Revision as of 00:03, 6 August 2019 view sourceInternetArchiveBot (talk | contribs)Bots, Pending changes reviewers5,388,133 edits Bluelinking 8 books for verifiability. #IABot (v2.1alpha2)← Previous edit | Latest revision as of 00:48, 30 December 2024 view source Citation bot (talk | contribs)Bots5,444,702 edits Add: jstor, doi. | Use this bot. Report bugs. | Suggested by Whoop whoop pull up | Category:Scientology | #UCB_Category 10/27 | ||
(163 intermediate revisions by 51 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{short description|Set of ideas and practices adopted by Scientologists}} | {{short description|Set of ideas and practices adopted by Scientologists}} | ||
{{about|the set of ideas and practices |
{{about|the set of ideas and practices|the 1950 book|Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health|the article in Astounding Science Fiction|Dianetics: The Evolution of a Science}} | ||
{{Distinguish| |
{{Distinguish|dialectics|Dynetics}} | ||
{{pp|small=yes}} | {{pp|small=yes}} | ||
{{Use |
{{Use mdy dates|date=August 2023}} | ||
{{multiple issues| | {{multiple issues| | ||
{{Original research|date=April 2010}} | {{Original research|date=April 2010}} | ||
{{Primary sources|date=January 2018}}}} | {{Primary sources|date=January 2018}}}} | ||
] | ] | ||
] | |||
'''Dianetics''' (from ] ''dia'', meaning "through", and ''nous'', meaning "]") is a set of ideas and practices regarding the ] relationship between the mind and body created by science fiction writer ]. Dianetics is practiced by followers of ],<ref name=Scientology>{{cite news|title=The Mothership of All Alliances|first=Eliza|last=Gray|url=http://www.tnr.com/article/politics/magazine/108205/scientology-joins-forces-with-nation-of-islam|newspaper=]|date=October 5, 2012|accessdate=November 19, 2012}}</ref><ref name=Scientology1>{{cite news|title=Louis Farrakhan renews call for self-determination among Nation of Islam followers|first1=Shelley|last1=Rossetter|first2=Thomas C.|last2=Tobin|url=http://www.tampabay.com/news/religion/louis-farrakhan-renews-call-for-self-determination-among-nation-of-islam/1128781|newspaper=]|date=October 18, 2012|accessdate=November 19, 2012|deadurl=yes|archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20121105093720/http://www.tampabay.com/news/religion/louis-farrakhan-renews-call-for-self-determination-among-nation-of-islam/1128781|archivedate=November 5, 2012|df=dmy-all}}</ref> the ] (as of 2010),<ref name=Auditing>{{cite web|title=Nation of Islam Auditors graduation held for third Saviours' Day in a row|first=Asahed|last=Mohammed|url=http://www.finalcall.com/artman/publish/National_News_2/article_9651.shtml|publisher=Final Call|date=February 28, 2013|accessdate=April 22, 2013}}</ref> and independent Dianeticist groups. | |||
{{Scientology sidebar}} | |||
'''Dianetics''' is a set of ideas and practices, invented in 1950 by science fiction writer ], regarding the human mind. Dianetics was originally conceived as a form of psychological treatment, but was rejected by the psychological and medical establishments as pseudoscientific. It was the precursor to ] and has since been incorporated into it.{{r|atack|pages=106–107}} It involves a process referred to as "]", which utilizes an ] meter, ostensibly to remove emotional burdens and "cure" people from their troubles. | |||
Dianetics divides the mind into three parts: the conscious "analytical mind", the subconscious "]", and the ] mind.<ref>Encyclopedia of Religious Freedom, Catharine Cookson, Taylor & Francis, 2003, {{ISBN|0-415-94181-4}}.(page 430/431)</ref> The goal of Dianetics is to erase the content of the "reactive mind", which ] believe interferes with a person's ethics, awareness, happiness, and sanity. The Dianetics procedure to achieve this erasure is called "]".<ref>Philosophers and Religious Leaders: An Encyclopedia of People Who Changed the World, Christian D. Von Dehsen & Scott L. Harris, Greenwood Publishing Group, 1999, {{ISBN|1-57356-152-5}}. (page 90).</ref> In auditing, the Dianetic auditor asks a series of questions (or commands) and elicits answers to help a person locate and deal with painful experiences of the past,<ref>{{Cite web|title = Official Church of Scientology Video: Auditing in Scientology, Spiritual Counseling|url = http://www.scientology.org/faq/scientology-and-dianetics-auditing/what-is-auditing.html |website=www.scientology.org |accessdate=June 20, 2015}}</ref> which Scientologists believe to be the content of the "reactive mind".<ref>{{Cite web |title=Parts of the Mind, Analytical & Reactive, L. Ron Hubbard, Dianetics: Official Church of Scientology |url=http://www.scientology.org/what-is-dianetics/basic-principles-of-scientology/the-parts-of-the-mind.html |website=www.scientology.org |accessdate=June 20, 2015}}</ref><ref>{{Cite book|title = The Hidden Story of Scientology|last = Garrison|first = Omar V.|publisher = Citadel Press, Lyle Stuart, Inc.|year = 1974|isbn = 978-0-8065-0440-7|location = Secaucus, NJ|pages = |url = https://archive.org/details/hiddenstoryofsci00garr/page/26}}</ref> | |||
"Auditing" uses techniques from ] that are intended to create ] and ] in the auditing subject.<ref name=HaSc24/> Hubbard eventually decided to present Dianetics as a form of spirituality that is part of the Church of Scientology,<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Dericquebourg |first=Régis |date=2017 |title=Scientology: From the Edges to the Core |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/26417718 |journal=Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions |volume=20 |issue=4 |pages=5–12 |doi=10.1525/nr.2017.20.4.5 |jstor=26417718 |issn=1092-6690}}</ref> after several practitioners had been arrested for ], and a prosecution trial was pending against the first Dianetics organization that Hubbard founded in Elizabeth, New Jersey.<ref>{{Cite book|last=Urban|first=Hugh B. |title=The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion |publisher=] |location=Princeton and Oxford |url=https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691158051/the-church-of-scientology|year=2011 |isbn=978-0-691-14608-9}}</ref>{{rp|62–68}}<ref>{{Cite book |last=Westbrook |first=Donald A. |year=2019 |title=Among the Scientologists: History, Theology, and Praxis |location=Oxford and New York |publisher=Oxford University Press |series=Oxford Studies in Western Esotericism |isbn=978-0190664978}}</ref>{{rp|81–83}}<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Kent |first=Stephen A. |author-link=Stephen A. Kent |year=1996 |title=Scientology's Relationship With Eastern Religious Traditions |journal=] |volume=11 |issue=1 |pages=21–36 |url=http://www.arts.ualberta.ca/~skent/Linkedfiles/Scientology%27s%20Relationship%20With%20Eastern%20Religious%20Traditions%20.htm |access-date=January 13, 2009 |doi=10.1080/13537909608580753 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120902204426/http://www.arts.ualberta.ca/~skent/Linkedfiles/Scientology%27s%20Relationship%20With%20Eastern%20Religious%20Traditions%20.htm |archive-date=September 2, 2012 }}</ref> As well as escaping prosecution, Hubbard also saw the possibility of reducing the tax burden from the sale of dianetics books and methods.<ref>{{Cite journal|last=Beit-Hallahmi|first=Benjamin|title=Scientology: Religion or Racket?|author-link=Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi|journal=]|volume=8|number=1|date=September 2003|pages=1–56|publisher=]|doi=10.17192/mjr.2003.8.3724|url=https://archiv.ub.uni-marburg.de/ep/0004/article/view/3724|doi-access=free|access-date=June 30, 2006}}</ref> | |||
Practitioners of Dianetics believe that "the basic principle of existence is to survive"<ref name=":2">{{Cite book|title = The Hidden Story of Scientology|last = Garrison|first = Omar V.|publisher = Citadel Press, Lyle Stuart, Inc.|year = 1974|isbn = 978-0-8065-0440-7|location = Secaucus, NJ|pages = |url = https://archive.org/details/hiddenstoryofsci00garr/page/23}}</ref> and that the basic personality of humans is sincere, intelligent, and good.<ref name=":2" /> The drive for goodness and survival is distorted and inhibited by aberrations<ref name=":2" /> "ranging from simple neuroses to different psychotic states to various kinds of sociopathic behavior patterns." Hubbard developed Dianetics, claiming that it could eradicate these aberrations.<ref>{{cite book | last1 = Melton | first1 = J. Gordon | authorlink1 = J. Gordon Melton | title = The Church of Scientology | editor = Massimo Introvigne | publisher = Signature Books | year = 2000 | isbn = 978-1-56085-139-4 | url = https://archive.org/details/churchofscientol00meltrich }}</ref> | |||
== Premise == | |||
When Hubbard formulated Dianetics, he described it as "a mix of Western technology and Oriental philosophy".<ref name="James R. Lewis 1997, page 287">{{cite journal |first=James R. |last=Lewis |title=Clearing the Planet: Utopian Idealism and the Church of Scientology |journal=Syzygy, Journal of Alternative Religion and Culture |volume=6 |issue=1–2 |year=1997 |page=287 |issn=1059-6860 }}</ref> He said that Dianetics "forms a bridge between" ] and ] (a set of ideas about education originated by ], which received much attention in the science fiction world in the 1940s)<ref>Hubbard, " {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20060204155459/http://www.dianetics.org/en_US/l-ron-hubbard/articles/terra/ |date=February 4, 2006}}," ''The Explorers Journal'', winter 1949 / spring 1950 (on the bridge between cybernetics and general semantics)</ref><ref>M. Kendig, editor ''Alfred Korzybski: Collected Writings, 1920-1950'', ch. 12, Institute of ], 1990 {{ISBN|0-910780-08-0}}. (Presented at the First American Congress for General Semantics, May 1935)</ref>—a claim denied by scholars of General Semantics,<ref>{{cite web|last=Klingbeil|first=José|title=General Semantics vs. Scientology|url=http://esgs.free.fr/uk/art/jk8.htm|accessdate=August 25, 2012}}</ref> including ], who expressed strong criticism of Dianetics as early as 1951.<ref>{{cite journal|last=Hayakawa|first=S. I.|title=Dianetics : From Science-fiction to Fiction-science|journal=ETC: A Review of General Semantics|year=1951|volume=8:4|pages=280–293}}</ref> Hubbard claimed that Dianetics could increase intelligence, eliminate unwanted emotions and alleviate a wide range of illnesses he believed to be ]. Among the conditions purportedly treated were arthritis, allergies, asthma, some coronary difficulties, eye trouble, ulcers, migraine headaches, "sexual deviation" (which for Hubbard included ]), and even death.<ref name=TwoMinds>{{cite news | title = Of Two Minds | url = http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,812852,00.html |work = ] |date=July 24, 1950 |accessdate=July 4, 2008}}</ref> Hubbard asserted that "memories of painful physical and emotional experiences accumulate in a specific region of the mind, causing illness and mental problems." He taught that "once these experiences have been purged through cathartic procedures he developed, a person can achieve superior health and intelligence."<ref>{{cite news | first = Joel | last = Sappell |author2=Robert W. Welkos | title = Costly Strategy Continues to Turn Out Bestsellers Series: The Scientology story. Today: The Making of a Best-Selling Author. Fifth in a six-part series. |date=June 28, 1990 |newspaper=Los Angeles Times }}</ref> Hubbard also variously defined Dianetics as "a spiritual healing technology" and "an organized science of thought."<ref>{{cite journal |title=Psychiatry and Psychology in the Writings of L. Ron Hubbard |journal=Journal of Religion and Health |date=September 2007 |volume=46 |issue=3 |pages=437–44 |doi=10.1007/s10943-006-9079-9|last1=McCall |first1=W. Vaughn }}<!--|accessdate=June 16, 2011 --></ref> | |||
The word ''Dianetics'' was coined from Greek ''dia'' meaning "through" and ''nous'' meaning "mind".{{r|lewis-ch20|p=394}} | |||
Dianetics is strongly related to the ideas of Sigmund Freud (psychoanalysis) and the ideas of William Sargant (abreaction therapy). Hubbard borrowed ideas heavily also from Carl Jung, Spiegel (hypnoanalysis), Korzybski (theory of identity), Nandor Fodor (prenatal and birth trauma), Otto Rank, and others.<ref>Genter, R. (2017). Constructing a Plan for Survival: Scientology as Cold War Psychology. Religion and American Culture, 27(2), 159-190.</ref><ref>Wallis, R. (1978). The road to total freedom: A sociological analysis of Scientology</ref><ref>Mcconahay, J. B. (1977). The road to total freedom: A sociological analysis of Scientology. Psyccritiques, 22(10), 784-785.</ref><ref>Atack, J. (1990). A Piece of Blue Sky. New York. pg 402</ref> | |||
Dianetics theory describes the human mind as two parts: the conscious "analytical mind" and the subconscious "]".{{r|TwoMinds}} The stated purpose of Dianetics technique, called "]", is to erase the contents of the reactive mind—the holder of painful and destructive emotions which can act on a person as posthypnotic suggestions.{{r|wright|p=61}} "Auditing" uses techniques from ] which are intended to create ] and ] in the auditing subject.<ref name=HaSc24>{{cite book |last1=Hassan |first1=Steven A.|author-link1=Steven Hassan|last2=Scheflin |first2=Alan W.|editor-last1=Linden|editor-last2=De Benedittis|editor-last3=Sugarman|editor-last4=Varga|editor-first1=Julie H.|editor-first2=Giuseppe|editor-first3=Laurence I.|editor-first4=Katalin|chapter=Understanding the Dark Side of Hypnosis as a Form of Undue Influence Exerted in Authoritarian Cults: Implications for Practice, Policy, and Education|title=The Routledge International Handbook of Clinical Hypnosis |date=2024 |publisher=] |location=Abingdon/New York |isbn=978-1-032-31140-1 |pages=755–772 |url=https://www.routledge.com/The-Routledge-International-Handbook-of-Clinical-Hypnosis/Linden-DeBenedittis-Sugarman-Varga/p/book/9781032311401}}</ref> In auditing, the person is asked questions intended to help them locate and deal with painful past experiences.{{r|wright|p=63}} | |||
Dianetics was described as a “branch of psychology.”<ref>Lewis, Jim R., and Olav Hammer, eds. Handbook of Religion and the Authority of Science. Brill, 2010., pg 757</ref><ref>Hubbard, L. R. Scientology: the fundamentals of thought. E.E. Manney, (1956), chapter one</ref><ref>Stearns, Frederick R. (March 1951). "Dianetics". Clinical Medicine</ref> Hubbard created the "Freudian Foundation of America" and offered graduate auditors certificates which included that of “Freudian Psychoanalyst.”<ref>Technical Bulletins of Dianetics & Scientology vol.2, p.32; St Petersburg Times, "Scientology," p.17</ref><ref>JCA-35</ref> Atack writes that the original Dianetic techniques can be derived almost entirely from Freud's lectures.<ref>Atack, J. (1990). A Piece of Blue Sky. New York. pg 121</ref> Hubbard differentiated Dianetics from Scientology, affirming that Dianetics was a mental therapy science and Scientology was a religion.<ref>JCA-40, Dianetics Bulletin of 4 May 1972</ref> | |||
Dianetics theory posits that "the basic principle of existence is to survive" and that the basic personality of humans is sincere, intelligent, and good. The drive for goodness and survival is distorted and inhibited by aberrations (deviations from rational thinking).{{r|garrison|page=25}} Hubbard claimed that Dianetics could increase intelligence, eliminate unwanted emotions and alleviate a wide range of illnesses he believed to be ]. Conditions purportedly treatable with Dianetics included arthritis, allergies, asthma, some coronary difficulties, eye trouble, ulcers, migraine headaches, and sexual deviation.<ref name=TwoMinds>{{cite news | title = Of Two Minds | url = http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,812852,00.html | archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20070930084842/http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,812852,00.html | url-status = dead | archive-date = 30 September 2007 |magazine = ] |date=July 24, 1950 |access-date=July 4, 2008}} (, )</ref> | |||
Dianetics predates Hubbard's classification of Scientology as an "applied religious philosophy". Early in 1951, he expanded his writings to include teachings related to the soul, or "]".<ref>{{Cite book|title = The Hidden Story of Scientology|last = Garrison|first = Omar V.|publisher = Citadel Press, Lyle Stuart, Inc.|year = 1974|isbn = 978-0-8065-0440-7|location = Secaucus, NJ|pages = |url = https://archive.org/details/hiddenstoryofsci00garr/page/34}}</ref> Today Dianetics is practiced by some independent Dianetics-only groups which do not practice Scientology. There are several ] or Independent Scientologists, which practice both Dianetics and Scientology, which operate outside of the incorporated Church of Scientology. The Church of Scientology has prosecuted a number of people in court for unauthorized publication of Scientology and Dianetics copyrighted material.<ref>{{cite web|last=Kapalko |first=Jamie |url=http://www.salon.com/1999/07/22/scientology/ |title=Copyright - or wrong?|work=Salon|date=July 22, 1999 |accessdate=December 3, 2015}}</ref> | |||
==History== | ==History== | ||
{{Main|History of Dianetics}} | |||
L. Ron Hubbard published Dianetics on May 9, 1950, as a "branch of self-help psychology".<ref>http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/l-ron-hubbard-publishes-dianetics</ref> In Dianetics, Hubbard introduced the "phenomena known as 'engrams'" as the source of "all psychological pain, which in turn harmed mental and physical health." He also claimed that individuals could reach the state of "clear", or a state of "exquisite clarity and mental liberation, by exorcising their engrams to an 'auditor,' or listener acting as therapist." | |||
While not accepted by the medical and scientific establishment, in the first two years of its publication, over 100,000 copies of the book were sold. Many enthusiasts emerged to form groups to study and practice Dianetics. The atmosphere from which Dianetics was written about in this period was one of "excited experimentation". Roy Wallis writes that Hubbard's work was regarded as an "initial exploration" for further development.<ref>{{cite journal |title=SCIENTOLOGY: THERAPEUTIC CULT TO RELIGIOUS SECT |journal=Sociology |year=1975 |volume=9 |issue=1 |pages=89–100 |jstor=42851574|doi=10.1177/003803857500900105|last1=Wallis |first1=Roy }}</ref> Hubbard wrote an additional six books in 1951, drawing the attention of a significant fan base.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/l-ron-hubbard-publishes-dianetics|title=L. Ron Hubbard publishes Dianetics|date=May 9, 1950|accessdate=2016-08-25|website= HISTORY.com}}</ref> | |||
{{Main|History of Dianetics and Scientology}} | |||
=== Prepublication === | |||
According to Hubbard, when he was sedated for a dental operation in 1938, he had a ] which inspired him to write the manuscript '']''. Though it was never published, this work would allegedly become the basis for Dianetics.{{r|wright|pages=29–30, 57}} The first publication on Dianetics was '']'', an article by Hubbard in '']'' (cover date May 1950).<ref name="Creation">{{cite journal |url=https://skent.ualberta.ca/contributions/scientology/the-creation-of-religious-scientology/ |title=The Creation of 'Religious' Scientology |journal=Religious Studies and Theology |volume=18 |issue=2 |date=December 1999 |access-date=2023-12-19 |url-status=live | archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20070312004725/http://www.solitarytrees.net/pubs/skent/creation.htm?FACTNet#txtref02 |archive-date=12 March 2007 |first=Stephen A. |last=Kent |pages=97–126 |doi=10.1558/rsth.v18i2.97 |author-link=Stephen A. Kent}}</ref> This was followed by the book '']'' (DMSMH) published May 9, 1950. In these works Hubbard claimed that the source of all psychological pain, and therefore the cause of mental and physical health problems, was a form of memory known as "]". According to Hubbard, individuals could reach a state he named "]" when all of their engrams had been removed through talking with an "]".{{r|Creation}} | |||
Hubbard always claimed that his ideas of Dianetics originated in the 1920s and 1930s. By his own account,<ref name="urban2006">Urban, Hugh B. "Fair Game: Secrecy, Security, and the Church of Scientology in Cold War America." '']'' '''74''':2 (2006)</ref> he had been injured by the premature detonation of a primer mechanism on a small depth charge that had become stuck in the launch rack aboard the navy ship he was assigned to in 1941. His injuries were mainly flash burns to his eyes and so was despatched ashore and he spent a great deal of his recovery time in the ] library (despite claiming in his authorised biography that he was blinded). LRH encountered the work of Thompson, Korzybski, Jung, Freud, Perls and other ]. | |||
While the technique was not accepted by the medical and scientific establishment, in the first two years of its publication DMSMH sold over 100,000 copies. Publication of DMSMH brought in a flood of revenue, which Hubbard used to establish Dianetics foundations in six major American cities.{{r|reitman|p=30}} Two of the strongest initial supporters of Dianetics in the 1950s were ], editor of ''Astounding Science Fiction'', and ], a writer and medical physician. Campbell published some of Hubbard's short stories, and Winter hoped that his own colleagues would likewise be attracted to Hubbard's Dianetics system.<ref>{{cite book |last1=Gallagher |first1=Eugene V. |title=The New Religious Movements Experience in America |publisher=Greenwood Publishing Group |year=2004 |isbn=9780313328077 |ol=10420337M}}</ref>{{rp|197}} | |||
In his 1955 Phoenix Lectures Series, Hubbard himself, explains that he took the opportunity to enter an office where research papers on the US Naval Medical Research Division's work on PTSD were kept in a filing cabinet and he spent the lunch hour free to read the notes left lying on the desk of the Naval Medical Officer involved. Much of what he learned then, along with his recent mastery of hypnotherapy technique by mail order, was influential in his later development of ideas and concepts for Dianetics Therapy from 1947 onwards. All he needed was medical and scientific testing and approval from any source. However, his several attempts were blocked by several luminaries of the (AMA) American Medical Association in the years 1948–1958, such as Professors Duncan Cameron and Allan Whyte (White), who both were senior authorities within the AMA-funded Psychiatric Research Department, then conducting their own research into drug therapies and controversial psycho-surgical techniques on severely traumatised war veterans. | |||
Readers formed groups to study and practice Dianetics technique. According to sociologist ], this period was one of "excited experimentation" and Hubbard's work was regarded as "an initial exploration to be developed further by others".<ref>{{cite journal |journal=Sociology |year=1975 |volume=9 |issue=1 |pages=89–100 |jstor=42851574|doi=10.1177/003803857500900105|last=Wallis |first=Roy |author-link=Roy Wallis |title=Scientology: Therapeutic Cult to Religious Sect |s2cid=144335265 }}</ref> Per Wallis, it was Dianetics' popularity as a lay ] that contributed to the Dianetics Foundation's downfall. Most people read the book, tried it out, then put it down. The remaining practitioners had no ties to the Foundation. Factions formed and followers challenged Hubbard's movement and his authority. The craze of 1950–51 was dead by 1952.<ref>{{cite journal |last=Wallis |first=Roy |author-link=Roy Wallis |title="Poor Man's Psychoanalysis?" Observations on Dianetics |journal=] |date=1976 |volume=1 |issue=1 |pages=9–24 |ref=zetetic-1-1 |url=https://skepticalinquirer.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/29/2019/03/1977-01.pdf#page=13}}</ref> | |||
Hubbard claimed in his several public lectures during the 1950s to have "undertaken clinical research at several of the institutions" they, Cameron and Whyte, had directed. Historical AMA records show that LRH was never officially involved in any approved clinical trials or research into PTSD. It is thought that Hubbard simply privately visited patients and conducted unauthorised interviews with several war veterans suffering from Trauma, Psychosomatic illness and practiced some of the newly identified PTSD techniques being clinically tested by several AMA medical institutions after WW2. (from personal Interviews with Joseph A. Winter, in Peoria,1959). | |||
In 1951, with debts piled up and facing bankruptcy, the Foundation was bailed out by Don Purcell, a wealthy Dianetics follower from Wichita.{{r|miller|pages=185ff}} The relief was short-lived, however, and the Foundation fell to bankruptcy in 1952. Hubbard fled to Phoenix, Arizona, having lost the Foundation, the rights to Dianetics, and the DMSMH copyrights to Purcell.{{r|miller|pages=199–200}} Hubbard sued and in 1954 Purcell settled by giving the copyrights back to Hubbard.{{r|miller|pages=218-9}} | |||
In April 1950, Hubbard, and several others (Marjorie Cameron, De Mille, Art Ceppos, AE Van Vogt, Joseph A. Winter, MD.), established the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation in ] to coordinate work related to the forthcoming publication of DMSMH by Random House in May 1950 in NYC. Through the marketing efforts of Hubbard's friend and mentor John W. Campbell Jnr. (editor of '']'' of Street and Smith fame), Hubbard's articles on Dianetics hit the newsstands in NYC and became an overnight sensation among the usual readers with almost 350,000 copies sold of the May 1950 issue. (See interviews with John Campbell in his published 1978 biography.) | |||
In Phoenix, Hubbard created "Scientology"; its techniques were intended to rehabilitate a person so that they might reach their full potential as a spiritual being.<ref>{{cite book |last1=Lebron |first1=Robyn E. |title=Searching for Spiritual Unity...can There Be Common Ground?: A Basic Internet Guide to Forty World Religions & Spiritual Practices |publisher=Crossbooks |year=2012 |isbn=978-1462712618 |ol=30658519M |pages=532–3}}</ref> Dianetics was incorporated into Scientology. In 1978, Hubbard introduced "New Era Dianetics" (NED) and ], and added them to ].{{r|lewis2017|pp=XIV-XV}}<ref name="childs">{{cite news|url=http://www.tampabay.com/news/scientology/climbing-the-bridge-a-journey-to-operating-thetan/1062094|title=Climbing The Bridge: A journey to 'Operating Thetan'|first1=Joe|last1=Childs|first2=Thomas C.|last2=Tobin|date=December 30, 2009|access-date=2016-08-26|newspaper=]|archive-date=June 17, 2018|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20180617115559/http://www.tampabay.com/news/scientology/climbing-the-bridge-a-journey-to-operating-thetan/1062094|url-status=dead}}</ref> | |||
=== Publication === | |||
Hubbard first introduced Dianetics to the public in the article '']'' published in the May 1950 issue of the magazine '']''.<ref name="Creation">{{cite web | url = http://www.solitarytrees.net/pubs/skent/creation.htm?FACTNet#txtref02 | title = The Creation of 'Religious' Scientology | publisher = Religious Studies and Theology | accessdate = 8 May 2006 | deadurl = yes | archiveurl = https://web.archive.org/web/20070312004725/http://www.solitarytrees.net/pubs/skent/creation.htm?FACTNet#txtref02 | archivedate = 12 March 2007 | df = dmy-all }} Originally published by Stephen A. Kent in December 1999.</ref> Hubbard wrote '']'' at that time, allegedly completing the 180,000-word book in six weeks.<ref>"L.R.H. Biography," Sea Org Flag Information Letter 67, 31 October 1977</ref> The introduction of the book was the subject of an Associated Press article on 29 March 1950, with the lead "Discovery of a sub-mind is claimed in a new book entitled ''Dianetics''".<ref>''Tucson (AZ) Daily Citizen'', 29 March 1950, p12</ref> | |||
== Concepts == | |||
When ''Dianetics'' was published in 1950, Hubbard announced in the opening pages, "The first contribution of Dianetics is the discovery that the problems of thought and mental function can be resolved within the bounds of the finite universe, which is to say that all data needful to the solution of mental action and Man's endeavor can be measured, sensed and experienced as scientific truths independent of mysticism or metaphysics." This was in line with Hubbard's initial presentation of Dianetics as a science, almost four years before he founded Scientology.<ref>{{cite journal |title=The creation of 'religious' Scientology |journal=Religious Studies and Theology |date=2 December 1999 |last=Kent |first=Stephen A |volume=18 |issue=2 |pages=97–126 |issn=0829-2922 }}</ref> | |||
In the book, '']'', Hubbard describes techniques that he suggests can rid individuals of fears and psychosomatic illnesses. A basic idea in Dianetics is that the mind consists of two parts: the "analytical mind" and the "]". The "reactive mind", the mind which operates when a person is physically unconscious, acts as a record of shock, trauma, pain, and otherwise harmful memories. Experiences such as these, stored in the "reactive mind" are dubbed "]". Dianetics is proposed as a method to erase these engrams in the reactive mind to achieve a state of ].<ref name="James R. Lewis 1997, page 287">{{cite journal |first=James R. |last=Lewis |authorlink1=James R. Lewis (scholar) |title=Clearing the Planet: Utopian Idealism and the Church of Scientology |journal=Syzygy, Journal of Alternative Religion and Culture |volume=6 |issue=1–2 |year=1997 |page=287 |issn=1059-6860 }}</ref><ref>{{cite journal | last1 = Cook | first1 = Pat | year = 1971 | title = Scientology and Dianetics | journal = The Journal of Education | volume = 153 | issue = 4| pages = 58–61 | doi = 10.1177/002205747115300409 | jstor=42773008| s2cid = 151258588 }}</ref> | |||
Publication of ''Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health'' brought in a flood of money, which Hubbard used to establish Dianetics foundations in six major American cities. Dianetics shared The New York Times best-seller list with other self-help writings, including Norman Vincent Peale's ''The Art of Happiness'' and Henry Overstreet's ''The Mature Mind''.<ref>{{cite book |last=Urban |first1=Hugh B. |url=https://books.google.com/?id=8lgHtauc5R4C&pg=PA29&lpg=PA29&dq=Dianetics+New+York+Times+best-seller+list+Norman+Vincent+Peale#v=onepage&q=Dianetics%20New%20York%20Times%20best-seller%20list%20Norman%20Vincent%20Peale&f=false |title=The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion |publisher=Princeton University Press |year=2011 |isbn=9780691146089 |accessdate=6 May 2016 |quote=While Dianetics may seem implausible to many readers today, it shared the same New York Times best-seller list with other self-help manuals such as Norman Vincent Peale's True Art of Happiness and Henry Overstreet's The Mature Mind }}</ref> Scholar Hugh B. Urban asserted that the initial success of Dianetics was reflective of Hubbard's "remarkable entrepreneurial skills."<ref name="Urban 2011">{{cite book |last=Urban |first1=Hugh B. |title=The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion |publisher=Princeton University Press |year=2011 }}</ref> Posthumously, Publisher's Weekly awarded Hubbard a plaque to acknowledge Dianetics appearing on its bestseller list for one hundred weeks, consecutively.<ref>{{cite journal |title=Sacred Texts in the United States |journal=Book History |year=2001 |last=Gutjahr |first=Paul C. |volume=4 |pages=335–70 |jstor=30227336 }}</ref> | |||
In Dianetics, the unconscious or reactive mind is described as a collection of "mental image pictures", which contain the recorded experience of past moments of unconsciousness, including all sensory perceptions and feelings involved, ranging from ] experiences, infancy and childhood, to even the traumatic feelings associated with events from past lives and extraterrestrial cultures. The type of mental image picture created during a period of ] involves the exact recording of a painful experience. Hubbard called this phenomenon an ], and defined it as "a complete recording of a moment of unconsciousness containing physical pain or painful emotion and all perceptions."<ref>] page 79 and Glossary</ref>{{Better source needed|date=April 2024}} | |||
Some of the initial strongest supporters of Dianetics in the 1950s were John W. Campbell, editor of Astounding Science Fiction and Joseph Augustus Winter, a writer and medical physician. Campbell published some of Hubbard's short stories and Winter hoped that his colleagues would likewise be attracted to Hubbard's Dianetics system.<ref>{{cite book |last=Gallagher |first1=Eugene V. |title=The New Religious Movements Experience in America |publisher=Greenwood Publishing Group |year=2004 |isbn=9780313328077 }}</ref> | |||
Hubbard proposed that these engrams caused "aberrations" (deviations from rational thinking) in the mind, which produced lasting adverse physical and emotional effects. When the analytical (conscious) mind shut down during these moments, events and perceptions of this period were stored as engrams in the unconscious or reactive mind. In Hubbard's earliest publications on the subject, engrams were variously referred to as ''norn'', ''impediment'', and ''comanome'' before "engram" was adapted from its existing usage at the suggestion of Joseph Augustus Winter, MD.{{r|winter|pp=17-18}}{{r|atack|p=109}} Some commentators noted Dianetics's blend of science fiction and ] orientations at the time.<ref name="Creation"/> | |||
In January 1951, the New Jersey Board of Medical Examiners instituted proceedings against the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation in Elizabeth for 'teaching medicine without a licence', which was quickly resolved when the courts were made aware that the HDRF deputy director Winter was registered as an MD in the state of Michigan and New York. .<ref>''Bulletin of the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation'', Elizabeth, NJ. January 1951</ref> | |||
Hubbard claimed that these engrams were the cause of almost all psychological and physical problems. In addition to physical pain, engrams could include words or phrases spoken in the vicinity while the patient was unconscious. For instance, Winter cites the example of a patient with a persistent headache supposedly tracing the problem to a doctor saying, "Take him now", during the patient's birth.{{r|winter|p=165}} | |||
Sociologist ] says it was Dianetics popularity as a lay psychotherapy that contributed to the Foundation's downfall. It was the craze of 1950-51, but the fad was dead by 1952. Most people read the book, tried it out, then put it down. The remaining practitioners had no ties to the Foundation and resisted its control. Because there were no trained Dianetics professionals, factions formed. The followers challenged Hubbard's movement and his authority. Wallis suggests Hubbard learned an implicit lesson from this experience. He would not make the same mistake when creating Scientology.<ref>{{cite journal |last1=Wallis |first1=Roy |title="Poor Man's Psychoanalysis?" Observations on Dianetics |journal=] |date=1976 |volume=1 |issue=1 |pages=9-24 |ref=zetetic-1-1}}</ref> | |||
The Foundation closed its doors when Hubbard ditched the Foundation, causing the proceedings to be vacated, but its creditors began to demand settlement of its outstanding debts. Don Purcell, a millionaire Dianeticist from ], offered a brief respite from bankruptcy, but the Wichita Foundation's finances soon failed again in 1952 when Hubbard ran off to Phoenix with all his Dianetics materials to avoid the court bailiffs sent in by Don Purcell, who had paid a considerable amount of money to Hubbard for the copyrights to Dianetics in an effort to keep Hubbard from bankruptcy again.<ref name="barefaced">{{cite book | author=Miller, Russell | authorlink=Russell Miller | title=Bare-faced Messiah, The True Story of L. Ron Hubbard | publisher=Henry Holt & Co | location=New York | edition=First American | year=1987 | isbn=978-0-8050-0654-4 | pages= | url=https://archive.org/details/barefacedmessiah00mill_0/page/305 | chapter=11. Bankrolling and Bankruptcy | chapterurl=http://www.clambake.org/archive/books/bfm/bfm11.htm }}</ref> | |||
{{Blockquote |text= can give a man arthritis, ], ], ], ], ] trouble, high ] ... And it is the only thing in the human being which can produce these effects ... Discharge the content of and the arthritis vanishes, ] gets better, heart illness decreases, asthma disappears, stomachs function properly and the whole catalog of ills goes away and stays away. |author=L. Ron Hubbard <ref>{{Cite web |last=Hubbard |first=L. Ron |url=http://www.dianetics.org/en_US/info/01/pg003.html |title=What is the Reactive Mind? |access-date=28 April 2006 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080408052033/http://www.dianetics.org/en_US/info/01/pg003.html |archive-date=8 April 2008 |publisher=Church of Scientology International}}</ref>}} | |||
In 1954, Hubbard defined Scientology as a religion focused on the spirit, differentiating it from Dianetics, and subsequently Dianetics Auditing Therapy, which he defined as a counseling based science that addressed the physical being. He stated, "Dianetics is a science which applies to man, a living organism; and Scientology is a religion."<ref name="Urban 2011"/> When Hubbard morphed Dianetics therapy into the religion of Scientology, Jesper Aagaard Petersen of Oxford University surmises that it could have been for the benefits from establishing it is a religion as much as it could have been from the result of Hubbard's "discovery of past life experiences and his exploration of the thetan."<ref>{{cite book |last=Petersen |first1=Jesper Aagaard |title=Controversial New Religions |publisher=Oxford University |year=2014 }}</ref> The reason being to avoid copyright infringement issues with use of the name Dianetics then held by Don Purcell. Purcell later donated the copyright ownership back (to Hubbard) after Winter and Van Vogt had independently negotiated charitable debt relief with the disenchanted oil millionaire Purcell. | |||
According to ], Hubbard created the illusion that Dianetics was the first ] to address ]s in their own time, but others had done so before as standard procedure.{{r|corydon}} ] wrote it was clear that Hubbard's work had been influenced by ], ] and ], and Hubbard himself mentioned similarities between Dianetics and Freud.{{r|urban|pp=45,49}} | |||
With the temporary sale of assets resulting from the HDRF's bankruptcy, Hubbard no longer owned the rights to the name "Dianetics",<ref name="barefaced"/> but its philosophical framework still provided the seed for Scientology to grow. Scientologists refer to the book ''Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health'' as "Book One." In 1952, Hubbard published a new set of teachings as "Scientology, a religious philosophy." Scientology did not replace Dianetics but extended it to cover new areas: Where the goal of Dianetics is to rid the individual of his ] ], the stated goal of Scientology is to rehabilitate the individual's spiritual nature so that he may reach his full potential.<ref>{{cite book |last=Lebron |first1=Robyn E. |title=Searching for Spiritual Unity...can There Be Common Ground?: A Basic Internet Guide to Forty World Religions & Spiritual Practices |publisher=Crossbooks |year=2012 |isbn=978-1462712618 }}</ref> | |||
Hubbard claimed that by using Dianetics technique the reactive mind could be emptied of all engrams; "cleared" of its contents. A person who has completed this process would be "Clear". The benefits of Clear might include a higher IQ, better relationships, or career success.{{r|urban|p=46}} | |||
In 1963 and again in May 1969, Hubbard reorganized the material in Dianetics, the auditing commands, and original Volney Mathieson invented ] use, naming the package "Standard Dianetics." In a 1969 bulletin, "This bulletin combines HCOB 27 April 1969 'R-3-R Restated' with those parts of HCOB 24 June 1963 'Routine 3-R' used in the new Standard Dianetic Course and its application. This gives the complete steps of Routine 3-R Revised."<ref>''HCOB 6 May 69 II "Routine 3-R Revised, Engram Running by Chains"''</ref> | |||
{{anchor|Dianetics session}} | |||
In 1978, Hubbard released ''New Era Dianetics'' (NED), a revised version supposed to produce better results in a shorter period of time. The course consists of 11 ] and requires a specifically trained auditor.<ref>{{cite web| url=http://www.auditing.org/13-ned.htm| title=New Era Dianetics Auditing| accessdate=5 October 2006}}</ref> It is similar to Standard Dianetics, but the person being audited is encouraged to find the decision or "postulate" he made during or as a result of the incident.<ref>L. Ron Hubbard ''New Era Dianetics Series 7RA'', HCOB 28 June 1978RA revised 15 September 1978, Hubbard Communications Office (HCO).</ref> ("Postulate" in Dianetics and Scientology has the meaning of "a conclusion, decision or resolution made by the individual himself; to conclude, decide or resolve a problem or to set a pattern for the future or to nullify a pattern of the past"<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.scientology.ie/p_jpg/wis/wiseng/gloss.htm#p |title=The Official Scientology and Dianetics Glossary |publisher=Scientology.ie |accessdate=22 November 2011 |deadurl=yes |archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20090428234523/http://www.scientology.ie/p_jpg/wis/wiseng/gloss.htm#p |archivedate=28 April 2009 |df=dmy-all }}</ref> in contrast to its conventional meanings.) | |||
== Procedure == | |||
] | |||
In the Church of Scientology, ] study several levels of ] before reaching the highest level.<ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.tampabay.com/news/scientology/climbing-the-bridge-a-journey-to-operating-thetan/1062094|title=Climbing The Bridge: A journey to 'Operating Thetan'|first1= Joe |last1= Childs |first2= Thomas C. |last2=Tobin|date=December 30, 2009|accessdate=2016-08-26|newspaper= ]}}</ref> | |||
The procedure of Dianetics therapy (known as ''auditing'') is a two-person activity. One person, the "auditor", guides the other person, the '']'', through the procedures. The preclear's job is to look at their mind and talk to the auditor. The auditor acknowledges what the preclear says and controls the process. | |||
The auditor and preclear sit down facing each other. After getting settled, the auditor tells the preclear to close their eyes and locate something that happened to them in the past. The preclear tells the auditor what happened in the incident like he is re-experiencing it again. The auditor coaxes the preclear to recall as much as possible, and goes back over the incident several times until the preclear is cheerful about it, at which point the auditor may end the session or find another incident and repeat the process.<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.rehabilitatenz.co.nz/pages/dianetics-auditing-steps.html |title=The Dianetics Procedure - 10 Simple Steps |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20030226223940/http://www.rehabilitatenz.co.nz/pages/dianetics-auditing-steps.html |archive-date=26 February 2003}}</ref>{{r|hubbard-dmsmh}} | |||
==Basic concepts== | |||
In the book, '']'', Hubbard describes techniques that he suggests can rid individuals of fears and psychosomatic illnesses. A basic idea in Dianetics is that the mind consists of two parts: the "analytical mind" and the "]." The "reactive mind", the mind which operates when a person is physically unconscious, acts as a record of shock, trauma, pain, and otherwise harmful memories. Experiences such as these, stored in the "reactive mind" are dubbed "]". Dianetics is proposed as a method to erase these engrams in the reactive mind to achieve a state of ].<ref name="James R. Lewis 1997, page 287"/><ref>{{cite journal | last1 = Cook | first1 = Pat | year = 1971 | title = Scientology and Dianetics | journal = The Journal of Education | volume = 153 | issue = 4| pages = 58–61 | jstor=42773008}}</ref> | |||
==Therapeutic claims== | |||
Hubbard described Dianetics as "an organized science of thought built on definite axioms: statements of ]s on the order of those of the physical sciences".<ref>Winter, J.A. ''Dianetics: A Doctor's Report'', p. 18 (Julian Press, 1987 reprint)</ref> In April 1950, before the public release of Dianetics, he wrote: "To date, over two hundred patients have been treated; of those two hundred, two hundred cures have been obtained."<ref>Hubbard, "Dianetics". ''Astounding Science Fiction'', May 1950.</ref> | |||
{{Blockquote |text=The slick craftsman of mass-production science-fiction, mustering his talents and energies for a supreme effort, produces a fictional science. Had dianetics been presented as fiction it might have been, like other ingenious science-fiction, good entertainment. |author=]{{r|hayakawa|page=281}} }} | |||
In Dianetics, the unconscious or reactive mind is described as a collection of "mental image pictures," which contain the recorded experience of past moments of unconsciousness, including all sensory perceptions and feelings involved, ranging from ] experiences, infancy and childhood, to even the traumatic feelings associated with events from past lives and extraterrestrial cultures. The type of mental image picture created during a period of ] involves the exact recording of a painful experience. Hubbard called this phenomenon an ], and defined it as "a complete recording of a moment of unconsciousness containing physical pain or painful emotion and all perceptions."<ref>] page 79 and Glossary</ref> | |||
In August 1950, amidst the success of '']'', Hubbard held a demonstration in Los Angeles' ] where he presented a young woman called Sonya Bianca (a pseudonym) to a large audience including many reporters and photographers as "the world's first ]". Despite Hubbard's claim that she had "full and perfect recall of every moment of her life", Bianca proved unable to answer questions from the audience testing her memory and analytical abilities, including the question of the color of Hubbard's tie. Hubbard explained Bianca's failure to display her promised powers of recall to the audience by saying that he had used the word "now" in calling her to the stage, and thus inadvertently froze her in "present time", which blocked her abilities.{{r|miller|pages=165–166}}{{r|atack|pages=114–115}} Later, in the late 1950s, Hubbard would claim that several people had reached the state of Clear by the time he presented Bianca as the world's first; these others, Hubbard said, he had successfully cleared in the late 1940s while working ''incognito'' in Hollywood posing as a ].<ref>{{cite speech| first=L. Ron| last=Hubbard| title=The Story of Dianetics and Scientology, Lecture 18| date=October 1958| quote=by 1947, I had achieved clearing.}}</ref> In 1966, Hubbard declared South African Scientologist John McMaster to be the first true Clear.<ref>{{cite magazine|first=Alan|last=Levy|title=Scientology|magazine=]|date=15 November 1968}}</ref><ref>{{cite journal|first=Wendy|last=Michener|title=Is This the Happiest Man in the World?|journal=]|date=22 August 1966}}</ref> | |||
Hubbard said that in Dianetics, it was the analytical mind and not the reactive mind that was the most important because the analytical mind "computes decisions" even when these are dictated by the reactive mind. The damage and aberration caused by the reactive mind would not be possible without the analytic mind. Hubbard stated, "the analytical is so important to the intelligent being and the somatic mind so important to the athlete that Dianetics processing can be said to consist of deintensifying the reactive mind so that the analytical and somatic minds can be free to function properly."<ref>{{cite journal |title=Rethinking Scientology A Thorough Analysis of L. Ron Hubbard's Formulation of Therapy and Religion in Dianetics and Scientology, 1950–1986 |journal=Alternative Spirituality and Religion Review |volume=7 |pages=155–227 |date=June 24, 2016 |last=Christensen |first=Dorthe Refslund |doi=10.5840/asrr201662323 }}</ref> | |||
Hubbard claimed, in an interview with '']'' in November 1950, that "he had already submitted proof of claims made in the book to a number of scientists and associations." He added that the public as well as proper organizations were entitled to such proof and that he was ready and willing to give such proof in detail.<ref name="freeman">{{Cite news |title=Psychologists Act Against Dianetics; Claims Made for New Therapy Not Backed by Empirical Evidence, Group Says Offered Proof, Says Author |work=The New York Times |date=9 September 1950 |url=https://www.nytimes.com/1950/09/09/archives/psychologists-act-against-dianetics-claims-made-for-new-therapy-not.html |url-access=subscription |first=Lucy |last=Freeman |author-link=Lucy Freeman}}</ref> In January 1951, the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation of ], published ''Dianetic Processing: A Brief Survey of Research Projects and Preliminary Results'', a booklet providing the results of psychometric tests conducted on 88 people undergoing Dianetics therapy. It presents case histories and a number of ] plates to support claims that Dianetics had cured "aberrations" including ], asthma, ], ] and "overt homosexuality", and that after Dianetic processing, test subjects experienced significantly increased scores on a standardized IQ test. The report's subjects are not identified by name, but one of them is clearly Hubbard himself ("Case 1080A, R. L.").<ref name="ibanez">{{cite book |last1=Ibanez |first1=Dalmyra |last2=Southon |first2=Gordon |last3=Southon |first3=Peggy |last4=Benton |first4=Peggy |title=Dianetic Processing: A Brief Survey of Research Projects and Preliminary Results |publisher=Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation |year=1951 |page=36}}</ref> | |||
Hubbard proposed that painful physical or emotional traumas caused "aberrations" (deviations from rational thinking) in the mind, which produced lasting adverse physical and emotional effects, similar to ]. When the analytical (conscious) mind shut down during these moments, events and perceptions of this period were stored as engrams in the unconscious or reactive mind. (In Hubbard's earliest publications on the subject, engrams were variously referred to as "Norns",<ref name="Creation"/> "Impediments," and "comanomes" before "engram" was adapted from its existing usage at the suggestion of Joseph Augustus Winter, MD.)<ref name="Blue Sky">{{cite book | last = Atack | first = Jon | authorlink = Jon Atack | year = 1990 | title = A Piece of Blue Sky | publisher = Carol Publishing Group | location = New York, NY | isbn = 978-0-8184-0499-3 | page = | url = https://archive.org/details/pieceofblueskysc00atac/page/109 }}</ref> Some commentators noted Dianetics's blend of science fiction and ] orientations at the time.<ref name="Creation"/> | |||
The authors provide no qualifications, although they are described in Hubbard's book ''Science of Survival'' (where some results of the same study were reprinted) as psychotherapists. Critics of Dianetics are skeptical of this study, both because of the bias of the source and because the researchers appear to ascribe all physical benefits to Dianetics without considering possible outside factors; in other words, the report lacks any ]s. Winter was originally an associate of Hubbard and an early adopter of Dianetics, but by the end of 1950 had cut ties with Hubbard and written an account of his personal experiences with Dianetics.{{r|winter|p=39}} He described Hubbard as "absolutistic and authoritarian",<ref name=departure/> and criticized the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation for failing to undertake "precise scientific research into the functioning of the mind".{{r|winter|p=40}} He also recommended that auditing be done by experts only and that it was dangerous for laymen to audit each other.<ref name=departure>{{cite news | title = Departure in Dianetics | url = http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,821638,00.html | archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20071114123503/http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,821638,00.html | url-status = dead | archive-date = 14 November 2007 | magazine = Time | date = 3 September 1951 | access-date = 14 February 2008 }}</ref> Hubbard writes: "Again, Dianetics is not being released to a profession, for no profession could encompass it."<ref>L. Ron Hubbard '']'', p. 204, ], 2007 {{ISBN|978-1-4031-4484-3}}; 1st ed. 1950</ref> | |||
Hubbard claimed that these engrams are the cause of almost all psychological and physical problems. In addition to physical pain, engrams could include words or phrases spoken in the vicinity while the patient was unconscious. For instance, Winter cites the example of a patient with a persistent headache supposedly tracing the problem to a doctor saying, "Take him now," during the patient's birth.<ref>Winter, ''Dianetics: A Doctor's Report'', p. 165</ref> Hubbard similarly claimed that ] is traceable to "an engram containing the phrase 'It turns my blood to water.'"<ref>Hubbard, ''A History of Man'', p.20. American Saint Hill Organization, 1968</ref> While it is sometimes claimed that the Church of Scientology no longer stands by Hubbard's claims that Dianetics can treat physical conditions, it still publishes them: "... when the knee injuries of the past are located and discharged, the ] ceases, no other injury takes its place and the person is finished with arthritis of the knee."<ref>Hubbard, L. Ron. . Retrieved 22 April 2006. {{webarchive |url=https://web.archive.org/web/20130211210501/http://www.smi.org/route/page06.htm |date=11 February 2013 }}</ref> " can give a man arthritis, ], ], ], ], ] trouble, high ] ... And it is the only thing in the human being which can produce these effects ... Discharge the content of and the arthritis vanishes, ] gets better, heart illness decreases, asthma disappears, stomachs function properly and the whole catalog of ills goes away and stays away."<ref>Hubbard, L. Ron. . Retrieved 28 April 2006. {{webarchive |url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080408052033/http://www.dianetics.org/en_US/info/01/pg003.html |date=8 April 2008 }}</ref> | |||
==Scientific rejection== | |||
Hubbard defined the third mind, or the somatic mind, as "that mind which, directed by the analytical or reactive mind, places solution into effect on the physical level." If an individual is not suffering from aberration or engrams are not restimulated, thus causing the person to relive pain, the analytical mind controls the somatic mind, in turn controlling blood flow, the heartbeat and endocrines. When a person is "aberrated," the reactive mind controls the somatic mind.<ref>{{cite journal |title=Rethinking Scientology A Thorough Analysis of L. Ron Hubbard's Formulation of Therapy and Religion in Dianetics and Scientology, 1950–1986 |journal=Alternative Spirituality and Religion Review |volume=7 |pages=155–227 |date=June 24, 2016 |last=Christensen |first=Dorthe Refslund |doi=10.5840/asrr201662323 }}</ref> | |||
Hubbard's original book on Dianetics attracted highly critical reviews from science and medical writers and organizations. The ] passed a resolution in 1950 calling "attention to the fact that these claims are not supported by ] evidence of the sort required for the establishment of scientific generalizations."{{r|freeman}}<ref name=timeapa>{{cite news | title = Tests & Poison | url = http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,813284,00.html | archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20090114212752/http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,813284,00.html | url-status = dead | archive-date = 14 January 2009 | magazine = Time | date = 18 September 1950 | access-date = 10 February 2008 }}</ref> Subsequently, Dianetics has achieved no acceptance as a ], and scientists cite Dianetics as an example of a ].{{r|gardner|page=274}}<ref>See e.g. Bauer, ''Scientific Literacy and the Myth of the Scientific Method'' and ''Science Or Pseudoscience: Magnetic Healing, Psychic Phenomena, and Other Heterodoxies''; Corsini et al., ''The Dictionary of Psychology''.</ref><ref name=":1">{{cite book|chapter=Demise of the Dogmatic Universe|title=Historical Encyclopedia of Natural and Mathematical Sciences|author=Ari Ben-Menahem|isbn=978-3-540-68831-0|year=2009|publisher=Springer Berlin Heidelberg|doi=10.1007/978-3-540-68832-7|pages=4301–4302}}</ref> | |||
Some of the ] ideas in Dianetics, in particular the ], can be traced to ]. Basic concepts, including ], are derived from ], whom Hubbard credited as an inspiration and source.<ref>Letter from John W. Campbell, cited in Winter, p. 3 - "His approach is, actually, based on some very early work of Freud"</ref> Freud had speculated 40 years previously that traumas with similar content join together in "chains," embedded in the unconscious mind, to cause irrational responses in the individual. Such a chain would be relieved by inducing the patient to remember the earliest trauma, "with an accompanying expression of emotion."<ref>Joseph Breuer and Sigmund Freud, "Studies in Hysteria", Vol II of the ''Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud''. Hogarth Press, London (1955).</ref><ref>L. Ron Hubbard ''A Critique of Psychoanalysis'', PAB 92, 10 July 1956.</ref> | |||
Few scientific investigations into the effectiveness of Dianetics have been published. Professor ] states in his 1970 evaluation of Dianetics: | |||
According to Bent Corydon, Hubbard created the illusion that Dianetics was the first ] to address ]s in their own time, but others had done so as standard procedure.<ref>https://web.archive.org/web/20130613033101/http://anonireland.com/content/wppdfcontent/books/messiahormadmen.pdf</ref> | |||
{{blockquote|Objective experimental verification of Hubbard's ] and psychological doctrines is lacking. To date, no regular scientific agency has established the validity of his theories of prenatal perception and engrams, or cellular memory, or Dianetic reverie, or the effects of Scientology auditing routines. Existing knowledge contradicts Hubbard's theory of recording of perceptions during periods of unconsciousness. |author=John A. Lee in '']'' (1970) <ref name="lee"/>}} | |||
One treatment method Hubbard drew from in developing Dianetics was ]. ] is a ] ] that means bringing to ], and thus adequate expression, material that has been unconscious. "It includes not only the recollection of forgotten memories and ], but also their reliving with appropriate emotional display and discharge of effect. This process is usually facilitated by the patient's gaining awareness of the ] between the previously undischarged ] and his ]s."<ref>Bent Corydon ''L. Ron Hubbard, Messiah or Madman?'', pp. 283-4, Barricade Books Inc., 1992 {{ISBN|0-942637-57-7}}</ref> | |||
The ] database records two independent scientific studies on Dianetics, both conducted in the 1950s under the auspices of ]. Harvey Jay Fischer tested Dianetic therapy against three claims made by proponents and found it does not effect any significant changes in intellectual functioning, mathematical ability, or the degree of personality conflicts;<ref>Fischer, Harvey Jay. "Dianetic therapy: an experimental evaluation. A statistical analysis of the effect of dianetic therapy as measured by group tests of intelligence, mathematics and personality". Abstract of Ph.D. thesis, 1953, New York University ()</ref> Jack Fox tested Hubbard's thesis regarding recall of engrams, with the assistance of the Dianetic Research Foundation, and could not substantiate it.<ref>{{Cite journal |first1=Jack |last1=Fox |first2=Alvin E. |last2=Davis |first3=B |last3=Lebovits |title=An Experimental Investigation of Hubbard's Engram Hypothesis (Dianetics) |journal=Psychological Newsletter |publisher=New York University |volume=10 |year=1959 |pages=131–134}}</ref> | |||
According to Hubbard, before Dianetics psychotherapists had dealt with very light and superficial incidents (e.g. an incident that reminds the patient of a moment of loss), but with Dianetic therapy, the patient could actually erase moments of pain and unconsciousness. He emphasized: "The discovery of the engram is entirely the property of Dianetics. Methods of its erasure are also owned entirely by Dianetics..."<ref>''A Critique of Psychoanalysis'', ibid. Pab 92</ref> | |||
Commentators from a variety of backgrounds have described Dianetics as an example of pseudoscience. For example, ] professor ] points to Dianetics' lack of empirical evidence: | |||
While 1950 style Dianetics was in some respects similar to older therapies, with the development of New Era Dianetics in 1978, the similarity vanished. New Era Dianetics uses an E-Meter and a rote procedure<ref>{{cite journal|last=Hubbard|first=L Ron|title=R3RA Commands|journal=HCO Bulletin |date=28 June 1978|series=New Era Dianetics Series 7RA}}</ref> for running ''chains'' of related traumatic incidents.<ref>{{cite journal|last=Hubbard|first=L Ron|title=Routine 3RA Engram Running by Chains|journal=HCO Bulletin |date=26 June 1978 |series=New Era Dianetics series 6RA}}</ref> | |||
{{blockquote|What Hubbard touts as a science of mind lacks one key element that is expected of a science: empirical testing of claims. The key elements of Hubbard's so-called science don't seem testable, yet he repeatedly claims that he is asserting only scientific facts and data from many experiments. It isn't even clear what such "data" would look like. Most of his data is in the form of anecdotes and speculations ... Such speculation is appropriate in fiction, but not in science.{{r|carroll}}}} | |||
Dianetics clarifies the understanding of psychosomatic illness in terms of ''predisposition'', ''precipitation'', and ''prolongation''. | |||
The validity and practice of auditing have been questioned by a variety of non-Scientologist commentators. Commenting on the example cited by Winter, the science writer ] asserts that "nothing could be clearer from the above dialogue than the fact that the dianetic explanation for the headache existed only in the mind of the therapist, and that it was with considerable difficulty that the patient was maneuvered into accepting it."{{r|gardner|p=278}} | |||
{{quotation|'''HCO Bulletin 11 July 1973RB''' | |||
Other critics and medical experts have suggested that Dianetic auditing is a form of ].{{r|atack|pages=110,170}}<ref>"Psychologist says church appeared to use hypnosis", '']'', 13 March 2003</ref><ref>"The 'Scientology Organization' (SO) as of July 2003", chapter 2, Landesamt für Verfassungsschutz Baden-Wuerttemberg, 2003</ref> Hubbard, who had previously used hypnosis for ], strongly denied this connection and cautioned against hypnosis in Dianetics auditing.<ref>{{cite book |last1=Westbrook |first1=Donald |title=Among the Scientologists: History, Theology, and Praxis |date=2018 |publisher=Oxford University Press |isbn=9780190664978 |pages=60 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=MzpxDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA60 |access-date=October 16, 2019 |language=en}}</ref><ref>"]", L. Ron Hubbard, p. 461 (2007 edition).</ref> Professor ], a leading expert on false memories, suggests that the feeling of well-being reported by preclear at the end of an auditing session may be induced by post-hypnotic ].<ref>"A Very Brief Overview of Scientology", Richard E. Ofshe, Ph.D.</ref> Other researchers have identified quotations in Hubbard's work suggesting evidence that false memories were created in ''Dianetics'', specifically in the form of birth and pre-birth memories.<ref>{{Cite journal|title = False memories in therapy and hypnosis before 1980.|journal = Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice|pages = 153–169|volume = 2|issue = 2|doi = 10.1037/cns0000044|first1 = Lawrence|last1 = Patihis|first2 = Helena J. Younes|last2 = Burton|year = 2015|doi-access = free}}</ref> | |||
Injury and illness are PREDISPOSED by the spiritual state of the person. They are PRECIPITATED by the being himself as a manifestation of his current spiritual condition. And they are PROLONGED by any failure to fully handle the spiritual factors associated with them.|Hubbard, LR|Assist Summary}} | |||
According to an article by physician ], "Hubbard's concept of psychosomatic disease is definitely wrong. Psychosomatic ailments are not simply caused by emotional disturbances: they are diseases in which the emotional and the organic factor are closely involved and interdependent."<ref>{{Cite news|url=https://newrepublic.com/article/121590/1950-takedown-l-ron-hubbards-scientology-book-dianetics|title=A Doctor's Scathing 1950 Takedown of L. Ron Hubbard's 'Dianetics'|magazine=]|access-date=2018-10-17|language=en-US |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150518182712/https://newrepublic.com/article/121590/1950-takedown-l-ron-hubbards-scientology-book-dianetics |archive-date=May 18, 2015 |first=Martin |last=Gumpert |author-link=Martin Gumpert |date=August 14, 1950}}</ref> | |||
With the use of Dianetics techniques, Hubbard claimed, the reactive mind could be processed and all stored engrams could be refiled as experience. The central technique was "auditing," a two-person ] designed to isolate and dissipate engrams (or "mental masses"). An auditor addresses questions to a subject, observes and records the subject's responses, and returns repeatedly to experiences or areas under discussion that appear painful until the troubling experience has been identified and confronted. Through repeated applications of this method, the reactive mind could be "cleared" of its content having outlived its usefulness in the ] of ]; a person who has completed this process would be "Clear".<ref>{{cite book |last=Wright |first1=Lawrence |title=Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief |url=https://books.google.com/?id=z4IDPV2hZL0C&printsec=frontcover&dq=l.+ron+hubbard+dianetics+reactive+mind+clear#v=onepage&q=reactive%20mind&f=false |publisher=Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group |year=2013 |isbn=9780385350273 |accessdate=2016-01-27 }}</ref> | |||
{{Blockquote |text=But even the limited good that dianetics may do by introducing a single, narrowly-defined role-playing technique into interpersonal relations is probably more than offset by the damage it can do with its accompanying pretentious and nonsensical doctrines. hose who are helped by dianetics will necessarily be kept at a low level of intellectual and emotional maturity by the nonsense they have absorbed in order to be helped. The lure of the pseudoscientific vocabulary and promises of dianetics cannot but condemn thousands who are beginning to emerge from scientific illiteracy to a continuation of their susceptibility to word-magic and semantic hash. —]{{r|hayakawa|page=293}} }} | |||
The benefits of going Clear, according to Hubbard, were dramatic. A Clear would have no compulsions, repressions, ] or ], and would enjoy a near-perfect memory as well as a rise in ] of as much as 50 points. He also claimed that "the atheist is activated by engrams as thoroughly as the zealot".<ref>Hubbard, "Dianetics and Religion," ''Dianetic Auditor's Bulletin'' vol. 1 no. 4, October 1950</ref> He further claimed that widespread application of Dianetics would result in "A world without ], without criminals and without war."<ref>Hubbard, ''Science of Survival: Prediction of Human Behavior'' p. 1, Bridge Publications, 1990 (reissue).</ref> | |||
== See also == | |||
One of the key ideas of Dianetics, according to Hubbard, is the fundamental existential command to survive. According to Hugh B. Urban, this would serve as the foundation of a big part of later Scientology.<ref>{{cite book |last=Urban |first1=Hugh B. |title=The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion |publisher=Princeton University Press |date=22 August 2011 }}</ref> | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
==References== | |||
According to the Scientology journal ''The Auditor'', the total number of "Clears" as of May 2006 stands at 50,311.<ref>"The Auditor," The Monthly Journal of Scientology, published by the American Saint Hill Organization, 1413 L. Ron Hubbard Way, Los Angeles, CA 90027, Issue 330, May 2006, page 7.</ref> | |||
{{Reflist|refs= | |||
<ref name="atack">{{Cite book |title=A Piece of Blue Sky: Scientology, Dianetics and L. Ron Hubbard Exposed |title-link=A Piece of Blue Sky |first=Jon |last=Atack |author-link=Jon Atack |date=1990 |publisher=] |isbn=081840499X |ol=9429654M}}</ref> | |||
When Hubbard presented Dianetics, he did so in terms of ''terra incognita,'' or to Scientologists the human mind. Hubbard wrote, “Dianetics is an adventure. It is an exploration of terra incognita, the human mind, the vast and hitherto unknown realm half an inch back of our foreheads." According to ''Scientology in Popular Culture,'' Hubbard set out to colonize terra incognita, where in the “practice of empire was auditing, the new technology of empire was the E-meter. This exploration of the human mind “would become a defining feature of Scientology because it provided the portal through which he could conquer many enemy thetans.”<ref>{{cite book |last=Kent |first1=Stephen A. |last2=Raine |first2=Susan |title=Scientology in Popular Culture: Influences and Struggles for Legitimacy |location=Santa Barbara, California |publisher=ABC-CLIO |year=2017 |isbn= 978-1440832499 }}</ref> | |||
<ref name="carroll">{{cite web |last=Carroll |first=Robert T |title=Dianetics |website=] |url=http://skepdic.com/dianetic.html}}</ref> | |||
==Procedure in practice== | |||
]s promoting Dianetics at ] in Washington, D.C.]] | |||
The procedure of Dianetics therapy (known as ''auditing'') is a two-person activity. One person, the "auditor", guides the other person, the "pre-clear". The pre-Clear's job is to look at the mind and talk to the auditor. The auditor acknowledges what the pre-Clear says and controls the process so the pre-Clear may put his full attention on his work. | |||
<ref name="corydon">{{cite book |title=L. Ron Hubbard, Messiah or Madman? |title-link=L. Ron Hubbard, Messiah or Madman? |first=Bent |last=Corydon |author-link=Bent Corydon |year=1987 |publisher=] |isbn=0818404442 |pages=263–264}} ( )</ref> | |||
The auditor and pre-Clear sit down in chairs facing each other. The process then follows in eleven distinct steps:<ref>This description is based on " {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20030226223940/http://www.rehabilitatenz.co.nz/pages/dianetics-auditing-steps.html |date=26 February 2003 }}"</ref> | |||
<ref name="gardner">{{cite book |first=Martin |last=Gardner |author-link=Martin Gardner |title=Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science |chapter=Chapter 22 : Dianetics |publisher=Dover Publications Inc. |year=1957 |isbn=978-0-486-20394-2 |title-link=Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science |ol=22475247M }}</ref> | |||
*1. The auditor assures the pre-Clear that he will be fully aware of everything that happens during the session. | |||
*2. The pre-Clear is instructed to close his eyes for the session, entering a state of "dianetic reverie", signified by "a tremble of the lashes". During the session, the preclear remains in full possession of his will and retains full recall thereafter. | |||
*3. The auditor installs a "canceller", an instruction intended to absolutely cancel any form of positive suggestion that could accidentally occur. This is done by saying "In the future, when I utter the word 'cancelled,' everything I have said to you while you are in a therapy session will be cancelled and will have no force with you. Any suggestion I may have made to you will be without force when I say the word 'cancelled.' Do you understand?" | |||
*4. The auditor then asks the pre-Clear to locate an exact record of something that happened to the pre-Clear in his past: "Locate an incident that you feel you can comfortably face." | |||
*5. The pre-Clear is invited by the auditor to "Go through the incident and say what is happening as you go along." | |||
*6a. The auditor instructs the pre-Clear to recall as much as possible of the incident, going over it several times "until the pre-Clear is cheerful about it". | |||
*6b. When the pre-Clear is cheerful about an incident, the auditor instructs the pre-Clear to locate another incident: "Let's find another incident that you feel you can comfortably face." The process outlined at steps 5 and 6a then repeats until the auditing session's time limit (usually two hours or so) is reached. | |||
*7. The pre-Clear is then instructed to "return to present time". | |||
*8. The auditor checks to make sure that the pre-Clear feels himself to be in "present time", i.e., not still recalling a past incident. | |||
*9. The auditor gives the pre-Clear the canceller word: "Very good. Cancelled." | |||
*10. The auditor tells the pre-Clear to feel alert and return to full awareness of his surroundings: "When I count from five to one and snap my fingers you will feel alert. Five, four, three, two, one." (snaps fingers) | |||
<ref name="garrison">{{cite book |first=Omar V |last=Garrison |title=The Hidden Story of Scientology |year=1974 |publisher=Citadel Press |isbn=0806504404 |ol=5071463M}}</ref> | |||
Auditing sessions are supposedly kept confidential. A few transcripts of auditing sessions with ] have been published as demonstration examples. Some extracts can be found in J.A. Winter's book '']''. Other, more comprehensive, transcripts of auditing sessions carried out by Hubbard himself can be found in volume 1 of the ''Research & Discovery Series'' (Bridge Publications, 1980). Examples of public group processing sessions can be found throughout the ''Congresses'' lecture series. | |||
<ref name="hayakawa">{{Cite journal |issn=0014-164X |volume=8 |issue=4 |pages=280–293 |last=Hayakawa |first=S. I. |author-link=S. I. Hayakawa |title=From Science-fiction to Fiction-science |journal=] |access-date=2023-12-19 |date=1951 |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/42580983 |jstor=42580983}} ()</ref> | |||
According to Hubbard, auditing enables the pre-Clear to "contact" and "release" engrams stored in the reactive mind, relieving him of the physical and mental aberrations connected with them. The pre-Clear is asked to inspect and familiarize himself with the exact details of his own experience; the auditor may not tell him anything about his case or evaluate any of the information the pre-Clear finds. | |||
<ref name="hubbard-dmsmh">{{cite book |title=Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health |title-link=Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health |year=1950 |first=L. Ron |last=Hubbard |author-link=L. Ron Hubbard}}</ref> | |||
==Criticism== | |||
<ref name="lee">{{cite book |title=The Lee Report on Dianetics and Scientology (Sectarian Healers and Hypnotherapy) |first=John A. |last=Lee |author-link=John Alan Lee |year=1970 |publisher=] |url=https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~dst/Cowen/audit/lee.html |via=]}}</ref> | |||
Hubbard's original book on Dianetics attracted highly critical reviews from science and medical writers and organizations. The ] passed a resolution in 1950 calling "attention to the fact that these claims are not supported by ] evidence of the sort required for the establishment of scientific generalizations."<ref>"Psychologists Act Against Dianetics", ''New York Times'', 9 September 1950</ref><ref name=timeapa>{{cite news | title = Tests & Poison | url = http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,813284,00.html | work = ] | date = 18 September 1950 | accessdate = 10 February 2008 }}</ref> Subsequently, Dianetics has achieved no acceptance as a ], and scientists cite Dianetics as an example of a ].<ref name=":0">See e.g. Gardner, '']''; Bauer, ''Scientific Literacy and the Myth of the Scientific Method'' and ''Science Or Pseudoscience: Magnetic Healing, Psychic Phenomena, and Other Heterodoxies''; Corsini ''et al.'', ''The Dictionary of Psychology''.</ref><ref name=":1">{{cite book|chapter=Demise of the Dogmatic Universe|title=Historical Encyclopedia of Natural and Mathematical Sciences|author=Ari Ben-Menahem|isbn=978-3-540-68831-0|year=2009|publisher=Springer Berlin Heidelberg|doi=10.1007/978-3-540-68832-7|pages=4301–4302}}</ref> | |||
<ref name=lewis2017>{{cite book |title=Handbook of Scientology |volume=Brill Handbooks on Contemporary Religion |editor1-last=Lewis |editor1-first=James R. |editor1-link=James R. Lewis (scholar)|editor2-last=Hellesoy |editor2-first=Kjersti |publisher=Brill |year=2017 |isbn=9789004330542 }}</ref> | |||
In August 1950, amidst the success of '']'', Hubbard held a demonstration in Los Angeles' ] where he presented a young woman called Sonya Bianca (a pseudonym) to a large audience including many reporters and photographers as 'the world's first ]." Despite Hubbard's claim that she had "full and perfect recall of every moment of her life", Bianca proved unable to answer questions from the audience testing her memory and analytical abilities, including the question of the color of Hubbard's tie. Hubbard explained Bianca's failure to display her promised powers of recall to the audience by saying that he had used the word "now" in calling her to the stage, and thus inadvertently froze her in "present time," which blocked her abilities.<ref>{{cite book|first=Russell|last=Miller|title=Bare-Faced Messiah: The True Story of L. Ron Hubbard|year=1987|isbn=978-0-8050-0654-4|url=https://archive.org/details/barefacedmessiah00mill_0}}</ref><ref name="atack">{{cite book|first=Jon|last=Atack|title=A Piece of Blue Sky: Scientology, Dianetics and L. Ron Hubbard Exposed|year=1990|isbn=978-0-8184-0499-3|url=https://archive.org/details/pieceofblueskysc00atac}}</ref> Later, in the late 1950s, Hubbard would claim that several people had reached the state of Clear by the time he presented Bianca as the world's first; these others, Hubbard said, he had successfully cleared in the late 1940s while working ''incognito'' in Hollywood posing as a ].<ref>{{cite speech| first=L. Ron| last=Hubbard| title=The Story of Dianetics and Scientology, Lecture 18| date=October 1958| quote="by 1947, I had achieved clearing."}}</ref> In 1966, Hubbard declared South African Scientologist John McMaster to be the first true Clear.<ref>{{cite journal|first=Alan|last=Levy|title=Scientology|journal=Life|date=15 November 1968}}</ref><ref>{{cite journal|first=Wendy|last=Michener|title=Is This the Happiest Man in the World?|journal=Maclean's|date=22 August 1966}}</ref> | |||
<ref name="lewis-ch20">{{cite book |title=Scientology |title-link=Scientology (Lewis book) |year=2009 |editor-first=James R. |editor-last=Lewis |editor-link=James R. Lewis (scholar) |isbn=9780199852321 |ol=16943235M |publisher=] |chapter=Celebrity, the Popular Media, and Scientology: Making Familiar the Unfamiliar |pages=389–410 |first=Carole M. |last=Cusack |author-link=Carole M. Cusack |doi=10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195331493.003.0021}}</ref> | |||
Few scientific investigations into the effectiveness of Dianetics have been published. Professor ] states in his 1970 evaluation of Dianetics: | |||
<ref name="miller">{{cite book |title=Bare-faced Messiah : The True Story of L. Ron Hubbard |title-link=Bare-faced Messiah |first=Russell |last=Miller |author-link=Russell Miller |ol=26305813M |isbn=0805006540 |date=1987 |publisher=] }}</ref> | |||
{{quote|Objective experimental verification of Hubbard's ] and psychological doctrines is lacking. To date, no regular scientific agency has established the validity of his theories of prenatal perception and engrams, or cellular memory, or Dianetic reverie, or the effects of Scientology auditing routines. Existing knowledge contradicts Hubbard's theory of recording of perceptions during periods of unconsciousness.<ref>Lee, John A. ''Sectarian Healers and Hypnotherapy'', 1970, Ontario</ref>}} | |||
<ref name="reitman">{{cite book |last=Reitman |first=Janet |author-link=Janet Reitman |title=Inside Scientology: The Story of America's Most Secretive Religion |title-link=Inside Scientology: The Story of America's Most Secretive Religion |date=2011 |isbn=9780618883028 |ol=24881847M |publisher=] }}</ref> | |||
The ] database records two independent scientific studies on Dianetics, both conducted in the 1950s under the auspices of ]. Harvey Jay Fischer tested Dianetics therapy against three claims made by proponents and found it does not effect any significant changes in intellectual functioning, mathematical ability, or the degree of personality conflicts;<ref>Fischer, Harvey Jay. "Dianetic therapy: an experimental evaluation. A statistical analysis of the effect of dianetic therapy as measured by group tests of intelligence, mathematics and personality." Abstract of Ph.D. thesis, 1953, New York University ()</ref> Jack Fox tested Hubbard's thesis regarding recall of engrams, with the assistance of the Dianetic Research Foundation, and could not substantiate it.<ref>Fox, J.; Davis, A.E.; Lebovits, B. "An experimental investigation of Hubbard's engram hypothesis (dianetics)". ''Psychological Newsletter'', New York University. 10 1959, 131-134</ref> | |||
<ref name="urban">{{cite book|last=Urban|first=Hugh B. |author-link=Hugh Urban |title=The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion |title-link=The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion |publisher=] |year=2011 |isbn=9780691146089}}</ref> | |||
Hubbard claimed, in an interview with '']'' in November 1950, that "he had already submitted proof of claims made in the book to a number of scientists and associations." He added that the public as well as proper organizations were entitled to such proof and that he was ready and willing to give such proof in detail.<ref>"Psychologists Act Against Dianetics", New York Times, 9 September 1950</ref> In January 1951, the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation of ] published ''Dianetic Processing: A Brief Survey of Research Projects and Preliminary Results'', a booklet providing the results of psychometric tests conducted on 88 people undergoing Dianetics therapy. It presents case histories and a number of ] plates to support claims that Dianetics had cured "aberrations" including ], asthma, ], ] and "overt homosexuality," and that after Dianetic processing, test subjects experienced significantly increased scores on a standardized IQ test. The report's subjects are not identified by name, but one of them is clearly Hubbard himself ("Case 1080A, R. L.").<ref>Benton, Peggy; Ibanex, Dalmyra.; Southon, Gordon; Southon, Peggy. ''Dianetic Processing: A Brief Survey of Research Projects and Preliminary Results'', Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation, 1951</ref> | |||
<ref name="winter">{{cite book |last=Winter |first=J.A. |title=Dianetics: A Doctor's Report |title-link=A Doctor's Report on Dianetics |year=1951 |publisher=] |isbn=0517564211 |ol=2725623M}}</ref> | |||
The authors provide no qualifications, although they are described in Hubbard's book ''Science of Survival'' (where some results of the same study were reprinted) as psychotherapists. Critics of Dianetics are skeptical of this study, both because of the bias of the source and because the researchers appear to ascribe all physical benefits to Dianetics without considering possible outside factors; in other words, the report lacks any ]s. J.A. Winter, M.D., originally an associate of Hubbard and an early adopter of Dianetics, had by the end of 1950 cut his ties with Hubbard and written an account of his personal experiences with Dianetics. He described Hubbard as "absolutistic and authoritarian",<ref name=departure/> and criticized the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation for failing to undertake "precise scientific research into the functioning of the mind".<ref>Winter, ''Dianetics: A Doctor's Report'', p. 40</ref> He also recommended that auditing be done by experts only and that it was dangerous for laymen to audit each other.<ref name=departure>{{cite news | title = Departure in Dianetics | url = http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,821638,00.html | work = ] | date = 3 September 1951 | accessdate = 14 February 2008 }}</ref> Hubbard writes: "Again, Dianetics is not being released to a profession, for no profession could encompass it."<ref>L. Ron Hubbard ''Dianetics: the Modernd Science of Mental Health'', p. 204, Bridge Publications Inc., 2007 {{ISBN|978-1-4031-4484-3}}; 1st ed. 1950</ref> | |||
<ref name="wright">{{cite book |last=Wright |first=Lawrence |author-link=Lawrence Wright |title=Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief |publisher=] |year=2013 |isbn=978-0-307-70066-7 |ol=25424776M |title-link=Going Clear (book)}}</ref> | |||
Commentators from a variety of backgrounds have described Dianetics as an example of pseudoscience. For example, ] professor ] points to Dianetics' lack of empirical evidence: | |||
}} | |||
{{quote|What Hubbard touts as a science of mind lacks one key element that is expected of a science: empirical testing of claims. The key elements of Hubbard's so-called science don't seem testable, yet he repeatedly claims that he is asserting only scientific facts and data from many experiments. It isn't even clear what such "data" would look like. Most of his data is in the form of anecdotes and speculations ... Such speculation is appropriate in fiction, but not in science.<ref>] , '']''</ref>}} | |||
] similarly comments that | |||
{{quote|Dianetics is nothing more than an example of pseudoscience trying to legitimize itself ... Hubbard, had he indeed been a scientist, would have known that truth is not built on axioms, and facts cannot be found from some a-priori knowledge. A true science is constructed on ], which are arrived at by the virtue of observed phenomena. Scientific knowledge is gained by observation and testing, not believing from some ] stipulation, as Hubbard would have us believe.<ref>Davis, W. Sumner. ''Just Smoke and Mirrors: Religion, Fear and Superstition in Our Modern World'', Writers Club Press, 2001 ({{ISBN|0-595-26523-5}})</ref>}} | |||
The validity and practice of auditing have been questioned by a variety of non-Scientologist commentators. Commenting on the example cited by Winter, the science writer ] asserts that "nothing could be clearer from the above dialogue than the fact that the dianetic explanation for the headache existed only in the mind of the therapist, and that it was with considerable difficulty that the patient was maneuvered into accepting it."<ref>Gardner, Martin. '' Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science''. Dover, 1957</ref> | |||
Other critics and medical experts have suggested that Dianetic auditing is a form of ],<ref>"Never believe a hypnotist - An investigation of L. Ron Hubbard's statements about hypnosis and its relationship to his Dianetics.", Jon Atack</ref><ref>"Psychologist says church appeared to use hypnosis", ''Irish Times'', 13 March 2003</ref><ref>"The 'Scientology Organization' (SO) as of July 2003", chapter 2, Landesamt für Verfassungsschutz Baden-Wuerttemberg, 2003</ref> although the Church of Scientology has strongly denied that hypnosis forms any part of Dianetics.<ref>" {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20060413195909/http://www.scientology.org/en_US/news-media/faq/pg005.html |date=13 April 2006 }}", Church of Scientology International</ref> To the contrary, L. Ron Hubbard expressly warns not to use any hypnosis or hypnosis-like methods, because a person under hypnosis would be receptive to suggestions. This would decrease his self-determinism instead of increasing it, which is one of the prime goals of Dianetics.<ref>"]", L. Ron Hubbard, p. 461 (2007 edition).</ref> Winter comments that the leading nature of the questions asked of a pre-Clear "encourage fantasy", a common issue also encountered with hypnosis, which can be used to form ]. The auditor is instructed not to make any assessment of a recalled memory's reality or accuracy, but instead to treat it as if it were objectively real. Professor ], a leading expert on false memories, suggests that the feeling of well-being reported by pre-Clear at the end of an auditing session may be induced by post-hypnotic ].<ref>"A Very Brief Overview of Scientology", Richard E. Ofshe, Ph.D.</ref> Other researchers have identified quotations in Hubbard's work suggesting evidence that false memories were created in ''Dianetics,'' specifically in the form of birth and pre-birth memories.<ref>{{Cite journal|title = False memories in therapy and hypnosis before 1980.|journal = Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice|pages = 153–169|volume = 2|issue = 2|doi = 10.1037/cns0000044|first = Lawrence|last = Patihis|first2 = Helena J. Younes|last2 = Burton|year = 2015}}</ref> | |||
According to an article by Martin Gumpert, “Hubbard’s concept of psychosomatic disease is definitely wrong. Psychosomatic ailments are not simply caused by emotional disturbances: they are diseases in which the emotional and the organic factor are closely involved and interdependent.”<ref>{{Cite news|url=https://newrepublic.com/article/121590/1950-takedown-l-ron-hubbards-scientology-book-dianetics|title=A Doctor’s Scathing 1950 Takedown of L. Ron Hubbard’s ‘Dianetics’|work=The New Republic|access-date=2018-10-17|language=en-US}}</ref> | |||
==Autocontrol== | |||
According to Hubbard, the majority of the people interested in the subject believed they could accomplish therapy alone. "It cannot be done" and he adds: "If a patient places himself in ] and regresses himself in an effort to reach illness or birth or prenatals, the only thing he will get is ill".<ref>Dianetics: the Modern Science of Mental Health -5oth anniversary edition- pp. 443-4.</ref> | |||
{{clear}} | |||
== Major related works published by Hubbard == | |||
* Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health | |||
* Scientology 0-8: The Book of Basics | |||
* Advanced Procedure and Axioms | |||
== See also == | |||
*'']'' | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
==References== | |||
{{Reflist|30em}} | |||
==Further reading== | ==Further reading== | ||
* {{cite magazine |first=Richard |last=Behar |author-link=Richard Behar |url=https://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,156952,00.html |title=Scientology: The Thriving Cult of Greed and Power |magazine=] |date=May 6, 1991 |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140525200902/https://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,156952,00.html |archive-date=May 25, 2014 }} | |||
* Atack, Jon: ''A Piece of Blue Sky'', Lyle Stuart, London, 1988 | |||
* Benton, P; Ibanex, D.; Southon, G; Southon, P. ''Dianetic Processing: A Brief Survey of Research Projects and Preliminary Results'', Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation, 1951 | |||
* Behard, Richard: ''The Thriving Cult of Greed and Power'', Time.com | |||
* Breuer J, Freud S, "Studies in Hysteria", Vol II of the ''Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud'' (Hogarth Press, London, 1955). | * Breuer J, Freud S, "Studies in Hysteria", Vol II of the ''Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud'' (Hogarth Press, London, 1955). | ||
* Carroll, Robert T: 'Dianetics', Skepdics Dictionary | |||
* Fischer, Harvey Jay: "Dianetic therapy: an experimental evaluation. A statistical analysis of the effect of dianetic therapy as measured by group tests of intelligence, mathematics and personality. " Abstract of Ph.D. thesis, 1953, New York University | * Fischer, Harvey Jay: "Dianetic therapy: an experimental evaluation. A statistical analysis of the effect of dianetic therapy as measured by group tests of intelligence, mathematics and personality. " Abstract of Ph.D. thesis, 1953, New York University | ||
* {{Cite web |first=David |last=Miscavige |author-link=David Miscavige |title=Speech to the International Association of Scientologists |date=8 October 1993 |url=https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~dst/Cowen/essays/speech.html |via=]}} | |||
* Fox, Jack et al.: ''An Experimental Investigation of Hubbard's Engram Hypothesis (Dianetics)'' in Psychological Newsletter, 1959, 10 131-134 | |||
* Freeman, Lucy: "Psychologists act against Dianetics", '']'', 9 September 1950 | |||
* Gardner, Martin: ''Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science'', 1957, Chapter 22, "Dianetics" | |||
* Hayakawa, S. I.: "From Science-Fiction to Fiction-Science," in ''ETC: A Review of General Semantics'', Vol. VIII, No. 4. Summer, 1951 | |||
* Lee, John A.: ''Sectarian Healers and Hypnotherapy'', 1970, Ontario | |||
* Miller, Russell: ''Bare-Faced Messiah'', 1987 | |||
* Miscavige, David: Speech to the ], 8 October 1993 | |||
* O'Brien, Helen: ''Dianetics in Limbo''. Whitmore, Philadelphia, 1966 | * O'Brien, Helen: ''Dianetics in Limbo''. Whitmore, Philadelphia, 1966 | ||
* Streissguth |
* {{Cite book |last=Streissguth |first=Thomas |title=Charismatic Cult Leaders |publisher=The Oliver Press |year=1995 |ol=1097441M |isbn=1881508188}} | ||
* van Vogt, A.E.: ''Dianetics and the Professions'', 1953 | * van Vogt, A.E.: ''Dianetics and the Professions'', 1953 | ||
* Williamson |
* {{Cite book |last=Williamson |first=Jack |title=Wonder's Child: My life in science fiction |publisher=Bluejay Books |location=New York |year=1984 |ol=2848895M |isbn=0312944543}} | ||
* Winter, J.A.: ''A Doctors Report on DIANETICS Theory and Therapy'', 1951 | |||
==External links== | ==External links== | ||
<!--======================== {{No more links}} ============================ | |||
| PLEASE BE CAUTIOUS IN ADDING MORE LINKS TO THIS ARTICLE. Misplaced Pages | | |||
| is not a collection of links nor should it be used for advertising. | | |||
| | | |||
| Excessive or inappropriate links WILL BE DELETED. | | |||
| See ] & ] for details. | | |||
| | | |||
| If there are already plentiful links, please propose additions or | | |||
| replacements on this article's discussion page, or submit your link | | |||
| to the relevant category at the Open Directory Project (dmoz.org) | | |||
| and link back to that category using the {{dmoz}} template. | | |||
======================= {{No more links}} =============================--> | |||
*{{official website|http://www.dianetics.org}} | *{{official website|http://www.dianetics.org}} | ||
Latest revision as of 00:48, 30 December 2024
Set of ideas and practices adopted by Scientologists This article is about the set of ideas and practices. For the 1950 book, see Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health. For the article in Astounding Science Fiction, see Dianetics: The Evolution of a Science. Not to be confused with dialectics or Dynetics.
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)
|
Part of a series on |
Scientology |
---|
|
Controversies |
More |
Dianetics is a set of ideas and practices, invented in 1950 by science fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard, regarding the human mind. Dianetics was originally conceived as a form of psychological treatment, but was rejected by the psychological and medical establishments as pseudoscientific. It was the precursor to Scientology and has since been incorporated into it. It involves a process referred to as "auditing", which utilizes an electrical resistance meter, ostensibly to remove emotional burdens and "cure" people from their troubles.
"Auditing" uses techniques from hypnosis that are intended to create dependency and obedience in the auditing subject. Hubbard eventually decided to present Dianetics as a form of spirituality that is part of the Church of Scientology, after several practitioners had been arrested for practicing medicine without a license, and a prosecution trial was pending against the first Dianetics organization that Hubbard founded in Elizabeth, New Jersey. As well as escaping prosecution, Hubbard also saw the possibility of reducing the tax burden from the sale of dianetics books and methods.
Premise
The word Dianetics was coined from Greek dia meaning "through" and nous meaning "mind".
Dianetics theory describes the human mind as two parts: the conscious "analytical mind" and the subconscious "reactive mind". The stated purpose of Dianetics technique, called "auditing", is to erase the contents of the reactive mind—the holder of painful and destructive emotions which can act on a person as posthypnotic suggestions. "Auditing" uses techniques from hypnosis which are intended to create dependency and obedience in the auditing subject. In auditing, the person is asked questions intended to help them locate and deal with painful past experiences.
Dianetics theory posits that "the basic principle of existence is to survive" and that the basic personality of humans is sincere, intelligent, and good. The drive for goodness and survival is distorted and inhibited by aberrations (deviations from rational thinking). Hubbard claimed that Dianetics could increase intelligence, eliminate unwanted emotions and alleviate a wide range of illnesses he believed to be psychosomatic. Conditions purportedly treatable with Dianetics included arthritis, allergies, asthma, some coronary difficulties, eye trouble, ulcers, migraine headaches, and sexual deviation.
History
Main article: History of Dianetics and ScientologyAccording to Hubbard, when he was sedated for a dental operation in 1938, he had a near-death experience which inspired him to write the manuscript Excalibur. Though it was never published, this work would allegedly become the basis for Dianetics. The first publication on Dianetics was Dianetics: The Evolution of a Science, an article by Hubbard in Astounding Science Fiction (cover date May 1950). This was followed by the book Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health (DMSMH) published May 9, 1950. In these works Hubbard claimed that the source of all psychological pain, and therefore the cause of mental and physical health problems, was a form of memory known as "engrams". According to Hubbard, individuals could reach a state he named "Clear" when all of their engrams had been removed through talking with an "auditor".
While the technique was not accepted by the medical and scientific establishment, in the first two years of its publication DMSMH sold over 100,000 copies. Publication of DMSMH brought in a flood of revenue, which Hubbard used to establish Dianetics foundations in six major American cities. Two of the strongest initial supporters of Dianetics in the 1950s were John W. Campbell, editor of Astounding Science Fiction, and Joseph Augustus Winter, a writer and medical physician. Campbell published some of Hubbard's short stories, and Winter hoped that his own colleagues would likewise be attracted to Hubbard's Dianetics system.
Readers formed groups to study and practice Dianetics technique. According to sociologist Roy Wallis, this period was one of "excited experimentation" and Hubbard's work was regarded as "an initial exploration to be developed further by others". Per Wallis, it was Dianetics' popularity as a lay psychotherapy that contributed to the Dianetics Foundation's downfall. Most people read the book, tried it out, then put it down. The remaining practitioners had no ties to the Foundation. Factions formed and followers challenged Hubbard's movement and his authority. The craze of 1950–51 was dead by 1952.
In 1951, with debts piled up and facing bankruptcy, the Foundation was bailed out by Don Purcell, a wealthy Dianetics follower from Wichita. The relief was short-lived, however, and the Foundation fell to bankruptcy in 1952. Hubbard fled to Phoenix, Arizona, having lost the Foundation, the rights to Dianetics, and the DMSMH copyrights to Purcell. Hubbard sued and in 1954 Purcell settled by giving the copyrights back to Hubbard.
In Phoenix, Hubbard created "Scientology"; its techniques were intended to rehabilitate a person so that they might reach their full potential as a spiritual being. Dianetics was incorporated into Scientology. In 1978, Hubbard introduced "New Era Dianetics" (NED) and New Era Dianetics for OTs, and added them to The Bridge to Total Freedom.
Concepts
In the book, Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health, Hubbard describes techniques that he suggests can rid individuals of fears and psychosomatic illnesses. A basic idea in Dianetics is that the mind consists of two parts: the "analytical mind" and the "reactive mind". The "reactive mind", the mind which operates when a person is physically unconscious, acts as a record of shock, trauma, pain, and otherwise harmful memories. Experiences such as these, stored in the "reactive mind" are dubbed "engrams". Dianetics is proposed as a method to erase these engrams in the reactive mind to achieve a state of clear.
In Dianetics, the unconscious or reactive mind is described as a collection of "mental image pictures", which contain the recorded experience of past moments of unconsciousness, including all sensory perceptions and feelings involved, ranging from pre-natal experiences, infancy and childhood, to even the traumatic feelings associated with events from past lives and extraterrestrial cultures. The type of mental image picture created during a period of unconsciousness involves the exact recording of a painful experience. Hubbard called this phenomenon an engram, and defined it as "a complete recording of a moment of unconsciousness containing physical pain or painful emotion and all perceptions."
Hubbard proposed that these engrams caused "aberrations" (deviations from rational thinking) in the mind, which produced lasting adverse physical and emotional effects. When the analytical (conscious) mind shut down during these moments, events and perceptions of this period were stored as engrams in the unconscious or reactive mind. In Hubbard's earliest publications on the subject, engrams were variously referred to as norn, impediment, and comanome before "engram" was adapted from its existing usage at the suggestion of Joseph Augustus Winter, MD. Some commentators noted Dianetics's blend of science fiction and occult orientations at the time.
Hubbard claimed that these engrams were the cause of almost all psychological and physical problems. In addition to physical pain, engrams could include words or phrases spoken in the vicinity while the patient was unconscious. For instance, Winter cites the example of a patient with a persistent headache supposedly tracing the problem to a doctor saying, "Take him now", during the patient's birth.
can give a man arthritis, bursitis, asthma, allergies, sinusitis, coronary trouble, high blood pressure ... And it is the only thing in the human being which can produce these effects ... Discharge the content of and the arthritis vanishes, myopia gets better, heart illness decreases, asthma disappears, stomachs function properly and the whole catalog of ills goes away and stays away.
— L. Ron Hubbard
According to Bent Corydon, Hubbard created the illusion that Dianetics was the first psychotherapy to address traumatic experiences in their own time, but others had done so before as standard procedure. Hugh Urban wrote it was clear that Hubbard's work had been influenced by Carl Jung, Sigmund Freud and Otto Rank, and Hubbard himself mentioned similarities between Dianetics and Freud.
Hubbard claimed that by using Dianetics technique the reactive mind could be emptied of all engrams; "cleared" of its contents. A person who has completed this process would be "Clear". The benefits of Clear might include a higher IQ, better relationships, or career success.
Procedure
The procedure of Dianetics therapy (known as auditing) is a two-person activity. One person, the "auditor", guides the other person, the preclear, through the procedures. The preclear's job is to look at their mind and talk to the auditor. The auditor acknowledges what the preclear says and controls the process.
The auditor and preclear sit down facing each other. After getting settled, the auditor tells the preclear to close their eyes and locate something that happened to them in the past. The preclear tells the auditor what happened in the incident like he is re-experiencing it again. The auditor coaxes the preclear to recall as much as possible, and goes back over the incident several times until the preclear is cheerful about it, at which point the auditor may end the session or find another incident and repeat the process.
Therapeutic claims
The slick craftsman of mass-production science-fiction, mustering his talents and energies for a supreme effort, produces a fictional science. Had dianetics been presented as fiction it might have been, like other ingenious science-fiction, good entertainment.
— S. I. Hayakawa
In August 1950, amidst the success of Dianetics, Hubbard held a demonstration in Los Angeles' Shrine Auditorium where he presented a young woman called Sonya Bianca (a pseudonym) to a large audience including many reporters and photographers as "the world's first Clear". Despite Hubbard's claim that she had "full and perfect recall of every moment of her life", Bianca proved unable to answer questions from the audience testing her memory and analytical abilities, including the question of the color of Hubbard's tie. Hubbard explained Bianca's failure to display her promised powers of recall to the audience by saying that he had used the word "now" in calling her to the stage, and thus inadvertently froze her in "present time", which blocked her abilities. Later, in the late 1950s, Hubbard would claim that several people had reached the state of Clear by the time he presented Bianca as the world's first; these others, Hubbard said, he had successfully cleared in the late 1940s while working incognito in Hollywood posing as a swami. In 1966, Hubbard declared South African Scientologist John McMaster to be the first true Clear.
Hubbard claimed, in an interview with The New York Times in November 1950, that "he had already submitted proof of claims made in the book to a number of scientists and associations." He added that the public as well as proper organizations were entitled to such proof and that he was ready and willing to give such proof in detail. In January 1951, the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation of Elizabeth, New Jersey, published Dianetic Processing: A Brief Survey of Research Projects and Preliminary Results, a booklet providing the results of psychometric tests conducted on 88 people undergoing Dianetics therapy. It presents case histories and a number of X-ray plates to support claims that Dianetics had cured "aberrations" including manic depression, asthma, arthritis, colitis and "overt homosexuality", and that after Dianetic processing, test subjects experienced significantly increased scores on a standardized IQ test. The report's subjects are not identified by name, but one of them is clearly Hubbard himself ("Case 1080A, R. L.").
The authors provide no qualifications, although they are described in Hubbard's book Science of Survival (where some results of the same study were reprinted) as psychotherapists. Critics of Dianetics are skeptical of this study, both because of the bias of the source and because the researchers appear to ascribe all physical benefits to Dianetics without considering possible outside factors; in other words, the report lacks any scientific controls. Winter was originally an associate of Hubbard and an early adopter of Dianetics, but by the end of 1950 had cut ties with Hubbard and written an account of his personal experiences with Dianetics. He described Hubbard as "absolutistic and authoritarian", and criticized the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation for failing to undertake "precise scientific research into the functioning of the mind". He also recommended that auditing be done by experts only and that it was dangerous for laymen to audit each other. Hubbard writes: "Again, Dianetics is not being released to a profession, for no profession could encompass it."
Scientific rejection
Hubbard's original book on Dianetics attracted highly critical reviews from science and medical writers and organizations. The American Psychological Association passed a resolution in 1950 calling "attention to the fact that these claims are not supported by empirical evidence of the sort required for the establishment of scientific generalizations." Subsequently, Dianetics has achieved no acceptance as a scientific theory, and scientists cite Dianetics as an example of a pseudoscience.
Few scientific investigations into the effectiveness of Dianetics have been published. Professor John A. Lee states in his 1970 evaluation of Dianetics:
Objective experimental verification of Hubbard's physiological and psychological doctrines is lacking. To date, no regular scientific agency has established the validity of his theories of prenatal perception and engrams, or cellular memory, or Dianetic reverie, or the effects of Scientology auditing routines. Existing knowledge contradicts Hubbard's theory of recording of perceptions during periods of unconsciousness.
— John A. Lee in The Lee Report (1970)
The MEDLINE database records two independent scientific studies on Dianetics, both conducted in the 1950s under the auspices of New York University. Harvey Jay Fischer tested Dianetic therapy against three claims made by proponents and found it does not effect any significant changes in intellectual functioning, mathematical ability, or the degree of personality conflicts; Jack Fox tested Hubbard's thesis regarding recall of engrams, with the assistance of the Dianetic Research Foundation, and could not substantiate it.
Commentators from a variety of backgrounds have described Dianetics as an example of pseudoscience. For example, philosophy professor Robert Carroll points to Dianetics' lack of empirical evidence:
What Hubbard touts as a science of mind lacks one key element that is expected of a science: empirical testing of claims. The key elements of Hubbard's so-called science don't seem testable, yet he repeatedly claims that he is asserting only scientific facts and data from many experiments. It isn't even clear what such "data" would look like. Most of his data is in the form of anecdotes and speculations ... Such speculation is appropriate in fiction, but not in science.
The validity and practice of auditing have been questioned by a variety of non-Scientologist commentators. Commenting on the example cited by Winter, the science writer Martin Gardner asserts that "nothing could be clearer from the above dialogue than the fact that the dianetic explanation for the headache existed only in the mind of the therapist, and that it was with considerable difficulty that the patient was maneuvered into accepting it."
Other critics and medical experts have suggested that Dianetic auditing is a form of hypnosis. Hubbard, who had previously used hypnosis for entertainment purposes, strongly denied this connection and cautioned against hypnosis in Dianetics auditing. Professor Richard J. Ofshe, a leading expert on false memories, suggests that the feeling of well-being reported by preclear at the end of an auditing session may be induced by post-hypnotic suggestion. Other researchers have identified quotations in Hubbard's work suggesting evidence that false memories were created in Dianetics, specifically in the form of birth and pre-birth memories.
According to an article by physician Martin Gumpert, "Hubbard's concept of psychosomatic disease is definitely wrong. Psychosomatic ailments are not simply caused by emotional disturbances: they are diseases in which the emotional and the organic factor are closely involved and interdependent."
But even the limited good that dianetics may do by introducing a single, narrowly-defined role-playing technique into interpersonal relations is probably more than offset by the damage it can do with its accompanying pretentious and nonsensical doctrines. hose who are helped by dianetics will necessarily be kept at a low level of intellectual and emotional maturity by the nonsense they have absorbed in order to be helped. The lure of the pseudoscientific vocabulary and promises of dianetics cannot but condemn thousands who are beginning to emerge from scientific illiteracy to a continuation of their susceptibility to word-magic and semantic hash. —S. I. Hayakawa
See also
References
- ^ Atack, Jon (1990). A Piece of Blue Sky: Scientology, Dianetics and L. Ron Hubbard Exposed. Lyle Stuart Books. ISBN 081840499X. OL 9429654M.
- ^ Hassan, Steven A.; Scheflin, Alan W. (2024). "Understanding the Dark Side of Hypnosis as a Form of Undue Influence Exerted in Authoritarian Cults: Implications for Practice, Policy, and Education". In Linden, Julie H.; De Benedittis, Giuseppe; Sugarman, Laurence I.; Varga, Katalin (eds.). The Routledge International Handbook of Clinical Hypnosis. Abingdon/New York: Routledge. pp. 755–772. ISBN 978-1-032-31140-1.
- Dericquebourg, Régis (2017). "Scientology: From the Edges to the Core". Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions. 20 (4): 5–12. doi:10.1525/nr.2017.20.4.5. ISSN 1092-6690. JSTOR 26417718.
- Urban, Hugh B. (2011). The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-0-691-14608-9.
- Westbrook, Donald A. (2019). Among the Scientologists: History, Theology, and Praxis. Oxford Studies in Western Esotericism. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0190664978.
- Kent, Stephen A. (1996). "Scientology's Relationship With Eastern Religious Traditions". Journal of Contemporary Religion. 11 (1): 21–36. doi:10.1080/13537909608580753. Archived from the original on September 2, 2012. Retrieved January 13, 2009.
- Beit-Hallahmi, Benjamin (September 2003). "Scientology: Religion or Racket?". Marburg Journal of Religion. 8 (1). University of Marburg: 1–56. doi:10.17192/mjr.2003.8.3724. Retrieved June 30, 2006.
- Cusack, Carole M. (2009). "Celebrity, the Popular Media, and Scientology: Making Familiar the Unfamiliar". In Lewis, James R. (ed.). Scientology. Oxford University Press. pp. 389–410. doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195331493.003.0021. ISBN 9780199852321. OL 16943235M.
- ^ "Of Two Minds". Time. July 24, 1950. Archived from the original on September 30, 2007. Retrieved July 4, 2008. (page2, page 3)
- ^ Wright, Lawrence (2013). Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief. Alfred A. Knopf. ISBN 978-0-307-70066-7. OL 25424776M.
- Garrison, Omar V (1974). The Hidden Story of Scientology. Citadel Press. ISBN 0806504404. OL 5071463M.
- ^ Kent, Stephen A. (December 1999). "The Creation of 'Religious' Scientology". Religious Studies and Theology. 18 (2): 97–126. doi:10.1558/rsth.v18i2.97. Archived from the original on March 12, 2007. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
- Reitman, Janet (2011). Inside Scientology: The Story of America's Most Secretive Religion. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. ISBN 9780618883028. OL 24881847M.
- Gallagher, Eugene V. (2004). The New Religious Movements Experience in America. Greenwood Publishing Group. ISBN 9780313328077. OL 10420337M.
- Wallis, Roy (1975). "Scientology: Therapeutic Cult to Religious Sect". Sociology. 9 (1): 89–100. doi:10.1177/003803857500900105. JSTOR 42851574. S2CID 144335265.
- Wallis, Roy (1976). ""Poor Man's Psychoanalysis?" Observations on Dianetics" (PDF). The Zetetic. 1 (1): 9–24.
- ^ Miller, Russell (1987). Bare-faced Messiah : The True Story of L. Ron Hubbard. Henry Holt and Company. ISBN 0805006540. OL 26305813M.
- Lebron, Robyn E. (2012). Searching for Spiritual Unity...can There Be Common Ground?: A Basic Internet Guide to Forty World Religions & Spiritual Practices. Crossbooks. pp. 532–3. ISBN 978-1462712618. OL 30658519M.
- Lewis, James R.; Hellesoy, Kjersti, eds. (2017). Handbook of Scientology. Vol. Brill Handbooks on Contemporary Religion. Brill. ISBN 9789004330542.
- Childs, Joe; Tobin, Thomas C. (December 30, 2009). "Climbing The Bridge: A journey to 'Operating Thetan'". Tampa Bay Times. Archived from the original on June 17, 2018. Retrieved August 26, 2016.
- Lewis, James R. (1997). "Clearing the Planet: Utopian Idealism and the Church of Scientology". Syzygy, Journal of Alternative Religion and Culture. 6 (1–2): 287. ISSN 1059-6860.
- Cook, Pat (1971). "Scientology and Dianetics". The Journal of Education. 153 (4): 58–61. doi:10.1177/002205747115300409. JSTOR 42773008. S2CID 151258588.
- Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health page 79 and Glossary
- ^ Winter, J.A. (1951). Dianetics: A Doctor's Report. Julian Press. ISBN 0517564211. OL 2725623M.
- Hubbard, L. Ron. "What is the Reactive Mind?". Church of Scientology International. Archived from the original on April 8, 2008. Retrieved April 28, 2006.
- Corydon, Bent (1987). L. Ron Hubbard, Messiah or Madman?. Lyle Stuart. pp. 263–264. ISBN 0818404442. (PDF TXT)
- ^ Urban, Hugh B. (2011). The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion. Princeton University Press. ISBN 9780691146089.
- "The Dianetics Procedure - 10 Simple Steps". Archived from the original on February 26, 2003.
- Hubbard, L. Ron (1950). Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health.
- ^ Hayakawa, S. I. (1951). "From Science-fiction to Fiction-science". ETC: A Review of General Semantics. 8 (4): 280–293. ISSN 0014-164X. JSTOR 42580983. Retrieved December 19, 2023. (PDF)
- Hubbard, L. Ron (October 1958). The Story of Dianetics and Scientology, Lecture 18 (Speech).
by 1947, I had achieved clearing.
- Levy, Alan (November 15, 1968). "Scientology". Life.
- Michener, Wendy (August 22, 1966). "Is This the Happiest Man in the World?". Maclean's.
- ^ Freeman, Lucy (September 9, 1950). "Psychologists Act Against Dianetics; Claims Made for New Therapy Not Backed by Empirical Evidence, Group Says Offered Proof, Says Author". The New York Times.
- Ibanez, Dalmyra; Southon, Gordon; Southon, Peggy; Benton, Peggy (1951). Dianetic Processing: A Brief Survey of Research Projects and Preliminary Results. Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation. p. 36.
- ^ "Departure in Dianetics". Time. September 3, 1951. Archived from the original on November 14, 2007. Retrieved February 14, 2008.
- L. Ron Hubbard Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health, p. 204, Bridge Publications Inc., 2007 ISBN 978-1-4031-4484-3; 1st ed. 1950
- "Tests & Poison". Time. September 18, 1950. Archived from the original on January 14, 2009. Retrieved February 10, 2008.
- ^ Gardner, Martin (1957). "Chapter 22 : Dianetics". Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science. Dover Publications Inc. ISBN 978-0-486-20394-2. OL 22475247M.
- See e.g. Bauer, Scientific Literacy and the Myth of the Scientific Method and Science Or Pseudoscience: Magnetic Healing, Psychic Phenomena, and Other Heterodoxies; Corsini et al., The Dictionary of Psychology.
- Ari Ben-Menahem (2009). "Demise of the Dogmatic Universe". Historical Encyclopedia of Natural and Mathematical Sciences. Springer Berlin Heidelberg. pp. 4301–4302. doi:10.1007/978-3-540-68832-7. ISBN 978-3-540-68831-0.
- Lee, John A. (1970). The Lee Report on Dianetics and Scientology (Sectarian Healers and Hypnotherapy). Queen's Printer – via David S. Touretzky.
- Fischer, Harvey Jay. "Dianetic therapy: an experimental evaluation. A statistical analysis of the effect of dianetic therapy as measured by group tests of intelligence, mathematics and personality". Abstract of Ph.D. thesis, 1953, New York University (Excerpt)
- Fox, Jack; Davis, Alvin E.; Lebovits, B (1959). "An Experimental Investigation of Hubbard's Engram Hypothesis (Dianetics)". Psychological Newsletter. 10. New York University: 131–134.
- Carroll, Robert T. "Dianetics". The Skeptic's Dictionary.
- "Psychologist says church appeared to use hypnosis", The Irish Times, 13 March 2003
- "The 'Scientology Organization' (SO) as of July 2003", chapter 2, Landesamt für Verfassungsschutz Baden-Wuerttemberg, 2003
- Westbrook, Donald (2018). Among the Scientologists: History, Theology, and Praxis. Oxford University Press. p. 60. ISBN 9780190664978. Retrieved October 16, 2019.
- "Science of Survival", L. Ron Hubbard, p. 461 (2007 edition).
- "A Very Brief Overview of Scientology", Richard E. Ofshe, Ph.D.
- Patihis, Lawrence; Burton, Helena J. Younes (2015). "False memories in therapy and hypnosis before 1980". Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice. 2 (2): 153–169. doi:10.1037/cns0000044.
- Gumpert, Martin (August 14, 1950). "A Doctor's Scathing 1950 Takedown of L. Ron Hubbard's 'Dianetics'". The New Republic. Archived from the original on May 18, 2015. Retrieved October 17, 2018.
Further reading
- Behar, Richard (May 6, 1991). "Scientology: The Thriving Cult of Greed and Power". Time. Archived from the original on May 25, 2014.
- Breuer J, Freud S, "Studies in Hysteria", Vol II of the Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud (Hogarth Press, London, 1955).
- Fischer, Harvey Jay: "Dianetic therapy: an experimental evaluation. A statistical analysis of the effect of dianetic therapy as measured by group tests of intelligence, mathematics and personality. " Abstract of Ph.D. thesis, 1953, New York University
- Miscavige, David (October 8, 1993). "Speech to the International Association of Scientologists" – via David S. Touretzky.
- O'Brien, Helen: Dianetics in Limbo. Whitmore, Philadelphia, 1966
- Streissguth, Thomas (1995). Charismatic Cult Leaders. The Oliver Press. ISBN 1881508188. OL 1097441M.
- van Vogt, A.E.: Dianetics and the Professions, 1953
- Williamson, Jack (1984). Wonder's Child: My life in science fiction. New York: Bluejay Books. ISBN 0312944543. OL 2848895M.
External links
L. Ron Hubbard | |
---|---|
Life | |
Founded | |
Novels and novellas | |
Short story collections | |
Film | |
Dianetics and Scientology | |
Music | |
Biographies |
|
Publishers' sites | |
Family |
|