Misplaced Pages

History of Falun Gong: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editContent deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 15:33, 27 June 2007 editAsdfg12345 (talk | contribs)Pending changes reviewers6,640 editsNo edit summary← Previous edit Latest revision as of 00:04, 31 December 2024 edit undoHeyoostorm (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users899 edits Before 1992Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile edit 
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|none}}
{{sprotected}}
{{Use dmy dates|date=May 2023}}
{{ActiveDiscuss}}
] Gong adherents practice the fifth exercise, a meditation, in ]]]
], also called Falun Dafa, is a spiritual practice and ] that combines the practice of meditation with the moral philosophy articulated by its leader and founder, ]. It emerged on the public radar in the Spring of 1992 in the northeastern Chinese city of ], and was classified as a system of ] identifying with the Buddhist tradition. Li claimed to have both supernatural powers like the ability to prevent illness, as well having eternal youth and promised that others can attain supernatural powers and eternal youth by following his teachings.<ref>{{Cite news |last=Yoffe |first=Emily |date=2001-08-10 |title=The Gong Show |language=en-US |work=Slate |url=https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2001/08/the-gong-show.html |access-date=2023-02-13 |issn=1091-2339}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |date=2019-04-25 |title=Were human organs stolen in 20-year conflict between Beijing and Falun Gong? |url=https://www.rfi.fr/en/asia-pacific/20190418-were-human-organs-stolen-20-year-conflict-between-beijing-and-falun-gong |access-date=2023-02-13 |website=RFI |language=en}}</ref> Falun Gong initially enjoyed official sanction and support from Chinese government agencies, and the practice grew quickly on account of the simplicity of its exercise movements, impact on health, the absence of fees or formal membership, and moral and philosophical teachings.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
''']''', ({{zh-tsp |t=]]] |s=法]功 |p=Fǎlún Gōng}}; literally "Practice of the Wheel of Law") also known as '''Falun Dafa''', ({{zh-tsp |t=法輪]法 |s=法轮大法 |p=Fǎlún dàfǎ}}; lit. "Great Law of the Wheel of Law") is a system of "mind and body cultivation" introduced by ] (whose surname is Li) to the public in 1992 Falun Gong has been the focus of international attention since ], ], when the government of the ] (PRC) began a nationwide crackdown, except in the ] of ] and ]. Several governments, international human rights organizations and scholars consider the ban a human rights violation. Particular concerns have been raised over reports of torture and illegal imprisonment of Falun Gong practitioners in China.<ref>Amnesty International: The crackdown on Falun Gong and other so-called ''heretical organizations'' (23 March 2000) </ref><ref>Falun Dafa Information Center: U.S. Congress Unanimously Passes Resolution Calling on Jiang Zemin Regime to Cease Persecution of Falun Gong </ref><ref>United Nations (], ]) [http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2004/hrcn1073.doc.htm Press Release
HR/CN/1073], retrieved ], ]</ref> The Chinese government claims to have banned the group for "''illegal activities, advocating superstition and spreading fallacies, hoodwinking people, inciting and creating disturbances, and jeopardizing social stability.''"<ref>, (], ]) ''People's Daily Online'', retrieved ], ]</ref> Amnesty International has stated: ''"All the information available indicates that the crackdown is politically motivated, with legislation being used retroactively to convict people on politically-driven charges, and new regulations introduced to further restrict fundamental freedoms."''<ref>Amnesty International: The crackdown on Falun Gong and other so-called ''heretical organizations'' (23 March 2000) </ref>


In the mid-1990s, however, Falun Gong became estranged from the state-run qigong associations, leading to a gradual escalation of tensions with ] (CCP) authorities that culminated in the Spring of 1999. Following a protest of 10,000 Falun Gong practitioners near the ] government compound on 25 April 1999 to request official recognition, then-] ] ordered Falun Gong be crushed. A campaign of propaganda, large-scale extrajudicial imprisonment, torture and coercive reeducation ensued. {{Citation needed|date=May 2024}}
Julia Ching from the University of Toronto, writing for the ], has suggested it was the Zhongnanhai demonstration of April 25 that led to "fear, animosity and suppression".<ref>American Asian Review, Vol. XIX, no. 4, Winter 2001, p. 12</ref> In addition, Jiang Zemin had received a letter from the former director of the 301 Military Hospital, "a doctor with considerable standing among the political elite", endorsing Falun Gong and advising high-level cadres to start practicing it.<ref>Critical Asian Studies 33:2 (2001), pp. 170-171</ref> Jiang also found out that Li's book, ''Zhuan Falun'', had been published by ], and that possibly seven hundred thousand Communist party members were practitioners. Ching opines that "Jiang accepts the threat of Falun Gong as an ideological one: spiritual beliefs against militant atheism and historical materialism. He wishes to purge the government and the military of such beliefs."<ref>American Asian Review, Vol. XIX, no. 4, Winter 2001, pp. 12-13</ref> She also says that "the accusation of Falun Gong's being an "evil cult" made previous arrests and imprisonments "constitutional." Of course, the accusation was made after the government had already started to crack down on Falun Gong . The enumeration of features of an "evil cult" was done by political officials on political premises, not by any religious authority. It was an atheistic, Communist government, handing down an executive decision by the pronouncement of an "evil cult," without an explanation of what would be its opposite: a good cult, or a good religion."<ref>ibid., p. 9</ref> Similar theories about the fundamental reasons are also supported by Elizabeth J. Perry in ]<ref>Critical Asian Studies 33:2 (2001)</ref>, a peer-reviewed quarterly journal.


Falun Gong practitioners have responded to the campaign with protests on ], the creation of their own media companies overseas, international lawsuits targeting Chinese officials, and the establishment of a network of underground publishing sites to produce literature on the practice within China. Falun Gong has emerged as a prominent voice for an end to one-party rule in China.
== Beginning of the Conflict ==
On ] ], Guangming Daily, one of Chinese Communist government's official newspapers, published an editorial article titled, "A Loud and Long Alarm Must Be Sounded Against Pseudo-Science," which claimed Falun Gong to promote superstition, and to be "Pseudo-Science." This is the first time the Chinese Communist government media made a critical article about the Falun Gong public.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents>http://clearwisdom.net/emh/articles/2004/8/27/chronicle.html A Chronicle of Major Events of Falun Dafa</ref>


==Timeline of major events==
On ] ], the Chinese News Publishing Bureau, which is under the Propaganda Bureau at the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist government, issued an internal order to in all cities and provinces, prohibiting the publishing of Zhuan Falun and China Falun Gong, and other Falun Gong books due to their nature of "promoting superstition."<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>


===Before 1992===
In the Beginning of ] the Chinese Public Security Ministry carried out an investigation throughout China trying to collect criminal evidence of Falun Gong as "an evil cult." But the police at all levels in China came back with the same report: "Haven't found any problem." Hence the investigation stopped.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>
Falun Gong has been classified variously as a form of spiritual cultivation practice in the tradition of Chinese antiquity, as a ] discipline, or as a religion or new religious movement.<ref name=Penny2012>], '']'', (], 2012.</ref> Qigong refers to a broad set of exercises, meditation and breathing methods that have long been part of the spiritual practices of select Buddhist sects, of ] alchemists, martial artists, and some ] scholars.<ref name=Palmer/><ref>Kenneth S. Cohen, "The Way of Qigong: The Art and Science of Chinese Energy Healing" (Random House, Inc., 1999)</ref>


Although qigong-like practices have a long history, the modern qigong movement traces its origins only to the late 1940s and 1950s. At that time, CCP ] began pursuing qigong as a means of improving health, and regarded it as a category of traditional ].<ref name=Palmer/> With official support from the party-state, qigong grew steadily in popularity, particularly in the period following the ]. The state-run China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985 to administer and oversee qigong practice across the country. Thousands of qigong disciplines emerged, some of them headed by "grandmasters" with millions of adherents.<ref name=Palmer>David Palmer. '']''. New York: ], 2007</ref><ref>Zhu Xiaoyang and ] (ed.), "The Qigong Boom," Chinese Sociology and Anthropology, Vol. 27, No. 1 (1994)</ref>
In May ] Beijing TV's "Fast Forward" program aired an interview with He Zuoxiu, a member of the Chinese Academy of Science, who attacked Falun Gong as being superstitious in the same segment where a reporter from the station interviewed practitioners at an exercise site in Beijing's Yu Yuantan Park and had practitioners describe the benefits of Falun Gong. After the show aired, hundreds of Falun Gong practitioners from Beijing and Hebei province either wrote letters or directly visited the TV station to point out that He Zuoxiu's attack on Falun Gong was inaccurate.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>


From his youth, Li Hongzhi claims to have been tutored by a variety of Buddhist and Daoist masters, who, according to his spiritual biography, imparted to him the practice methods and moral philosophy that would come to be known as Falun Gong.<ref name=Penny2003/>
In June 20 - 22, ] after Qilu Evening News published an article slandering Falun Dafa, over 1,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Jinan went to the newspaper to clarify the truth about Falun Gong.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>


*1951 or 1952 – Falun Gong asserts that ], founder of Falun Gong, was born on 13 May 1951 in Gongzhuling, ] Province.<ref name=Penny2003>], "," '']'', Vol. 175 (2003), pp. 643–661. Hosted by the ]. Cambridge University Databases. ].</ref> Official Chinese birth dates for Li have been given as 7 or 27 July 1952.
In ], ] the 1st Bureau of the Chinese Ministry of Public Security issued Document No. 555, "Notice of the Investigation of Falun Gong," which claimed that Falun Gong was an "evil cult." The Ministry of Public Security carried out a series of investigations on Falun Gong that were known as "finding guilty first and then collecting evidence." These actions included, but were not limited to, tapping Falun Gong assistants' phones, tailing Falun Gong assistants, closing down Falun Gong practice sites, forcefully dispersing the practitioners during group exercise practice, ransacking practitioners' houses, confiscating their personal properties, and other things.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>
*1955 – According to his spiritual biography, Li begins learning under the tutelage of master Quan Je, a tenth-generation master of Buddhist cultivation who imparts to Li the principles of Zhen, Shan, Ren (truth, compassion, forbearance). The instruction lasts eight years.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1963 – According to his spiritual biography, Daoist master Baji Zhenren begins training Li in Daoist martial arts disciplines and physical skills training.<ref name=Penny2003/>
*1970 – Li begins working at a military horse farm in northeast China, and in 1972 works as a trumpet player with a division of the provincial forestry police.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1972 – Li continues his spiritual training under the instruction of a master Zhen Daozhi, who imparts methods of ]. According to Li's spiritual biography, his training in this period mostly took place under cover of night, possibly due to the political environment of the ].<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1974 – Li's biography states that he begins studying the instruction of a female Buddhist master. Throughout the next several years, Li continued his studies and observations of spiritual cultivation systems.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*Early 1980s – Having had his middle and high school education interrupted by the Cultural Revolution, Li completes his high school education via correspondence courses.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1984 – According to his spiritual biography, to Li creates Falun Gong with his masters as a more accessible version of Falun Fofa, based on other qigong.<ref name=Penny2003/>
*Mid-1980s – Li begins studying and observing a variety of other qigong disciplines, apparently in preparation for establishing and publicizing his own qigong system.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1985 – Chinese authorities create a national organization to oversee the great variety of qigong disciplines that were proliferating across the country. The China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985, and convened its first meeting in Beijing in 1986. The organization counted among its leadership several eminent members and former members of the Politburo and National People's Congress, as well as former ministers of health and education.<ref>Benjamin Penny, Qigong boom, pp. 13–20.</ref>
*1989 – Li begins private instruction of Falun Gong to select students.<ref name=Penny2012/><ref name=zeng>Zeng, Jennifer. ''Witnessing history: one Chinese woman's fight for freedom'', Soho Press, 2006, pp. 329–335</ref>


===1992–1995===
In the second half of ] in response to letters from people who reported the police's unjust treatment of Falun Gong practitioners, Qiao Shi, the formal chairman of the People's National Congress, led other retired senior members of the congress to perform a thorough investigation on Falun Gong that lasted several months. The investigation concluded that "Falun Gong has hundreds of benefits for the Chinese people and China, and does not have one single bad effect." The retired leaders submitted the investigation report to the Political and Legislative Affairs Committee of the Chinese Communist Party's Central Committee.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>


Falun Gong was publicly founded in the Spring of 1992, toward the end of China's "qigong boom," a period which saw the proliferation of thousands of disciplines. Li Hongzhi and his Falun Gong became an "instant star" of the qigong movement, and were welcomed into the government-administered China Qigong Scientific Research Society (CQRS).<ref name="Ownbyworld">David Ownby, "," '']'', Sep 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p. 306</ref> From 1992 to 1994, Li traveled throughout China giving 54 lecture seminars on the practice and beliefs of Falun Gong.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> Seminars typically lasted 8–10 days, and attracted as many as 6,000 participants per class.<ref name=Schechter>Danny Schechter, Falun Gong's Challenge to China: Spiritual Practice of "Evil Cult"? (New York: Akashic Books, 2000), pp. 42.</ref> The practice grew rapidly based on its purported efficacy in improving health and its moral and philosophical elements, which were more developed than those of other qigong schools.<ref>Scott Lowe, Chinese and InternationalContexts for the Rise of Falun Gong. Nova Religio 6 (2 April 2003)</ref>
In ], ] the Chinese National Sports Bureau sent a team to Changchun and Harbin to investigate Falun Gong. After the investigation, the leader of the team confirmed Falun Gong's effects on good health and its positive role in improving social stability and spiritual civilization.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>


*1992 – On 13 May, Li begins public teaching of Falun Gong at the No. 5 Middle School in Changchun, Jilin Province, lecturing to a crowd of several hundred.<ref name=Porter>Noah Porter, "Falun Gong in the United States: An Ethnographic Study," 2003, p. 70</ref> The seminar ran for nine days at a cost of 30 Yuan per person.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
In ], ] He Zuoxiu published an article titled "Teenagers Should Not Practice Qigong" in Teenager Expo, quoting cases that had been included in a prior Beijing TV program and had already been found to be untrue.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>
*1992 – June, Li is invited by the China Qigong Scientific Research Society to lecture in ].
*1992 – In September, Falun Gong is recognized as a qigong branch under the administration of the state-run China Qigong Scientific Research Society (CQRS).<ref name="Ownby (2003)">David Ownby, "The Falun Gong in the New World," European Journal of East Asian Studies, Sep 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p. 306.</ref>
*1992 – Li is formally declared a "Master of Qigong" by the CQRS, and received a permit to teach nationwide.<ref name=faluninfotime>Falun Dafa Information Center, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20170502142634/http://faluninfo.net/topic/22/ |date=2 May 2017 }} accessed 24 November 2010</ref>
*1992 – Li and several Falun Gong students participate in the 1992 Asian Health Expo in Beijing from 12 to 21 December. The organizer of the health fair remarked that Falun Gong and Li "received the most praise at the fair, and achieved very good therapeutic results."<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> The event helped cement Li's popularity in the qigong world, and journalistic reports of Falun Gong's healing powers spread.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1992 – By the end of the year, Li had given five week-long lecture seminars in Beijing, four in Changchun, one in Tayuan, and one in Shandong.<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1993 – China Falun Gong (中国法轮功), the first major instructional text by Li Hongzhi, is published by Military Yiwen Press in April. The book sets forth an explanation of Falun Gong's basic cosmology, moral system, and exercises. A revised edition is released in December of the same year.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=zeng />
*1993 – In the spring and summer of 1993, a series of glowing article appear in Qigong magazines nationwide lauding the benefits of Falun Gong. Several feature images of Li Hongzhi on the cover, and asserting the superiority of the Falun Gong system.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=Penny2012/>
*1993 – The Falun Xiulian Dafa Research Society is established as a branch of the CQRS on 30 July.<ref>James Tong (2002), p. 670.</ref>
*1993 – In August, an organization under ] sends a letter to the CQRS thanking Li Hongzhi for providing his teachings to police officers injured in the line of duty. The letter claimed that of the 100 officers treated by Li, only one failed to experience "obvious improvement" to their health.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=Penny2012/>
*1993 – On Sept 21, The People's Public Security Daily, a publication of the Ministry of Public Security, commends Falun Gong for "promoting the traditional crime-fighting virtues of the Chinese people, in safeguarding social order and security, and in promoting rectitude in society."<ref name=faluninfotime />
*1993 – Li again participates in the Asian Health Expo in Beijing from 11 to 20 Dec, this time as a member of the organizing committee. He wins several awards at the event,<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> and is proclaimed the "Most Acclaimed Qigong Master." Falun Gong also received the "Special Gold Award" and award for "Advancing Frontier Science."<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1994 – The Jilin Province Qigong Science Research Association proclaims Li Hongzhi a "Grandmaster of Qigong" on 6 May.<ref name=zeng />
*1994 – Li gives two lectures on Falun Gong at the ] in Beijing, and contributes profits from the seminars to a foundation for injured police officers.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1994 – On 3 August, the City of Houston, Texas, declares Li Hongzhi an honorary citizen for his "unselfish public service for the benefit and welfare of mankind."<ref name=faluninfotime />
*1994 – As revenues from the sale of his publications grew, Li ceased to charge fees for his classes, and thereafter insists that Falun Gong must be taught free of charge.<ref name=Ownbyfuture />
*1994 – The last full seminar on Falun Gong practice and philosophy takes place from 21 to 29 December in the southern city of Guangzhou.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1995 – ''Zhuan Falun'' (转法轮), the complete teachings of Falun Gong, is published in January by the China Television Broadcasting Agency Publishing Company. A publication ceremony is held in the Ministry of Public Security auditorium on 4 January.<ref name=Ownbyfuture>David Ownby, '']'' (2008) ], p. 89.</ref>
*1995 – In February, Li is approached by the Chinese National Sports Committee, Ministry of Public Health, and China Qigong Science Research Association to jointly establish a Falun Gong association. Li declines the offer.<ref name=Palmer />
*1995 – Official attitudes towards the Qigong movement within some segments of the government begin to change, as criticisms of qigong begin appearing in the state-run press.<ref name=Palmer/>
*1995 – Li leaves China and begins spreading his practice overseas.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/>
*1995 – At the invitation of the Chinese embassy in Paris, Li begins teaching Falun Gong abroad. On 13 March, he gives a seven-day class in Paris, followed by another lecture series in Sweden in April (Gothenburg, Stockholm and Uddevalla).<ref name=Ownbyfuture /><ref name=Penny2012/>


===1996–June 1999===
In April 18 - 24, ] Falun Gong practitioners in Tianjin went to the Tianjin Teacher's College (the publisher of Teenager Expo) and other related organizations to clarify the truth about Falun Gong. Within several days, thousands of Falun Gong practitioners arrived in Tianjin to help clarify the truth.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>
Having announced that he was finished teaching his practice in China, Li Hongzhi begins teaching his practice in Europe, Oceania, North America and Southeast Asia. In 1998, Li relocates permanently to the United States.<ref name=Ownbyfuture />


As the practice continues to grow within China, tensions emerge between Falun Gong and Chinese authorities. In 1996, Falun Gong withdraws from the China Qigong Scientific Research Society, and thereafter finds itself the subject of growing scrutiny and criticism in the state-run press.<ref name=Palmer/><ref name=Porter/> The practice becomes a subject of high-level debates within the government and CCP, with some ministries and government authorities expressing continued support for the practice, and others becoming increasingly wary of the group.<ref name=Palmer/><ref name=Tong/> This tension also played out in the media, as some outlets continued to laud the effects of Falun Gong, while others criticized it as pseudoscience.<ref name=Penny2012/>
In April 23 - 24, 1999 The Tianjin Public Security Bureau sent in 300 S.W.A.T. policemen, who used violence and excessive force to disperse Falun Gong practitioners who had gone to the Tianjin Teacher's College to clarify the truth about Falun Gong. The police arrested 45 Dafa practitioners. Some practitioners were injured by the police.<ref name=ChronicleOfMajorEvents/>


Tensions continue to escalate over this period, culminating in a demonstration on 25 April 1999 near the ] government compound, where over ten thousand Falun Gong practitioners gather to request official recognition. Following the event, ], then-CCP general secretary, quietly prepares for the launch of a nationwide campaign to persecute the practice.
Of these protests, an ''Asiaweek'' article reported: “What Falungong does do is besiege opponents, literally. Li Hongzhi's demand that followers 'promote the law' and 'protect the law' seems to foster intolerance of criticism. Believers encircled media organizations in China 77 times over the past few years (and once in Hong Kong) over what they said was unfair coverage.”<ref></ref>
In one of his articles entitled “Digging Out the Roots,” ] discussed the motivations behind the false and damaging media reports, and suggested how practitioners might respond to them:
:Recently, a few scoundrels from literary, scientific, and ''qigong'' circles, who have been hoping to become famous through opposing ''qigong'', have been constantly causing trouble, as though the last thing they want to see is a peaceful world. Some newspapers, radio stations and TV stations in various parts of the country have directly resorted to these propaganda tools to harm our Dafa, having a very bad impact on the public. This was deliberately harming Dafa and cannot be ignored. Under these very special circumstances, Dafa disciples in Beijing adopted a special approach to ask those people to stop harming Dafa—this actually was not wrong. This was done when there was no other way (other regions should not copy their approach). But when students voluntarily approach those uninformed and irresponsible media agencies and explain to them our true situation, this should not be considered wrong.


*1996 – The book Zhuan Falun is listed as a bestseller by Beijing Youth Daily (北京青年报) in January, March, and April.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=faluninfotime />
:What I would like to tell you is not whether this incident itself was right or wrong. Instead, I want to point out that this event has exposed some people. They still have not fundamentally changed their human notions, and they still perceive problems with the human mentality wherein human beings protect human beings. I have said that Dafa absolutely should not get involved in politics. The purpose of this event itself was to help the media understand our actual situation and learn about us positively so that they would not drag us into politics. Speaking from another perspective, Dafa can teach the human heart to be good and it can stabilize society. But you must be clear that Dafa certainly is not taught for these purposes, but rather for cultivation practice.
*1996 – Falun Gong files for withdrawal from the China Qigong Scientific Research Society in March. Li later explains that he had found the state-run CQRS to be more concerned with profiting from qigong than engaging in genuine research.<ref name=Porter/> Li had also apparently rejected a new CQRS policy that mandated that all qigong practices create CCP branches within their organizations.<ref name=Palmer/><ref name=Tong/> Falun Gong is left entirely without government oversight or sanction.<ref>Danny Schechter, Falun Gong's Challenge to China, p. 66.</ref>
*1996 – At Li's direction, administrators of the Falun Gong Research Association of China apply for registration with three other government organizations, including the ] and ]. All applications are ultimately denied.<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 248</ref>
*1996 – The first major state-run media article criticizing Falun Gong appears in the '']'' newspaper on 17 June. The article writes that Falun Gong represents a manifestation of feudal superstition, and that its core text Zhuan Falun is a work of "pseudo-science" that swindles the masses.<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 249</ref> Falun Gong practitioners responded to the article's publication with a letter-writing campaign to the newspaper and national qigong association.<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1996 – Several Buddhist journals and magazines start to write articles criticizing Falun Gong as a "heretical sect".<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 262</ref>
*1996 – On 24 July, Falun Gong books are banned from further publication by the China News Publishing Bureau, a branch of the CCP ]. The reason cited for the ban is that Falun Gong is "spreading superstition." Pirated and copied versions of Falun Gong books proliferate, with Li Hongzhi's approval.<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 180</ref>
*1996 – Li begins another international lecture tour in the summer of 1996, traveling to Hong Kong, Sydney, Bangkok, Houston, New York, and Beijing.<ref name=Ownbyfuture />
*1996 – The China Qigong Scientific Research Society issues a resolution on the cancellation of Falun Gong's membership with the society. The resolution stated that although practitioners of Falun Gong had "attained unparalleled results in terms of fitness and disease prevention," Li Hongzhi "propagated theology and superstition," failed to attend association meetings, and departed from the association's procedures.<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1997 – The Ministry of Public Security launches an investigation into whether Falun Gong should be deemed xie jiao ("heretical religion"). The report concludes that "no evidence has appeared thus far."<ref name="Palmer 2007, p. 265">Palmer 2007, p. 265</ref>
*1997–1999 – Criticism of Falun Gong escalates in state-run media. With the encouragement of Li, Falun Gong practitioners respond to criticisms by peacefully petitioning outside media offices seeking redress against perceived unfair reporting. The tactic succeeds frequently, often resulting in the retraction of critical articles and apologies from the news organizations.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> Not all media coverage was negative in this period, however, and articles continued to appear highlighting Falun Gong's health benefits.<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1998 - On 13 January, the China Buddhist Association held a meeting on how to react to Falun Gong.<ref name=Palmer/>
*1998 – On 21 July, the Ministry of Public Security issues Document No. 555, "Notice of the Investigation of Falun Gong." The document asserts that Falun Gong is an "evil religion," and mandates that another investigation be launched to seek evidence of the conclusion. The faction hostile toward Falun Gong within the ministry was reportedly led by ].<ref name=Palmer/> Security agencies began monitoring and collecting personal information on practitioners;<ref name=Tong/> Falun Gong sources reported authorities were tapping phone lines, harassing and tailing practitioners, ransacking homes, and closing down Falun Gong meditation sessions.<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1998 – According to Falun Gong sources, ], the former Chairman of the ], lead his own investigation into Falun Gong and concluded that "Falun Gong has hundreds of benefits for the Chinese people and China, and does not have one single bad effect."<ref name=Penny2012/><ref name="Palmer 2007, p. 265"/>
*1998 – China's National Sports Commission launches its own investigation in May, and commissions medical professionals to conduct interviews of over 12,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Guangdong province. 97.9 percent of respondents say Falun Gong improved their health.<ref name="Palmer"/> By October the investigation concludes, noting "We're convinced the exercises and effects of Falun Gong are excellent. It has done an extraordinary amount to improve society's stability and ethics. This should be duly affirmed."<ref name=faluninfotime />
*1998 – Estimates provided by the State Sports Commission suggest there are upwards of 60 to 70 million Falun Gong practitioners in China.<ref>Seth Faison, "," New York Times, 27 April 1999; Joseph Kahn, "," New York Times, 27 April 1999; Renee Schoff, "Growing group poses a dilemma for China," Associated Press, 26 April 1999.</ref>
*1999 – Li Hongzhi continues to teach Falun Gong internationally, with occasional stops in China. By early 1999, Li had lectured in Sydney, Bangkok, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Hong Kong, Taipei, Frankfurt, Toronto, Singapore, Geneva, Houston and New York, as well as in Changchun and Beijing.<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1999 – Wu Shaozu, An official from China's National Sports Commission, says in an interview with U.S. News & World Report on 14 February that as many as 100 million may have taken up Falun Gong and other forms of qigong. Wu notes that the popularity of Falun Gong dramatically reduces health care costs, and "Premier Zhu Rongji is very happy about that."<ref>"An opiate of the masses?," U.S. News & World Report, 22 February 1999.</ref><ref name=rn>Phillip Adams, , Late Night Live, Radio National Australia</ref>
*1999 – In April, physicist He Zuoxiu from the Chinese Academy of Sciences publishes an article in Tianjin Normal University's Youth Reader magazine criticizing Falun Gong as superstitious and potentially harmful for youth and stating that he knew someone who died because of it.<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 266</ref> At that time, some countries near China had people practicing, like Vietnam.<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://moitruongphapluancongvn.org|title=Trang chủ {{!}} Việt Nam {{!}} Sự thật môi trường Pháp Luân Công|website=Trang chủ {{!}} Việt Nam {{!}} Sự thật môi trường Pháp Luân Công|language=en|access-date=2018-08-30}}</ref>
*1999 – Tianjin Falun Gong practitioners respond to the article by peacefully petitioning in front of the editorial offices. Editors initially agree to publish a retraction of the He Zuoxiu article, then renege.<ref>Palmer 2007, pp. 266-267</ref>
*1999 – On 23 April, some 300 security forces are called in to break up ongoing Falun Gong demonstration. Forty-five Falun Gong practitioners are beaten and detained.<ref name=gutmannfuyou>Ethan Gutmann, An Occurrence on Fuyou Street, ''National Review'' 13 July 2009</ref><ref name="Schechter 2000, p.69">Schechter (2000), p.69</ref>
*1999 – Falun Gong practitioners petition Tianjin City Hall for the release of the detained practitioners. They are reportedly told that the order to break up the crowd and detain protesters came from central authorities in Beijing, and that further appeals should be directed at Beijing.<ref name=gutmannfuyou /><ref name="Schechter 2000, p.69"/>


] government compound in April 1999 to request official recognition.]]
:Dafa has created a way of existence for the lowest level, mankind. Then, among various types of human behavior within the human form of existence at this level, which include collectively presenting facts to someone, and so forth, aren’t these one of the numerous forms of existence that Dafa gives to mankind at the lowest level? It is just that when humans do things, good and evil coexist. Thus, there are struggles and politics. Under extremely special circumstances, however, Dafa disciples adopted that approach from the Fa at the lowest level, and they completely applied their good side. Wasn’t this an act that harmonized the Fa at the level of mankind? Except under special extreme circumstances, this type of approach is not to be adopted.<ref></ref>


*1999 – On 25 April 10,000–20,000 Falun Gong practitioners quietly assemble outside the Central Appeals Office, adjacent to the Zhongnanhai leadership compound in Beijing. Five Falun Gong representatives meet with Premier ] to request official recognition and an end to escalating harassment against the group. Zhu agrees to release the Tianjin practitioners, and assures the representatives that the government does not oppose Falun Gong. The same day, however, at the urging of Luo Gan, CCP general secretary Jiang Zemin issues a letter stating his intention to suppress the practice.<ref>Tong (2009), pp. 3–10</ref>
This article was written one month after the group had held a protest against the Beijing TV station; the “special approach” refers to the protest. On May 27, 1998 — twelve days after the China Central TV, China's largest network, had aired a positive coverage of the group — the local Beijing TV station broadcast a program in which a professor of China's Academy of Science disparaged the group, calling it a "cult." Under pressure, the TV station fired the 24-year-old reporter involved and broadcast a favorable report about the group a few days later.<ref></ref>
*1999 – On 26 April, Jiang Zemin convenes a meeting of the Politburo Standing Committee to discuss the Falun Gong demonstration. Some Politburo members reportedly favored a conciliatory position towards Falun Gong, while others – such as Jiang and security czar Luo Gan – favored a decisive suppression of the group.<ref name=Zong>Zong Hairen, Zhu Rongji in 1999, (Ming Jing, 2001), pp. 60–61.</ref>
*1999 – Authorities increased surveillance on Falun Gong, tapping telephones of practitioners and monitoring practitioners in several cities.<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1999 – On 2 May, Li Hongzhi gives a press conference to journalists in Sydney, Australia. When asked by a reporter whether he believed the government would kill or imprison his disciples to maintain social order, Li responded that " practitioners will never go against the law. In terms of the scenario you describe, I don't think it will happen. since the economic reform and opening up, the Chinese government has been quite tolerant in this respect."<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1999 – In May and June, just as preparations are quietly underway for a crackdown, Falun Gong practitioners continue their public meditation sessions.<ref name=Penny2012/> The Far Eastern Economic Review wrote "in a park in western Beijing, 100 or so Falun Gong practitioners exercised under a bold yellow banner proclaiming their affiliation... far from running scared."<ref>Susan V. Lawrence, "Religion: Pilgrim's Protest," Far Eastern Economic Review, 13 May 1999.</ref>
*1999 – On 2 June, Li purchases space in several Hong Kong newspapers to publish an article defending Falun Gong, and urging Chinese leaders not to "risk universal condemnation" and "waste manpower and capital" by antagonizing the group.<ref name=Penny2012/><ref>Li Hongzhi, , 2 June 1999.</ref>
*1999 – On 3 June, 70,000 practitioners from Jilin and ] travel to Beijing in an attempt to appeal to authorities. They were intercepted by security forces, sent home, and placed under surveillance.<ref name=Penny2012/><ref>Sing Tao Jih Pao, "Police Break Up Falun Gong Gathering of 70,000 in Beijing," 7 June 1999.</ref>
*1999 – On 7 June 1999, Jiang Zemin convened a meeting of the ] to address the Falun Gong issue. In the meeting, Jiang described Falun Gong as a grave threat to CCP authority – "something unprecedented in the country since its founding 50 years ago"<ref name=Jamestown>Sarah Cook and Leeshai Lemish, , China Brief, Volume 11 Issue 17 (9 November 2011).</ref> – and ordered the creation of a special leading group within the party's ] to "get fully prepared for the work of disintegrating ."<ref name=Jamestown/>
*1999 – On 10 June, the ] was formed to handle day-to-day coordination of the anti-Falun Gong campaign. Luo Gan was selected to helm of the office, whose mission at the time was described as studying, investigating, and developing a "unified approach...to resolve the Falun Gong problem"<ref name=Tong>James Tong, '']'', ] (2009).</ref> The office was not created with any legislation, and there are no provisions describing its precise mandate.<ref name=Jamestown/>
*1999 – On 17 June 1999, On 17 June, Jiang Zemin declared in a Politburo meeting that Falun Gong is "the most serious political incident since the '4 June' political disturbance in 1989."<ref name=Zong/> The 610 Office came under the newly created Central Leading Group for Dealing with Falun Gong, headed by ]. Both Li and Luo were members of the ], and the four other deputy directors of the Central Leading Group also held high-level positions in the CCP, including minister of the propaganda department.<ref name=Tong/>
*1999 – On 26 June, thirteen Falun Gong exercise sites in public parks are shut down by Beijing security officials.<ref name=Penny2012/>


===July 1999–2001 ===
In Switzerland, 1998, Li Hongzhi said: "Not so long ago, when a television station broadcast a groundless report on us and we went to meet with them, everyone talked to them rationally and with goodwill. A lot of people went there that time, but having a large number of people didn’t necessarily make it a bad incident. The attitude and approach that people adopt can be good or bad. They explained things with reason and in an entirely kind way. They didn’t get involved in the nation’s political issues, nor did they damage public property. Everyone managed to act like a cultivator and explain our reasoning. People were moved because they had never met people like that."<ref></ref>
] following the ban]]


In July 1999, a nationwide campaign is rolled out to "eradicate" Falun Gong. The persecution campaign is characterized by a "massive propaganda campaign" against the group, public burnings of Falun Gong books, and imprisonment of tens of thousands of Falun Gong practitioners in prisons, reeducation through labor camps, psychiatric hospitals and other detention facilities. Authorities are given the broad mandate of 'transforming' practitioners, resulting in the widespread use of torture against Falun Gong practitioners, sometimes resulting in death.
==Zhongnanhai demonstration and aftermath==
On the morning of ] ], more than ten thousand Falun Gong practitioners and/or supporters were directed by police to surround ], where top Chinese leaders both live and work. They stayed in silence for 12 hours, reading and meditating, in protest of the mass arrests and beatings of practitioners in Tianjin city, at the same time seeking legal status and protection of the practice. Premier Zhu Rongji met with some representatives of the practitioners and after the arrested practitioners were released, the protesters dispersed.<ref name="Rutgers03">Smith, Chrandra D. (] ]) , '''', retreived ] ]</ref> Nevertheless, it was reported that Falun Gong practitioners organizing a protest alarmed many senior leaders, particularly ].<ref name="ReidG"/> According to some estimates, at this time there were more than 100,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Beijing.<ref name="ReidG"/> This protest immediately brought Falun Gong and its founder, Li Hongzhi, to the attention of the central government of China, as well as to that of the world. After three months, on ] ], the persecution of Falun Gong was officially started by the Chinese government, which again attracted a great deal of media attention around the world.


From late 1999 to early 2001, hundreds of Falun Gong practitioners per day travel to Tiananmen Square to stage peaceful protests against the persecution. The protests take the form of performing Falun Gong exercises or meditation, or holding banner proclaiming Falun Gong's innocence. The protests are broken up, often violently, by security forces.
] wrote in September 1999: "After April 25, the government went into a panic. As Robert Thurman, the renowned Buddhism scholar at Columbia University, says, Falun Gong had "scared the hell out of them." So the regime "went nuts," revealing its weakness and self-doubt for all the world to see. According to reports, President Jiang Zemin in particular is worried about Falun Gong, even obsessed with it. On the fateful day, he asked to be driven around the Zhongnanhai in his limousine, to stare at the throng through tinted windows. That night, seemingly in the grip of a spiritual crisis, he wrote to the Politburo: "I believe Marxism can triumph over Falun Gong." He mutters incessantly to Western envoys about the troublesome movement."<ref>National Review, 27. September 1999, Vol. 51 Issue 18, p. 26</ref>


*1999 – During a 19 July meeting of senior CCP cadres, Jiang Zemin's decision to eradicate Falun Gong was announced. The campaign was originally intended to have begun on 21 July, but as the document was apparently leaked, the crackdown started on 20 July.<ref name=Penny2012/> A nationwide propaganda campaign is launched to discredit Falun Gong.<ref>Tong 2009, p. 44</ref>
Julia Ching refers to an article that was published in ] in July 1999<ref>World Journal, American edition, June 20, 1999</ref>, stating that the Zhongnanhai demonstrations might have been organized in part by the government "to help trump up charges against Falun Gong which it had observed and monitored for years through its infiltrators. It even gives the name of a high official, Gan, as being the chief Communist organizer of the Zhongnanhai gathering. As secretary general of the State Council, had been investigating Falun Gong and had wanted it banned since 1996 but could not find any legal basis for transgression. In that case, it is not certain where the Falun followers intended first to make their petition, but had the police direct them to Zhongnanhai, in order to create an incident with which they afterwards could be charged."<ref>American Asian Review, Vol. XIX, no. 4, Winter 2001, p. 12</ref> The practitioners have said that they wanted to make a peaceful appeal at the citizens' appeal office, located at Fuyou street, near Zhongnanhai.
*1999 – Just after midnight on 20 July, Falun Gong practitioners and "assistants" are abducted and detained across numerous cities in China.<ref name=dangerous>{{cite book |first=Mickey |last=Spiegel |url=http://hrw.org/reports/2002/china/ |title=Dangerous Meditation: China's Campaign Against Falungong |publisher=Human Rights Watch |year=2002 |isbn=1-56432-270-X|access-date=28 September 2007}}</ref> In response, tens of thousands of practitioners petition local, provincial and central appeals offices.<ref name=Penny2012/> In Beijing and other cities, protesters are detained in sports stadiums.<ref name=dangerous/>
*1999 – On 22 July, The Ministry of Civil Affairs declared the "Research Society of Falun Dafa and the Falun Gong organization under its control" to be unregistered, and therefore illegal, organizations.<ref name=Tong/> The same day, the Ministry of Public Security issues a notice prohibiting 1) the display of Falun Gong images or symbols; 2) the public distribution of Falun Gong books or literature; 3) assembling to perform group Falun Gong exercises; 4)using sit-ins, petitions, and other demonstrations in defense of Falun Gong; 5) the spreading of rumors meant to disturb social order; and 6) taking part in activities opposing the government's decision.<ref name=Penny2012/>
*1999 – The 19 July circular is released publicly on 23 July.<ref name=Tong/> In it, Falun Gong is declared the "most serious political incident" since 1989. The ] forbids party members from practicing Falun Gong, and launches study sessions to ensure cadres understand that Falun Gong is incompatible with the belief system of ].<ref name=dangerous/>
*1999 – on 26 July, the authorities begin the process of confiscating and destroying all publications related to Falun Gong, including "books, pictures, audio-video products, and electronic publications."<ref name=dangerous/> Within one week, two million copies of Falun Gong literature are confiscated and destroyed by steam-rollers and public ].<ref name=Schechter/><ref name=dangerous/>
*1999 – In late July, overseas Falun Gong websites are hacked or subject to ].<ref name=dangerous/> According to Chinese internet expert Ethan Gutmann, the attacks originated from servers in Beijing and Shenzhen, and was among the first serious attempts at network disruption by China.<ref name=HackerNation>Ethan Gutmann, {{usurped|}}, World Affairs Journal, May/June 2010.</ref>
*1999 – 29 July, Chinese authorities ask ] to seek the arrest of Li Hongzhi. Interpol declines. The following week, Chinese authorities offer a substantial cash reward for the extradition of Li from the United States. The U.S. government similarly declines to follow up.<ref name=dangerous/>
*1999 – On 29 July, the Beijing Bureau of Justice issues a notice requiring all lawyers and law firms to obtain approval before providing consultation or representation to Falun Gong practitioners. According to Human Rights Watch, the notice was "inconsistent with international standards which call on governments to ensure that lawyers are able to perform their professional functions without intimidating hindrance, harassment, or improper interference."<ref name=dangerous/>
*1999 – In October, 30 Falun Gong practitioners hold a secret press conference for foreign media in Beijing to tell of the violence and persecution they are suffering. At the end of the press briefing, participants are arrested, and some of the foreign reporters present are questioned and briefly detained. Ten of the organizers were detained almost immediately afterwards, and one of them, a 31-year-old hairdresser names Ding Yan, is later tortured to death in custody, according to Falun Gong sources.<ref>Falun Gong Human Rights Working Group, , accessed 04-05-2012</ref> During the press conference, some of the first allegations of Falun Gong torture deaths in custody are made.<ref>Erik Eckholm, "China Sect Members Covertly Meet Press and Ask World's Help," New York Times, 29 October 1999</ref>
*1999 – On 30 October, the ] issues a resolution on article 300 of the criminal code. The resolution elaborates on the identification and punishments for individuals who use "heretical religions" to undermine the implementation of the law.<ref name=AI>Amnesty International, "China: The crackdown on Falun Gong and other so-called 'heretical organizations,'" 23 March 2000</ref>
*1999 – On 5 November 1999, the ] issues a circular giving instruction to the people's courts that Falun Gong should be prosecuted as a 'heretical religion' under article 300.<ref name=dangerous/><ref name=AI/> The notice, sent to all local courts in China, stressed that it was their ''political duty'' to ''severely'' punish Falun Gong, and to handle these cases ''under the leadership of the Party committees.''<ref name=AI/>
*1999 – On 27 December, four high-profile Falun Gong practitioners are put on trial for "undermining the implementation of the law" and illegally obtaining state secrets. They include Beijing engineer and prominent Falun Gong organizer Zhiwen Wang, sentenced to 16 years in prison, and Li Chang, an official of the Ministry of Public Security, sentenced to 18 years.<ref name=AI/> According to ], in these prosecutions and others, "the judicial process was biased against the defendants at the outset and the trials were a mere formality."<ref name=AI/>
*2000 – During Lunar New Year celebrations in early February, at least 2,000 Falun Gong practitioners are detained on Tiananmen Square while attempting to peacefully protest the ban against the group.
*2000 – On 20 April, '']'' reporter ] publishes the first article in a series on Falun Gong. The article details the torture death of 58-year-old grandmother in ] city, who was beaten, shocked, and forced to run barefoot through the snow because she refused to denounce Falun Gong. Johnson went on to win the 2001 ] for the series.<ref>Ian Johnson, , Wall Street Journal, 20 April 2000.</ref>
*2000 – On 21 April, ] admits for the first time the difficulty the Central authorities have had in stamping out Falun Gong, noting that since "22 July 1999, Falun Gong members have been causing trouble on and around Tiananmen Square in Central Beijing nearly every day."<ref>"China Admits Banned Sect Is Continuing Its Protest" Elisabeth Rosenthal. New York Times, 21 April 2000</ref>
*2000 – Zhao Ming, a graduate student at Ireland's Trinity College, is sent to the Tuanhe ] in Beijing in May. He spends two years in the camp amidst international pressure for his release, and is reportedly tortured with electric batons.<ref>Irish Times, 3 March 2002</ref>
*2000 – On 1 October, thousands of Falun Gong practitioners travel to Tiananmen Square to stage protests against the persecution. Foreign media correspondents witness security officers beating and practitioners on the square.<ref>Washington Post Foreign Service, "Falun Gong Protests Mar Chinese Holiday," 1 October 2000</ref>
*2000 – In November, Zhang Kunlun, a Canadian citizen and professor of art, is detained while visiting his mother in China and held in a forced labor camp where he reported being beaten and shocked with electric batons. Canadian politicians intervene on his behalf, eventually winning his release to Canada.<ref>Human Rights Watch, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20071101022047/http://china.hrw.org/book/export/html/50332 |date=1 November 2007 }}, accessed 18 March 2011</ref>
*2001 – On 23 January, five individuals ] on Tiananmen Square. State-run media claim they are Falun Gong practitioners, driven to suicide by the practice. Falun Gong sources deny involvement, saying that Falun Gong forbids suicide and violence, and arguing that the event was staged by the government to turn public opinion against the practice.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=Schechter/> Authorities seize on the event to escalate a media campaign against the group, and support for Falun Gong wanes.<ref name=Pomfret/>
*2001 – As sympathy for Falun Gong erodes in Mainland China, authorities for the first time openly sanction the "systematic use of violence" against the group, establishing a network of brainwashing classes and rooting out Falun Gong practitioners "neighborhood by neighborhood and workplace by workplace."<ref name=Pomfret>John Pomfret and Philip P. Pan. "Torture is Breaking Falun Gong." Washington Post, 5 August 2001.</ref>
*2001 – By February, international concern grows over psychiatric abuses committed against Falun Gong practitioners, several hundred of whom had reportedly been held and tortured in psychiatric facilities for refusing to denounce the practice.<ref>Khabir Ahmad, "International concern grows over psychiatric abuses in China", The Lancet, Volume 356, Issue 9233, Page 920, 9 September 2000</ref>
*2001 – On 20 November, a group of 35 Falun Gong practitioners from 12 different countries gathers on Tiananmen Square to meditate under a banner that reads: "Truth, Compassion, Tolerance" – Falun Gong's core moral tenets. They are arrested within minutes, and some are beaten while resisting arrest.<ref>Vancouver Falun Dafa Practitioners' Protest Site, , accessed 19 March 2011</ref>
*2001 – On 23 December, a New York District Court hands down a default judgement against Zhao Zhifei, Public Security Bureau chief for Hubei Province, for his role in the wrongful death and torture of Falun Gong practitioners.<ref name="Direct Litigation">Human Rights Law Foundation, {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20111111144251/http://www.hrlf.net/direct.html |date=11 November 2011 }}, accessed 19 March 2011</ref>


===2002–2004 ===
On ], ], the government established the "6-10" office<ref>Morais, Richard C. (] ]), ''Forbes'', retrieved ] ]</ref>, an extra-constitutional body, to facilitate the crackdown. Most political analysts believe that this was the direct result of events that occurred in April 1999.
By 2002, Falun Gong practitioners had all but completely abandoned the approach of protesting on Tiananmen Square, and coverage in Western news outlets declined precipitously.<ref name=lemish>Leeshai Lemish, Media and New Religious Movements: The Case of Falun Gong, A paper presented at The 2009 CESNUR Conference, Salt Lake City, Utah, 11–13 June 2009</ref>{{better source needed|date=December 2019}}


Falun Gong practitioners continued adopting more novel approaches to protesting, including the establishment of a vast network of underground 'material sites' that create and distribute literature,<ref name=dangerous/> and tapping into television broadcasts to replace them with Falun Gong content.<ref>Ethan Gutmann: "The Chinese Internet: A dream deferred?" Tiananmen 20 years on Laogai Research Foundation/NED Panel 1: Refinement of Repression, 9:15 am, 2 June 2009</ref> Practitioners outside China established a television station to broadcast into China, designed censorship-circumvention tools to break through Internet censorship and surveillance, and filed dozens of largely symbolic lawsuits against Jiang Zemin and other Chinese officials alleging genocide and crimes against humanity.<ref name="Direct Litigation"/>
"By unleashing a ]-style movement , Jiang is forcing senior cadres to pledge allegiance to his line," a Communist Party veteran later told ]'s Willy Lam. "This will boost Jiang's authority-and may give him enough momentum to enable him to dictate events at the pivotal 16th Communist Party congress next year."


From 2002 to 2004, the ] of power in China were transferred from Jiang Zemin to ]. Annual Falun Gong deaths in custody continued to grow through 2004, according to reports published by Falun Gong sources, but coverage of Falun Gong declined over the period.<ref name=lemish/>{{better source needed|date=December 2019}}
The Minghui/Clearwisdom website claims that over 3000 Falun Gong practitioners have verifiably died through torture or beating while in police or government custody.<ref>Minghui/Clearwisdom, , retrieved ] ]</ref>


]
These events also saw He Zuoxiu accuse some Falun Gong practitioners of harassment because of the articles he wrote, publishing a book entitled ''How Falun Gong Harassed Me and My Family''. He Zuoxiu is a relative of ], one of the chief perpetrators of the persecution, and he is said to have "become a national hero" for opposing Falun Gong. Noah Porter therefore uspects He Zuoxiu of politically motivated careerism (e.g. , p99).
*2002 – On 14 February, 53 Falun Gong practitioners from North America, Europe and Australia attempt to stage a demonstration on Tiananmen Square. They are detained, and several reportedly assaulted by security forces before being expelled from China.<ref>CNN, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121007090314/http://articles.cnn.com/2002-02-14/world/china.falungong_1_falun-gong-chinese-police-tiananmen-square?_s=PM:asiapcf |date=7 October 2012 }}, 14 February 2002</ref>
*2002 – On 5 March, a group of six Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun city intercept television broadcasts, replacing them with content about Falun Gong and the persecution. Apparently believing that it to be a signal that the ban on Falun Gong had been lifted, citizens gather in public squares to celebrate.<ref name=airwaves/> The Falun Gong broadcasts run for 50 minutes before the city goes black. Over the next three days, security forces arrest some 5,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun. Amnesty International reports that "police 'stop-and-search' checkpoints have reportedly been established across the city." All six individuals involved in the television hijacking are later tortured to death.<ref name=airwaves>Ethan Gutmann, "", Weekly Standard 6 DEC 2010, VOL. 16, NO. 12</ref>
*2002 – In June, Jiang Zemin visits ]. Dozens of Falun Gong practitioners from around the world attempt to travel to the country to protest, but find their names on an international blacklist organized at the behest of Chinese authorities, suggesting extensive espionage against foreign Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Philip Shenon. "Iceland Bars American Falun Gong Followers." New York Times, 15 June 2002. pg. A.7</ref>
*2002 – Falun Gong practitioners in New York establish ], a Chinese-language station created to present an alternative to state-run Chinese media.<ref>Chen, Kathy, , The Wall Street Journal, 15 November 2007</ref>
*2002 – On 24 July, U.S. House of Representatives passes a unanimous resolution (House Concurrent Resolution 188) condemning the persecution of Falun Gong in China.<ref>Clearwisdom.net, "", 19 March 2011</ref>
*2002 – On 21 October, Falun Gong practitioners from North America, Europe and Australia file a legal case against Jiang Zemin, ], and ] to the United Nations Human Rights Committee and the International Criminal Court for their involvement in the persecution of Falun Gong.<ref>Clearwisdom.net, "", accessed 19 March 2011</ref>
*2002 – In November, ] begins the process of taking over China's leadership from Jiang Zemin, assuming the position General Secretary of the CCP.
*2003 – On 22 January, Falun Gong practitioner and American citizen Dr. Charles Lee is arrested by security forces in Nanjing immediately upon his arrival in China. Lee is sentenced to three years in prison.<ref>, 22 July 2004</ref>
*2003 – On 1 May, Pan Xinchun, Deputy Consul General at the Chinese consulate in Toronto, published a letter in the Toronto Star in which he said that local Falun Gong practitioner Joel Chipkar is a member of a "sinister cult." In February 2004, the Ontario Superior Court found Pan liable for libel, and demanded he pay $10,000 in compensation to Chipkar. Pan refused to pay, and left Canada.<ref>John Turley-Ewart, "Falun Gong persecution spreads to Canada," The National Post, 20 March 2004.</ref>
*2003 – June, A San Francisco District Court issues a default ruling against Beijing Party Secretary and former Beijing Mayor Liu Qi and Deputy Governor of Liaoning Province Xia Deren, who had been accused of overseeing the torture of Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Falun Dafa Information Center, "", 20 June 2003</ref>
*2003 – On 26 December, Liu Chengjun, one of the leaders behind the Changchun television broadcasts, is tortured to death while serving out a 19-year prison sentence.<ref name=airwaves />
*2004 – In October, U.S. House of Representatives passed a unanimous resolution detailing and condemning the Chinese government's attempts to interfere with and intimidate Falun Gong practitioners in the United States.<ref>United States Congressional Resolution, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100704174143/http://old.faluninfo.net/displayAnArticle.asp?ID=8960 |date=4 July 2010 }}, 10-6-2004</ref>
*2004 – In December, prominent ] lawyer ] writes to the National People's Congress detailing torture and sexual abuse against Falun Gong practitioners in custody. In response to his letter, Gao's law firm is shut down, his legal license is revoked, and he is put under house arrest.<ref>Gao Zhisheng, "A China More Just: My Fight As a Rights Lawyer in the World's Largest Communist State," Broad Pr U.S.A, 2007</ref>


===2005–2007 ===
On ], ] in Sydney, Australia in an interview with western media Li denied that the Zhongnanhai protest was organized by anyone. He stated: “there was no organization and no formalities, one person would trigger another person's heart, and that's why everyone came.…No one mobilized them, no one told them.”


As Falun Gong becomes more overt in its rhetorical charges against CCP rule, allegations emerge that Chinese security agencies engage in large-scale overseas spying operations against Falun Gong practitioners, and that Falun Gong prisoners in China are killed to supply China's organ transplant industry.
==The media war==


*2005 – On 15 February, Li Hongzhi issues a statement renouncing his earlier membership in the Communist Youth League.
The ]'s nation-wide persecution of Falun Gong began on ], ]. The state-controlled media was used to label the practice an "evil ]" spreading ] to deceive people. Jiang, the former leader of the CPC, condemned the group in the state-controlled media, stating a position the Chinese government promotes to this day. ]
*2005 – On 4 June, Chinese diplomat Chen Yonglin, a political consul at the Chinese consulate in Sydney, defects to Australia. He reports that a large part of his job was to monitor and harass Falun Gong practitioners in Australia. Days later, on 8 June, Hao Fengjun, a former member of the Tianjin city 610 office, goes public with his story of defection, and tells of abuse against Falun Gong in China.<ref name="cyber assault">Gutmann, Ethan. "Hacker Nation: China's Cyber Assault," World Affairs MAY/JUNE 2010</ref>
*2005 – On 16 June, ] is reported tortured to death in Shenyang at the age of 37.<ref>Amnesty International, 27 June 2005</ref>
*2005 – In June, the number of Falun Gong practitioners allegedly killed as a result or torture and abuse in custody exceeds 2,500.<ref>Falun Dafa Information Center, " {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110501233445/http://faluninfo.net/topic/4/ |date=1 May 2011 }}", 17 May 2008</ref>
*2006 – UN special rapporteur on torture ] releases the findings of his 2005 investigation on torture in China. He reports that two-thirds of reported torture cases are against Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Manfred Nowak (2006). "Report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment: MISSION TO CHINA". United Nations. p. 13.</ref>
*2006 – In July 2006, former Canadian Member of Parliament ] and international human rights attorney ] release the findings of their investigation into ]. Although their evidence was largely circumstantial, they conclude that involuntary organ extractions from Falun Gong practitioners are widespread and ongoing. Chinese officials deny the allegations.<ref>David Kilgour and David Kilgour (2007) (in 22 languages)</ref>
*2006 – Falun Gong practitioners in the United States establish ], a classical Chinese dance company that begins touring internationally in 2007.<ref></ref>
*2007 – Falun Gong sources report that the number of persecution deaths exceeds 3,000.<ref name=faluninfotime />
*2007 – August, practitioners of Falun Gong launch the ], which toured to over 35 of countries in 2007 and 2008 ahead of the ].<ref name=Eriksen>Alanah May Eriksen, New Zealand Herald. . 17 December 2007.</ref><ref>The Calgary Herald, {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121107003127/http://www.canada.com/calgaryherald/news/city/story.html?id=4b4fd555-3455-40ba-b594-3cd16aa28624 |date=7 November 2012 }}. 20 May 2008.</ref> The relay was intended to draw attention to a range of human rights issues in China in connection with the Olympics, especially those related to Falun Gong and ], and received support from hundreds of elected officials, past Olympic medallists, human rights groups and other concerned organizations.<ref name=Eriksen/>


=== 2008–2014 ===
Elizabeth J. Perry, writing for ], has described Beijing's use of media in the beginnings stages of the persecution: "For weeks after the campaign began, each night pictures were broadcast of huge piles of Falun Gong materials that had been either voluntarily turned over by practitioners or confiscated in police raids on bookstores and publishing houses. (Interestingly, the People’s Liberation Army Press was responsible for a number of Falun Gong publications.) Some were disposed of in gigantic bonfires, others were recycled. Relatives of Falun Gong victims testified about the terrible tragedies that had befallen their loved ones. Former adherents also began to come forward to explain how they had been hoodwinked by Li Hongzhi and to express regret at their gullibility. Physical education teachers pointed to healthy alternatives to Falun Gong in the form of badminton, ballroom dancing, bowling, and the like. Happy pictures of those who had kicked the Falun Gong habit and were now pursuing more benign varieties of exercise began to flood the evening news. The basic patterns of the government’s offensive were familiar from decades of previous such mobilized suppression efforts, from the anti-rightist campaign of the 1950s to the anti-spiritual pollution campaigns of the 1980s."<ref>Critical Asian Studies 33:2 (2001), p. 173</ref>
Top-level Chinese authorities continue to launch strike-hard campaigns against Falun Gong surrounding sensitive events and anniversaries, and step up efforts to coercively "transform" Falun Gong practitioners in detention facilities and reeducation centers. ] who seek to represent Falun Gong defendants continue to face punishment from Chinese authorities, including harassment, disbarment, and imprisonment.


*2008 – On 6 February, ] 11 days after being taken into custody in Beijing. His wife, artist Xu Na, is sentenced to 3 years in prison for possessing Falun Gong literature.<ref>New York Times, , accessed 19 March 2011</ref>
The CPC claims that the practice has exploited spiritual cultivation to engage its practitioners in seditious politics. They also allege that manipulation via their "lies and fallacies", Falun Gong "caused needless deaths of large numbers of practitioners". "Over 1,000 practitioners died because they followed Li's teachings and refused to seek medical treatment for their illnesses. Several hundred practitioners committed self-mutilation or suicide. Over 30 innocent people were killed by mentally deranged practitioners of "Falun Gong". <ref>http://www.china-embassy.org/eng/zt/ppflg/t263446.htm</ref>


]
House Concurrent Resolution 188 <ref> U.S. Congress (] ]) , ''Library of Congress'', retrieved ] ]</ref> unanimously Passed, by a vote of 420-0, by the United States Congress states:
<blockquote>
"Falun Gong is a peaceful and nonviolent form of personal belief and practice with millions of adherents in the People's Republic of China and elsewhere"
</blockquote>
<blockquote>
"Jiang Zemin's regime has created notorious government '610' offices throughout the People's Republic of China with the special task of overseeing the persecution of Falun Gong members through organized brainwashing, torture, and murder;"
</blockquote>
<blockquote>
"Propaganda from state-controlled media in the People's Republic of China has inundated the public in an attempt to breed hatred and discrimination."
</blockquote>


] scenes in ]]]
[[Image:FalunDafa DestroyBook.jpg|thumb|right|150px| The words on the steamroller read “Smash
Falun Gong’s printed materials to pieces.”]]
In China, the CPC has blocked access to certain sites on the Internet (including this article, see '']''), all Falun Gong Websites and burned Falun Gong's books and materials. In addition, some ] filters are targeting ]s related to the Falun Gong spiritual practice and other dissidents.


*2008 – In the first six months of the year, over 8,000 Falun Gong practitioners are abducted by security forces under the pretext of preventing protests during the Beijing Olympics.<ref>Congressional-Executive Commission on China, {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121212041846/http://www.cecc.gov/pages/annualRpt/annualRpt08/CECCannRpt2008.pdf |date=12 December 2012 }}, 31 October 2008.</ref>
On the other hand, there have been incidents in which China's state-owned television networks were jammed with reports on the persecution of Falun Gong. In addition, a syndicated ] newspaper with worldwide circulation, '']'', is accused of having a pro-Falun Gong platform, mainly because it has been the mouthpiece of much of Falun Gong's claims of suppression and torture, but also partly because it has published articles suggesting a declining state in the CPC. These articles include '''', '''', and others .
*2009 – CCP heir apparent ] is put in charge of ], a strike hard effort to crack down on Tibetans, democracy activists and Falun Gong practitioners around sensitive anniversaries. ] heads a parallel effort to crack down on Falun Gong practitioners, ethnic separatism, and protests.<ref>Ching Cheong. {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120320124326/http://www.hkej.com/template/blog/php/blog_details.php?blog_posts_id=2277 |date=20 March 2012 }}. Singapore Straits Times. 3 March 2009</ref>

*2009 – In March, U.S. House of Representatives passes a resolution on recognizing and condemning the ongoing persecution of Falun Gong in China.<ref>Einhorn, Bruce. "Congress Challenges China on Falun Gong & Yuan", Business Week, 17 March 2010</ref>
According to , eight Falun Gong practitioners were arrested after one of the jamming incidents in Changchun city, including Liu Chengjun, who was allegedly tortured to death after 21 months incarceration in Jilin Prison.
*2009 – On 13 May, ] Zhang Kai(张凯) and Li Chunfu(李春富) are violently beaten and detained in ] for investigating the death of Jiang Xiqing(江锡清), a 66-year-old Falun Gong practitioner killed in a labor camp.<ref>Human Rights in China, , 13 May 2009.</ref>

*2009 – On 4 July, Dalian city lawyer Wang Yonghang(王永航) is taken from his home by security agents, interrogated, and beaten for defending Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Amnesty International. . 28 July 2009</ref> In November 2009, Wang was sentenced in a closed court to seven years in prison for his advocacy on behalf of Falun Gong practitioners. When his lawyers were permitted to see him in January 2010, they reported that he had been tortured.<ref>Congressional Executive Commission on China. , 10 October 2010, p. 104.</ref>
==The Tiananmen Square self-immolation incident==
*2009 – In November, Jiang Zemin and other high-ranking Chinese officials are indicted by a Spanish court on charges of genocide and crimes against humanity for their involvement in the persecution of Falun Gong.<ref>, 14 November 2009</ref> A month later, an Argentine judge concludes that top Chinese officials Jiang Zemin and Luo Gan had adopted a "genocidal strategy" in pursuing the eradication of Falun Gong, and asks Interpol to seek their arrest<ref>Luis Andres Henao, "," 22 December 2009</ref>
{{main|Tiananmen_Square_self-immolation_incident}}
*2010 – Over 100 Falun Gong practitioners in Shanghai are abducted and detained in connection with the Shanghai World Expo. Some reportedly face torture for their refusal to disavow Falun Gong.<ref name=CECC>Congressional Executive Commission on China, , 2010.</ref>
The '''Tiananmen Square self-immolation incident''' was an incident occurring on ], ], in ], ] in which six people engaged in ]. The Communist Party government and media claimed the people to be Falun Gong practitioners; the survivors, too, stating in the presence of state-run media that they were Falun Gong practitioners. Falun Gong denied that those people could have been practitioners, citing parts of the teachings which forbid suicide and killing<ref>, from Zhuan Falun</ref>, at the same time claiming the event was staged by the Chinese government to deceive the public and escalate the persecution. Some third-party commentators have affirmed this version of events, stating that the incident was staged by the government in order to turn public opinion against the practice and to justify and escalate its persecution.
*2010 – In the Spring of 2010, Chinese authorities launch a new, three-year campaign whose goal is to coercively transform large portions of the known Falun Gong population through attendance in reeducation classes.<ref>CECC, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20111202130133/http://www.cecc.gov/pages/virtualAcad/index.phpd?showsingle=154369 |date=2 December 2011 }}, 22 March 2011, accessed 19 March 2011</ref>

*2010 – On 22 April 2010, Beijing lawyers ] and ] were permanently disbarred for defending Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Amnesty International, 05-10-2010</ref>
==Torture Methods==
*2011 – In February, a Falun Gong practitioner named Qin Yueming dies in custody at the Jiamusi Prison. His family state that his body was covered with extensive bruising, with blood in his nose, though authorities said the cause of death was heart attack. A petition seeking redress for his death garners over 15,000 signatures. Qin's wife and daughter are subsequently imprisoned and reportedly tortured for their efforts to draw attention to the case.<ref name=AmnestyQin>Amnesty International, , 22 August 2012.</ref>
Falun Gong related websites, independent organisations monitoring the treatment of Falun Gong by the Chinese government, as well as human rights organisations and other NGOs, have published reports of alleged torture or mistreatment of Falun Gong practitioners by the Chinese government. Along with firsthand accounts of alleged torture or mistreatment, some publications contain compilations of the alleged torture methods used against Falun Gong practitioners. The ''United Nations Reports on China’s Persecution of Falun Gong (2004)'' lists 31 different forms of torture, with multiple variations on each type,<ref>{{Citation | first = United Nations | title = The United Nations Reports on China’s Persecution of Falun Gong (2004)| publisher = The Falun Gong Human Rights Working Group | url = http://flghrwg.net/reports/UN2004/UN2004.pdf | year = 2004}}
*2011 – In May, a lawsuit is filed on behalf of Falun Gong practitioners against ]. The suit alleges, based mainly on internal Cisco documents, that the technology company "designed and implemented a surveillance system for the Chinese Communist Party, knowing it would be used to root out members of the Falun Gong religion and subject them to detention, forced labor and torture."<ref>Terry Baynes, , Reuters, 20 May 2011.</ref>
</ref> while Falun Gong sources have suggested that up to 100 different forms of torture are in use.<ref>{{cite web | title = Norway: Practitioners hold an Anti-Torture Exhibition and Receive Positive Media Coverage (Photos)| publisher = Falun Dafa Clearwisdom.net | url = http://www.clearwisdom.net/emh/articles/2004/8/4/51010.html| date = 2004-08-04 | accessdate = 2007-02-12}}</ref> The main purpose of torture is to have suspected Falun Gong practitioners sign "repentance statements" or statements denouncing the practice, and to have them stop practicing Falun Gong. One variation of some of the torture methods reported as most common are listed below, with some of the similar methods being combined.
*2011 – In Hebei province, 3,000 Chinese citizens sign a petition calling for the release of detained Falungong practitioners Zhou Xiangyang and Li Shanshan, who were being held at the Gangbei Prison and Tangshan reeducation center, respectively.<ref>Amnesty International, , 14 November 2011.</ref>

*2012 – In June 2012, 15,000 people in Heilongjiang Province signed and affixed their fingerprints to a petition requesting that the government investigate the death of Qin Yueming, a Falun Gong practitioner who died in custody.<ref name=AmnestyQin/>
===Shocking with electricity===
*2012 – In early June, Falun Gong practitioner Li Lankui was detained and sent to a reeducation-through-labour camp in Hebei province. Hundreds of villagers mobilized to call for Li's release, including by signing petitions calling for an end to the persecution of Falun Gong. This prompted further crackdowns by security agents, leading to the arrest of at least 16 villagers. Some reported that they were tortured for expressing their support for Li Lankui.<ref>Amnesty International, , 22 October 2012.</ref><ref></ref>
<ref>{{cite web | title = Torture Methods / Burning | publisher = Falun Dafa Information Center.net | url = http://www.faluninfo.net/torturemethods2/burning/| accessdate = 2007-02-12}}</ref>]]
*2012 – in December, a woman in ] finds a letter written in both Chinese and English in a box of Halloween decorations purchased from Kmart. The letter said that the decorations were assembled in Unit 8, Department 2 of ]. It went on to describe forced labor conditions in the camp, and noted that many of the detainees were Falun Gong practitioners being held without trial. The letter's author, a Falun Gong practitioner from Beijing, was later identified by ''The New York Times''.<ref name=NYT61113>{{cite news|title=Behind Cry for Help From China Labor Camp|url=https://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/12/world/asia/man-details-risks-in-exposing-chinas-forced-labor.html|access-date=12 June 2013|newspaper=The New York Times|date=11 June 2013|author=]}}</ref>
The use of electric batons by police officers and prison guards is reported as the most widespread form of torture used against Falun Gong practitioners. The Falun Dafa Information Center claims that the batons carry voltages of up to 300 000 volts, and are used to shock the sensitive areas of practitioners' bodies, such as mouths, centers of the palms, bottoms of the feet, as well as breasts and genitals. Often more than one baton is applied at one time. Police are reported to use homemade versions of these devices, which are more powerful: “The skin will break open and bleed in every place that receives a shock from this device.”<ref>{{cite web | title = Torture Methods / Electric Shock | publisher = Falun Dafa Information Center.net | url = http://www.faluninfo.net/torturemethods2/electric-shock/| accessdate = 2007-02-12}}</ref>
*2013 – Central 610 Office authorities launch a new three-year campaign calling for the ideological "transformation" of Falun Gong practitioners. Local governments issue quotas and targets for the number of Falun Gong practitioners to reeducate, and prescribe the appropriate means for doing so.<ref name=Amnesty2013/>

*2013 – A photojournalism magazine in China publishes an exposé detailing human rights abuses committed by female detainees at the ] in ], where Falun Gong practitioners were estimated to comprise approximately half the detainees. The article was promptly removed from the magazine's website, but not before galvanizing nationwide opposition to and condemnation of the labor camp system. Soon thereafter, New York Times photographer ] releases a documentary on the Masanjia labor camp.<ref name=Amnesty2013/>
===Forced to stand, sit or squat for a long time===
*2013 – Chinese officials begin dismantling the nationwide network of reeducation-through-labour camps, in which Falun Gong practitioners comprised a significant portion of detainees. Human rights groups expressed skepticism at the scope of reforms, however, noting that other forms of extralegal detention were still being used to detain Falun Gong practitioners and political dissidents.<ref name=Amnesty2013>{{cite book|publisher=Amnesty International|title=Changing the soup but not the medicine: Abolishing re-education through labor in China|date=Dec 2013|location=London, UK|url=https://www.amnesty.org/es/documents/asa17/042/2013/es/}}</ref><ref>Freedom House, , January 2015. Quote: "...for Falun Gong practitioners, the abolition of the RTL camp system coincided with an increased use of prison sentences on the one hand, and detention in extra-legal "legal education centers" for forced conversion on the other."</ref>
These are listed in the UN report as three different forms of torture, and each have their own variations. This form of torture is reported to last “for many days”, and is often accompanied by the deprivation of food, sleep, water and use of the toilet. Sometimes, convicted prisoners watch over practitioners during this type of torture. Failure to hold the positions is said to result in being beaten, shocked with electric batons, kicked or slapped. The sitting and squatting forms may result in necrosis in the buttocks, muscle spasms and nerve damage.
*2013 – On 12 December, European Parliament adopts a resolution on organ harvesting in China, where it "Calls for the EU and its Member States to raise the issue of organ harvesting in China"<ref>European Parliament, . Quote: "Expresses its deep concern over the persistent and credible reports of systematic, state‑sanctioned organ harvesting from non-consenting prisoners of conscience in the People's Republic of China, including from large numbers of Falun Gong practitioners imprisoned for their religious beliefs, as well as from members of other religious and ethnic minority groups"</ref>

*2014 – In August, investigative journalist ] publishes his book "The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvesting, and China's Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem," in which he writes that ].<ref>Barbara Turnbull, , Toronto Star, 21 October 2014.</ref><ref>Thomas Nelson, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150206213828/http://iar-gwu.org/content/slaughter-mass-killings-organ-harvestings-and-china%E2%80%99s-secret-solution-its-dissident-problem |date=6 February 2015 }}, International Affairs Review.</ref>
===Burning===
*2014 – Four lawyers in ] are detained and reportedly tortured by the police while investigating abuses against Falun Gong practitioners held at the Qinglongshan farm reeducation centre.<ref>Amnesty International, , 4 April 2014.</ref>
The Falun Dafa Information Center says they have received “numerous reports” of torture in the form of burning. Reported instruments include car lighters, irons, hot metal rods (see image) or cigarettes. The UN report states that the parts of the body targeted by this form of torture include the fingers, toes, faces, nipples and vagina. In some cases, this form of torture is reported to have been used to induce practitioners to state that they will stop practicing Falun Gong.<ref>{{cite web | title = Torture Methods / Burning | publisher = Falun Dafa Information Center.net | url = http://www.faluninfo.net/torturemethods2/burning/| accessdate = 2007-02-12}}</ref> In the case of Wang Huajun, Hubei Province, after being seized for speaking publicly about the Chinese government's alleged persecution of Falun Gong, she was "beaten viciously" by police, and later on the verge of death "...dragged outside of the city hall, drenched in gasoline, and set ablaze."<ref>Ibid.</ref>

===Force-Feeding===
The Falun Dafa information center states that over 10% of all confirmed deaths of Falun Gong practitioners in custody are a result of force feeding torture, and provides a list of the purported confirmed deaths.<ref>{{cite web | title = Force Feeding: A Form of Torture | publisher = Falun Dafa Information Center | url = http://www.faluninfo.net/displayAnArticle.asp?ID=6837| accessdate = 2007-03-08}}</ref> The UN report claims that it is the number one cause of deaths.
Both Faluninfo and the UN report contextualize this activity not as an attempt by police officers to nourish practitioners who have used hunger strikes as a form of protest, but as a form of either punishment or torture.<ref>{{cite web | title = Falun Gong Woman Dies from Force Feeding Torture | publisher = Falun Dafa Information Center | url = http://www.faluninfo.net/DisplayAnArticle.asp?ID=7678| accessdate = 2007-03-08}}</ref> The UN report states that the purpose is “…to punish practitioners and to cause so much pain that they will renounce Falun Gong practice. To that end, the police have used many different means to cause excruciating pain and injury…” Some examples given are: the insertion and withdrawing of feeding tubes in a violent way which leads to death through puncturing the lungs; leaving the feeding tubes in the stomach for prolonged periods; knocking out teeth to enable force-feeding, including use of pliers and crowbars, or boaring holes in the side of the mouth; force-feeding of either salt water, vinegar, straight alcohol, hot pepper oil, boiling water, or urine and feces.

Chinaview, an independent website focused on human rights abuses in China, states that in the Summer of 2003 the Gaoyang Forced Labour Camp was the first to begin force-feeding Falun Gong practitioners with human urine and excrement, and that “…the Chinese government awarded them for this innovation, and sent labour camp staff from around the country to learn this procedure.” <ref>{{cite web | title = Torture Methods 05 / Force-Feeding| publisher = Chinaview | url = http://chinaview.wordpress.com/2007/01/12/photo-china-modern-torture-methods-5-force-feeding/| accessdate = 2007-03-08}}</ref> ]]

===Sexual Abuses===
Amnesty International's ''"Falun Gong Persecution Factsheet"'' lists sexual abuses as one of the forms of torture Falun Gong practitioners are subject to.<ref>{{cite web | title = FALUN GONG PERSECUTION FACTSHEET| publisher = Amnesty International | url = http://www.amnesty.org.nz/web/pages/home.nsf/dd5cab6801f1723585256474005327c8/83fba691f912206bcc2571d3001824ed!OpenDocument | accessdate = 2007-03-08}}</ref> Further details are provided in the UN report and on Falun Gong related websites. One article on Clear Harmony, a Falun Gong website, states that in June 2000 "...eighteen Falun Gong women being held at the Masanjia Labour Camp in Liaoning province were stripped naked and thrown into prison cells with violent male criminals, who were encouraged to rape and abuse the women." The article later asserts that of the over 44,000 documented cases of torture and severe abuse of Falun Gong practitioners in China, many have involved sexual abuse or rape.<ref>{{cite web | title = EFGIC Press Release: Two Falun Gong Women Raped Amid UN Rapporteur Visit | publisher = European Falun Gong Information Centre | url = http://www.clearharmony.net/articles/200512/30200.html | accessdate = 2007-03-08}}</ref> Gao Zhisheng, a prominent Beijing-based human rights lawyer, in his third open letter to the Beijing leadership stated that:
<blockquote>“Among the true accounts of unbelievable brutality, among the records of the government's inhuman torture of its own people, the immoral acts that shocked my soul the most were the lewd yet routine practice of attacking women's genitals by 6-10 Office staff and the police. Almost every woman's genitals and breasts or every man's genitals have been sexually assaulted during the persecution in a most vulgar fashion. Almost all who have been persecuted, be they male or female, were first stripped naked before any torture. No language or words could describe or re-create our government's vulgarity and immorality in this respect. Who with a warm body could afford to stay silent when faced with such truths?”<ref>{{cite web | title = Gao Zhisheng's third open letter to Chinese leaders | publisher = Coalition to Investigate the Persecution of Falun Gong in China | url = http://cipfg.org/en/index.php?news=290 | accessdate = 2007-03-08}}</ref></blockquote>

The UN report provides a list of some of the alleged, female-specific, and sexual violations, including rape and gang rape—sometimes by police officers directly, sometimes by throwing female Falun Gong practitioners into prison cells—forced abortion, pinching or biting off of nipples, sticking needles through the nipples, electric baton shock of nipples and vaginas, rape with bottles or batons, burning the vagina with a cigar, inserting and rotating brushes inside the vagina and inserting hot pepper paste into the vagina. The section concludes with the statement that “This torture has often inflicted permanent psychological and physical damage on the practitioners in question, and on more than one occasion the practitioners have later died under mysterious circumstances.”<ref>{{Citation | first = United Nations | title = The United Nations Reports on China’s Persecution of Falun Gong (2004)| publisher = The Falun Gong Human Rights Working Group | url = http://flghrwg.net/reports/UN2004/UN2004.pdf | year = 2004}}
</ref>

===Miscellaneous===
Some of the other forms of reported torture mentioned in the UN report, human rights websites, or Falun Gong related websites employed to have Falun Gong practitioners renounce the practice, include: suffocation with plastic bags, buckets, or thick, soaked paper; ramming bamboo sticks through the fingernails; beating the buttocks with boards up to hundreds of times; exposure to hemp plants; being hand-cuffed and hung up for prolonged periods; being tied-up and hung up for prolonged periods; various forms of solitary confinement including being locked in a small cell or cage, tied to a board, or put in a water dungeon, all for prolonged periods of time; having icy or boiling water poured over the head (the UN report states this is a “routine” form of torture); forced to stay in extreme weather; various types of deprivation of physiological needs, as well as beatings.

==Psychiatric Abuses==
The Chinese government admits a sharp increase in instances of Falun Gong practitioners being detained in psychiatric facilities, attributing the causes to the alleged harmful effects of Falun Gong practice, at the same time maintaining that all remedial actions have been taken in accordance with the law. Falun Gong sources claim that there are illegal, systematic and widespread abuses of mentally healthy Falun Gong practitioners in psychiatric custody. Some independent writers seek to corroborate the claims of Falun Gong while others dismiss them. A noted writer on the alleged psychiatric abuses of the Chinese government is Robin Munro. Sunny Y. Lu and Viviana B. Galli write in the ''The Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law'' that Munro “…first drew sustained, worldwide attention to the abuses of forensic psychiatry in China in general and of Falun Gong practitioners in particular.” Some third-party commentators, such as Sing Lee and Arthur Kleinman have expressed skepticism and criticism towards Munro’s reports. Lee and Kleinman suggest that Munro may be biased and his sources flawed, and that the profession of psychiatry in China is not severely compromised by the Chinese government's alleged regime of repression, as Munro suggests. Munro responded to these criticisms in the same journal, saying "...nowhere in their critique of my allegations of political psychiatric abuse in China do Lee and Kleinman even attempt to make any substantive rebuttal of the principal evidence I present..."

With regard to allegations of psychiatric abuses of Falun Gong practitioners, the Chinese government has stated that the government’s actions against Falun Gong are carried out in accordance with Chinese law. The Chinese government refers to Falun Gong as a cult, and reports that “The cult has led to more than 650 cases of psychological disorder, with 11 practitioners becoming homicides and 144 others physically disabled.”<ref>{{Citation | title = China Refutes Western Accusations against Falun Gong Crackdown | publisher = People's Daily | url = http://english.peopledaily.com.cn/english/200004/14/eng20000414_38937.html | year = 2000 | accessed = 10th March 2007}}</ref> Ji Shi in his book ''Li Hongzhi and his “Falun Gong”—Deceiving the Public and Ruining Lives'', writes that “According to doctors at the Beijing University of Medical Science, since 1992 the number of patients with psychiatric disorders caused by practicing “Falun Gong” has increased markedly, accounting for 10.2 percent of all patients suffering from mental disorders caused by practicing various ‘’qigong’’ exercises. In the first half of this year the number rose further, accounting for 42.1 percent.”<ref> Ji Shi, “Li Hongzhi and His "Falun Gong" - Deceiving the Public and Ruining Lives”, New Star Publishers, Beijing 1999, p 12</ref>

A report from the Falun Dafa Information Center states that an estimated 1,000 Falun Gong practitioners have been forcefully detained in mental hospitals, with reports of psychological abuses, administration of sedatives or anti-psychotic drugs and torture by electrocution, force-feeding, beating or starvation. It is claimed that practitioners are admitted because they refuse to give up Falun Gong, “...went to the government to appeal for an end to the persecution of Falun Gong, or because they refused to defame Falun Gong's founder, Li Hongzhi, as the authorities demanded.”<ref>{{Citation | title = Falun Gong Practitioners Tortured in Mental Hospitals Throughout China | publisher = Falun Dafa Information Center | url = http://www.faluninfo.net/hrreports/PsychAbuse.pdf | year = | accessed = 10th March 2007}}</ref>

In his article "Judicial Psychiatry in China and its Political Abuses" published in the ''Colombia Journal of Asian Law'', Munro attempts to contextualize the alleges abuses of Falun Gong practitioners in a history of politicization of the psychiatric profession by the Chinese government since the 1950’s.<ref>Robin J. Munro, “Political Psychiatry in Post-Mao China and its Origins in the Cultural Revolution”, MA J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 30:97–106, 2002. p 109</ref> He suggests that many outside observers find the Chinese government’s “…continuing campaign against the Falun Gong to be closely reminiscent of the kinds of extreme and unbridled political campaigns waged by the Party during the Cultural Revolution.”<ref> Ibid., Munro, 2002, p 109 </ref> And that “Since the latter part of 1999… it has become abundantly clear that religious sectarians also now also form a major target of politically repressive psychiatry in China.” <ref>Ibid., Munro, 2002, p 106</ref> He later adds more specifically that “The most distinctive aspect of the government’s protracted campaign to crush the Falun Gong, aside from its sheer scope and brutality, has been the flood of reports… indicating that large numbers of the group’s detained practitioners were being forcibly sent to mental hospitals by the security authorities.”

Lu and Galli in their study entitled "Psychiatric Abuse of Falun Gong practitioners in China" give a similar portrayal of the alleged psychiatric abuses by the Chinese government:<blockquote>Using mental hospitals as places of government-directed torture in China had been in a steady decline in the 1990s, but the government of Jiang Zemin resurrected this practice as part of a comprehensive and brutal campaign to “eradicate” Falun Gong. The political abuse of psychiatry by the Soviet Union was aimed at political dissenters and nonconformists, but Falun Gong practitioners are neither political nor nonconformists.”<ref>Sunny Y. Lu, MD, PhD, and Viviana B. Galli, MD, “Psychiatric Abuse of Falun Gong Practitioners in China”, J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 30:126–30, 2002, p 124</ref></blockquote>

Munro describes some of the common abuses detained practitioners are reported to receive, such as being drugged with various unknown kinds of medication, kept in dark rooms for prolonged periods of time, subjected to electro-convulsive therapy or painful forms of electrical acupuncture treatment, denial of adequate food and water, restricted access to toilet facilities, and forced confessional statements renouncing belief in Falun Gong (as a condition of eventual release, followed by fines of several thousand yuan for their stay).<ref> Ibid., Munro, 2002, p 107 </ref> Lu and Galli include in their list of alleged abuses: medications forcefully administered through nasogastric tubes as a form of torture or punishment, increases in medication dosages of up to five or six times, and physical torture including binding tightly with ropes in very painful positions. They also go on to describe some of the effects of this treatment, including the toxic effects of various drugs, chemicals or other unknown substances: loss of memory, migraines, extreme weakness, protrusion of the tongue, rigidity, loss of consciousness, vomiting, nausea and seizures. They write that medical staff are reported to deal with practitioners violently, reported comments including phrases such as “Aren’t you practicing Falun Gong? Let us see, which is stronger, Falun Gong or our medicines?”<ref>Ibid., Lu and Galli, 2002, p. 128</ref>

Munro gives an account of the case of Tan Guihua, a 42 year old female from Shandong Province:

<blockquote>On September 12, 1999, Tan went home after appealing in Beijing for the Falun Gong. Before she could sit down, some officers from her work unit and the Politics and Law Commission broke into her home and took her to the mental hospital.</blockquote>

<blockquote>The officers dragged her into the mental hospital by force. By then, they had already prepared a big dose of injection and planned to give her the shot as soon as she arrived. Tan refused to take the injection. A tall nurse then went out and brought back eight mental patients. They pressed her down and gave her the injection. In only a few seconds, she began to feel faint and sick. Her heart started to beat extremely fast. She had to press her head against the wall and hold the ground firmly with both hands. While in great pain, she bit down tightly on the comforter in her mouth and tried not to make any noise. Her mouth bled from the biting. She then lost consciousness. She did not feel better until the effects of the drug gradually abated.</blockquote>
<blockquote>
Later, a female doctor asked Tan daily whether she would continue to practice Falun Gong. Tan said "yes," and the doctor then shocked her with electrical needles. She was shocked in this way altogether seven times. Meanwhile, she had been force-fed medicines and given injections three times a day. She spent two months in the hospital like this.</blockquote>

<blockquote>Later, the female doctor asked a nurse named Ma to give her another kind of injection. It was said to be some kind of imported medicine, and the drug effect would last for over one month. After that injection, Tan's period stopped coming. Her eyeballs couldn't move and she became slow in reacting to things. A few days later, they added another medicine to the injection. After this shot, Tan shook all over violently and couldn't even hold the bowl. She was tortured like this for 20 days. When her family members finally picked her up, she was all muddleheaded and could not see things clearly. Her mind was totally blank and could not recall things for a long period. Her whole body was puffy. Her eyes looked dull. Her reactions became slow, and it took a long time for her to say a single word.<ref>Ibid., Munro, 2002, p 110</ref></blockquote>

Lu and Galli write that not long after the crackdown began, government agents, police, and sometimes family members of practitioners began forcing mentally healthy Falun Gong practitioners into psychiatric facilities. With no formal legal procedures for commitment, local police officers and members of the 610 office have the power to arbitrarily commit Falun Gong practitioners to psychiatric institutions--while lengths of detention may range from days to years. Lu and Galli state that “The perversion of mental health facilities for the purpose of the torture of Falun Gong practitioners is widespread.”<ref>Ibid., Lu and Galli, 2002, p 126</ref> Lu and Galli claim that the targets come from all tiers of society, including physicians, nurses, judges, military personnel, police officers and school teachers, and that diagnoses range from obsessive-compulsive disorder, “mental problems induced by superstition”, “qigong-induced mental disorder”, or as Munro points out, the revised “hyperdiagnosis” of “evil cult-induced mental disorder” (''xie-jiao suo zhi jingshen zhang’ai'')--which he describes as a throwback to the model found in Soviet forensic psychiatry. Munro describes this as a “politically opportunistic new diagnosis,” with the Chinese government effectively issuing the “health warning”: “Spiritual or religious beliefs banned on political grounds can drive people mad.”<ref>Ibid., Munro, 2002, p 105 </ref>

Lu and Galli write that in cases where hospitals know that the persons to be committed do not have any mental illness and therefore express reluctance to admit them, the government, through police pressure, often forces them to commit the practitioners. These involuntary commitments are because the individuals practice Falun Gong, pass out flyers against the government suppression, otherwise appeal to the government, refuse to renounce Falun Gong, or write petition letters. It is also claimed that the Chinese government uses extreme measures to prevent any investigation of the alleged psychiatric abuses. Lu and Galli cite: threats or bribes towards family members, summary cremation of victims' bodies, detainment of anyone else who knows the truth or will talk about it to western media, censorship of the internet, restricted access for western media, blocking attempts at investigations by international organizations such as Amnesty International, and detaining, harassing, deporting or revoking the licenses of journalists.<ref>Ibid., Lu and Galli, 2002, p 128</ref>

Dr. Arthur Kleinman and Dr. Sing Lee from Harvard Medical School, long-time researchers on various psychiatric topics in China since 1978,{{Fact|date=May 2007}} both have had experience with patients suffering from “Qigong-induced mental disorder”.{{Fact|date=May 2007}} Partly in response to Munro’s suggestion that the term “qigong-induced mental disorder” may be in part a politicized, misused term to advance the Chinese government’s regime of suppression, they state that “In the scientific community, controlled phenomenologic, treatment, and outcome studies have been published in the past two decades that support the disease validity of qigong-related mental disorder…” And, go on to state that in international psychiatry this illness would be recognized as “…a specific type of brief reactive psychosis or as the precipitation of an underlying mental illness, such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or posttraumatic stress disorder.” <ref>Sing Lee, MB, BS, and Arthur Kleinman, MD, “Psychiatry in its Political and Professional Contexts: A Response to Robin Munro”, J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 30:120–5, 2002, p 122</ref>

Lee and Kleinman state that “…Falun Gong is one of many kinds of qigong that share certain similarities, such as the attainment of a trance state, patterned bodily posture or movement…”, the practice of which could induce mental illnesses in some of its practitioners. As part of Lee’s research in China in 1997 she reports interviewing a 54-year-old housewife who had practiced Falun Gong for two years. Before recounting the case directly, Lee narrates that “…the trance state and the spontaneous bodily movement that the practice brought about enthralled her.”—notwithstanding that the references to a “trance state” and “spontaneous bodily movement” are not consistent with the teachings of Falun Gong which state “…You cannot be in a trance or lose yourself when practicing…”<ref>{{Citation | title = Falun Gong | author = Li Hongzhi | publisher = falundafa.org | url = http://www.falundafa.org/book/eng/pdf/flg_en.pdf | year = Updated April 2001| accessed = 10th March 2007 p 49}}</ref> and that “Your Main Consciousness should govern you at all times as you do the exercises.”<ref>Ibid., Li Hongzhi, 2001, p 49</ref>

Despite this, Lee recounts that the patient started to find that her body moved in ways that were no longer under her control, and that: <blockquote>“She thought that these movements “talked” to her, sometimes by writing through her hand, telling her that continuous practice of Falun Gong could transform her into a Buddha. That she was plump and had long earlobes, resembling the popular appearance of a Buddha, convinced her that this possibility was real. In due course, however, she was frightened because the movements began to tell her to die by not eating and by taking an overdose of pills. She believed she was possessed by a shapeless fox spirit a thousand years old that required her body to turn into a real Buddha. She became an insomniac, restless, and distressed. Her distraught family members took her to a psychiatric hospital where she initially resisted treatment because she did not think that she was mentally ill but was only having a paranormal experience… Subsequently, she stayed in the hospital for one month and gradually recovered with antipsychotic drug treatment. She accepted the advice of her doctor that she had a sensitive disposition that was not suited for practicing qigong and stopped the Falun Gong altogether. She knew of many middle-aged people who practiced and derived benefit from Falun Gong for health reasons and loneliness after retirement. But she also heard about some who died by self-induced starvation or suicide as they attempted to ascend to the Falun heaven.” <ref> Ibid., Lee and Kleinman, 2002, p 123</ref></blockquote>

In responding to Munro’s report, Lee and Kleinman state that “Much of his argument about the political abuse of psychiatry in China is based on unconfirmed allegations, many from human rights groups with their own axes to grind, and others from the Falun Gong religious cult, which, whatever we think of it, we must remember is engaged in a nasty political struggle with the Chinese state.”<ref> Ibid., Lee and Kleinman, 2002, p 120</ref> And that "Munro has based his essay entirely on indirect accounts
and unconfirmed reports from sources that are clearly biased."<ref>Lee and Kleinman, 2002, p 122</ref> They express their dissatisfaction that “We are not convinced by Munro’s argument that the Chinese government uses mental hospitals rather than the much cheaper regular prisons to detain Falun Gong practitioners because of the need for ‘self-justificatory vanity’ and ‘international prestige’”<ref> Ibid., Lee and Kleinman, 2002, p 124</ref> and also reject the assertion of both Munro and Lu & Galli that the modern Chinese psychiatric profession has become implicated in the Communist Party’s political agenda, citing personal anecdotes that “...during informal discussions regarding the Falun Gong, a number of Chinese psychiatrists whom we know of have expressed strongly the view that professional practice and politics should be separated, a phenomenon that was barely possible during the Maoist era.”<ref> Ibid., Lee and Kleinman, 2002, p 124</ref> They also caution Munro against “…creating a witch hunt that attributed to the profession as a whole the misuses and abuses of what may well turn out to be only a small number of practitioners.”<ref> Ibid., Lee and Kleinman, 2002, p 124</ref>

In his response to Lee and Kleinman, Munro responds to the claim that he “…based his essay entirely on indirect accounts and unconfirmed reports from sources that are clearly biased”, by saying:

<blockquote>“The overwhelming majority of the evidence I have publicly presented on this question to date consists of facts, commentary, and survey material written and compiled by Chinese psychiatrists and law-enforcement officers themselves, all of it published in China’s officially authorized professional literature over the past few decades. In what plausible sense can such material credibly be characterized as “indirect,” “unconfirmed,” and “clearly biased”? (Lee and Kleinman regularly cite this same scholarly psychiatric literature from China in their own published work.) Above all, nowhere in their critique of my allegations of political psychiatric abuse in China do Lee and Kleinman even attempt to make any substantive rebuttal of the principal evidence I present—namely, the copious documentation drawn from several decades worth of the country’s own professional literature on psychiatry and the law. On all this, they are disappointingly silent. Instead, they rhetorically conflate this formidable body of evidence with the small quantity of unconfirmed Falun Gong material and then misleadingly dismiss both as being “indirect, unconfirmed, and biased.” Because they have chosen not to address the principal evidence I presented, one must assume that they simply have no answer to it.” <ref>{{cite journal
| last = Munro
| first = Robin
| authorlink = Robin Munro
| title = On the Psychiatric Abuse of Falun Gong and Other Dissenters in China: A Reply to Stone, Hickling, Kleinman, and Lee
| journal = The Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law
| volume = 30
| issue = 2
| pages = 266–274
| date = ]
| url = http://www.jaapl.org/cgi/reprint/30/2/266.pdf
| format = ]}}
</ref></blockquote>

He says that the four Falun Gong case notes were selected on the basis of their typicality “…from among several hundred such accounts that have so far been compiled and published by the Falun Gong’s human rights monitoring units.”<ref>Ibid., Munro, 2002, p 269</ref> And that “According to the latter’s extensive network of informants in China, already more than 300 Falun Gong detainees have died in police custody nationwide since July 1999, three of them in forced psychiatric detention and all reportedly as a direct consequence of police brutality… Independent investigations by foreign journalists based in Beijing… have confirmed the Falun Gong’s version of events in the cases that have been examined.”<ref>Ibid., Munro, 2002, p 270</ref>

Munro finishes his response to the question of the quality of the evidence he presented by saying that “…more fair-minded readers will conclude that the more than 100 pages of closely documented evidence of the systematic, decades-long political misuse of psychiatry by the Chinese authorities that directly preceded this short section on the Falun Gong cases… transfer the burden of proof squarely back onto the Chinese authorities, if they want to convince their own citizens and the outside world that the appalling accounts of extreme physical and psychological ill treatment supplied by detained Falun Gong practitioners since the crackdown began in mid-1999 are either false or substantially inaccurate.” <ref>Ibid., Munro, 2002, p 270</ref>

In February 2005, a World Psychiatric Association delegation visited China to investigate the allegation. Dr. Alan Stone, professor of law and psychiatry at Harvard, a former president of the American Psychiatric Association and recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship to study the international political abuse of psychiatry, later published his findings as a member of the delegation. He states: “The lack of qualified psychiatrists, the divergent standards of training, the intense economic pressures, and the absence of central government control and command regulation all suggest a quite different situation than that which existed in the Soviet Union. If Falun Gong practitioners have been misdiagnosed and mistreated in psychiatric hospitals across China (and there is no doubt in my mind that they have been) it is not because orders came down from the Ministry of Health or Security in Beijing. Nor is there any evidence that an influential group of forensic psychiatrists carried out this psychiatric persecution of the Falun Gong in the secure Ankang hospitals (mental hospital).”

==Allegations of organ harvesting==
{{POV-section}}
On ], ] the Falun Gong news paper ] reported a "heinous crime": six thousand practitioners were killed in a secret concentration camp in Sujiatun District, Shenyang City. “No detainees have managed to leave the concentration camp alive… internal organs are all removed from the bodies and sold,” said Mr. R, an anonymous person who broke the story to Epoch Times.

The story developed further on ] when another anonymous person whose family members were allegedly involved in removing organs from Falun Gong practitioners gave further details that were published in the Epoch Times. According to this anonymous source, the concentration camp is located in the Liaoning Provincial Thrombosis Hospital of Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine where she once worked. Since 2001, according to this source, the hospital has detained practitioners in a huge system of secret underground chambers. Then she made a horrifying accusation that topped all others ever made by the group: “Many Falun Gong practitioners were still alive when their organs were taken. After their organs were cut out, some of these people were thrown directly into the crematorium to be burnt, thus leaving no evidence.” Claiming no connection with the Falun Gong, she said she had to speak up to save those still alive there. Similar claims were made by Mr. R.

On ]], ], the Executive Director of the ] and the ] located in ] released a report stating that:"I arranged for people inside China to visit the Sujiatun scene. From ], the investigators canvassed the entire Sujiatun area. On ], the investigators visited two military barracks in Sujiatun. On ], the investigators secretly visited the Chinese Medical Blood Clotting Treatment Center in Sujiatun. On ], the investigators went to the Kongjiashan prison near Sujiatun. None of the aforementioned investigations revealed any trace of the concentration camp. The investigators provided me with photographs and written reports on their investigation and results on ], 17, 27, 29, 30 and ]."

] covered the allegations on ] ] in an article by ]. According to the article, Jin Zhong (a pseudonym for the journalist who fled China recently) said he first learned of the harvesting operation between October and December. Mr Jin, who in the past has been a contributor to a Japanese news agency, calls Sujiatun "a murder sponsored by a state". Jin came across the underground detention center while researching the Chinese government's response to SARS. The article claims that several other hospital workers have also revealed details about the prisoner organ harvesting. Jin Zhong has had to hide his true identity after being threatened by Chinese government agents. He was arrested twice for his reporting and recently fled to the United States, where he hopes to seek political asylum. Jin also professes that the bodies of prisoners were burned in the boiler room of the hospital and that boiler room workers had taken jewelry and watches from the dead and sold them.<ref>Gertz, Bill (] ]) , ''Washington Times'', retrieved ] ]</ref>

After more then two weeks, on ], Chinese Foreign Ministry Spokesman Qin Gang stated: "This absurd lie is not worth refuting and no one will buy it." He also urged reporters to go to Shenyang's Sujiatun district to look into the claims.<ref> (] ]) ''Pravda'', retrieved ] ]</ref>

On ], Falun Gong's Epoch Times reported a new informant, identifying himself as a veteran military doctor in Shenyang military zone, has told about a system of similar concentration camps in China. The informant claims: "The reports from outside China about Sujiatun Concentration Camp imprisoning Falun Gong practitioners are true, although some of the details are incorrect." He says that more than 10,000 people were detained in Sujiatun in early 2005, but now the number of detainees is maintained at 600-750. Many detainees have been transferred to other camps, especially after the news on Sujiatun was publicized. The informant also asserts that the hospital in Sujiatun is only one of 36 similar camps all over China. Jilin camp, codenamed 672-S, holds over 120,000 people, not only Falun Gong practitioners. Specially dispatched freight trains can transfer 5,000-7,000 people in one night, and everyone on the trains is handcuffed to specially designed handrails on top of the ceiling, claims the informant.

On ], ] released an article entitled "U.N. envoy looks at Falun Gong torture allegations". According to the report, the ] torture investigator ] shall be looking into the Sujiatun case. "I am presently in the process of investigating as far as I can these allegations ... If I come to the conclusion that it is a serious and well-founded allegation, then I will officially submit it to attention of the Chinese government," he told a news briefing.

On ], ], an official from the hospital gave the following statement: “the hospital is lacking the required facilities to conduct organ transplants and has no basement to house the Falun Gong practitioners.”

This hospital—the Liaoning Thrombus Medical Treatment Center—is partly owned by a Malaysian company, Country Heights Health Sanctuary, therefore subject to over sight beyond local Chinese government officials. During an official visit to China in September, 2004 the Minister of Health of Malaysia visited the hospital and reported nothing unusual.

On ], ] the U.S. State Department reported the findings of its investigation. The report states that: "U.S. representatives have found no evidence to support allegations that a site in northeast China has been used as a concentration camp to jail Falun Gong practitioners and harvest their organs." According to the report stuff from U.S. embassy in Beijing and the U.S. consulate in Shenyang have visited the area and the specific site on two separate occasions and that "the officers were allowed to tour the entire facility and grounds and found no evidence that the site is being used for any function other than as a normal public hospital."

On ], ] Canadian ] and ] issued their report “Report into allegations of organ harvesting of Falun Gong practitioners in China”. In this report they claim to have found “credible evidence that the organs of Falun Gong adherents in China are being harvested for paid transplants.” This report has been the subject of controversy and has been disputed by fellow anti-Chinese government activist ].

On ], ], following travels to approximately thirty national capitals to raise awareness about the issue, Matas and Kilgour released a revised version of their report, now called "BLOODY HARVEST"<ref>http://www.OrganHarvestInvestigation.net/</ref>. The revised report adds new evidence and recommendations for action in response to their findings. <ref>{{cite press release| title = New Evidence in Matas/Kilgour Revised Report on Organ Harvest of Falun Gong Practitioners in China | publisher = Kilgour, David; Matas, David | date = 2007-02-02 | url = http://OrganHarvestInvestigation.net/ | accessdate = 2007-06-10}}</ref>

==Related legal cases==
*

*

*

*

*

* (Case 04-1070, PDF File)

*

*


==References== ==References==
<!--- This section should only contain items that are referenced in the article. ---> <!--- This section should only contain items that are referenced in the article. --->
{{Reflist}}
<div class="references-small">
<references/>
<!--- References above this have been verified and placed in order. ---> <!--- References above this have been verified and placed in order. --->

==Further reading==
* {{cite journal|last=Li|first=Junpeng|url=https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/politics-and-religion/article/abs/religion-of-the-nonreligious-and-the-politics-of-the-apolitical-the-transformation-of-falun-gong-from-healing-practice-to-political-movement/721645CB0ED458B1540460F1D99F0B89|title=The Religion of the Nonreligious and the Politics of the Apolitical: The Transformation of Falun Gong from Healing Practice to Political Movement|journal=]|publisher=]|date=2013-11-01|volume=7|issue=1|pages=177–208|doi=10.1017/S1755048313000576|s2cid=145591972 }}
* {{cite journal|last=Ownby|first=David|url=https://online.ucpress.edu/nr/article-abstract/6/2/223/71159/A-History-for-Falun-Gong-Popular-Religion-and-the?redirectedFrom=fulltext|title=A History for Falun Gong: Popular Religion and the Chinese State Since the Ming Dynasty|journal=]|publisher=]|volume=6|issue=2|date=April 2003|pages=223–243|doi=10.1525/nr.2003.6.2.223|jstor=10.1525/nr.2003.6.2.223}}


==External links== ==External links==
* a photo collection of the evidence of the persecution from ClearWisdom.net
*
* or see the video documentary
*
*
*
*
*
* 2001 Pulitzer Prize Article (section 1): ,
* 2001 Pulitzer Prize Article (section 10):


{{commons category|Falun Gong}}
*

{{Falun Gong}}

{{DEFAULTSORT:History of Falun Gong}}
] ]
]
]

Latest revision as of 00:04, 31 December 2024

Falun Gong adherents practice the fifth exercise, a meditation, in Manhattan

Falun Gong, also called Falun Dafa, is a spiritual practice and system of beliefs that combines the practice of meditation with the moral philosophy articulated by its leader and founder, Li Hongzhi. It emerged on the public radar in the Spring of 1992 in the northeastern Chinese city of Changchun, and was classified as a system of qigong identifying with the Buddhist tradition. Li claimed to have both supernatural powers like the ability to prevent illness, as well having eternal youth and promised that others can attain supernatural powers and eternal youth by following his teachings. Falun Gong initially enjoyed official sanction and support from Chinese government agencies, and the practice grew quickly on account of the simplicity of its exercise movements, impact on health, the absence of fees or formal membership, and moral and philosophical teachings.

In the mid-1990s, however, Falun Gong became estranged from the state-run qigong associations, leading to a gradual escalation of tensions with Chinese Communist Party (CCP) authorities that culminated in the Spring of 1999. Following a protest of 10,000 Falun Gong practitioners near the Zhongnanhai government compound on 25 April 1999 to request official recognition, then-CCP general secretary Jiang Zemin ordered Falun Gong be crushed. A campaign of propaganda, large-scale extrajudicial imprisonment, torture and coercive reeducation ensued.

Falun Gong practitioners have responded to the campaign with protests on Tiananmen Square, the creation of their own media companies overseas, international lawsuits targeting Chinese officials, and the establishment of a network of underground publishing sites to produce literature on the practice within China. Falun Gong has emerged as a prominent voice for an end to one-party rule in China.

Timeline of major events

Before 1992

Falun Gong has been classified variously as a form of spiritual cultivation practice in the tradition of Chinese antiquity, as a qigong discipline, or as a religion or new religious movement. Qigong refers to a broad set of exercises, meditation and breathing methods that have long been part of the spiritual practices of select Buddhist sects, of Daoist alchemists, martial artists, and some Confucian scholars.

Although qigong-like practices have a long history, the modern qigong movement traces its origins only to the late 1940s and 1950s. At that time, CCP cadres began pursuing qigong as a means of improving health, and regarded it as a category of traditional Chinese medicine. With official support from the party-state, qigong grew steadily in popularity, particularly in the period following the Cultural Revolution. The state-run China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985 to administer and oversee qigong practice across the country. Thousands of qigong disciplines emerged, some of them headed by "grandmasters" with millions of adherents.

From his youth, Li Hongzhi claims to have been tutored by a variety of Buddhist and Daoist masters, who, according to his spiritual biography, imparted to him the practice methods and moral philosophy that would come to be known as Falun Gong.

  • 1951 or 1952 – Falun Gong asserts that Li Hongzhi, founder of Falun Gong, was born on 13 May 1951 in Gongzhuling, Jilin Province. Official Chinese birth dates for Li have been given as 7 or 27 July 1952.
  • 1955 – According to his spiritual biography, Li begins learning under the tutelage of master Quan Je, a tenth-generation master of Buddhist cultivation who imparts to Li the principles of Zhen, Shan, Ren (truth, compassion, forbearance). The instruction lasts eight years.
  • 1963 – According to his spiritual biography, Daoist master Baji Zhenren begins training Li in Daoist martial arts disciplines and physical skills training.
  • 1970 – Li begins working at a military horse farm in northeast China, and in 1972 works as a trumpet player with a division of the provincial forestry police.
  • 1972 – Li continues his spiritual training under the instruction of a master Zhen Daozhi, who imparts methods of internal cultivation. According to Li's spiritual biography, his training in this period mostly took place under cover of night, possibly due to the political environment of the Cultural Revolution.
  • 1974 – Li's biography states that he begins studying the instruction of a female Buddhist master. Throughout the next several years, Li continued his studies and observations of spiritual cultivation systems.
  • Early 1980s – Having had his middle and high school education interrupted by the Cultural Revolution, Li completes his high school education via correspondence courses.
  • 1984 – According to his spiritual biography, to Li creates Falun Gong with his masters as a more accessible version of Falun Fofa, based on other qigong.
  • Mid-1980s – Li begins studying and observing a variety of other qigong disciplines, apparently in preparation for establishing and publicizing his own qigong system.
  • 1985 – Chinese authorities create a national organization to oversee the great variety of qigong disciplines that were proliferating across the country. The China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985, and convened its first meeting in Beijing in 1986. The organization counted among its leadership several eminent members and former members of the Politburo and National People's Congress, as well as former ministers of health and education.
  • 1989 – Li begins private instruction of Falun Gong to select students.

1992–1995

Falun Gong was publicly founded in the Spring of 1992, toward the end of China's "qigong boom," a period which saw the proliferation of thousands of disciplines. Li Hongzhi and his Falun Gong became an "instant star" of the qigong movement, and were welcomed into the government-administered China Qigong Scientific Research Society (CQRS). From 1992 to 1994, Li traveled throughout China giving 54 lecture seminars on the practice and beliefs of Falun Gong. Seminars typically lasted 8–10 days, and attracted as many as 6,000 participants per class. The practice grew rapidly based on its purported efficacy in improving health and its moral and philosophical elements, which were more developed than those of other qigong schools.

  • 1992 – On 13 May, Li begins public teaching of Falun Gong at the No. 5 Middle School in Changchun, Jilin Province, lecturing to a crowd of several hundred. The seminar ran for nine days at a cost of 30 Yuan per person.
  • 1992 – June, Li is invited by the China Qigong Scientific Research Society to lecture in Beijing.
  • 1992 – In September, Falun Gong is recognized as a qigong branch under the administration of the state-run China Qigong Scientific Research Society (CQRS).
  • 1992 – Li is formally declared a "Master of Qigong" by the CQRS, and received a permit to teach nationwide.
  • 1992 – Li and several Falun Gong students participate in the 1992 Asian Health Expo in Beijing from 12 to 21 December. The organizer of the health fair remarked that Falun Gong and Li "received the most praise at the fair, and achieved very good therapeutic results." The event helped cement Li's popularity in the qigong world, and journalistic reports of Falun Gong's healing powers spread.
  • 1992 – By the end of the year, Li had given five week-long lecture seminars in Beijing, four in Changchun, one in Tayuan, and one in Shandong.
  • 1993 – China Falun Gong (中国法轮功), the first major instructional text by Li Hongzhi, is published by Military Yiwen Press in April. The book sets forth an explanation of Falun Gong's basic cosmology, moral system, and exercises. A revised edition is released in December of the same year.
  • 1993 – In the spring and summer of 1993, a series of glowing article appear in Qigong magazines nationwide lauding the benefits of Falun Gong. Several feature images of Li Hongzhi on the cover, and asserting the superiority of the Falun Gong system.
  • 1993 – The Falun Xiulian Dafa Research Society is established as a branch of the CQRS on 30 July.
  • 1993 – In August, an organization under Ministry of Public Security sends a letter to the CQRS thanking Li Hongzhi for providing his teachings to police officers injured in the line of duty. The letter claimed that of the 100 officers treated by Li, only one failed to experience "obvious improvement" to their health.
  • 1993 – On Sept 21, The People's Public Security Daily, a publication of the Ministry of Public Security, commends Falun Gong for "promoting the traditional crime-fighting virtues of the Chinese people, in safeguarding social order and security, and in promoting rectitude in society."
  • 1993 – Li again participates in the Asian Health Expo in Beijing from 11 to 20 Dec, this time as a member of the organizing committee. He wins several awards at the event, and is proclaimed the "Most Acclaimed Qigong Master." Falun Gong also received the "Special Gold Award" and award for "Advancing Frontier Science."
  • 1994 – The Jilin Province Qigong Science Research Association proclaims Li Hongzhi a "Grandmaster of Qigong" on 6 May.
  • 1994 – Li gives two lectures on Falun Gong at the Public Security University in Beijing, and contributes profits from the seminars to a foundation for injured police officers.
  • 1994 – On 3 August, the City of Houston, Texas, declares Li Hongzhi an honorary citizen for his "unselfish public service for the benefit and welfare of mankind."
  • 1994 – As revenues from the sale of his publications grew, Li ceased to charge fees for his classes, and thereafter insists that Falun Gong must be taught free of charge.
  • 1994 – The last full seminar on Falun Gong practice and philosophy takes place from 21 to 29 December in the southern city of Guangzhou.
  • 1995 – Zhuan Falun (转法轮), the complete teachings of Falun Gong, is published in January by the China Television Broadcasting Agency Publishing Company. A publication ceremony is held in the Ministry of Public Security auditorium on 4 January.
  • 1995 – In February, Li is approached by the Chinese National Sports Committee, Ministry of Public Health, and China Qigong Science Research Association to jointly establish a Falun Gong association. Li declines the offer.
  • 1995 – Official attitudes towards the Qigong movement within some segments of the government begin to change, as criticisms of qigong begin appearing in the state-run press.
  • 1995 – Li leaves China and begins spreading his practice overseas.
  • 1995 – At the invitation of the Chinese embassy in Paris, Li begins teaching Falun Gong abroad. On 13 March, he gives a seven-day class in Paris, followed by another lecture series in Sweden in April (Gothenburg, Stockholm and Uddevalla).

1996–June 1999

Having announced that he was finished teaching his practice in China, Li Hongzhi begins teaching his practice in Europe, Oceania, North America and Southeast Asia. In 1998, Li relocates permanently to the United States.

As the practice continues to grow within China, tensions emerge between Falun Gong and Chinese authorities. In 1996, Falun Gong withdraws from the China Qigong Scientific Research Society, and thereafter finds itself the subject of growing scrutiny and criticism in the state-run press. The practice becomes a subject of high-level debates within the government and CCP, with some ministries and government authorities expressing continued support for the practice, and others becoming increasingly wary of the group. This tension also played out in the media, as some outlets continued to laud the effects of Falun Gong, while others criticized it as pseudoscience.

Tensions continue to escalate over this period, culminating in a demonstration on 25 April 1999 near the Zhongnanhai government compound, where over ten thousand Falun Gong practitioners gather to request official recognition. Following the event, Jiang Zemin, then-CCP general secretary, quietly prepares for the launch of a nationwide campaign to persecute the practice.

  • 1996 – The book Zhuan Falun is listed as a bestseller by Beijing Youth Daily (北京青年报) in January, March, and April.
  • 1996 – Falun Gong files for withdrawal from the China Qigong Scientific Research Society in March. Li later explains that he had found the state-run CQRS to be more concerned with profiting from qigong than engaging in genuine research. Li had also apparently rejected a new CQRS policy that mandated that all qigong practices create CCP branches within their organizations. Falun Gong is left entirely without government oversight or sanction.
  • 1996 – At Li's direction, administrators of the Falun Gong Research Association of China apply for registration with three other government organizations, including the Buddhist Association of China and United Front Work Department. All applications are ultimately denied.
  • 1996 – The first major state-run media article criticizing Falun Gong appears in the Guangming Daily newspaper on 17 June. The article writes that Falun Gong represents a manifestation of feudal superstition, and that its core text Zhuan Falun is a work of "pseudo-science" that swindles the masses. Falun Gong practitioners responded to the article's publication with a letter-writing campaign to the newspaper and national qigong association.
  • 1996 – Several Buddhist journals and magazines start to write articles criticizing Falun Gong as a "heretical sect".
  • 1996 – On 24 July, Falun Gong books are banned from further publication by the China News Publishing Bureau, a branch of the CCP Central Propaganda Department. The reason cited for the ban is that Falun Gong is "spreading superstition." Pirated and copied versions of Falun Gong books proliferate, with Li Hongzhi's approval.
  • 1996 – Li begins another international lecture tour in the summer of 1996, traveling to Hong Kong, Sydney, Bangkok, Houston, New York, and Beijing.
  • 1996 – The China Qigong Scientific Research Society issues a resolution on the cancellation of Falun Gong's membership with the society. The resolution stated that although practitioners of Falun Gong had "attained unparalleled results in terms of fitness and disease prevention," Li Hongzhi "propagated theology and superstition," failed to attend association meetings, and departed from the association's procedures.
  • 1997 – The Ministry of Public Security launches an investigation into whether Falun Gong should be deemed xie jiao ("heretical religion"). The report concludes that "no evidence has appeared thus far."
  • 1997–1999 – Criticism of Falun Gong escalates in state-run media. With the encouragement of Li, Falun Gong practitioners respond to criticisms by peacefully petitioning outside media offices seeking redress against perceived unfair reporting. The tactic succeeds frequently, often resulting in the retraction of critical articles and apologies from the news organizations. Not all media coverage was negative in this period, however, and articles continued to appear highlighting Falun Gong's health benefits.
  • 1998 - On 13 January, the China Buddhist Association held a meeting on how to react to Falun Gong.
  • 1998 – On 21 July, the Ministry of Public Security issues Document No. 555, "Notice of the Investigation of Falun Gong." The document asserts that Falun Gong is an "evil religion," and mandates that another investigation be launched to seek evidence of the conclusion. The faction hostile toward Falun Gong within the ministry was reportedly led by Luo Gan. Security agencies began monitoring and collecting personal information on practitioners; Falun Gong sources reported authorities were tapping phone lines, harassing and tailing practitioners, ransacking homes, and closing down Falun Gong meditation sessions.
  • 1998 – According to Falun Gong sources, Qiao Shi, the former Chairman of the National People's Congress, lead his own investigation into Falun Gong and concluded that "Falun Gong has hundreds of benefits for the Chinese people and China, and does not have one single bad effect."
  • 1998 – China's National Sports Commission launches its own investigation in May, and commissions medical professionals to conduct interviews of over 12,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Guangdong province. 97.9 percent of respondents say Falun Gong improved their health. By October the investigation concludes, noting "We're convinced the exercises and effects of Falun Gong are excellent. It has done an extraordinary amount to improve society's stability and ethics. This should be duly affirmed."
  • 1998 – Estimates provided by the State Sports Commission suggest there are upwards of 60 to 70 million Falun Gong practitioners in China.
  • 1999 – Li Hongzhi continues to teach Falun Gong internationally, with occasional stops in China. By early 1999, Li had lectured in Sydney, Bangkok, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Hong Kong, Taipei, Frankfurt, Toronto, Singapore, Geneva, Houston and New York, as well as in Changchun and Beijing.
  • 1999 – Wu Shaozu, An official from China's National Sports Commission, says in an interview with U.S. News & World Report on 14 February that as many as 100 million may have taken up Falun Gong and other forms of qigong. Wu notes that the popularity of Falun Gong dramatically reduces health care costs, and "Premier Zhu Rongji is very happy about that."
  • 1999 – In April, physicist He Zuoxiu from the Chinese Academy of Sciences publishes an article in Tianjin Normal University's Youth Reader magazine criticizing Falun Gong as superstitious and potentially harmful for youth and stating that he knew someone who died because of it. At that time, some countries near China had people practicing, like Vietnam.
  • 1999 – Tianjin Falun Gong practitioners respond to the article by peacefully petitioning in front of the editorial offices. Editors initially agree to publish a retraction of the He Zuoxiu article, then renege.
  • 1999 – On 23 April, some 300 security forces are called in to break up ongoing Falun Gong demonstration. Forty-five Falun Gong practitioners are beaten and detained.
  • 1999 – Falun Gong practitioners petition Tianjin City Hall for the release of the detained practitioners. They are reportedly told that the order to break up the crowd and detain protesters came from central authorities in Beijing, and that further appeals should be directed at Beijing.
Falun Gong practitioners demonstrate outside the Zhongnanhai government compound in April 1999 to request official recognition.
  • 1999 – On 25 April 10,000–20,000 Falun Gong practitioners quietly assemble outside the Central Appeals Office, adjacent to the Zhongnanhai leadership compound in Beijing. Five Falun Gong representatives meet with Premier Zhu Rongji to request official recognition and an end to escalating harassment against the group. Zhu agrees to release the Tianjin practitioners, and assures the representatives that the government does not oppose Falun Gong. The same day, however, at the urging of Luo Gan, CCP general secretary Jiang Zemin issues a letter stating his intention to suppress the practice.
  • 1999 – On 26 April, Jiang Zemin convenes a meeting of the Politburo Standing Committee to discuss the Falun Gong demonstration. Some Politburo members reportedly favored a conciliatory position towards Falun Gong, while others – such as Jiang and security czar Luo Gan – favored a decisive suppression of the group.
  • 1999 – Authorities increased surveillance on Falun Gong, tapping telephones of practitioners and monitoring practitioners in several cities.
  • 1999 – On 2 May, Li Hongzhi gives a press conference to journalists in Sydney, Australia. When asked by a reporter whether he believed the government would kill or imprison his disciples to maintain social order, Li responded that " practitioners will never go against the law. In terms of the scenario you describe, I don't think it will happen. since the economic reform and opening up, the Chinese government has been quite tolerant in this respect."
  • 1999 – In May and June, just as preparations are quietly underway for a crackdown, Falun Gong practitioners continue their public meditation sessions. The Far Eastern Economic Review wrote "in a park in western Beijing, 100 or so Falun Gong practitioners exercised under a bold yellow banner proclaiming their affiliation... far from running scared."
  • 1999 – On 2 June, Li purchases space in several Hong Kong newspapers to publish an article defending Falun Gong, and urging Chinese leaders not to "risk universal condemnation" and "waste manpower and capital" by antagonizing the group.
  • 1999 – On 3 June, 70,000 practitioners from Jilin and Liaoning travel to Beijing in an attempt to appeal to authorities. They were intercepted by security forces, sent home, and placed under surveillance.
  • 1999 – On 7 June 1999, Jiang Zemin convened a meeting of the Politburo to address the Falun Gong issue. In the meeting, Jiang described Falun Gong as a grave threat to CCP authority – "something unprecedented in the country since its founding 50 years ago" – and ordered the creation of a special leading group within the party's Central Committee to "get fully prepared for the work of disintegrating ."
  • 1999 – On 10 June, the 6-10 Office was formed to handle day-to-day coordination of the anti-Falun Gong campaign. Luo Gan was selected to helm of the office, whose mission at the time was described as studying, investigating, and developing a "unified approach...to resolve the Falun Gong problem" The office was not created with any legislation, and there are no provisions describing its precise mandate.
  • 1999 – On 17 June 1999, On 17 June, Jiang Zemin declared in a Politburo meeting that Falun Gong is "the most serious political incident since the '4 June' political disturbance in 1989." The 610 Office came under the newly created Central Leading Group for Dealing with Falun Gong, headed by Li Lanqing. Both Li and Luo were members of the Politburo Standing Committee, and the four other deputy directors of the Central Leading Group also held high-level positions in the CCP, including minister of the propaganda department.
  • 1999 – On 26 June, thirteen Falun Gong exercise sites in public parks are shut down by Beijing security officials.

July 1999–2001

Falun Gong practitioners being arrested in Tiananmen Square following the ban

In July 1999, a nationwide campaign is rolled out to "eradicate" Falun Gong. The persecution campaign is characterized by a "massive propaganda campaign" against the group, public burnings of Falun Gong books, and imprisonment of tens of thousands of Falun Gong practitioners in prisons, reeducation through labor camps, psychiatric hospitals and other detention facilities. Authorities are given the broad mandate of 'transforming' practitioners, resulting in the widespread use of torture against Falun Gong practitioners, sometimes resulting in death.

From late 1999 to early 2001, hundreds of Falun Gong practitioners per day travel to Tiananmen Square to stage peaceful protests against the persecution. The protests take the form of performing Falun Gong exercises or meditation, or holding banner proclaiming Falun Gong's innocence. The protests are broken up, often violently, by security forces.

  • 1999 – During a 19 July meeting of senior CCP cadres, Jiang Zemin's decision to eradicate Falun Gong was announced. The campaign was originally intended to have begun on 21 July, but as the document was apparently leaked, the crackdown started on 20 July. A nationwide propaganda campaign is launched to discredit Falun Gong.
  • 1999 – Just after midnight on 20 July, Falun Gong practitioners and "assistants" are abducted and detained across numerous cities in China. In response, tens of thousands of practitioners petition local, provincial and central appeals offices. In Beijing and other cities, protesters are detained in sports stadiums.
  • 1999 – On 22 July, The Ministry of Civil Affairs declared the "Research Society of Falun Dafa and the Falun Gong organization under its control" to be unregistered, and therefore illegal, organizations. The same day, the Ministry of Public Security issues a notice prohibiting 1) the display of Falun Gong images or symbols; 2) the public distribution of Falun Gong books or literature; 3) assembling to perform group Falun Gong exercises; 4)using sit-ins, petitions, and other demonstrations in defense of Falun Gong; 5) the spreading of rumors meant to disturb social order; and 6) taking part in activities opposing the government's decision.
  • 1999 – The 19 July circular is released publicly on 23 July. In it, Falun Gong is declared the "most serious political incident" since 1989. The Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party forbids party members from practicing Falun Gong, and launches study sessions to ensure cadres understand that Falun Gong is incompatible with the belief system of Marxism.
  • 1999 – on 26 July, the authorities begin the process of confiscating and destroying all publications related to Falun Gong, including "books, pictures, audio-video products, and electronic publications." Within one week, two million copies of Falun Gong literature are confiscated and destroyed by steam-rollers and public book burning.
  • 1999 – In late July, overseas Falun Gong websites are hacked or subject to denial-of-service attack. According to Chinese internet expert Ethan Gutmann, the attacks originated from servers in Beijing and Shenzhen, and was among the first serious attempts at network disruption by China.
  • 1999 – 29 July, Chinese authorities ask Interpol to seek the arrest of Li Hongzhi. Interpol declines. The following week, Chinese authorities offer a substantial cash reward for the extradition of Li from the United States. The U.S. government similarly declines to follow up.
  • 1999 – On 29 July, the Beijing Bureau of Justice issues a notice requiring all lawyers and law firms to obtain approval before providing consultation or representation to Falun Gong practitioners. According to Human Rights Watch, the notice was "inconsistent with international standards which call on governments to ensure that lawyers are able to perform their professional functions without intimidating hindrance, harassment, or improper interference."
  • 1999 – In October, 30 Falun Gong practitioners hold a secret press conference for foreign media in Beijing to tell of the violence and persecution they are suffering. At the end of the press briefing, participants are arrested, and some of the foreign reporters present are questioned and briefly detained. Ten of the organizers were detained almost immediately afterwards, and one of them, a 31-year-old hairdresser names Ding Yan, is later tortured to death in custody, according to Falun Gong sources. During the press conference, some of the first allegations of Falun Gong torture deaths in custody are made.
  • 1999 – On 30 October, the National People's Congress of the People's Republic of China issues a resolution on article 300 of the criminal code. The resolution elaborates on the identification and punishments for individuals who use "heretical religions" to undermine the implementation of the law.
  • 1999 – On 5 November 1999, the Supreme People's Court of the People's Republic of China issues a circular giving instruction to the people's courts that Falun Gong should be prosecuted as a 'heretical religion' under article 300. The notice, sent to all local courts in China, stressed that it was their political duty to severely punish Falun Gong, and to handle these cases under the leadership of the Party committees.
  • 1999 – On 27 December, four high-profile Falun Gong practitioners are put on trial for "undermining the implementation of the law" and illegally obtaining state secrets. They include Beijing engineer and prominent Falun Gong organizer Zhiwen Wang, sentenced to 16 years in prison, and Li Chang, an official of the Ministry of Public Security, sentenced to 18 years. According to Amnesty International, in these prosecutions and others, "the judicial process was biased against the defendants at the outset and the trials were a mere formality."
  • 2000 – During Lunar New Year celebrations in early February, at least 2,000 Falun Gong practitioners are detained on Tiananmen Square while attempting to peacefully protest the ban against the group.
  • 2000 – On 20 April, Wall Street Journal reporter Ian Johnson publishes the first article in a series on Falun Gong. The article details the torture death of 58-year-old grandmother in Weifang city, who was beaten, shocked, and forced to run barefoot through the snow because she refused to denounce Falun Gong. Johnson went on to win the 2001 Pulitzer Prize for International Reporting for the series.
  • 2000 – On 21 April, Xinhua News Agency admits for the first time the difficulty the Central authorities have had in stamping out Falun Gong, noting that since "22 July 1999, Falun Gong members have been causing trouble on and around Tiananmen Square in Central Beijing nearly every day."
  • 2000 – Zhao Ming, a graduate student at Ireland's Trinity College, is sent to the Tuanhe forced labor camp in Beijing in May. He spends two years in the camp amidst international pressure for his release, and is reportedly tortured with electric batons.
  • 2000 – On 1 October, thousands of Falun Gong practitioners travel to Tiananmen Square to stage protests against the persecution. Foreign media correspondents witness security officers beating and practitioners on the square.
  • 2000 – In November, Zhang Kunlun, a Canadian citizen and professor of art, is detained while visiting his mother in China and held in a forced labor camp where he reported being beaten and shocked with electric batons. Canadian politicians intervene on his behalf, eventually winning his release to Canada.
  • 2001 – On 23 January, five individuals set themselves on fire on Tiananmen Square. State-run media claim they are Falun Gong practitioners, driven to suicide by the practice. Falun Gong sources deny involvement, saying that Falun Gong forbids suicide and violence, and arguing that the event was staged by the government to turn public opinion against the practice. Authorities seize on the event to escalate a media campaign against the group, and support for Falun Gong wanes.
  • 2001 – As sympathy for Falun Gong erodes in Mainland China, authorities for the first time openly sanction the "systematic use of violence" against the group, establishing a network of brainwashing classes and rooting out Falun Gong practitioners "neighborhood by neighborhood and workplace by workplace."
  • 2001 – By February, international concern grows over psychiatric abuses committed against Falun Gong practitioners, several hundred of whom had reportedly been held and tortured in psychiatric facilities for refusing to denounce the practice.
  • 2001 – On 20 November, a group of 35 Falun Gong practitioners from 12 different countries gathers on Tiananmen Square to meditate under a banner that reads: "Truth, Compassion, Tolerance" – Falun Gong's core moral tenets. They are arrested within minutes, and some are beaten while resisting arrest.
  • 2001 – On 23 December, a New York District Court hands down a default judgement against Zhao Zhifei, Public Security Bureau chief for Hubei Province, for his role in the wrongful death and torture of Falun Gong practitioners.

2002–2004

By 2002, Falun Gong practitioners had all but completely abandoned the approach of protesting on Tiananmen Square, and coverage in Western news outlets declined precipitously.

Falun Gong practitioners continued adopting more novel approaches to protesting, including the establishment of a vast network of underground 'material sites' that create and distribute literature, and tapping into television broadcasts to replace them with Falun Gong content. Practitioners outside China established a television station to broadcast into China, designed censorship-circumvention tools to break through Internet censorship and surveillance, and filed dozens of largely symbolic lawsuits against Jiang Zemin and other Chinese officials alleging genocide and crimes against humanity.

From 2002 to 2004, the paramount position of power in China were transferred from Jiang Zemin to Hu Jintao. Annual Falun Gong deaths in custody continued to grow through 2004, according to reports published by Falun Gong sources, but coverage of Falun Gong declined over the period.

Westerners stages a demonstration in Tiananmen Square, 2002
  • 2002 – On 14 February, 53 Falun Gong practitioners from North America, Europe and Australia attempt to stage a demonstration on Tiananmen Square. They are detained, and several reportedly assaulted by security forces before being expelled from China.
  • 2002 – On 5 March, a group of six Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun city intercept television broadcasts, replacing them with content about Falun Gong and the persecution. Apparently believing that it to be a signal that the ban on Falun Gong had been lifted, citizens gather in public squares to celebrate. The Falun Gong broadcasts run for 50 minutes before the city goes black. Over the next three days, security forces arrest some 5,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun. Amnesty International reports that "police 'stop-and-search' checkpoints have reportedly been established across the city." All six individuals involved in the television hijacking are later tortured to death.
  • 2002 – In June, Jiang Zemin visits Iceland. Dozens of Falun Gong practitioners from around the world attempt to travel to the country to protest, but find their names on an international blacklist organized at the behest of Chinese authorities, suggesting extensive espionage against foreign Falun Gong practitioners.
  • 2002 – Falun Gong practitioners in New York establish New Tang Dynasty Television, a Chinese-language station created to present an alternative to state-run Chinese media.
  • 2002 – On 24 July, U.S. House of Representatives passes a unanimous resolution (House Concurrent Resolution 188) condemning the persecution of Falun Gong in China.
  • 2002 – On 21 October, Falun Gong practitioners from North America, Europe and Australia file a legal case against Jiang Zemin, Zeng Qinghong, and Luo Gan to the United Nations Human Rights Committee and the International Criminal Court for their involvement in the persecution of Falun Gong.
  • 2002 – In November, Hu Jintao begins the process of taking over China's leadership from Jiang Zemin, assuming the position General Secretary of the CCP.
  • 2003 – On 22 January, Falun Gong practitioner and American citizen Dr. Charles Lee is arrested by security forces in Nanjing immediately upon his arrival in China. Lee is sentenced to three years in prison.
  • 2003 – On 1 May, Pan Xinchun, Deputy Consul General at the Chinese consulate in Toronto, published a letter in the Toronto Star in which he said that local Falun Gong practitioner Joel Chipkar is a member of a "sinister cult." In February 2004, the Ontario Superior Court found Pan liable for libel, and demanded he pay $10,000 in compensation to Chipkar. Pan refused to pay, and left Canada.
  • 2003 – June, A San Francisco District Court issues a default ruling against Beijing Party Secretary and former Beijing Mayor Liu Qi and Deputy Governor of Liaoning Province Xia Deren, who had been accused of overseeing the torture of Falun Gong practitioners.
  • 2003 – On 26 December, Liu Chengjun, one of the leaders behind the Changchun television broadcasts, is tortured to death while serving out a 19-year prison sentence.
  • 2004 – In October, U.S. House of Representatives passed a unanimous resolution detailing and condemning the Chinese government's attempts to interfere with and intimidate Falun Gong practitioners in the United States.
  • 2004 – In December, prominent Weiquan lawyer Gao Zhisheng writes to the National People's Congress detailing torture and sexual abuse against Falun Gong practitioners in custody. In response to his letter, Gao's law firm is shut down, his legal license is revoked, and he is put under house arrest.

2005–2007

As Falun Gong becomes more overt in its rhetorical charges against CCP rule, allegations emerge that Chinese security agencies engage in large-scale overseas spying operations against Falun Gong practitioners, and that Falun Gong prisoners in China are killed to supply China's organ transplant industry.

