Misplaced Pages

Latest revision as of 22:05, 5 January 2025

The Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) was a nationally operated health clinic in the United Kingdom that specialised in working with transgender and gender diverse youth, including those with gender dysphoria. Launched in 1989, GIDS was commissioned by NHS England and took referrals from across the UK, although it was operated at a Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust site. GIDS was the only gender identity clinic for people under 18 in England and Wales and was the subject of much controversy.

In the late 2010s, the GIDS became controversial because of growing public attention on trans issues and concerns about the service, including a huge increase in patients and a lack of longitudinal evidence to support the treatments it gave. Some of its most prominent critics were gender-critical psychotherapists and psychoanalysts who argued against gender-affirming care for minors altogether.

By 2020, a large increase in referrals led to waiting lists in excess of two years. Between 2020 and 2021, GIDS stopped offering hormonal treatments to youth following the judgement in Bell v Tavistock, until the decision was overturned on appeal. In July 2022, the NHS decided to close GIDS and replace it with regional healthcare centres, following the release of the interim report of the Cass Review, in order to reduce waiting lists and provide better quality care to young people. The service closed in March 2024.

History

Pre-establishment

GIDS was a service provided by the Tavistock Clinic. Originally located at Tavistock Square in London, the clinic specialised in psychiatric care. The Tavistock Clinic treated both adults and children, with their first patient being a child. It mainly focused on military psychology, including shell-shock, now termed PTSD. In 1948, with the creation of the NHS, the Tavistock Clinic launched its children's department, which developed many works by James Robertson and John Bowlby on attachment theory. In 1959, it opened an adolescent department and in 1967 it was absorbed into the London Child Guidance Clinic.

Early years

The Gender Identity Development Clinic was founded in 1989 by Dr Domenico Di Ceglie, a child and adolescent psychiatrist. It was one of the first child gender services in the world. After its opening, "it got two referrals over the whole year". It was initially based at St George's Hospital before moving to the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust in 1994. The clinic saw 12 patients that year, increasing to 24 two years later. The last word of the clinic's name varied over time, shifting to Unit before being standardised in the late 2000s as Service.

In its early years, the service took a primarily psychoanalytic approach reflecting object relations theory, drawing from Di Ceglie's training. Di Ceglie described the children referred to the clinic as suffering from "atypical gender identity organization". In the early 2000s, some of Di Ceglie's colleagues at Tavistock published articles in The Guardian arguing that medical transition was a form of "mutilation" and that rights won in the European Court of Human Rights for transgender people were a "a victory of fantasy over reality".

Di Ceglie estimated in 1993 that only 5% of his patients would "commit themselves to a change of gender". Puberty blockers were considered a usable option by the end of the 1990s but only for patients aged 16 or over who had first tried extensive therapy. In 2000, a retrospective audit led by David Freeman looked at the records of 124 patients the service had seen since opening. The audit showed it was very rare (2.5% of the sample) for young people referred to GIDS to have no associated problems, that children do not "grow out of it" and that problems increase with the onset of puberty.

In 2009, Dr Polly Carmichael, a consultant clinical psychologist, succeeded Di Ceglie as the clinic's director. In that same year, GIDS became a nationally commissioned NHS service.

Expansion in the 2010s

In 2011, in response to changing international standards for gender care, the clinic began a research study allowing a "carefully selected group of young people" to receive puberty blockers after the age of 12. In 2014, prior to the study's completion, the clinic received NHS approval to offer them without mandating enrollment in a research study. In 2012, the service was extended to a satellite site in Leeds. Endocrine support was also extended to Leeds Children's Hospital at the Leeds General Infirmary site in 2013.

In 2011, a patient satisfaction survey found the majority were satisfied, but a quarter expressed dissatisfaction with long wait lists. Other concerns included geographic inaccessibility and the requirement for real-life experience.

Between 2014 and 2015, 697 youth were referred to GIDS and in 2015-2016 1,419 were. In September 2015, GIDS overshot its 18-week waiting time target for the first time. The same year, an external report by Femi Nzegwu stated that GIDS was "facing a crisis of capacity" and recommended capping referrals. By 2016 average wait times rose to nine months.

In 2016, the Women and Equalities Committee released a report which said that a number of trans advocacy groups had raised concerns that patients could not access treatment quickly enough and under current protocols and that Gillick competence was not being observed. They also heard that the requirement that youth complete 12 months of puberty blockers before being perscribed cross-sex hormones was unreasonable as youth certain of the gender identity were unable to mature physically at the same rate as their peers. Re-assesment on transfer to adult care was also highlighted as an issue.

In February 2019, it was revealed that the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) had announced a £1.3 million grant for a voluntary study following young people referred to GIDS, to compare outcomes for those who elect to medically transition and those who do not.

In 2020, over 2,000 children were referred to GIDS and in 2021 this rose to more than 5,000, leading to waiting lists of over 2 years. In January 2021, the Care Quality Commission rated GIDS as "inadequate", the worst rating possible, citing long delays, high caseloads, deficient record-keeping, and poor leadership.

Criticism

In the late 2010s, the GIDS came under increased public scrutiny because of growing public attention on trans issues, an "exponential" increase in its number of referrals, and the "ballooning" of its waiting list. Critics raised concerns about the service, including the role of trans advocacy groups in clinical decisions, a lack of longitudal studies supporting the prescription of puberty blockers to TGGNC youth, and allegations of rushed treatments without sufficient prior consultation and assessment. In November 2018, parents of 17- to 25-year-old patients complained in a letter to the Trust board that their children were transitioning too quickly and they felt psychosocial factors made them want to transition.

In 2022, a series of news articles published by The Daily Telegraph reported concerns that the transgender youth charity Mermaids may have exerted undue influence on GIDS' clinical decisions, particularly concerning the prescription of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to minors. However, in October 2024, an inquiry by The Charity Commission found no evidence to suggest that Mermaids had inappropriate influence or ties to GIDS. A report by Sky News found that, between 2016 and 2019, 35 psychologists resigned from GIDS' London branch. Six of these psychologists voiced concerns there was an "over-diagnosis" of gender dysphoria and a push for early medical intervention.

Gender-critical opposition

Some of GIDS' most prominent critics included psychotherapists and psychoanalysts, some of whom also expressed the "gender-critical" belief, beyond concerns about the quality of the services provided at GIDS, to oppose gender transition, particularly in young people, in its entirety. GIDS received criticism from prominent figures associated with the UK's gender-critical movement, such as Graham Linehan.

Bell report

Dr David Bell worked at the Tavistock Trust as a consultant psychiatrist for 25 years. In 2018, while a staff governor, and in response to concerns shared with him by GIDS staff, he submitted an internal report on GIDS to the trust's leaders. The report was highly critical, saying GIDS was "not fit for purpose", could result in "damaging consequences" to children's lives, and failed to fully consider a child's mental health background.

Since releasing his report, Bell has said that some children who identify as trangender might resolve their gender dysphoria without the need for gender-affirming care if other troubles, such as internalised homophobia and intergenerational trauma, were addressed. He further suggested that most transgender children would desist and that, while he thinks that medical transition is the "only reasonable option" for some people, it would be preferable to help a patient without doing so.

Dr Marcus Evans

Dr Marcus Evans, a longstanding member of the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust governance board, resigned that week in response to Bell's report, which he supported. His wife, Sue Evans, had resigned from work as a psychoanalyst a decade previously. Together, they wrote a book in 2021 sharing their views on how to help a young person overcome their wish to transition and supporting gender exploratory therapy. Reviewers noted the book was full of prejudicial value judgements about transgender people. Marcus Evans went on to co-found the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine, which the Southern Poverty Law Center described as a hub of anti-LGBT pseudoscience.

Sonia Appleby

In July 2020, it was reported that Sonia Appleby, the "Named Professional for Safeguarding Children" at the gender identity clinic, had been in dispute with her employers since November 2019. Appleby said staff had come to her in 2015-2016 with "a worry that some young children are being actively encouraged to be transgender without effective scrutiny of their circumstances". Between 2017 and 2019 she made six protected disclosures and in 2018 told a colleague that there could be a "Jimmy Savile-type situation". In 2019, she was called to an informal meeting with the Trust's medical director who said a letter was placed on her file due to the Savile comparison. In September 2021, Appleby was awarded £20,000 by an employment tribunal which found the Trust's "quasi disciplinary treatment" of her had damaged her professional reputation and "prevented her from proper work on safeguarding".

Bell v Tavistock

In October 2019, Sue Evans and the mother of a 15-year-old patient on the waiting list filed a lawsuit against GIDS. The pair's solicitor said "the provision at the Tavistock for young people up to the age of 18 is illegal because there isn't valid consent" and that Gillick competence – a UK legal principle that those under 16 can make their own medical decisions "if and when the child achieves sufficient understanding and intelligence to fully understand what is proposed" – should not apply to gender-affirming care. Later, Evans passed their role as complainant to Keira Bell, a previous service user and detransitioner. In a judgment delivered on 1 December 2020, the judges said that it was "highly unlikely that a child aged 13 or less would be competent to give consent to the administration of puberty blockers", and that it was "doubtful that 14 or 15 year olds could understand the long-term risks and consequences" of this form of treatment. Where the young person is 16 or over, the judges said "clinicians may well regard these as cases where the authorisation of the court should be sought prior to commencing the clinical treatment."

Following the High Court judgement, GIDS suspended all new referrals to endocrinology. The Court granted a stay on further implementation of the judgement until 22 December 2020 or until appeals were exhausted. Amnesty International and Liberty issued a joint statement emphasising their concern on "the wider implications this will have on the rights of children and young people of all genders, particularly on consent and bodily autonomy." Consortium issued a statement stating that the ruling "could have a potentially devastating impact on young people seeking access to medical services". In 2021, the Court of Appeal overturned the judgment as "innapropriate", since it was an established legal principle that "it was for clinicians rather than the court to decide on competence".

Closure

In 2020, due to a significant rise in the number of referrals to GIDS, NHS England and NHS Improvement commissioned Hilary Cass, a paediatrician and former President of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, to lead a review into gender identity services for children and young people.

In March 2022, Cass published the interim report of the Cass Review. The report said the existing model was "neither safe nor viable", partly as the rise in referrals had left GIDS staff overwhelmed and led to "unacceptable" waiting times, and recommended the creation of a new network of regional centres. It criticised the care at GIDS, saying that its clinical approach "has not been subjected to some of the usual control measures" expected of an innovative treatment and sidelined the patients' other mental health needs.

In July 2022, the NHS decided to close GIDS and replace it with regional healthcare centres. The regional centres are intended to provide more "holistic care", linking to other mental health services. After a delay, GIDS closed in March 2024, and was replaced with the new NHS Children and Young People's Gender Services, which initially constituted two new services at Great Ormond Street Hospital in London and Alder Hey Children's Hospital in Liverpool, intended to be the first of eight regional centres.

In February 2023, Newsnight journalist Hannah Barnes published a book on GIDS, titled Time to Think: The Inside Story of the Collapse of the Tavistock's Gender Service for Children.

Services

Services provided included:

• Assessments, to assess primary medical aims and necessary support;
• Gender development support, including access to therapy, tailored support and therapy groups;
• Physical intervention, including endocrinological intervention such as puberty blockers and sex hormones;
• Mental health support, usually working alongside CAMHS;
• Ongoing support post social or medical transition and referral to adult gender identity services.

No surgical transition options were available through GIDS.

People referred to GIDS could also contribute to NIHR studies into gender dysphoria in children.

See also

• Transitioning (transgender)
• Transgender health care
• Transgender rights in the United Kingdom
• Childhood gender nonconformity
• Gender dysphoria in children
• Transgender youth

References

1. ^ Osserman 2024, p. 594.
2. Osserman 2024, p. 592-593.
3. ^ Brooks, Libby (19 January 2023). "'A contentious place': the inside story of Tavistock's NHS gender identity clinic". The Guardian. Retrieved 30 January 2023.
4. Dicks, H.V., (1970). 50 Years of the Tavistock Clinic. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. Reissued by Routledge, 2014, ISBN 978 1 138 82194 1
5. "The London Child Guidance Clinic in Islington". Lost Hospitals of London. Archived from the original on 10 January 2020. Retrieved 10 January 2020.
6. Barnes 2023, p. 11.
7. ^ Stevens, Jenny (16 November 2016). "Meet the Doctor Who Runs the Only Clinic for Trans Children in the UK". Vice Media Group. Archived from the original on 24 December 2020. Retrieved 5 December 2020.
8. ^ Barnes 2023, p. 15.
9. Barnes 2023, p. 18.
10. ^ Osserman 2024, p. 593.
11. Barnes 2023, p. 13-14.
12. Di Ceglie, Domenico; Freedman, David; McPherson, Susan; Richardson, Phil (2002). "Children and Adolescents Referred to a Specialist Gender Identity Development Service: Clinical Features and Demographic Characteristics". International Journal of Transgenderism. 5 (4): s3 – s11. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2023-326681. ISSN 0003-9888. PMID 38594046.
13. ^ Barnes 2023, p. xvii.
14. "Meet Children with gender identity issues 'need help from all sides'". BBC News. 17 July 2019. Archived from the original on 20 February 2022. Retrieved 20 February 2022.
15. "The service director's view". The Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust. Archived from the original on 20 February 2022. Retrieved 20 February 2022.
16. Osserman 2024, p. 593-594.
17. Butler, Gary; De Graaf, Nastasja; Wren, Bernadette; Carmichael, Polly (2018). "Assessment and support of children and adolescents with gender dysphoria". Archives of Disease in Childhood. 103 (7): 631–636. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2018-314992. PMID 29650510. S2CID 4785372. Archived from the original on 1 March 2021. Retrieved 7 March 2021.
18. Davies, Andrew; Bouman, Walter Pierre; Richards, Christina; Barrett, James; Ahmad, Sheraz; Baker, Karen; Lenihan, Penny; Lorimer, Stuart; Murjan, Sarah; Mepham, Nick; Robbins-Cherry, Sally; Seal, Leighton J.; Stradins, Linda (1 November 2013). "Patient satisfaction with gender identity clinic services in the United Kingdom". Sexual and Relationship Therapy. doi:10.1080/14681994.2013.834321. ISSN 1468-1994.
19. ^ "The crisis at the Tavistock's child gender clinic". BBC News. 30 March 2021. Retrieved 13 August 2024.
20. Transgender Equality (PDF) (Report). House of Commons Women and Equalities Committee. 14 January 2016.
21. ^ Doward, Jamie (23 February 2019). "Governor of Tavistock Foundation quits over damning report into gender identity clinic". The Observer. ISSN 0029-7712. Archived from the original on 18 January 2020. Retrieved 13 January 2020.
22. Hayward, Eleanor; Bannerman, Lucy (29 July 2022). Ames, Jonathan (ed.). "Tavistock child gender clinic forced to close over safety fears". The Times. News Corp.
23. Brooks, Libby (20 January 2021). "Gender identity development service for children rated inadequate". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 20 January 2021. Retrieved 1 January 2025.
24. Hunte, Ben (20 January 2021). "NHS Tavistock child gender clinic rated 'inadequate'". BBC News. Archived from the original on 30 January 2021. Retrieved 1 January 2025.
25. Doward, Jamie (3 November 2018). "Gender identity clinic accused of fast-tracking young adults". The Observer. ISSN 0029-7712. Archived from the original on 6 December 2019. Retrieved 13 January 2020.
26. Siddique, Haroon (17 November 2022). "Mermaids: why has the trans charity been in the news?". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 2 December 2022. Retrieved 30 December 2024.
27. Baska, Maggie (28 May 2023). "Ex-Mermaids CEO slams claim that Tavistock gender clinic links were inappropriate". PinkNews. Archived from the original on 30 December 2024. Retrieved 30 December 2024.
28. Kelleher, Patrick (1 October 2022). "Why young people will pay the price for The Telegraph's 'attacks' on Mermaids". PinkNews. Archived from the original on 5 January 2025. Retrieved 5 January 2025.
29. Melley, James (24 October 2024). "Trans charity Mermaids was mismanaged, says regulator". BBC News. Archived from the original on 24 October 2024. Retrieved 30 December 2024.
30. Donnelly, Laura (12 December 2019). "Children's transgender clinic hit by 35 resignations in three years as psychologists warn of gender dysphoria 'over-diagnoses'". The Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Archived from the original on 18 January 2020. Retrieved 13 January 2020.
31. "NHS 'over-diagnosing' children having transgender treatment, former staff warn". Sky News. 12 December 2019. Archived from the original on 18 January 2020. Retrieved 13 January 2020.
32. Parsons, Vic (11 February 2020). "Graham Linehan compares doctors treating trans kids to Nazi experiments in concentration camps". PinkNews. Archived from the original on 29 December 2024. Retrieved 5 January 2025.
33. Milton, Josh (24 February 2020). "BBC pelted with complaints after Graham Linehan compared doctors treating trans kids to Nazi experiments". PinkNews. Archived from the original on 29 September 2023. Retrieved 5 January 2025.
34. Fox, Aine (7 April 2024). "Tavistock whistleblower 'had no alternative' but to raise concerns". The Independent. Archived from the original on 7 April 2024. Retrieved 5 January 2025.
35. Bannerman, Lucy (5 December 2020). "David Bell: Tavistock gender clinic whistleblower faces the sack". The Times. Archived from the original on 29 December 2024. Retrieved 5 January 2025.
36. Doward, Jamie (23 February 2019). "Governor of Tavistock Foundation quits over damning report into gender identity clinic". The Observer. Archived from the original on 3 July 2020. Retrieved 5 January 2025.
37. Osserman 2024, p. 594-595.
38. Osserman 2024, p. 595.
39. Cravens, R.G.; McLamore, Quinnehtukqut; Leveille, Lee; Hodges, Emerson; Wunderlich, Sophie; Bates, Lydia (12 December 2023). "Group dynamics and division of labor within the anti-LGBTQ+ pseudoscience network". Southern Poverty Law Center. Retrieved 21 December 2023.
40. Wuest, Joanna; Last, Briana S. (1 March 2024). "Agents of scientific uncertainty: Conflicts over evidence and expertise in gender-affirming care bans for minors". Social Science & Medicine. 344: 116533. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2023.116533. ISSN 0277-9536.
41. Kirkup, James (8 July 2020). "Are whistleblowers being silenced at the NHS gender clinic?". The Spectator. Archived from the original on 22 April 2021. Retrieved 22 April 2021.
42. ^ Griffiths, Sian; Das, Shanti (4 September 2021). "Gender identity clinic whistleblower wins damages for 'vilification'". Retrieved 31 December 2024.
43. Connett, David (4 September 2021). "NHS gender identity clinic whistleblower wins damages". Guardian. Observer. Archived from the original on 4 September 2021. Retrieved 5 September 2021.
44. "NHS child gender identity clinic whistleblower wins tribunal". BBC News. 5 September 2021. Archived from the original on 19 September 2021. Retrieved 19 September 2021.
45. "Lawyer in the news: Elliot Hammer 20 September 2021". law gazette. Law Society Gazette. Archived from the original on 3 October 2021. Retrieved 26 September 2021.
46. Hurst, Greg (12 October 2019). "Mother sues Tavistock child gender clinic over treatments". The Times. ISSN 0140-0460. Archived from the original on 13 January 2020. Retrieved 13 January 2020.
47. Doward, Jamie (5 January 2020). "High court to decide if children can consent to gender reassignment". The Observer. ISSN 0029-7712. Retrieved 31 December 2024.
48. "Puberty blockers: Under-16s unlikely to be able to give informed consent 1 December 2020". BBC News. December 2020. Archived from the original on 6 December 2020. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
49. "Update on the Judicial Review, Tuesday 1 December 2020". The Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust. December 2020. Archived from the original on 6 December 2020. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
50. "Amnesty International UK and Liberty joint statement on puberty blockers". www.amnesty.org.uk. Archived from the original on 10 April 2021. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
51. "Consortium Statement on Bell v Tavistock Outcome". www.consortium.lgbt. Archived from the original on 10 April 2021. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
52. Siddique, Haroon (17 September 2021). "Appeal court overturns UK puberty blockers ruling for under-16s 17 September 2021". Guardian. Archived from the original on 17 September 2021. Retrieved 17 September 2021.
53. Marsh, Sarah (22 September 2020). "NHS to hold review into gender identity services for children and young people". Guardian. Archived from the original on 13 March 2022. Retrieved 13 March 2022.
54. Thomas, Rebecca (28 July 2022). "Failing children's gender service to be replaced by local hubs". The Independent. Archived from the original on 28 July 2022. Retrieved 28 July 2022.
55. Brooks, Libby (10 March 2022). "NHS gender identity service for children can't cope with demand, review finds 10 March 2022". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 13 March 2022. Retrieved 13 March 2022.
56. Bannerman, Lucy (10 March 2022). "Tavistock gender clinic not safe for children, report finds". The Times. Archived from the original on 29 March 2022. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
57. "NHS to close Tavistock child gender identity clinic". BBC News. 28 July 2022. Archived from the original on 28 July 2022. Retrieved 28 July 2022.
58. Hayward, Eleanor (28 July 2022). "Tavistock gender clinic forced to shut over safety fears". The Times. Archived from the original on 28 July 2022. Retrieved 29 July 2022.
59. Barnes & Clare (23 May 2023). "23 May 2023 Tavistock: Top doctor questions need for change at gender clinic". BBC News. Retrieved 30 May 2023.
60. "Children and young people's gender services: implementing the Cass Review recommendations". NHS England. 7 August 2024. Archived from the original on 8 August 2024. Retrieved 3 January 2025.
61. Bowers, Shauna (29 April 2024). "What now for transgender healthcare in Ireland after publication of the Cass review?". The Irish Times. Archived from the original on 29 April 2024. Retrieved 3 January 2025.
62. "What to do if your child wants to transition". The Daily Telegraph. 28 July 2024. Archived from the original on 28 July 2024. Retrieved 3 January 2025. A first step for a parent would be to approach the child's GP, who can refer them to the NHS Children and Young People's Gender Services, where they will be seen by psychologists, psychotherapists and social workers, she says.
63. Campbell, Denis (7 August 2024). "Delayed puberty blocker clinical trial to start next year in England". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 13 August 2024.
64. Lloyd, Will (15 February 2023). "Hannah Barnes: Inside the collapse of the Tavistock gender clinic". New Statesman. Archived from the original on 18 February 2023. Retrieved 8 March 2023.
65. ^ "About us". GIDS. Archived from the original on 13 January 2020. Retrieved 13 January 2020.
66. "Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust". www.cqc.org.uk. Archived from the original on 13 January 2020. Retrieved 13 January 2020.

Works cited

• Barnes, Hannah (2023). Time to Think: The Inside Story of the Collapse of the Tavistock's Gender Service for Children. Swiff Press. ISBN 978-1800751118.
• Osserman, Jordan (2024). "Psychoanalysis and Trans". In Frosh, Stephen; Vyrgioti, Marita; Walsh, Julie (eds.). The Palgrave Handbook of Psychosocial Studies. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 978-3031303654.
• Cass, Hilary (10 April 2024). "Final Report – Cass Review" (PDF). The Cass Review. Archived (PDF) from the original on 27 December 2024. Retrieved 10 April 2024.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: date and year (link)

External links

• Official website

• Transgender health care
• Defunct National Health Service organisations
• 1989 establishments in the United Kingdom
• 2024 disestablishments in the United Kingdom
• Government agencies established in 1989
• Government agencies disestablished in 2024
• Transgender history in the United Kingdom