| Revision as of 18:37, 11 September 2024 editAtsme (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users, Page movers, New page reviewers, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers42,813 edits keep← Previous edit | Latest revision as of 12:27, 1 October 2024 edit undoAirshipJungleman29 (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Page movers, New page reviewers, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers, Template editors44,274 edits close GAR Misplaced Pages:Good article reassessment/Crab dip/1 as keep (GANReviewTool) | ||
| (7 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| ===]=== | ===]=== | ||
| {{atopg}} | |||
| : {{al|Crab dip|noname=yes}} • <span class="plainlinksneverexpand"></span> • ] | : {{al|Crab dip|noname=yes}} • <span class="plainlinksneverexpand"></span> • ] | ||
| : <span>{{#ifeq:{{PAGENAME}}|Good article reassessment/Crab dip/1|]}} '''Result''': Kept with suggestions for further improvement.</span> ] (]) 12:27, 1 October 2024 (UTC)<br/> | |||
| : {{GAR/current}}<br/> | |||
| This article is missing several sections, including its history, the cuisine it is used in, and its uses outside of the United States. ] (]) 20:37, 9 September 2024 (UTC) | This article is missing several sections, including its history, the cuisine it is used in, and its uses outside of the United States. ] (]) 20:37, 9 September 2024 (UTC) | ||
| *'''KEEP''' - it was easier for geneticists to trace human existence back to its ] than what it would be to trace the history of the exact (or evolving) ingredients for crab dip. I am not aware of any Without the latter or other form of verifiable proof, the sections claimed to be missing are, quite frankly, quite a {{stretch}}. Having said that, I commend Z1720 for exercising due diligence in wanting our GAs to be really, really good articles. ] ] ] 18:37, 11 September 2024 (UTC) | *'''KEEP''' - it was easier for geneticists to trace human existence back to its ] than what it would be to trace the history of the exact (or evolving) ingredients for crab dip. I am not aware of any Without the latter or other form of verifiable proof, the sections claimed to be missing are, quite frankly, quite a {{stretch}}. Having said that, I commend Z1720 for exercising due diligence in wanting our GAs to be really, really good articles. ] ] ] 18:37, 11 September 2024 (UTC) | ||
| **'''Comment'''. Atsme, I would think there is probably ''something'' that could be, um, cooked up, about how it came to be associated with Maryland, and about whether it is used outside of the US. In other words, I'm wondering whether you could meet the criticisms part way? --] (]) 19:16, 11 September 2024 (UTC) | |||
| ***I reviewed the article, and it meets the requirements for GA. Can it be expanded? Perhaps, but that is not a reason to file a GAR. There is no documented history about this particular recipe that I can find, though there is a that doesn't specifically mention crab dip, and there is also about crabbing in Maryland which lists ways to prepare crab meat; crap dip is on the list, but just passing mention. The lead of the crab dip article states that it is ''sometimes'' referred to as '''Maryland crab dip'''. If someone wants to expand the article as a potential FA candidate, they can certainly give it a shot, but finding the documented history that states the where/when/how, it's just another mom & pop homestyle recipe that is typically passed along by word of mouth, online, or in multiple recipe books with some variation. It is also possible that there is a long established, upscale Maryland seafood restaurant that makes claim to their own crab dip recipe, and has it documented but again, that's just a variation of the ubiquitous basic ingredients for crab dip. j/s ] ] ] 12:44, 12 September 2024 (UTC) | |||
| ****Thoughts {{ping|Z1720|Tryptofish}}? ] (]) 15:33, 18 September 2024 (UTC) | |||
| *****I still think Atsme might meet the review issues part way, but I see that more as friendly advice than as something that would make me want to de-list the page. I'll defer to whatever Z1720 prefers. --] (]) 18:19, 18 September 2024 (UTC) | |||
| :::::*Real life has caused me to get too busy to properly look for additional sources. When I did a quick search a couple weeks ago, I found some sources that might be included, but the information was not as substantial as I would like. I think before this is declared "keep" I would hope that an editor can do a thorough search for sources on ], Google Scholar, and other databases to ensure that the missing sections do not have reliable sources that could be used to instead. ] (]) 21:29, 29 September 2024 (UTC) | |||
| {{abot}} | |||
Latest revision as of 12:27, 1 October 2024
Crab dip
The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.
- Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
- Result: Kept with suggestions for further improvement. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 12:27, 1 October 2024 (UTC)
This article is missing several sections, including its history, the cuisine it is used in, and its uses outside of the United States. Z1720 (talk) 20:37, 9 September 2024 (UTC)
- KEEP - it was easier for geneticists to trace human existence back to its Mitochondrial mother than what it would be to trace the history of the exact (or evolving) ingredients for crab dip. I am not aware of any patents on crap dip. Without the latter or other form of verifiable proof, the sections claimed to be missing are, quite frankly, quite a . Having said that, I commend Z1720 for exercising due diligence in wanting our GAs to be really, really good articles. Atsme 💬 📧 18:37, 11 September 2024 (UTC)
- Comment. Atsme, I would think there is probably something that could be, um, cooked up, about how it came to be associated with Maryland, and about whether it is used outside of the US. In other words, I'm wondering whether you could meet the criticisms part way? --Tryptofish (talk) 19:16, 11 September 2024 (UTC)
- I reviewed the article, and it meets the requirements for GA. Can it be expanded? Perhaps, but that is not a reason to file a GAR. There is no documented history about this particular recipe that I can find, though there is a National Crab Meat Day that doesn't specifically mention crab dip, and there is also documented history about crabbing in Maryland which lists ways to prepare crab meat; crap dip is on the list, but just passing mention. The lead of the crab dip article states that it is sometimes referred to as Maryland crab dip. If someone wants to expand the article as a potential FA candidate, they can certainly give it a shot, but finding the documented history that states the where/when/how, it's just another mom & pop homestyle recipe that is typically passed along by word of mouth, online, or in multiple recipe books with some variation. It is also possible that there is a long established, upscale Maryland seafood restaurant that makes claim to their own crab dip recipe, and has it documented but again, that's just a variation of the ubiquitous basic ingredients for crab dip. j/s Atsme 💬 📧 12:44, 12 September 2024 (UTC)
- Thoughts @Z1720 and Tryptofish:? ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 15:33, 18 September 2024 (UTC)
- I still think Atsme might meet the review issues part way, but I see that more as friendly advice than as something that would make me want to de-list the page. I'll defer to whatever Z1720 prefers. --Tryptofish (talk) 18:19, 18 September 2024 (UTC)
- Thoughts @Z1720 and Tryptofish:? ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 15:33, 18 September 2024 (UTC)
- I reviewed the article, and it meets the requirements for GA. Can it be expanded? Perhaps, but that is not a reason to file a GAR. There is no documented history about this particular recipe that I can find, though there is a National Crab Meat Day that doesn't specifically mention crab dip, and there is also documented history about crabbing in Maryland which lists ways to prepare crab meat; crap dip is on the list, but just passing mention. The lead of the crab dip article states that it is sometimes referred to as Maryland crab dip. If someone wants to expand the article as a potential FA candidate, they can certainly give it a shot, but finding the documented history that states the where/when/how, it's just another mom & pop homestyle recipe that is typically passed along by word of mouth, online, or in multiple recipe books with some variation. It is also possible that there is a long established, upscale Maryland seafood restaurant that makes claim to their own crab dip recipe, and has it documented but again, that's just a variation of the ubiquitous basic ingredients for crab dip. j/s Atsme 💬 📧 12:44, 12 September 2024 (UTC)
- Comment. Atsme, I would think there is probably something that could be, um, cooked up, about how it came to be associated with Maryland, and about whether it is used outside of the US. In other words, I'm wondering whether you could meet the criticisms part way? --Tryptofish (talk) 19:16, 11 September 2024 (UTC)
- Real life has caused me to get too busy to properly look for additional sources. When I did a quick search a couple weeks ago, I found some sources that might be included, but the information was not as substantial as I would like. I think before this is declared "keep" I would hope that an editor can do a thorough search for sources on WP:LIBRARY, Google Scholar, and other databases to ensure that the missing sections do not have reliable sources that could be used to instead. Z1720 (talk) 21:29, 29 September 2024 (UTC)