panic and flee as far as Beth-horon. A poem is quoted from the Book of Jasher, which states that the sun stood still at Gibeon, and the moon in the valley of Ajalon, in order that Joshua could complete the battle. Despite the five kings' cowardly attempt at avoiding retribution by hiding inside a cave, they are discovered and trapped there until their army has been completely obliterated. Afterwards, the kings are brought to Joshua, who first humiliates them, then orders their death and has them impaled for public display. At sunset, the bodies are thrown back into the cave from which they hid, and the entrance sealed.

Jabin, king of Hazor, his army, and his vassals, rendezvous at Merom. Joshua, however, executes a swift attack and is able to defeat them. Pursuing them to a great distance, he hamstrings their horses, burns their chariots, captures Hazor, slaughters its inhabitants, and burns it to the ground. Lesser royal residences are also captured and their inhabitants slaughtered, although the cities on the hill remain.

Historicity of the conquest of Canaan

See also: Battle of Jericho

Archaeologist Ann Killebrew says: "Recent research on the emergence of Israel points unequivocally to the conclusion that biblical Israel's roots lie in the final century of Bronze Age Canaan." The first record of the name Israel occurs in the Merneptah stele, erected for Egyptian Pharaoh Merneptah c. 1209 BCE, "Israel is laid waste and his seed is not" (the Bible narratives are ascribed to the eras they depict by Bava Batra 14b ff. (Talmud) and early Church Fathers). This Israel is widely identified as a people already settled at that time in the central highlands of Palestine. Some 300 new villages appeared in the highland area, mostly in the northern part, in Iron Age I (1200-1000 BCE), their population growing from 20,000 in the 12th century to double that number in the 11th. One interesting feature of these villages is an absence of pig bones, but the reasons behind this are unclear.

Many scholars are tempted to attribute widespread Late Bronze city destructions west of the Jordan to invading Hebrews. Miller and Hayes list three problems with this use of archaeological evidence: "it is not clear ... that these cities were destroyed simultaneously", or by a single enemy, or by military action; Miller and Hayes also believe that with a few exceptions (Hazor, Lachish), the cities where destructions are indicated are not the ones the Bible associates with Joshua's conquest; and they believe that those cities that are associated with the Biblical account usually have little or no sign of even being occupied or destroyed at the time.

Ethical issues

One difficulty arises out of the numerous commands from God recorded in the book for the Israelites to destroy people and animals in the land that they are occupying. This is related to the concept of cherem (set apart for God, or set under a ban) in which entire cities (such as Jericho; see Joshua 6:17-19) are recorded as commanded to be devoted to destruction.

Some theologians (including many adherents of liberal theology) see this as an ethically unjustifiable order to commit genocide, which is inconsistent with the overall view in the Hebrew and Christian scriptures of God as a loving, compassionate Creator. They see it as a theological polemic, with the majority of events invented during or after the Babylonian captivity, to encourage faithfulness to the Jewish creed at a time when it was being threatened. For instance, Morton says that Joshua "should be understood as a rite of ancient peoples (Israel among them) whereby within the context of their times, they attempted to please their God (or the gods)".

Others, including many conservative theologians who see the book as a historically accurate account written during or soon after the life of Joshua, explain the cruelty of the Israelites as God's way of making an example of nations that engaged in abhorrent practices. Although the book gives no explicit justification for the commands to kill, Deuteronomy 9:4 indicates that this is on account of the "wickedness of those nations". Some theologians have pointed to evidence of practices such as child sacrifice, although others argue that it may have been polemic invented at a later date in order to justify the act of extermination. Hence they believe that the message of Joshua was intended not only for the surrounding nations, but for the Israelites as well (e.g. the stoning of Achan due to his transgression of the cherem).

A Christian alternative viewpoint is to cite progressive revelation in which God reveals himself partially to Joshua and the Jews, but (in due time) fully through Jesus Christ. Proponents of this view argue that the description of war in the book of Joshua was culturally conditioned. For instance, Chapman suggests that the accounts of war and genocide are "the gradual process by which God works in the history of a particular people for whom war is an essential part of religion and culture". The Mennonite scholar John Howard Yoder suggests that the concept of cherem was unique in relation to the morality of the time not in its violence, but in ensuring that "war does not become a source of immediate enrichment through plunder", and hence was the beginning of a trajectory that would lead ultimately to the teaching of nonviolence. The Mesha Stele, however, contains a statement by King Mesha of Moab that he captured the town of Nebo and killed all seven thousand people there, "for I had devoted them to destruction for (the god) Ashtar-Chemosh." This suggests that the concept of herem was not unique to Israel.

See also

Notes

Books of Nevi'im
 
Former Prophets
Latter Prophets (major)
Latter Prophets (Twelve minor)
Hebrew Bible
  1. Knoppers, Gary, and McConville, J. Gordon, "Reconsidering Israel and Judah: recent studies on the Deuteronomistic history" (Eisenbrauns, 2000) p.1
  2. Knoppers, Gary, and McConville, J. Gordon, "Reconsidering Israel and Judah: recent studies on the Deuteronomistic history" (Eisenbrauns, 2000) p.1
  3. Barton, John, and Muddiman, John (eds) "The Oxford Bible commentary" (Oxford University Press, 2001) p.159
  4. Barton, John, and Muddiman, John (eds) "The Oxford Bible commentary" (Oxford University Press, 2001) p.159
  5. Barton, John, and Muddiman, John (eds) "The Oxford Bible commentary" (Oxford University Press, 2001) p.160
  6. Killebrew, Ann E., "Biblical Peoples and Ethnicity: An Archaeological Study of Egyptians, Canaanites, and Early Israel, 1300-1100 BCE" (Society of Biblical Literature, 2005), p. 149.
  7. Lawrence E. Stager, Forging an Identity: The Emergence of Ancient Israel, in Coogan, Michael D. (ed), "The Oxford History of the Biblical World (Oxford University Press, 1998), p. 91.
  8. McDermott, John J. (1998). What are they saying about the formation of Israel?. Paulist Press. p. 17. ISBN 0-8091-3838-7.
  9. Niels Peter Lemche, "The Israelites in History and Tradition" (Westminster John Knox, 1998) pp. 38.
  10. Paula McNutt, "Reconstructing the Society of Ancient Israel" pp. 69–70.
  11. Killebrew, Ann E., "Biblical Peoples and Ethnicity: An Archaeological Study of Egyptians, Canaanites, and Early Israel, 1300-1100 BCE" (Society of Biblical Literature, 2005)p.157
  12. Miller, James Maxwell, and Hayes, John Haralson, "A history of ancient Israel and Judah" (Westminster John Knox, 1986) pp.71-72
  13. Morton, pp. 324-325
  14. John, Day (2002). Yahweh and the gods and goddesses of Canaan. Sheffield Academic Press. ISBN 1-85075-986-3.
  15. Dodd, C.H. (1952). The authority of the bible. Nisbet & Co.
  16. Colin Chapman, "Holy War", in Zondervan Handbook to the Bible (1999), ed. David Alexander
  17. Yoder, John Howard. (1971). "If Abraham Is Our Father." In The Original Revolution: Essays on Christian Pacifism. Wipf and Stock.
  18. James B. Pritchard (ed.), Ancient Near Eastern Texts Relating to the Old Testament (3rd ed., 1969), 320.

References

  • Morton, William H. Joshua. The Broadman Bible Commentary, Vol. 2. Ed. Clifton J. Allen, et al. Nashville: Broadman Press, 1970.
  • Halley, Henry H. Halley's Bible Handbook. Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House, 1927, 1965.
  • Mazar, Amihai. The Archaeology of the land of the Bible. New York: Doubleday, 1990.
  • Anati, Emmanuel. The Time of Exodus In the Light of Archaeological Testimony, Epigraphy and Palaeoclimate. Har Karkom, a guide to major sites, Capo di Ponte , 2005.

External links

Translations

Public Domain This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domainEaston, Matthew George (1897). Easton's Bible Dictionary (New and revised ed.). T. Nelson and Sons. {{cite encyclopedia}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)  This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domainSinger, Isidore; et al., eds. (1901–1906). The Jewish Encyclopedia. New York: Funk & Wagnalls. {{cite encyclopedia}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)

Preceded byDeuteronomy Hebrew Bible Followed byJudges
Christian Old Testament
Categories: