| Revision as of 04:15, 1 February 2015 view sourceIjonTichyIjonTichy (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users7,586 edits →Criticism of media coverage of the film: Allegations of objectifying the Iraqi people← Previous edit |
Latest revision as of 12:11, 12 June 2017 view source Primefac (talk | contribs)Edit filter managers, Autopatrolled, Bureaucrats, Checkusers, Oversighters, Administrators209,782 edits replace deprecated template |
| (36 intermediate revisions by 12 users not shown) |
| Line 1: |
Line 1: |
|
|
#REDIRECT ] |
|
<!-- Please do not remove or change this AfD message until the issue is settled --> |
|
|
{{Article for deletion/dated|page=American Sniper (film) controversies|timestamp=20150128202347|year=2015|month=January|day=28|substed=yes|help=off}} |
|
|
<!-- For administrator use only: {{Old AfD multi|page=American Sniper (film) controversies|date=28 January 2015|result='''keep'''}} --> |
|
|
<!-- End of AfD message, feel free to edit beyond this point --> |
|
|
The 2014 film '']'', directed by Clint Eastwood, has been criticized by ex-soldiers, film directors, actors and critics, academics, investigative journalists, authors, media figures, political figures, and watchdog groups for its alleged inaccuracies and misleading portrayal of US Navy Seal ]. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
{{rcat shell|{{r to section}}}} |
|
The controversies involve political, historical, social, cultural, philosophical, moral, religious, racial/ethnic and other aspects of society. |
|
|
|
|
|
==Criticism of political, historical, social, cultural, philosophical, moral, religious, and racial aspects of the film== |
|
|
|
|
|
The ] said that the release of the movie coincided with increased threats against Arabs and Muslims.<ref>http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/01/24/american-sniper-anti-muslim-threats_n_6537950.html</ref> It has also accused Eastwood of dishonestly linking the ] with Iraq.<ref>http://www.vox.com/2015/1/21/7641189/american-sniper-history</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
] tweeted, in response to ''American Sniper'', "My uncle killed by sniper in WW2. We were taught snipers were cowards. Will shoot you in the back. Snipers aren't heroes. And invaders are worse." {{sic}}<ref> (2015-01-25), '']''. ""Here's the truth they can't or won't report: I'm the one who has supported these troops - much more than the bloviators on Fox News," Moore writes."</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
] criticized "what the worship of a movie about a cold-blooded killer says about the American people."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.alternet.org/watch-chomsky-blasts-american-sniper-and-media-glorifies-it?akid=12720.215495.Cq35--&rd=1&src=newsletter1030911&t=3|title=WATCH: Chomsky Blasts 'American Sniper' and the Media that Glorifies It|work=Alternet}}</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
] of '']'' wrote: "In his memoir, Kyle reportedly described killing as “fun”, something he “loved”; he was unwavering in his belief that everyone he shot was a “bad guy”. “I hate the damn savages,” he wrote. “I couldn’t give a flying fuck about the Iraqis.”" and: "If he (Eastwood), intentionally or not, makes a hero out of Kyle – who, bare minimum, was a racist who took pleasure in dehumanising and killing brown people – is he responsible for validating racism, murder, and dehumanisation? Is he a propagandist if people use his work as propaganda?"<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/06/real-american-sniper-hate-filled-killer-why-patriots-calling-hero-chris-kyle |title=The real American Sniper was a hate-filled killer. Why are simplistic patriots treating him as a hero? |last=West |first=Lindy |publisher=The Guardian |date=6 Jan 2015 |accessdate=28 Jan 2015}}</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
Zack Beauchamp of ] felt that the film's greatest sin was condescending "to Americans and American troops by acting as if we could not possibly handle moral ambiguity about America's mission in Iraq. But it did, and that is a disservice not just to film's viewers, but to the millions of Americans who were affected by the war and deserve to have that story told honestly."<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.vox.com/2015/1/21/7641189/american-sniper-history |title=American Sniper is a dishonest whitewash of the Iraq war |last=Beauchamp |first=Zack |publisher=Vox |date=21 Jan 2015 |accessdate=28 Jan 2015}}</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
John Wight, writing for '']'', strongly criticized the film and its reception to date. He said, "The moral depravity into which the US is sinking is shown by American Sniper glorifying the exploits of a racist killer receiving six Oscar nominations, whereas ] depicting ]'s struggle against racism has been largely ignored."<ref>. John Wight, 23 January 2015. ] Op Edge.</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
] wrote that "''Sniper'' is a movie whose politics are so ludicrous and idiotic that under normal circumstances it would be beneath criticism" and that "Eastwood plays for cheap applause and goes super-dumb even by Hollywood standards."<ref> (2015-01-23), '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
], in an article titled "Killing Ragheads for Jesus", wrote that "''American Sniper'' lionizes the most despicable aspects of U.S. society—the gun culture, the blind adoration of the military, the belief that we have an innate right as a 'Christian' nation to exterminate the 'lesser breeds' of the earth, a grotesque hypermasculinity that banishes compassion and pity, a denial of inconvenient facts and historical truth, and a belittling of critical thinking and artistic expression. Many Americans, especially white Americans trapped in a stagnant economy and a dysfunctional political system, yearn for the supposed moral renewal and rigid, militarized control the movie venerates."<ref>"", '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
] of ] attacked ''American Sniper''{{'}}s inaccuracies, arguing both the film and Kyle's reputation "are all built on a set of half-truths, myths and outright lies."<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.salon.com/2015/01/23/7_enormous_lies_american_sniper_is_telling_america_partner/ |title=7 heinous lies 'American Sniper' is telling America |last=Jilani |first=Zaid |publisher=Salon |date=23 Jan 2015 |accessdate=25 Jan 2015}}</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
] said the film ''American Sniper'' is "filled with lies and distortion from start to finish," makes a hero out of "a pathological liar and a mass killer" and promotes falsehoods about Navy SEAL Chris Kyle along with the US invasion and occupation of Iraq. Blumenthal said the film is a "bogus whitewash of the atrocities committed by American troops in Iraq."<ref>, '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
] was accused of criticizing the film when he tweeted that the film reminded him of the Nazi sniper propaganda film showing in the third act of ]'s 2009 film '']''. He later stated that he was not criticizing the film but making a comparison.<ref></ref><ref>. "American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee writes to Bradley Cooper and Clint Eastwood requesting action as threat complaints triple."</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
Sophia A. McClennen, a Professor of International Affairs and Comparative Literature at the Pennsylvania State University, said there are "insanities and fantasies at the heart of" ''American Sniper'' and that "despite the fact that the film depicts Kyle as a hero and a martyr, the real American sniper was heartless and cruel. Rather than struggle with moral dilemmas as we see in the film, the actual man had no such hesitation and no such conscience. But to focus on ''American Sniper''{{'}}s depiction of Kyle is to miss the larger problems of the film. In addition to sugarcoating Kyle, the film suffers from major myopia — from a complete inability to see the larger picture. And that is why criticism of the film has to look at its director, Clint Eastwood, and the troubling ways he represents a dark, disturbing feature of the GOP mind-set."<ref></ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
Ross Caputi, a former marine who participated in the ], criticized ''American Sniper'', writing that "What American Sniper offers us — more than a heart-wrenching tale about Chris Kyle's struggle to be a soldier, a husband, and a father; more than an action packed story about America's most lethal sniper — is an exposure of the often hidden side of American war culture. The criminality that has characterized American military engagements since the ], and most recently in Iraq and Afghanistan, is hardly noticeable in this film."<ref></ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
Comedian ] stated "He's a psychopath patriot, and we love him," and "'I hate the damn savages' doesn't seem like a very Christian thing to say," comparing Kyle disfavourably to anti-war general ].<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/01/24/bill-maher-blasts-american-sniper-calls-chris-kyle-a-psychopath-patriot.html |title=Bill Maher Blasts ‘American Sniper,’ calls Chris Kyle a ‘psychopath patriot’ |last=Stern |first=Marlow |publisher= The Daily Beast |date=24 Jan 2015 |accessdate=28 Jan 2015}}</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
Journalist Eamon Murphy wrote on ] that "it's hard to know, when watching Eastwood's Iraq War, where doltish film conventions end and rotten politics begins. (] was an awful lot like an idiotic blockbuster in the first place.) The bits of military exposition are outrageously at odds with the facts, but they also sound so hokey it seems almost stupid to object by citing reality."<ref>, '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
] wrote the film "ignores history" and that the film makes no attempt to provide "anything beyond Kyle’s limited comprehension of what was happening." He added that the movie is "utterly false to the experience of millions of Iraqis and to the historical record. Further, it’s no act of patriotism to celebrate, without context or discussion, a grunt’s view that the people killed in Iraq were animals deserving their six-feet-under fate." Maass also wrote public statements made by Bradley Cooper, the film’s star and co-producer, appear to show Cooper may "fail to understand how war movies operate in popular culture. When a film venerates an American sniper but portrays as sub-human the Iraqis whose country we were occupying—the film has one Iraqi who seems sympathetic but turns out to be hiding a cache of insurgent weapons—it conveys a political message that is flat wrong. Among other things, it ignores and dishonors the scores of thousands of Iraqis who fought alongside American forces and the hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians who were killed or injured in the crossfire." Maass added, "While it is about a certain type of bravery, the film itself is not brave."<ref>, '']'' </ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
==Allegations of stereotyping and objectifying Iraqis, and presenting children as legitimate targets== |
|
|
Janet Weil, a military family member, wrote "And what about the locals? In his brilliant analysis in ''Reel Bad Arabs,'' Professor Jack Shaheen gives a sort of taxonomy of Arab male types in popular films — the evil Arab, the silly/horny Arab, the primitive Arab, and the nervous/arrogant Arab. With the exception of the “primitive” type with camels, these stereotypes are on display in “American Sniper,” plus a couple of others I would name “Pitiful Father” and “Kid as Target.” The presentation of children as potential or actual evildoers, and thus “deserving” victims of Kyle’s kill shots, seems to me a sinister new development in American film." ... "The Iraqis that Kyle kills lie flat, literally and metaphorically, like images in a video game, and we hear no one weep for them (with the exception of “The Sheikh,” whose screaming daughter runs to his corpse). One scene briefly shows dogs eating Iraqi corpses. The American dead, by contrast, are pulled at great risk from the battleground, wept over, accompanied in their flag-covered coffins in flights home, and laid to rest in magnificent ceremonies, remembered. The American dead were persons, and they count. The Iraqi dead were objects in a sniper’s scope, and they are counted. That in a nutshell is the message of “American Sniper.”" ... "And the boy in Fallujah with the RPG in his arms? Kyle kills him, and the woman with him. We as audience are asked to ... empathize, not with the boy in the devastated street, but with a “tormented” man becoming a hardened killer, who calls Iraqis “savages” in several scenes." Weil said the movie portrays snipers as protectors, and invaders as "The Good Guys," and that Iraqi children are portrayed as "legitimate targets" ... She further wrote: "I left the movie theater with ... a heavy heart, and the feeling that this is a very dangerous film."<ref>, '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
==Allegations of overly simplistic portrayal of Iraq== |
|
|
Janet Weil wrote "The violent battle scenes had, for me, a tedious inevitability that kept me from being pulled in emotionally. What hurt me the most ... was my sense of Iraq being used as backdrop. It’s reduced to a hot, dirty place that “smells like dog shit,” as one Marine says in the opening scene. “This place is evil,” Kyle’s psychologically shattered younger brother, a fellow veteran, tells him as he departs the country. One war-blasted city looks much like another, almost as if a painted stage backdrop representing “Urban War Scene” were just hauled from one scene to the next." ... "Iraq is battleground and backdrop for American deeds and emotions — nothing more." <ref>, '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
==Allegations of the film serving as war propaganda== |
|
|
Janet Weil wrote that ""American Sniper" is well acted, slickly produced, and occasionally gripping. It's also war propaganda." She wrote that "Al-Qaeda in Iraq ... is mentioned frequently throughout the film, without one line of dialogue as to how al-Qaeda had penetrated Iraq following the U.S. invasion." ... "How Chris Kyle and hundreds of thousands of other, mostly young Americans came to invade and occupy, wound and be wounded, kill and be killed in Iraq — for what politics, for whose profits — cannot be touched upon in ''American Sniper.'' Because to do so would be to move the narrative away from the isolated, tragic white male — that hoary old trope of Western Civ — toward something more politically and historically informed, and much less of a money maker." ... "In war propaganda — a huge genre in which American Sniper stands as a well-acted, high-production example — fictional narratives borrow just enough from true-life stories to reinforce already established memes. Cowboy, family man, Navy SEAL, sniper, trainer, author, veteran, celebrity, murderer, and eventually a murder ''victim'' of another tormented combat veteran — Chris Kyle was a mystery. American Sniper portrays the life of a flawed “hero” who is also a blank slate on which other Americans can project rage, hatred, and ignorant misconceptions about Iraqis and other Arabs, as well as their — our — many conflicted feelings about war, “the troops,” and veterans." <ref>, '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
==Criticism of media coverage of the film== |
|
|
] criticized ''American Sniper'' and the media that glorified it. He drew a parallel between ''Sniper'' and the US "global assassination campaign, the drone campaign, which officially is aimed at murdering people who are suspected of maybe someday planning to harm us."<ref></ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
==Popular/cultural evaluation== |
|
|
] commented on the popular/cultural evaluation of Kyle: "Despite what some people think, hero is not a synonym for competent government-hired killer." Richman said if ''American Sniper'' launches a frank public conversation about war and heroism, Eastwood will have performed a "badly needed" service. Richman added: "Jeanine Pirro, a Fox News commentator, said, “Chris Kyle was clear as to who the enemy was. They were the ones his government sent him to kill.” Appalling! Kyle was a hero because he eagerly and expertly killed whomever the government told him to kill? Conservatives, supposed advocates of limited government, sure have an odd notion of heroism. Excuse me, but I have trouble seeing an essential difference between what Kyle did in Iraq and what Adam Lanza did at Sandy Hook Elementary School. It certainly was not heroism."<ref>, '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
Film historian Max Alvarez, in an article titled ''From Psychopaths to American Hero? A Short History of Sniper Cinema,'' expressed the view that "It can only be hoped that ''American Sniper'' will not set the tone for future Hollywood movies in which “sharpshooters” are portrayed heroically."<ref>, Max Alvarez, '']''</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
==Eastwood's response== |
|
|
Responding to critics that called the film Pro-War on Terror, Pro-Republican and ], Eastwood said that it is a "stupid analysis" and that the film has nothing to do with political parties. He stated: "I was a child growing up during World War II. That was supposed to be the one to end all wars. And four years later, I was standing at the draft board being drafted during the Korean conflict, and then after that there was Vietnam, and it goes on and on forever ... I just wonder ... does this ever stop? And no, it doesn’t. So each time we get in these conflicts, it deserves a lot of thought before we go wading in or wading out. Going in or coming out. It needs a better thought process, I think."<ref>{{cite news|last=Howell|first=Peter|title=Think before you shoot, Clint Eastwood says of war: interview|url=http://www.thestar.com/entertainment/movies/2015/01/13/think_before_you_shoot_clint_eastwood_says_of_war_interview.html|newspaper=The Star|date=January 16, 2015}}</ref> Eastwood called ''American Sniper'' "the biggest anti-war statement any film can make," and said that "the fact of what does to the family and the people who have to go back into civilian life like Chris Kyle did" and “what it (war) does to the people left behind." Eastwood further stated: "One of my favorite war movies that I’ve been involved with is '']'' and that was about family, about being taken away from life, being sent someplace. In ], everybody just sort of went home and got over it. Now there is some effort to help people through it."<ref>{{cite news|last=Kilday|first=Gregg|title=Clint Eastwood on 'American Sniper's' "Biggest Antiwar Statement"|url=https://www.yahoo.com/movies/clint-eastwood-on-american-snipers-biggest-109039032327.html|newspaper=The Hollywood Reporter|date=January 24, 2015}}</ref> |
|
|
|
|
|
==References== |
|
|
{{reflist}} |
|
|
|
|
|
{{Uncategorized|date=January 2015}} |
|