  • 2005 – On 15 February, Li Hongzhi issues a statement renouncing his earlier membership in the Communist Youth League.
  • 2005 – On 4 June, Chinese diplomat Chen Yonglin, a political consul at the Chinese consulate in Sydney, defects to Australia. He reports that a large part of his job was to monitor and harass Falun Gong practitioners in Australia. Days later, on 8 June, Hao Fengjun, a former member of the Tianjin city 610 office, goes public with his story of defection, and tells of abuse against Falun Gong in China.
  • 2005 – On 16 June, Gao Rongrong is reported tortured to death in Shenyang at the age of 37.
  • 2005 – In June, the number of Falun Gong practitioners allegedly killed as a result or torture and abuse in custody exceeds 2,500.
  • 2006 – UN special rapporteur on torture Manfred Nowak releases the findings of his 2005 investigation on torture in China. He reports that two-thirds of reported torture cases are against Falun Gong practitioners.
  • 2006 – In July 2006, former Canadian Member of Parliament David Kilgour and international human rights attorney David Matas release the findings of their investigation into allegations of organ harvesting. Although their evidence was largely circumstantial, they conclude that involuntary organ extractions from Falun Gong practitioners are widespread and ongoing. Chinese officials deny the allegations.
  • 2006 – Falun Gong practitioners in the United States establish Shen Yun Performing Arts, a classical Chinese dance company that begins touring internationally in 2007.
  • 2007 – Falun Gong sources report that the number of persecution deaths exceeds 3,000.
  • 2007 – August, practitioners of Falun Gong launch the Human Rights Torch Relay, which toured to over 35 of countries in 2007 and 2008 ahead of the 2008 Beijing Olympics. The relay was intended to draw attention to a range of human rights issues in China in connection with the Olympics, especially those related to Falun Gong and Tibet, and received support from hundreds of elected officials, past Olympic medallists, human rights groups and other concerned organizations.

2008–2014

Top-level Chinese authorities continue to launch strike-hard campaigns against Falun Gong surrounding sensitive events and anniversaries, and step up efforts to coercively "transform" Falun Gong practitioners in detention facilities and reeducation centers. Lawyers who seek to represent Falun Gong defendants continue to face punishment from Chinese authorities, including harassment, disbarment, and imprisonment.

The human rights torch relay launch in Athens, Greece, 9 August 2007.
Falun Gong practitioners enact torture scenes in New York City
  • 2008 – In the first six months of the year, over 8,000 Falun Gong practitioners are abducted by security forces under the pretext of preventing protests during the Beijing Olympics.
  • 2009 – CCP heir apparent Xi Jinping is put in charge of 6521 Project, a strike hard effort to crack down on Tibetans, democracy activists and Falun Gong practitioners around sensitive anniversaries. Zhou Yongkang heads a parallel effort to crack down on Falun Gong practitioners, ethnic separatism, and protests.
  • 2009 – In March, U.S. House of Representatives passes a resolution on recognizing and condemning the ongoing persecution of Falun Gong in China.
  • 2009 – On 13 May, Weiquan lawyers Zhang Kai(张凯) and Li Chunfu(李春富) are violently beaten and detained in Chongqing for investigating the death of Jiang Xiqing(江锡清), a 66-year-old Falun Gong practitioner killed in a labor camp.
  • 2009 – On 4 July, Dalian city lawyer Wang Yonghang(王永航) is taken from his home by security agents, interrogated, and beaten for defending Falun Gong practitioners. In November 2009, Wang was sentenced in a closed court to seven years in prison for his advocacy on behalf of Falun Gong practitioners. When his lawyers were permitted to see him in January 2010, they reported that he had been tortured.
  • 2009 – In November, Jiang Zemin and other high-ranking Chinese officials are indicted by a Spanish court on charges of genocide and crimes against humanity for their involvement in the persecution of Falun Gong. A month later, an Argentine judge concludes that top Chinese officials Jiang Zemin and Luo Gan had adopted a "genocidal strategy" in pursuing the eradication of Falun Gong, and asks Interpol to seek their arrest
  • 2010 – Over 100 Falun Gong practitioners in Shanghai are abducted and detained in connection with the Shanghai World Expo. Some reportedly face torture for their refusal to disavow Falun Gong.
  • 2010 – In the Spring of 2010, Chinese authorities launch a new, three-year campaign whose goal is to coercively transform large portions of the known Falun Gong population through attendance in reeducation classes.
  • 2010 – On 22 April 2010, Beijing lawyers Liu Wei and Tang Jitian were permanently disbarred for defending Falun Gong practitioners.
  • 2011 – In February, a Falun Gong practitioner named Qin Yueming dies in custody at the Jiamusi Prison. His family state that his body was covered with extensive bruising, with blood in his nose, though authorities said the cause of death was heart attack. A petition seeking redress for his death garners over 15,000 signatures. Qin's wife and daughter are subsequently imprisoned and reportedly tortured for their efforts to draw attention to the case.
  • 2011 – In May, a lawsuit is filed on behalf of Falun Gong practitioners against Cisco. The suit alleges, based mainly on internal Cisco documents, that the technology company "designed and implemented a surveillance system for the Chinese Communist Party, knowing it would be used to root out members of the Falun Gong religion and subject them to detention, forced labor and torture."
  • 2011 – In Hebei province, 3,000 Chinese citizens sign a petition calling for the release of detained Falungong practitioners Zhou Xiangyang and Li Shanshan, who were being held at the Gangbei Prison and Tangshan reeducation center, respectively.
  • 2012 – In June 2012, 15,000 people in Heilongjiang Province signed and affixed their fingerprints to a petition requesting that the government investigate the death of Qin Yueming, a Falun Gong practitioner who died in custody.
  • 2012 – In early June, Falun Gong practitioner Li Lankui was detained and sent to a reeducation-through-labour camp in Hebei province. Hundreds of villagers mobilized to call for Li's release, including by signing petitions calling for an end to the persecution of Falun Gong. This prompted further crackdowns by security agents, leading to the arrest of at least 16 villagers. Some reported that they were tortured for expressing their support for Li Lankui.
  • 2012 – in December, a woman in Oregon finds a letter written in both Chinese and English in a box of Halloween decorations purchased from Kmart. The letter said that the decorations were assembled in Unit 8, Department 2 of Masanjia forced labour camp. It went on to describe forced labor conditions in the camp, and noted that many of the detainees were Falun Gong practitioners being held without trial. The letter's author, a Falun Gong practitioner from Beijing, was later identified by The New York Times.
  • 2013 – Central 610 Office authorities launch a new three-year campaign calling for the ideological "transformation" of Falun Gong practitioners. Local governments issue quotas and targets for the number of Falun Gong practitioners to reeducate, and prescribe the appropriate means for doing so.
  • 2013 – A photojournalism magazine in China publishes an exposé detailing human rights abuses committed by female detainees at the Masanjia forced labour camp in Shenyang, where Falun Gong practitioners were estimated to comprise approximately half the detainees. The article was promptly removed from the magazine's website, but not before galvanizing nationwide opposition to and condemnation of the labor camp system. Soon thereafter, New York Times photographer Du Bin releases a documentary on the Masanjia labor camp.
  • 2013 – Chinese officials begin dismantling the nationwide network of reeducation-through-labour camps, in which Falun Gong practitioners comprised a significant portion of detainees. Human rights groups expressed skepticism at the scope of reforms, however, noting that other forms of extralegal detention were still being used to detain Falun Gong practitioners and political dissidents.
  • 2013 – On 12 December, European Parliament adopts a resolution on organ harvesting in China, where it "Calls for the EU and its Member States to raise the issue of organ harvesting in China"
  • 2014 – In August, investigative journalist Ethan Gutmann publishes his book "The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvesting, and China's Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem," in which he writes that large number of Falun Gong practitioners and ethnic Uyghurs have been killed for their organs in China.
  • 2014 – Four lawyers in Northeast China are detained and reportedly tortured by the police while investigating abuses against Falun Gong practitioners held at the Qinglongshan farm reeducation centre.

References

  1. Yoffe, Emily (10 August 2001). "The Gong Show". Slate. ISSN 1091-2339. Retrieved 13 February 2023.
  2. "Were human organs stolen in 20-year conflict between Beijing and Falun Gong?". RFI. 25 April 2019. Retrieved 13 February 2023.
  3. ^ David Ownby, Falun Gong and the Future of China (2008) Oxford University Press, p. 89.
  4. ^ Benjamin Penny, The Religion of Falun Gong, (University of Chicago Press, 2012.
  5. ^ David Palmer. Qigong Fever: Body, Science and Utopia in China. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2007
  6. Kenneth S. Cohen, "The Way of Qigong: The Art and Science of Chinese Energy Healing" (Random House, Inc., 1999)
  7. Zhu Xiaoyang and Benjamin Penny (ed.), "The Qigong Boom," Chinese Sociology and Anthropology, Vol. 27, No. 1 (1994)
  8. ^ Benjamin Penny, "The Life and Times of Li Hongzhi: Falun Gong and Religious Biography," The China Quarterly, Vol. 175 (2003), pp. 643–661. Hosted by the Friedrich Ebert Foundation. Available at Cambridge University Databases. Available at JSTOR.
  9. Benjamin Penny, Qigong boom, pp. 13–20.
  10. ^ Zeng, Jennifer. Witnessing history: one Chinese woman's fight for freedom, Soho Press, 2006, pp. 329–335
  11. David Ownby, "The Falun Gong in the New World," European Journal of East Asian Studies, Sep 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p. 306
  12. ^ Danny Schechter, Falun Gong's Challenge to China: Spiritual Practice of "Evil Cult"? (New York: Akashic Books, 2000), pp. 42.
  13. Scott Lowe, Chinese and InternationalContexts for the Rise of Falun Gong. Nova Religio 6 (2 April 2003)
  14. ^ Noah Porter, "Falun Gong in the United States: An Ethnographic Study," 2003, p. 70
  15. David Ownby, "The Falun Gong in the New World," European Journal of East Asian Studies, Sep 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p. 306.
  16. ^ Falun Dafa Information Center, "Overview of Falun Gong," Archived 2 May 2017 at the Wayback Machine accessed 24 November 2010
  17. James Tong (2002), p. 670.
  18. ^ James Tong, Revenge of the Forbidden City, Oxford University Press (2009).
  19. Danny Schechter, Falun Gong's Challenge to China, p. 66.
  20. Palmer 2007, p. 248
  21. Palmer 2007, p. 249
  22. Palmer 2007, p. 262
  23. Palmer 2007, p. 180
  24. ^ Palmer 2007, p. 265
  25. Seth Faison, "In Beijing: A Roar of Silent Protestors," New York Times, 27 April 1999; Joseph Kahn, "Notoriety Now for Movement's Leader," New York Times, 27 April 1999; Renee Schoff, "Growing group poses a dilemma for China," Associated Press, 26 April 1999.
  26. "An opiate of the masses?," U.S. News & World Report, 22 February 1999.
  27. Phillip Adams, Media and Internet Censorship in China, Late Night Live, Radio National Australia
  28. Palmer 2007, p. 266
  29. "Trang chủ | Việt Nam | Sự thật môi trường Pháp Luân Công". Trang chủ | Việt Nam | Sự thật môi trường Pháp Luân Công. Retrieved 30 August 2018.
  30. Palmer 2007, pp. 266-267
  31. ^ Ethan Gutmann, An Occurrence on Fuyou Street, National Review 13 July 2009
  32. ^ Schechter (2000), p.69
  33. Tong (2009), pp. 3–10
  34. ^ Zong Hairen, Zhu Rongji in 1999, (Ming Jing, 2001), pp. 60–61.
  35. Susan V. Lawrence, "Religion: Pilgrim's Protest," Far Eastern Economic Review, 13 May 1999.
  36. Li Hongzhi, 'Some Thoughts of Mine', 2 June 1999.
  37. Sing Tao Jih Pao, "Police Break Up Falun Gong Gathering of 70,000 in Beijing," 7 June 1999.
  38. ^ Sarah Cook and Leeshai Lemish, 'The 610 Office:Policing the Chinese Spirit', China Brief, Volume 11 Issue 17 (9 November 2011).
  39. Tong 2009, p. 44
  40. ^ Spiegel, Mickey (2002). Dangerous Meditation: China's Campaign Against Falungong. Human Rights Watch. ISBN 1-56432-270-X. Retrieved 28 September 2007.
  41. Ethan Gutmann, 'Hacker Nation: China's Cyber Assault', World Affairs Journal, May/June 2010.
  42. Falun Gong Human Rights Working Group, Ding Yan Tortured to Death in the "Water Cage", accessed 04-05-2012
  43. Erik Eckholm, "China Sect Members Covertly Meet Press and Ask World's Help," New York Times, 29 October 1999
  44. ^ Amnesty International, "China: The crackdown on Falun Gong and other so-called 'heretical organizations,'" 23 March 2000
  45. Ian Johnson, 'A Deadly Exercise', Wall Street Journal, 20 April 2000.
  46. "China Admits Banned Sect Is Continuing Its Protest" Elisabeth Rosenthal. New York Times, 21 April 2000
  47. Irish Times, "Freed student has not applied for Dublin yet," 3 March 2002
  48. Washington Post Foreign Service, "Falun Gong Protests Mar Chinese Holiday," 1 October 2000
  49. Human Rights Watch, "ZHANG KUNLUN -- AN ILLUSTRATIVE CASE" Archived 1 November 2007 at the Wayback Machine, accessed 18 March 2011
  50. ^ John Pomfret and Philip P. Pan. "Torture is Breaking Falun Gong." Washington Post, 5 August 2001.
  51. Khabir Ahmad, "International concern grows over psychiatric abuses in China", The Lancet, Volume 356, Issue 9233, Page 920, 9 September 2000
  52. Vancouver Falun Dafa Practitioners' Protest Site, Timeline of Persecution, accessed 19 March 2011
  53. ^ Human Rights Law Foundation, Direct Litigation Archived 11 November 2011 at the Wayback Machine, accessed 19 March 2011
  54. ^ Leeshai Lemish, Media and New Religious Movements: The Case of Falun Gong, A paper presented at The 2009 CESNUR Conference, Salt Lake City, Utah, 11–13 June 2009
  55. Ethan Gutmann: "The Chinese Internet: A dream deferred?" Tiananmen 20 years on Laogai Research Foundation/NED Panel 1: Refinement of Repression, 9:15 am, 2 June 2009
  56. CNN, China detains 40 Western Falun Gong activists Archived 7 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine, 14 February 2002
  57. ^ Ethan Gutmann, "Into Thin Airwaves", Weekly Standard 6 DEC 2010, VOL. 16, NO. 12
  58. Philip Shenon. "Iceland Bars American Falun Gong Followers." New York Times, 15 June 2002. pg. A.7
  59. Chen, Kathy, "Different Wavelength: Chinese Dissidents Take On Beijing Via Media Empire", The Wall Street Journal, 15 November 2007
  60. Clearwisdom.net, "U.S. House of Representatives Unanimously Passes Resolution Urging Chinese Government to Cease Its Persecution of Falun Gong Practitioners", 19 March 2011
  61. Clearwisdom.net, "Table of Lawsuits Filed Against Former Chinese Leader Jiang Zemin and His Followers by Falun Gong Practitioners around the World", accessed 19 March 2011
  62. Congressional Record Senate, 22 July 2004
  63. John Turley-Ewart, "Falun Gong persecution spreads to Canada," The National Post, 20 March 2004.
  64. Falun Dafa Information Center, "High-Level Chinese Officials Found Guilty of Crimes Against Humanity", 20 June 2003
  65. United States Congressional Resolution, Expressing sense of Congress Regarding Oppression by China of Falun Gong in the United States Archived 4 July 2010 at the Wayback Machine, 10-6-2004
  66. Gao Zhisheng, "A China More Just: My Fight As a Rights Lawyer in the World's Largest Communist State," Broad Pr U.S.A, 2007
  67. Gutmann, Ethan. "Hacker Nation: China's Cyber Assault," World Affairs MAY/JUNE 2010
  68. Amnesty International, "China: People's Republic of China–Abolishing 'Re-education through Labour'". 27 June 2005
  69. Falun Dafa Information Center, "Persecution: Timeline Archived 1 May 2011 at the Wayback Machine", 17 May 2008
  70. Manfred Nowak (2006). "Report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment: MISSION TO CHINA". United Nations. p. 13.
  71. David Kilgour and David Kilgour (2007) "Bloody Harvest: Kilgour Matas Report on Allegation of Organ Harvesting from Falun Gong Practitioners in China" (in 22 languages)
  72. About the company
  73. ^ Alanah May Eriksen, New Zealand Herald. Human rights marchers want Olympic boycott. 17 December 2007.
  74. The Calgary Herald, City rally hears student's tale of torture, imprisonment in China Archived 7 November 2012 at the Wayback Machine. 20 May 2008.
  75. New York Times, Falun Gong, accessed 19 March 2011
  76. Congressional-Executive Commission on China, Annual Report 2008 Archived 12 December 2012 at the Wayback Machine, 31 October 2008.
  77. Ching Cheong. "China Acts to Defuse 'Crisis Year'" Archived 20 March 2012 at the Wayback Machine. Singapore Straits Times. 3 March 2009
  78. Einhorn, Bruce. "Congress Challenges China on Falun Gong & Yuan", Business Week, 17 March 2010
  79. Human Rights in China, 'Beijing Lawyers Beaten for Representing Falun Gong Case', 13 May 2009.
  80. Amnesty International. 'Human Rights Lawyer Detained, Tortured'. 28 July 2009
  81. Congressional Executive Commission on China. '2010 Annual Report', 10 October 2010, p. 104.
  82. La Audiencia pide interrogar al ex presidente chino Jiang por genocidio, 14 November 2009
  83. Luis Andres Henao, "Argentine judge asks China arrests over Falun Gong," 22 December 2009
  84. Congressional Executive Commission on China, Annual Report, 2010.
  85. CECC, "Communist Party Calls for Increased Efforts To 'Transform' Falun Gong Practitioners as Part of Three-Year Campaign" Archived 2 December 2011 at the Wayback Machine, 22 March 2011, accessed 19 March 2011
  86. Amnesty International, "China: No Rule of Law when Defence Lawyers Cannot Perform their Legitimate Role," 05-10-2010
  87. ^ Amnesty International, Document – China: Further information: Falun Gong practitioners tortured, 22 August 2012.
  88. Terry Baynes, 'Suit claims Cisco helped China repress religious group', Reuters, 20 May 2011.
  89. Amnesty International, China: Local residents petition for Falun Gong releases, 14 November 2011.
  90. Amnesty International, China: Villagers detained, at risk of torture, 22 October 2012.
  91. "Over 700 People Join in Effort to Rescue Mr. Li Lankui (Photos)"
  92. Andrew Jacobs (11 June 2013). "Behind Cry for Help From China Labor Camp". The New York Times. Retrieved 12 June 2013.
  93. ^ Changing the soup but not the medicine: Abolishing re-education through labor in China. London, UK: Amnesty International. December 2013.
  94. Freedom House, The Politburo's Predicament: Confronting the Limitations of Communist Party Repression, January 2015. Quote: "...for Falun Gong practitioners, the abolition of the RTL camp system coincided with an increased use of prison sentences on the one hand, and detention in extra-legal "legal education centers" for forced conversion on the other."
  95. European Parliament, European Parliament resolution of 12 December 2013 on organ harvesting in China (2013/2981(RSP)). Quote: "Expresses its deep concern over the persistent and credible reports of systematic, state‑sanctioned organ harvesting from non-consenting prisoners of conscience in the People's Republic of China, including from large numbers of Falun Gong practitioners imprisoned for their religious beliefs, as well as from members of other religious and ethnic minority groups"
  96. Barbara Turnbull, , Toronto Star, 21 October 2014.
  97. Thomas Nelson, The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvestings, and China's Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem by Ethan Gutmann: A Review by Thomas Nelson Archived 6 February 2015 at the Wayback Machine, International Affairs Review.
  98. Amnesty International, "Document – Amnesty International calls for an investigation into the allegations of torture of four lawyers in China", 4 April 2014.

Further reading

External links

Falun Gong
Main articles
Media
Related topics
Books
Category: