Revision as of 11:31, 24 February 2022 editIchthyovenator (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users26,132 edits These states cannot be called "Neo-Assyrian" since that designation is used for a previous period - calling them Assyrian at all is questionable since academia leans towards identifying many of them as Iranian. The cited source does not support this either. The section works just as well without this and already makes continuity into Sasanian times clear.Tag: Visual edit← Previous edit | Revision as of 08:44, 28 February 2022 edit undoIchthyovenator (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users26,132 edits WP:BOLD overhaul of the article per talk page discussion – the previous version was more like an essay than an article, cited various unreliable sources, was unfocused and difficult to follow and contained WP:OR as well as deliberately misquoted and misrepresented material. This version stays on-topic, is well-sourced to academic works and makes it clear that modern academia generally supports continuity (and why), and also contains the history of the theoryNext edit → | ||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{short description| |
{{short description|Continuity between ancient and modern Assyrians}} | ||
{{Use British English|date=May 2020}} | |||
]'' in Nuhadra (], Iraq)]] | ]'' in Nuhadra (], Iraq)]] | ||
{{image frame|content={{Photomontage | |||
| photo1a = Flag of the Assyrians.svg | |||
| photo2a = Ashur god.jpg | |||
| photo2b = Ashur5.jpg | |||
| size = 295 | |||
| spacing = 3 | |||
}} | |||
| width = 300 | |||
| caption = The modern ] (top) prominently incorporates ancient Assyrian elements, including the god ] (bottom left) and the star of the god ] (bottom right) | |||
}} | |||
'''Assyrian continuity''' is the theory of continuity between the modern ], an ] minority in the ], and the people of ancient ]. Assyrian continuity is a key part of the identity of the modern Assyrian people.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=605}} Given that there is no evidence of the original Assyrian population being replaced in the aftermath of the fall of Assyria,{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} contemporary scholarship generally supports Assyrian continuity, recognizing the modern Assyrians as descendants of the ]-speaking populations of the ],{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}}{{Sfn|Frahm|2017|p=7}}{{Sfn|Biggs|2005|p=10}}{{sfn|Saggs|1984|p=290}}<!-- more sources and discussion can be found under "Academic position" --> which were composed of both the old native Assyrian population{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}}{{Sfn|Frahm|2017|p=7}}{{sfn|Saggs|1984|p=290}} and of ] settlers in the ].{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}}{{Efn|At the height of the ], there were around 20 million Assyrians.{{sfn|Parpola|2004|p=22}} Estimates for the number of people resettled under Neo-Assyrian rule (not all of whom were Arameans and not all of whom were settled in the Assyrian heartland) range from 1.5 million to 4.5 million.{{Sfn|Bedford|2009|p=33}}}}<!-- this is not denial of continuity with ancient Assyria - as explained in the rest of the article, the Aramean settlers did not replace the original population, nor would they themselves after a few generations have identified as anything other than Assyrians --> | |||
Due to a shortage of sources beyond the ] and works by classical authors, western historians prior to the 19th century believed Assyria to have been completely annihilated. Modern ] has increasingly challenged this perception; today, Assyriologists recognize that Assyrian culture and people clearly survived the violent fall of the Neo-Assyrian Empire. The last period of ancient Assyrian history is now regarded to be the long ], during which the ] went extinct but other aspects of Assyrian culture, such as religion, traditions, and naming patterns, survived in a reduced but highly recognizable form for nearly a millennium.{{Sfn|Hauser|2017|p=240}} | |||
'''Assyrian continuity''' is the theory—supported by a number of scholars and ]—that today's modern Assyrians descend from the ], a ] people native to ancient ], that originally spoke the ], a dialect of the ]. They later spoke the ]. Notions of Assyrian continuity are based on both ], genetic, linguistic and historical claims, and the asserted continuity of Assyria's historical and cultural heritage after the fall of the ].{{sfn|Yildiz|1999|p=16-19}}{{sfn|Gewargis|2002|p=77–95}}{{sfn|Parpola|2004|p=5-22}}{{sfn|Yana|2008|p=19-60}} | |||
The extinction of Akkadian and its replacement with Aramaic does not reflect the disappearance of the original Assyrian population;{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} Aramaic was used not only by Aramean settlers but was also adopted by native Assyrians,{{Sfn|Frahm|2017|p=7}} in time even becoming used by the royal administration itself.{{Sfn|Radner|2021|p=149}}{{sfn|Luukko|Van Buylaere|2017|p=319}} Due to assimiliation efforts encouraged by Assyrian kings, Arameans and other groups in the Assyrian heartland are also likely to quickly have self-identified, and been regarded, as Assyrians.{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} The population of northern Mesopotamia was ] between the 1st and 4th centuries AD. Aramaic-language sources from the Christian period predominantly use the self-designations ''ʾārāmāyā'' ("Aramean") and ''suryāyā''.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=600}} "Assyrian" (''ʾāthorāyā'') also continously survived as the designation for a Christian from ] (ancient Nineveh) and its vicinity.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=|pp=600–601}} The reluctance of the overall Christian population to adopt ''ʾāthorāyā'' as a self-designation probably derives from Assyria's portrayal in the Bible. The different terms did not refer to different groups, given that some individuals are described as both ''ʾārāmāyā'' and ''suryāyā''.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=600}} ''Suryāyā'', sometimes translated as "Syrian" or "Syriac", is also not technically a different identity than "Assyrian" given that the term is thought to derive from the ancient Akkadian ''assūrāyu''.{{sfn|Benjamen|2022|p=2}}{{Sfn|Parpola|2004|pp=16–17}} The academic consensus is that the modern name "Syria" originated as a shortened form of "Assyria".{{Sfn|Shehadeh|2011|p=17}} | |||
Claims of continuity have an important place in public life of modern Assyrian communities, both in their homeland and throughout the ].<ref>{{Cite news | url=https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-11669994 | title=Iraqi Christians' long history| work=BBC News| date=November 2010}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web | url=https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/8-things-didnt-know-assyrian-christians |title = 8 things you didn't know about Assyrian Christians|website = ]|date = 2015-03-21}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web | url=https://www.christianity.com/church/denominations/discover-the-assyrians-10-things-to-know-about-their-history-faith.html |title = Who are the Assyrians? 10 Things to Know about their History & Faith}}</ref> Modern Assyrians are accepted to be an ] ] of modern ], southeastern ], northeastern ], and border areas of northwestern ], a region that roughly corresponds to the areas of ancient Assyria.<ref>{{Cite web | url=https://unpo.org/members/7859 |title = UNPO: Assyria}}</ref><ref>{{Cite news | url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-11669994 |title = Iraqi Christians' long history|work = BBC News|date = November 2010}}</ref> | |||
] developed near the end of the 19th century, coinciding with increasing contacts with Europeans and with increased expressions nationalism in other Middle Eastern groups, such as the ], ], ] and ].{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=603}} Through the large-scale adoption and promotion of identities such as ''ʾāthorāyā'' and ''ʾasurāyā'', Assyrian intellectuals and authors hoped to inspire the unification of the Assyrian nation, transcending long-standing denominational divisions.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=603}} This effort has been met with both support and opposition in various communities; some denominations have rejected unity and promoted alternate identities, such as ]. Though some religious officials and activists have promoted such identities as separate ethnic groups rather than simply religious groups, they are not generally treated as such by international organizations.{{sfn|Petrosian|2006|pp=143–144}} | |||
Assyrians are a modern people who still speak, read and write Akkadian-influenced{{sfn|Kaufman|1974|p=}} ] dialects, such as ].{{sfn|Khan|2012|p=173-199}} Most are ],{{sfn|Hanish|2015|p=517}} being members of various denominations of ]: the ], the ], the ], the ], the ]; as well as the ] denominations of the ] and the ].{{sfn|Wolk|2008|p=108}} | |||
== Assyrians after the Assyrian Empire == | |||
There has been a significant contingent of contemporary scholars supporting Assyrian continuity, including ],{{sfn|Parpola|2000|p=1–16}}{{sfn|Parpola|2004|p=5-22}}<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://atour.com/education/20040416a.html|title=Assyrian Identity in Ancient Times and Today by Dr. Simo Parpola|website=atour.com|access-date=2019-10-20}}</ref> ],{{sfn|Frye|1992|p=281–285}}{{sfn|Frye|1997|p=30–36}} ],{{sfn|Nisan|2002}} John Brinkman,<ref></ref> ],{{sfn|Biggs|2005|p=1–23}} and ].{{sfn|Saggs|1984}} Among Assyrian scholars, one of the most prominent supporters of Assyrian continuity is university professor and ] scholar Amir Harrak.{{sfn|Harrak|2001|p=168-189}}{{sfn|Harrak|2005|p=45-65}}<ref></ref> | |||
=== Early assumption of Assyrian annihilation === | |||
==Evidence for continuity from the Classical Antiquity== | |||
]]] | |||
Evidence of Assyrian continuity from the period of ] refers to archeological and historical data related to the Assyrian regional, cultural and ethnic continuity during the periods of ], ], ], ], ], ] and early ] rule (7th century BCE - 7th century CE). In terms of an unbroken continuity of Assyrian regional traditions and identity, one of the main evidence is provided by the survival of Assyrian regional name, that not only outlived the fall of the ], but was also officially used by some successive states as administrative (provincial) designation for the ] (see: ], Sassanid ], and Roman ]).{{sfn|Parpola|2000|p=1–16}}{{sfn|Parpola|2004|p=5-22}} | |||
Ancient ] fell in the late 7th century BC through the ], with its major population centers violently sacked and most of its territory incorporated into the ].{{Sfn|Frahm|2017b|p=192}} In the millennia following the fall of Assyria, knowledge of the ancient empire chiefly survived in western literary tradition through accounts of Assyria in the ] and works by classical authors,{{Sfn|Trolle Larsen|2017|p=|pp=583–584}} both of which described Assyria's fall as violent and comprehensive destruction.{{Sfn|Frahm|2017c|p=560}}{{Sfn|Kuhrt|1995|p=239}} Before the 19th century, the prevalent belief in Biblically-influenced western scholarship was that ancient Assyria and Babylonia had been literally annihilated due to provoking divine wrath.{{Sfn|Reade|2018|p=286}} This belief was reinforced through archaeologists in the Middle East initially not finding many remains fitting with the conventional European image of ancient cities, with stone columns and great sculptures, beyond those of ancient Persia;{{Sfn|Reade|2018|p=286}} Assyria and other Mesopotamian civilizations left no magnificent ruins above ground—all that remained to see were huge grass-covered mounds in the plains which travellers at times believed to simply be natural features of the landscape.{{Sfn|Trolle Larsen|2017|p=|pp=583–584}} Early European archaeologists in the Middle East were also for the most part more interested in confirming Biblical truth through their excavations than to spend time on new interpretations of the evidence they discovered.{{Sfn|Dalley|1993|p=134}} | |||
Though the Bible and other Hebrew texts describe the destruction of the Assyrian Empire, they do not actually claim that the Assyrian people were destroyed. The 2nd century BC apocryphal ] states that the ] king ] ({{Reign}}605–562 BC) "ruled over the Assyrians in the great city of ]", the ] refers to the Persian king ] as "king of Assyria", and the ] states that there will come a day when God will proclaim "Blessed be Egypt my people, and Assyria the work of my hands, and Israel my heritage".{{Sfn|Frahm|2017c|pp=560–561}} The idea of Assyrian annihilation, despite increasing evidence to the contrary, proved to be enduring in western academia. As late as 1925, the Assyriologist ] wrote that "The disappearance of the Assyrian people will always remain an unique and striking phenomenon in ancient history. Other, similar kingdoms and empires have indeed passed away, but the people have lived on ... No other land seems to have been sacked and pillaged so completely as was Assyria".{{Sfn|Dalley|1993|p=|pp=135–136}} Just a year later, Smith had abandoned the idea of the Assyrians having been eradicated and recognized the persistence of Assyrians through the Christian period.{{Sfn|Smith|1926|p=69}} | |||
Second group of evidence is related to archeological finds from various post-Imperial periods. Modern archeological excavations in the ] have indicated that there was a substantial continuity of local occupancy, accompanied by preservation of regional and cultural identities, primarily in terms of continuation of main Assyrian religious cults and practices.{{sfn|Dalley|1993|p=134–147}}{{sfn|Kuhrt|1995|p=239-254}}{{sfn|Curtis|2003|p=157-167}}{{sfn|Curtis|2005|p=175-195}} | |||
Additional questions, that were raised by several authors already during the period of Classical Antiquity, referred to ] and ] relations between terms ''Assyria'' and ''Syria''. The discovery (1997) of the ] appears to prove the already largely prevailing position that the term "Syria" ultimately derives from the Akkadian term '''''Aššūrāyu''''' (]: 𒀸𒋗𒁺𐎹) through ]. The Çineköy inscription is a ]-] ], uncovered from ] in ], Turkey (ancient ]), dating to the 8th century BCE.{{sfn|Tekoğlu|Lemaire|İpek|Tosun|2000|p=961-1007}} This Indo-European corruption of Assyrian was later adopted by the ] from the late 4th century BC or early 3rd century BC and also then applied (or misapplied) to non-Assyrian peoples from the ], causing not only the true ]ns (Syrians), but also the largely ], ]n and ] peoples of the Levant to be collectively called "Syrians" or "Syriacs" ({{Lang-la|Syriaci}}, {{Lang-grc|Συρίακοι}}) in the ]. | |||
=== Post-imperial Assyria in modern Assyriology === | |||
In ] usage, "Syria" and "Assyria" were used almost interchangeably. Herodotus's distinctions between the two in the 5th century BC were a notable early exception.{{sfn|Dalley|Reyes|1998|p=94}} ] has emphasized that Herodotus "never" applied the term Syria to Mesopotamia, which he always called "Assyria", and used "Syria" to refer to inhabitants of the coastal Levant.{{sfn|Joseph|2000|p=21}} While himself maintaining a distinction, Herodotus also claimed that "those called ''Syrians'' by the ] are called ''Assyrians'' by the barbarians (non-Greeks).<ref name="Herodotus VII.63">(Pipes 1992), ]<br />{{cite web |author=Herodotus |author-link= Herodotus|title=Herodotus VII.63 |url=http://www.fordham.edu/Halsall/ancient/greek-babylon.html |quote=VII.63: The Assyrians went to war with helmets upon their heads made of brass, and plaited in a strange fashion which is not easy to describe. They carried shields, lances, and daggers very like the Egyptian; but in addition they had wooden clubs knotted with iron, and linen corselets. This people, whom the Hellenes call Syrians, are called Assyrians by the barbarians. The Babylonians served in their ranks, and they had for commander Otaspes, the son of Artachaeus.}}<br />{{citation |author=Herodotus |title=Herodotus VII.72|quote=VII.72: In the same fashion were equipped the Ligyans, the Matienians, the Mariandynians, and the Syrians (or Cappadocians, as they are called by the Persians).}}</ref>{{sfn|Frye|1992|p=281–285}}{{sfn|Frye|1997|p=30–36}} | |||
{{See also|Post-imperial Assyria}} | |||
] and erected in ] in the 2nd century AD (under ] rule) by the local ruler ]{{Sfn|Radner|2015|p=20}}<!--The name given in the Wikimedia Commons description, Re'n-tayar, is either erroneous or an alternate transliteration; Radner identifies this figure R'uth-Assor.-->]]Modern Assyriology does not support the idea that the fall of Assyria also brought with it a complete eradication of the Assyrian people and their culture.{{Sfn|Hauser|2017|p=229}} Though in the past regarded as a "post-Assyrian" age, Assyriologists today consider the last period of ancient Assyrian history to be the long ],{{Sfn|Hauser|2017|p=229}}{{Sfn|Frahm|2017|p=5}} extending from 609 BC to around AD 240.{{Sfn|Hauser|2017|p=229}} Though the centuries that followed the fall of Assyria are characterized by a distinct lack of surviving sources from the region,{{sfn|Hauser|2017|p=229}} the idea that Assyria was rendered uninhabited and desolated stems from the contrast with the richly attested Neo-Assyrian period, not necessarily from the actual sources from the post-imperial period.{{Sfn|Kuhrt|1995|p=240}} | |||
Though the Assyrian bureaucracy and governmental institutions disappeared with Assyria's fall, Assyrian population centers and culture did not.{{Sfn|Kuhrt|1995|p=240}} At ], one of the largest settlements along the ] river, a large Assyrian palace, dubbed the "Red House" by archaeologists, continued to be used in Neo-Babylonian times, with cuneiform records there being written by people with Assyrian names, in Assyrian style, though dated to the reigns of the early Neo-Babylonian kings.{{sfn|Hauser|2017|p=230}} These documents mention officials with Assyrian titles and invoke the ancient Assyrian national deity ].{{Sfn|Kuhrt|1995|p=240}} Two Neo-Babylonian texts discovered at the city of ] in Babylonia attest to there being royally appointed governors at both ] and ], another Assyrian site in the north. ] is attested as a thriving city, but only very late in the Neo-Babylonian period, and there were attempts to revive the city of ] in reign of ] ({{Reign}}560–556 BC), who returned a cult statue to the site. ] was revitalized, with its great temple dedicated to the lunar god ] being rebuilt under ] ({{Reign}}556–539 BC).{{sfn|Hauser|2017|p=230}} | |||
The Greek historian ] reports that during the ] (c. 410 BC), the ] intercepted a ] who was carrying a message from the Great King to ]. The man was taken prisoner, brought to Athens, and the letters he was carrying were translated "from the Assyrian language" which was Imperial Aramaic, an ] first of the former ] and then a ] of the succeeding ]. | |||
Individuals with Assyrian names are attested at multiple sites in Babylonia during the Neo-Babylonian Empire, including Babylon, ], ], ], ] and ]. The Assyrians in Uruk apparently continued to exist as a community until the reign of the Achaemenid king ] ({{Reign}}530–522 BC) and were closely linked to a local cult dedicated to Ashur.{{Sfn|Frahm|2017b|p=194}} Individiuals with clearly Assyrian names are also known from the rule of the ], sometimes in high levels of government. A prominent example is ], who served as the secretary of Cambyses II.{{sfn|Parpola|1999}} The temple dedicated to Ashur in Assur was rebuilt by local Assyrians in the reign of ].{{Sfn|Radner|2015|p=6}} | |||
Greek geographer and historian ] (d. in 24 CE) described, in his "'']''", both Assyria and Syria, dedicating specific chapters to each of them,{{sfn|Roller|2014|p=689-699, 699-713}} but also noted, in his chapter on Assyria: | |||
Under the ] and ] empires, Assyria began to be rebuilt and the ancient population centers began to be resettled,{{sfn|Hauser|2017|p=238}} with the predominant portion of the population remaining native Assyrian.{{sfn|Reade|1998|p=71}} The original Assyrian capital of Assur is in particular known to have fluorished under Parthian rule.{{Sfn|Haider|2008|p=193}} Continuity from ancient Assyria is clear in Assur during this period, with personal names of the city's denizens greatly reflecting names used in the Neo-Assyrian Empire, such as ''Qib-Assor'' ("command of Ashur"), ''Assor-tares'' ("Ashur judges") and even ''Assor-heden'' ("Ashur has given a brother", a late version of the name ''Aššur-aḫu-iddina'', i.e. ]).{{Sfn|Livingstone|2009|p=154}} The Assyrians at Assur continued to follow the traditional ], worshipping Ashur (at this time known as ''Assor'') and other gods.{{Sfn|Haider|2008|p=197}} Assur may even have been the capital of its own semi-autonomous vassal state, either under the suzerainty of the ],{{sfn|Radner|2015|p=19}} or under direct Parthian suzerainty.{{Sfn|Harper|Klengel-Brandt|Aruz|Benzel|1995|p=18}} Though this golden age of Assur came to an end with the conquest, sack and destruction of the city by the ] {{Circa}} AD 240,{{Sfn|Radner|2015|p=7}} the inscriptions, temples, continued celebration of festivals and the wealth of theophoric elements (divine names) in personal names of the Parthian period illustrate a strong continuity of traditions, and that the most important deities of old Assyria were still worshipped at Assur more than 800 years after the Assyrian Empire had been destroyed.{{Sfn|Hauser|2017|p=240}} | |||
{{Blockquote|text="Those who have written histories of the Syrian empire say that when the Medes were overthrown by the Persians, and the Syrians by the Medes, they spoke of the Syrians only as those who built the palaces at Babylon and Ninos. Of these, Ninos founded Ninos in Atouria, and his wife Semiramis succeeded her husband and founded Babylon ... The city of Ninos was destroyed immediately after the overthrow of the Syrians. It was much greater than Babylon and was situated in the plain of Atouria."{{sfn|Roller|2014|p=689-690}}}} | |||
== Identity in ancient Assyria == | |||
Throughout his work, Strabo used terms ''Atouria'' (]) and ] (and also terms ''Assyrians'' and ''Syrians'') in relation to specific terminological questions, while comparing and analyzing views of previous writers. Reflecting on the works of ] (d. 51 BCE), Strabo noted: | |||
=== Development and distinctions === | |||
{{Blockquote|text="For the people of Armenia, the Syrians, and the Arabians display a great racial kinship, both in their language and their lives and physical characteristics, particularly where they are adjacent ... Considering the latitudes, there is a great difference between those toward the north and south and the Syrians in the middle, but common condition s prevail, and the Assyrians and Arameans somewhat resemble both each other and the others. He infers that the names of these peoples are similar to each other, for those whom we call Syrians are called Aramaians by the Syrians themselves, and there is a resemblance between this , and that of the Arameans, Arabians, and Erembians."{{sfn|Roller|2014|p=71}}}} | |||
] depicting a ] king, accompanied by attendants]] | |||
] and ] are largely based in self-perception and self-designation.{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} In ancient Assyria, a distinct Assyrian identity appears to have formed already in the ] ({{Circa}} 2025–1364 BC), when distinctly Assyrian burial practices, foods and dress codes are attested{{Sfn|Düring|2020|p=39}} and Assyrian documents appear to consider the inhabitants of Assur to be a distinct cultural group.{{sfn|Michel|2017|p=81}} A wider Assyrian identity appears to have spread across northern Mesopotamia under the ] ({{Circa}} 1363–912 BC), since later writings concerning the reconquests of the early Neo-Assyrian kings refer to some of their wars as liberating the Assyrian people of the cities they reconquered.{{Sfn|Düring|2020|p=145}} Though there for much of ancient Assyria's history existed a distinct Assyrian identity, Assyrian culture and civilization, like any other culture and civilization, did not develop in isolation. As the Assyrian Empire expanded and contracted, elements from regions the Assyrians conquered or traded with culturally influenced the Assyrian heartland and the Assyrians themselves. Early Assyrian culture was greatly influenced by the ], a people that also lived in northern Mesopotamia, and by the culture of southern Mesopotamia, particularly that of ].{{Sfn|Frahm|2017|p=7}} | |||
Surviving evidence suggests that the ancient Assyrians had a relatively open definition of what it meant to be Assyrian. Modern ideas such as a person's ethnic background, or the Roman idea of legal citizenship, do not appear to have been reflected in ancient Assyria.{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} Although Assyrian accounts and artwork of warfare frequently describe and depict foreign enemies, they are not depicted with different physical features, but rather with different clothing and equipment. Assyrian accounts describe enemies as ] only in terms of their behavior, as lacking correct religious practices, and as doing wrongdoings against Assyria. All things considered, there does not appear to have been any well-developed concepts of ethnicity or ] in ancient Assyria.{{Sfn|Bahrani|2006|pp=56–57}} What mattered for a person to be seen by others as Assyrian was mainly fulfillment of obligations (such as military service), being affiliated with the Assyrian Empire politically, and maintaining loyalty to the Assyrian king; some kings, such as ] ({{reign}}722–705 BC), explicitly encouraged assimilation and mixture of foreign cultures with that of Assyrian.{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} | |||
Terms "Syria" and "Assyria" were not fully distinguished by Greeks until they became better acquainted with the ]. Under ] rule after Syria's conquest by ], "Syria" was restricted to the land west of the Euphrates. While the ] mostly corrected their usage as well,{{sfn|Joseph|1997|p=38}} they and the Greeks continued to conflate the terms. | |||
=== Arameans and Aramaic === | |||
] historian ], writing in the 1st century AD about various peoples who were descended from the ], according to ] tradition, noted that: "''Assyras founded the city of Ninus, and gave his name to his subjects, the Assyrians, who rose to the height of prosperity. Arphaxades named those under his rule Arphaxadaeans, the Chaldaeans of to-day. Aramus ruled the Aramaeans, whom the Greeks term Syrians''".{{sfn|Thackeray|1961|p=71}} Those remarks testify that Josephus regarded all there peoples (Assyrians, Chaldeans, Arameans) as his contemporaries, thus confirming that in his time Assyrians were not considered to be extinct. | |||
] once belonging to the king ] ({{reign}}727–722 BC). The weight is inscribed in both ] and ].]] | |||
In the wake of the ] around 1200 BC, ] tribes began to migrate into Assyrian territory. In the first millennium BC, Aramean influence on Assyria grew greater and greater, owing to further migrations as well as mass deportations enacted by several Assyrian kings.{{Sfn|Frahm|2017|p=7}} Though the expansion of the Assyrian Empire, in combination with resettlements and deportations, changed the ethno-cultural make-up of the Assyrian heartland, there is no evidence to suggest that the more ancient Assyrian inhabitants of the land ever disappeared or became restricted to a small elite, nor that the ethnic and cultural identity of the new settlers was anything other than "Assyrian" after one or two generations.{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} | |||
Because the Assyrians never imposed their language on foreign peoples whose lands they conquered outside of the Assyrian heartland, there were no mechanisms in place to stop the spread of languages other than Akkadian. Beginning with the migrations of Arameans into Assyrian territory during the Middle Assyrian period, this lack of linguistic policies facilitated the spread of the Aramaic language.{{sfn|Luukko|Van Buylaere|2017|p=318}} As the most widely spoken and mutually understandable of the Semitic languages (the language group containing many of the languages spoken through the empire),{{Sfn|Radner|2021|p=147}} Aramaic grew in importance throughout the Neo-Assyrian period and increasingly replaced the Akkadian language even within the Assyrian heartland itself.{{Sfn|Frahm|2017b|p=180}}{{Sfn|Radner|2021|p=149}} From the 9th century BC onwards, Aramaic became the '']'' lingua franca, with Akkadian becoming relegated to a language of the political elite (i.e. governors and officials).{{sfn|Luukko|Van Buylaere|2017|p=318}} | |||
], the Roman historian wrote in 300 AD: ''The ''Assyrians'', who are afterwards called ''Syrians'', held their empire thirteen hundred years''.<ref>The Origins of Syrian Nationhood: Histories, Pioneers and Identity Adel Beshara</ref> | |||
The widespread adoption of the language does not indicate a wholesale replacement of the original native population; the Aramaic language was used not only by Aramean settlers but also by native Assyrians, who adopted it and its alphabetic script.{{Sfn|Frahm|2017|p=7}} The Aramaic language had entered the Assyrian royal administration by the reign of ] ({{reign}}859–824 BC), given that Aramaic writings are known from a palace he built in ].{{Sfn|Radner|2021|p=149}} By the time of ] ({{reign}}745–727 BC), the Assyrian kings employed both Akkadian and Aramaic-language royal scribes, confirming the rise of Aramaic to a position of an official language used by the imperial administration.{{Sfn|Radner|2021|p=149}}{{sfn|Luukko|Van Buylaere|2017|p=319}} It is clear that Aramaic was spoken by the Assyrian royal family from at least the late 8th century BC onwards, given that Tiglath-Pileser's son ] ({{reign}}727–722 BC) owned a set of ] inscribed with text in both Akkadian and Aramaic.{{sfn|Luukko|Van Buylaere|2017|p=319}} A recorded drop in the number of cuneiform documents late in the reign of ] ({{reign}}669–631 BC) could indicate a greater shift to Aramaic, often written on perishable materials like leather scrolls or papyrus,{{sfn|Luukko|Van Buylaere|2017|p=318}} though it could perhaps alternatively be attributed to political instability in the empire.{{Sfn|Frahm|2017b|p=190}} The denizens of Assur and other former Assyrian population centers under Parthian rule, who clearly connected themselves to ancient Assyria, wrote and spoke Aramaic.{{sfn|Reade|1998|p=71}} | |||
In the 380s AD, the Roman historian ] during his travels in Upper Mesopotamia with ] states that; "Within this circuit is ], which was formerly called Assyria;" Ammianus Marcellinus also refers to an extant region still called ] located between the ] and ] rivers.<ref></ref> | |||
== Pre-modern self-identities == | |||
Reflecting on various meanings of ''Syrian'' designations in works of classical authors, modern scholar Nathanael Andrade pointed that some of those uses are indicating the existence of ] continuities: | |||
]|left]] | |||
Though many foreign states ruled over the Assyrian heartland in the millennia following the empire's fall, there is no evidence of any large scale influx of immigrants that replaced the original population,{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} which instead continued to make up a significant portion of the region's people until ] and ] massacres in the late 14th century.{{sfn|Filoni|2017|p=37}} In pre-modern Syriac-language (the type of Aramaic used in Christian Mesopotamian writings) sources, the typical self-designations used are ''ʾārāmāyā'' ("Aramean") and ''suryāyā'' (as well as the shortened ''surayā''), with the term ''ʾāthorāyā'' ("Assyrian") rarely being used as a self-designation. It is clear from the surviving sources that ''ʾārāmāyā'' and ''suryāyā'' were not distinct and mutually exclusive identities, but rather interchangeable terms used to refer to the same people; the Syriac author ] (154–222) is for instance referred to in 4th-century Syriac translations of ]'s '']'' as both ''ārāmāyā'' and ''suryāyā''.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=600}} | |||
{{Blockquote|text="This shift to "Syrian" as a social regional formulation did not suppress all veins of ethnic Syrianness. The Syrian ethnic articulations of Syrianness that characterized Seleucid times persisted through the Roman imperial period. The previously mentioned examples of ] and ]’s ''On the Syrian Goddess'' indicate this, and Strabo and Josephus posited ethnic continuity between Syrians and ancient Assyrians or Arameans."{{sfn|Andrade|2013|p=110}}}} | |||
''Suryāyā'', which also occurs in the forms ''suryāyē'' and ''sūrōyē'',{{sfn|Benjamen|2022|p=2}} though sometimes translated to "Syrian",{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=601}} is not technically a different identity than "Assyrian". The term is believed to derive from the ancient Akkadian term ''assūrāyu'' ("Assyrian"), which was sometimes even in ancient times rendered in the shorter form ''sūrāyu''.{{sfn|Benjamen|2022|p=2}}{{Sfn|Parpola|2004|pp=16–17}} ] and ] texts from the time of the Neo-Assyrian Empire, such as the ], sometimes use the shortened "Syria" for the Assyrian Empire.{{Sfn|Rollinger|2006|pp=285–287}} The consensus in modern academia is thus that "Syria" is simply a shortened form of "Assyria".{{Sfn|Shehadeh|2011|p=17}} The modern distinction between "Assyrian" and "Syrian" is the result of ancient Greek historians and cartographers, who designated the ] as "]" and Mesopotamia as "Assyria". By the time the terms are first attested in Greek texts (in the 4th century BC), the local denizens in both the Levant and Mesopotamia had already long used both terms interchangeably for the entire region, and continued to do so well into the later Christian period.{{Sfn|Tamari|2019|p=113}} Whether the Greeks began referring to Mesopotamia as "Assyria" because they equated the region with the Assyrian Empire, long fallen by the time the term is first attested in Greek, or because they named the region after the people who lived there, the (As)syrians, is not known.{{Sfn|Rollinger|2006|p=284}} | |||
== Evidence for continuity from the Medieval Period and Renaissance == | |||
Arab conquest of the ] during the 7th century CE marked the beginning of gradual ] and ] of native Christian communities, including Christian Assyrians, who were by that time mainly under the jurisdiction of the ancient ]. During the early period of Muslim rule, terms for Assyria and Assyrians entered ]. The 10th-century AD ] scholar ], while describing the books and scripture of many people, defines the word "{{transl|sem|ʾāšūriyyūn}}" ({{Lang-ar|آشوريون}}) as "a sect of ]" inhabiting northern Mesopotamia.<ref name="ReferenceA">''The Fihrist (Catalog): A Tenth Century Survey of Islamic Culture''. Abu 'l Faraj Muhammad ibn Ishaq al Nadim. ''Great Books of the Islamic World''. Kazi Publications. Translator: Bayard Dodge.</ref> | |||
Although ''suryāyā'' is thus clearly connected to "Assyrian", the more prevalent term for ancient Assyrians, ''ʾāthorāyā'' is not the typical self-designation in pre-modern sources. Syriac sources did however prominently use ''ʾāthorāyā'' in other contexts, particularly in relation to ancient Assyria. Ancient Assyria was typically referred to as ''ʾāthor'', which also survived as a designation for the region surrounding its last great capital, Nineveh.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=|pp=600–601}} The reluctance of Medieval Syriac Christians to use ''ʾāthorāyā'' as a self-designation could perhaps be explained by the Assyrians described in the Bible being prominent enemies of Israel; the term ''ʾāthorāyā'' was sometimes employed in Syriac writings as a term for enemies of Christians. In this context, the term was sometimes applied to the Persians of the ]; the 4th-century Syriac writer ] for instance referred to the Sasanian Empire as "filthy ''ʾāthor'', mother of corruption". In a similar fashion, the term in this context was also sometimes applied to the later Muslim rulers.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=|pp=600–601}} Though not used by the overall Syriac-speaking community in the Middle Ages, the term ''ʾāthorāyā'' did survive as a self-identity throughout the period as it was the typically used designation for a Syriac Christian from ] (ancient Nineveh) and its vicinity.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=|pp=600–601}} | |||
The earliest recorded Western mention of the Christians of the area is by Jacques de Vitry in 1220/1: he wrote that they "denied that Mary was the Mother of God and claimed that Christ existed in two persons. They consecrated leavened bread and used the 'Chaldean' language".{{sfn|Baum|Winkler|2003|p=83}} | |||
]; their legend prominently incorporates the ancient Assyrian king ]]] | |||
Pre-modern Syriac-language sources at times identified positively with the ancient Assyrians{{sfn|Hauser|2017|p=241}} and drew connections between the ancient empire and themselves.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=601}} Most prominently, ancient Assyrian kings and figures long appeared in local folklore and literary tradition{{Sfn|Kalimi|Richardson|2014|p=5}} and claims of descent from ancient Assyrian royalty were forwarded both for figures in folklore and by actual living high-ranking members of society in northern Mesopotamia.{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=|pp=205, 217}} Figures like Sargon II,{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=214}} ] ({{reign}}705–681 BC), ] ({{reign}}681–669 BC), Ashurbanipal and ] long figured in local folklore and literary tradition.{{Sfn|Kalimi|Richardson|2014|p=5}} In large part, tales from the Sasanian period and later times were invented narratives, based on ancient Assyrian history but applied to local and current landscapes.{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=209}} Medieval tales written in Syriac, such as that of ], for instance by and large characterize Sennacherib as an archetypical pagan king assassinated as part of a family feud, whose children convert to Christianity.{{Sfn|Kalimi|Richardson|2014|p=5}} | |||
The 7th-century Assyrian '']'' made the titular saint, ], out to be a descendant of the legendary Biblical Mesopotamian king ] and the historical Sennacherib, with his illustrious descent manifesting in Mar Qardagh's mastery of archery, hunting and ].{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=205}} A sanctuary constructed for Mar Qardagh during this time was built directly on top of the ruins of a Neo-Assyrian temple.{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=208}} The legendary figure Nimrod, otherwise traditionally viewed as simply Mesopotamian, is explicitly referred to as Assyrian in many of the Sasanian-period texts and is inserted into the line of Assyrian kings.{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=214}} Nimrod, as well as other legendary Mesopotamian (though explicitly Assyrian in the texts) rulers, such as ] and ], sometimes play significant roles in the writings.{{sfn|Minov|2020|pp=187, 191}} Certain Christian texts considered the Biblical figure ] to have prophesized the ]; a local Assyrian version of this narrative appears in some Syriac-language writings from the Sasanian period, which allege that Balaam's prophecy was remembered only through being transmitted through the ancient Assyrian kings.{{sfn|Minov|2020|p=203}} In some stories, explicit claims of descent are made. According to the 6th-century '']'', twelve of the noble families of Karka (ancient ]) were descendants of ancient Assyrian nobility who lived in the city during the time of Sargon II.{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=217}} | |||
The language that today is usually called Aramaic was called Chaldean by ] (c. 347 — 420).{{sfn|Gallagher|2012|p=123-141}} This usage continued down the centuries: it was still the normal terminology in the nineteenth century.{{sfn|Gesenius|Prideaux-Tregelles|1859|p=}}{{sfn|Fürst|1867|p=}}{{sfn|Davies|1872|p=}} Accordingly, in the earliest recorded Western mentions of the Christians of what is now Iraq and nearby countries the term is used with reference to their language. In 1220/1 Jacques de Vitry wrote that "they denied that Mary was the Mother of God and claimed that Christ existed in two persons. They consecrated leavened bread and used the 'Chaldean' (Syriac) language".{{sfn|Baum|Winkler|2003|p=83}} In the fifteenth century the term "Chaldeans" was first applied to East Syrians no longer generically in reference to their language but specifically to some living in Cyprus who entered a short-lived union with Rome.{{sfn|Baum|Winkler|2003|p=112}}{{sfn|O’Mahony|2006|p=526-527}} | |||
== Modern identity and nationalism == | |||
Following the ], ] went to Rome, claiming to have been elected as patriarch of the ]. He made a profession of faith that was there judged to be orthodox, was admitted into communion with the ] and was consecrated patriarch by ]. He returned to Mesopotamia as "Patriarch of the Chaldeans",{{sfn|Tisserant|1931|p=228}}{{sfn|Baumer|2006|p=248}}{{sfn|Healey|2010|p=45}} or "patriarch of Mosul",{{sfn|Frazee|2006|p=57}}{{sfn|Wilmshurst|2019|p=194}} or "patriarch of the Eastern Assyrians", as stated by Pietro Strozzi on the second-last unnumbered page before page 1 of his ''De Dogmatibus Chaldaeorum'',<ref>{{cite book|author=Pietro Strozzi|title=De dogmatibus chaldaeorum disputatio ad Patrem ... Adam Camerae Patriarchalis Babylonis ...|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=2u2hpp2f3G0C|year=1617|publisher=ex typographia Bartholomaei Zannetti}}</ref> of which an English translation is given in Adrian Fortescue's ''Lesser Eastern Churches''.<ref></ref> | |||
{{See also|Assyrian nationalism}} | |||
=== 19th century identities and developments === | |||
Herbert Chick's "Chronicle of the Carmelites in Persia", which speaks of the Aramaic-speaking Christians generically as Chaldeans, quotes a letter of ] to the Persian ] (1571–1629) on 3 November 1612 asking for leniency towards those "who are called Assyrians or ] and inhabit ]".<ref></ref> | |||
] (1817–1894), credited with the popularization of Assyrian continuity in western academia]] | |||
Early travellers and ] in northern Mesopotamia in the 19th century observed connections between the indigenous Christian population and the ancient Assyrians. The British traveller ] (1787–1821) referenced "Assyrian Christians" in ''Narrative of a Residence in Koordistan and on the site of Ancient Nineveh'' (published posthumously in 1836, though describing a 1820 journey). It is possible that Rich considered "Assyrian" a geographic, rather than ethnic, term since he in a footnote on the same page also referenced the "Christians of Assyria". More clear-cut evidence of Assyrian self-identity in the 19th century can be seen in the writings of the American missionary ] (1812–1894). In Southgate's ''Narrative of a Visit to the Syrian Church of Mesopotamia'' (1844) he remarked with surprise that Armenians referred to the Syriac Christians as ''Assouri'', which Southgate associated with the English "Assyrians", rather than ''Syriani'', which he himself had been using.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=602}} Armenian sources have since antiquity consistently referred to Assyrians as ''Assouri'' or ''Asori''.{{sfn|Becker|2015|p=328}}{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=602}} Southgate also mentioned that the Syriac Christians themselves at this point claimed origin from the ancient Assyrians as "sons of Assour". Southgate's account thus demonstrates that modern Assyrians claimed ancient Assyrian descent already in the middle of the 19th century.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=602}} | |||
Connections between the modern population and ancient Assyrians were popularized in the west and academia by the archaeologist and traveller ] (1817–1894), responsible for the early excavations of several major ancient Assyrian sites, such as ]. In ''Nineveh and its Remains'' (1849), Layard argued that the Christians he met in northern Mesopotamia were "descendants of the ancient Assyrians". It is possible that Layard's assessment of them as such derived from his partnership with the local Assyrian archaeologist ] (1826–1910).{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=602}} | |||
In his '']'', ], a 16th-century AD ] historian, mentions ''Asuri'' (Assyrians) as being extant in northern Mesopotamia.<ref>Sharafnameh", translated by Jamil Rozbeyati, Al-Najah Publishing house, Baghdad – 1953</ref> | |||
Towards the end of the 19th century, a so-called "religious renaissance" or "awakening" took place in ], Iran. Perhaps partly encouraged by ], ] and ] missionary efforts, the concepts of ] and ] were introduced to the Assyrians in Urmia, who began to adopt the term ''ʾāthorāyā'' as a self-identity, and began building a national ideology more heavily based around ancient Assyria. This was not an isolated phenomenon: Middle Eastern nationalism, probably influenced by developments in Europe, also began to be strongly expressed in other communities during this time, such as among the Armenians, ], ] and ]. This time also saw the development of ], a new literary language based on the at the time spoken ] dialects. Through the promotion of an identity rooted in ancient Assyria, various communities could transcend their denominational differences and unite under one national identity.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=603}} | |||
Poutrus Nasri, an Egyptian theologian, claims that the ] had many adherents who espoused an Assyrian identity during the ] and ] periods.<ref>see Poutrus Nasri (1974). ''History of Syriac Literature''. Cairo.</ref> | |||
=== Contemporary identities and name debate === | |||
===Scarcity of Assyrian names in the Christian Era=== | |||
{{See also|Terms for Syriac Christians}}] (1891–1926), a prominent early Assyrian nationalist]]In the years before ], several prominent Aramaic-language authors and intellectuals promoted Assyrian nationalism. Among them were for instance ] (1891–1926), who in 1911 published an influential article titled ''Who are the Syrians'' ''? How is Our Nation to Be Raised Up?'', in which he pointed out the connection between ''surayē'' and "Assyrian" and argued for the adoption of ''ʾāthorāyā''. The early 20th century saw an increase in the use of the term ''ʾāthorāyā'' as a self-identity. Also used as the ] ''ʾasurāyā'', perhaps inspired by the Armenian ''Asori''.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=603}} The adoption of ''ʾāthorāyā'' and a stronger association with ancient Assyria through nationalism is not a unique development in regard to the Assyrians. Greeks, for instance, due to associating the term "Greek" with the ancient pagan Greeks, overwhelmingly self-identified as ] (''Rhōmaîoi''){{Sfn|Cameron|2009|p=7}} up until nationalism around the time of the ], when a more strong association with Ancient Greece spread among the populace.{{Sfn|Efstathiadou|2011|p=191}}{{Sfn|Morrison|2018|p=39}} | |||
One of the main arguments against the continuity hypothesis is the scarcity of Assyrian and Mesopotamian (]) pagan personal names among the Assyrian Christian priests, bishops and other religious figures. This argument has been put forward by ], ] and David Wilmshurst. | |||
As a consequence of World War I, the '']'' (Assyrian genocide) and various other massacres, a majority of Assyrians have today been displaced from their homeland, living in ] in countries such as Germany, Sweden, Denmark, the United Kingdom, Greece, Australia, New Zealand and the United States. In the aftermath of these events, explicit Assyrian self-identity became even more widespread and established in their communities, not only in order to unify communities in the diaspora (who often originated from different regions) but also because "Syrian" became internationally established as the ] of the newly created country of ].{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=604}} Some from outside the ] also embraced Assyrian nationalism, such as ] (1901–1979), who in 1933 helped found the ] and religiously identified as ] but ethnically identified as Assyrian. In 1935, Perley wrote that "The Assyrians, although representing but one single nation as the direct heirs of the ancient Assyrian Empire … are now doctrinally divided … No one can coherently understand the Assyrians as a whole until he can distinguish that which is religion or church from that which is nation …" and even proposed uniting all Assyrians under a single patriarch of the Church of the East.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=605}} | |||
Dominican Syriac scholar J. M. Fiey noted that while Eastern Christian writers wrote extensively about Assyrians and Babylonians, they did not identify with them. Fiey comments, | |||
For communities that identify as Assyrian, Assyrian continuity forms a key part of their self-identity. Many modern Assyrians are named after ancient Mesopotamian figures, such as Sargon, Sennacherib and Nebuchadnezzar, and the modern ] displays symbolism deriving from ancient Assyria.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=605}} From the second half of the 20th century to the present, Assyrians, particularly in the diaspora, have continued to promote Assyrian nationalism as a unifying force of their people. Some denominational groups have opposed being lumped in as "Assyrians" and have started counter-movements of their own;{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=605}} the so-called "name debate" is still today a hotly discussed topic within Syriac Christian communities, especially in the diaspora outside the Assyrian homeland.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=599}} An alternative promoted by some Syriac Orthodox church officials is Aramean (''ʾārāmāyā'') identity, for instance advocated for by Patriarch ] (patriarch 1933–1957). More recently, Syriac Orthodox adherents have preferred to identify simply as "Syriac", the name of their church and the liturgical language and an alternate transliteration of ''suryayā''. In 1981, Patriarch ] advocated for Syriac identity over both Assyrian and Aramean identity.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=605}} Today, people who identify as Aramean or Syriac typically use those identites interchangeably. Some of the adherents to the ], "]", have also in recent times advocated for recognition as a distinct group.{{sfn|Gaunt|Atto|Barthoma|2017|p=ix}} Modern international organizations do not generally recognize Assyrians, Syriacs, Arameans and Chaldeans as different ethnic groups but merely as alternate names{{sfn|Petrosian|2006|pp=143–144}} and numerous church leaders have also affirmed that they belong to the same ethnic group, albeit to different Christian denominations.{{sfn|Salem|2020}} | |||
{{Blockquote|text=I have made indices of my ''Assyrie chretienne'', and have had to align some 50 pages of proper names of people; there is not a single writer who has an 'Assyrian' name.' Wilmshurst comments, 'The names of thousands of Assyrian and Chaldean Catholic bishops, priests, deacons and scribes between the third and nineteenth centuries are known, and there is not a Sennacherib or Ashurbanipal among them.{{sfn|Fiey|1965|p=146-148}}{{sfn|Joseph|1998|p=70-76}}{{sfn|Wilmshurst|2011|p=415}}}} | |||
== Other forms of continuity == | |||
Defenders of the continuity hypothesis have argued that it is usual and common for peoples to adopt biblical names after undergoing ], particularly as names such as "Sennacherib" and "Ashurbanipal" have clearly pagan connotations, and thus unlikely to be used by Christian priests.{{citation needed|date=January 2017}} Fred Aprim has claimed that distinct Assyrian names continued in an unbroken line from ancient times to the present, giving examples of Assyrian personal names used as late as 238 AD.<ref></ref> Among names attested for pagan individuals at Assur in the 3rd century AD were Aramean names clearly deriving from ancient Assyrian ones, such as ''Qib-Assor'' and ''Assor-heden'' (a version of the ancient name ]).<ref>{{Cite journal|last=Livingstone|first=Alasdair|date=2009|title=Remembrance at Assur: The Case of the dated Aramaic memorials|url=https://journal.fi/store/article/view/52458|journal=Studia Orientalia Electronica|volume=106|pages=151–157}}</ref> Fiey's claim that no ancient names continued to be used in the Christian period is demonstrably incorrect. A bishop referred to as ''Bukthanaṣar'' in Arabic sources is for instance attested at ] in the 13th century. The name ''Bukthanaṣar'' clearly derives from the name ].<ref>{{cite book|last=Jackson|first=Cailah|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=LngxEAAAQBAJ|title=Islamic Manuscripts of Late Medieval Rum, 1270s-1370s: Production, Patronage and the Arts of the Book|publisher=Edinburgh University Press|year=2020|isbn=978-1474451505|location=Edinburgh}} Chapter 1.</ref> | |||
] (ancient Arbela), today the ''de facto'' capital of the autonomous ] in Iraq, has been continuously inhabited since the days of the ]]] | |||
In addition to continuity in self-designation and self-perception, there continued to be important continuities between ancient and contemporary Mesopotamia in terms of religion, literary culture and settlement well after the post-imperial period.{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=208}} Assyrian settlements continued to be occupied into the Christian period. The ancient capital of Nineveh, for instance, became the seat of a bishop, the Bishop of Nineveh, and a church (later converted to a mosque under Islamic rule) was built on top of the ruins of an ancient Assyrian palace. The main population center in the city gradually shifted to the opposite bank of the river, which became the city today known as Mosul; ancient Nineveh only gradually fell into ruin and eventually became open countryside.{{Sfn|Reade|2018|p=286}} Though most of the old population centers were similarly gradually abandoned and fell into ruin some also endured. The ancient city of Arbela, today known as ], has been continuously inhabited since the time of the Neo-Assyrian Empire.{{Sfn|Trolle Larsen|2017|p=584}} Although the ancient Mesopotamian pantheon ceased to be worshipped at Assur with the city's destruction in the 3rd century AD, it persisted at other localities, despite the overwhelming conversion of the region to Christianity, for much longer; the old faith persisted at ] until at least the 10th century and at ] until as late as the 18th century.{{Sfn|Parpola|2004|p=21}} | |||
Names clearly reminiscent of those used by Assyrians in the Neo-Assyrian Empire continued to be used at Assur throughout the post-imperial period, at least until the 3rd century AD.{{Sfn|Livingstone|2009|p=154}} Though some opponents to Assyrian continuity, such as David Wilmshurst, have claimed that Assyrian names ceased being used in the Christian period and that this in turn was evidence of a lack of continuity,{{Sfn|Wilmshurst|2011|p=415}} ancient names were not wholly abandoned. Arabic-language records from 13th-century ] for instance record a man by the name Nebuchadnezzar (rendered ''Bukthanaṣar'' in the Arabic text), a relative of a Patriarch of the Syriac Orthodox Church named ] (also a name with ancient Assyrian connections, deriving either from Nimrud or Nimrod).{{sfn|Jackson|2020|loc=Chapter 1}} Modern Assyrian authors, such as Odisho Malko Gewargis, contend that a decrease in ancient pagan names invoking gods such as Ashur, ] and Sîn is hardly surprising given the Christianization of the Assyrians; similar cases of native names being increasingly replaced by Biblically-derived names are also known from numerous other Christianized peoples.{{Sfn|Gewargis|2002|p=89}} | |||
Similarly, Odisho Gewargis explained the general scarcity of autochthonous personal names as a process taking place only after Christianisation, when peoples generally replace native names with biblical names; giving as an example of this the scarcity of traditional English names such as "Wolfstan," "Redwald," "Aethelred," "Offa" and "Wystan" among modern Englishmen, compared to the commonality of non-English biblical names such as "John," "Mark," "David," "Paul," "Thomas," "Daniel," 'Michael," "Matthew," "Benjamin," "Elizabeth," "Mary," "Joanne," "Josephine," "Paula," "Rebecca," "Simone," "Ruth" etc. Gewargis also noted: "If the children of Sennacherib were, for centuries, taught to pray and damn Babylon and Assyria, how does the researcher expect from people who wholeheartedly accepted the Christian faith to name their children Ashur and Esarhaddon?"{{sfn|Gewargis|2002|p=89}} In response, John Joseph strongly criticizes this argument as contradictory with Gewargis's other arguments: | |||
] | |||
Though modern Assyrian languages, most prominently the ], are ] with little resemblance to the old Akkadian language,{{sfn|Luukko|Van Buylaere|2017|p=314}} they are not wholly without Akkadian influence. Most notably there are several examples of Akkadian loanwords in both ancient and modern Aramaic languages. The ], an Aramaic dialect today mainly used ], has at least fourteen exclusive (i.e. not attested in other dialects) loanwords from Akkadian, including nine of which are clearly from the ancient Assyrian dialect (six of which are architectural or topographical terms).{{sfn|Kaufman|1974|p=164}} | |||
== Academia and politics == | |||
{{Blockquote|text="Contradicting himself, Mr. Gewargis notes that centuries ago, monks and ecclesiastics of the Eastern churches had 'great praise and exaltation for the Assyrians and their kings, their clergy and their judges and obvious downgrading of the prophets, clergy, kings and the elders of Israel. Thus one can say,' he concludes, that Sabhrisho, and monk Yaqqira and patriarch Ishoyabh 'were Assyrians filled with national pride.' We have here an unusual situation: 1. The Church fathers proudly calling themselves 'Aturaye'; 2. The common people, members of the church, for centuries calling themselves 'Suryaye'; 3. And Mr. Gewargis, an Aramaic-language expert who won't tell us the difference between these two Aramaic words, Aturaye and Suryaye."{{sfn|Joseph|2003|p=}}}} | |||
The use of the Assyrian name by modern Assyrians has historically led to controversy and misunderstanding, not only within but also outside the Assyrian community.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=599}} Discussions on the connection between the modern and ancient Assyrians have also entered into academia.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=599}} In addition to support by prominent historical Assyriologists, such as Austen Henry Layard{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=602}} and Sidney Smith,{{Sfn|Smith|1926|p=69}} Assyrian continuity enjoys wide support within contemporary Assyriology. Among proponents of continuity are prominent Assyriologists such as ],{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=599}}{{Sfn|Parpola|2004|p=5–22}} ],{{Sfn|Biggs|2005|loc=p. 10: "Especially in view of the very early establishment of Christianity in Assyria and its continuity to the present and the continuity of the population, I think there is every likelihood that ancient Assyrians are among the ancestors of modern Assyrians of the area"}} ],{{sfn|Saggs|1984|loc=p. 290: "The destruction of the Assyrian Empire did not wipe out its population. They were predominantly peasant farmers, and since Assyria contains some of the best wheat land in the Near East, descendants of the Assyrian peasants would, as opportunity permitted, build new villages over the old cities and carried on with agricultural life, remembering traditions of the former cities. After seven or eight centuries and after various vicissitudes, these people became Christians. These Christians, and the Jewish communities scattered amongst them, not only kept alive the memory of their Assyrian predecessors but also combined them with traditions from the Bible"}} ],{{Sfn|Roux|1992|pp=276–277, 419–420}} J. A. Brinkman<ref> "There is no reason to believe that there would be no racial or cultural continuity in Assyria since there is no evidence that the population of Assyria was removed".</ref> and Mirko Novák.{{sfn|Novák|2016|p=132}} Historians of other fields have also supported Assyrian continuity, such as ],{{Sfn|Frye|1999|pp=69–70}} ],{{Sfn|Hitti|1951|p=519}} ],{{Sfn|Crone|Cook|1977|p=55}} ],{{Sfn|Crone|Cook|1977|p=55}} ]{{Sfn|Nisan|2002|p=181}} and Joshua J. Mark (contributor of the ]).{{Sfn|Mark|2018|loc="there are still Assyrians living in the regions of Iran and northern Iraq, and elsewhere, in the present day"}} Other scholars supporting continuity include, among others, the linguist ],{{Sfn|Segal|1970|pp=47, 51, 68–70}} the political scientist ],{{sfn|Jupp|2001|loc=p. 174: "The Assyrians are the descendants of the once mighty Assyrian nation which inhabited the northern part of the country known as Iraq", "The Assyrians, who were Christians, managed to survive in the lands of their forefathers until the outbreak of the First World War"}} the genocide researcher Hannibal Travis,{{sfn|Travis|2010|pp=148–151}}{{sfn|Travis|2010|p=|loc=p. 148: "Although some authors doubt that Assyrian people could have survived from 600 BCE to the nineteenth century, many of the factors that justify recognizing Armenians, Jews, or other groups as continuously existing since ancient times also apply to the Assyrians, namely common patterns of worship, consistent self-identification, and genetic continuity"}} and the geneticists ], Paolo Menozzi, ],{{Sfn|Cavalli-Sforza|Menozzi|Piazza|5=1994|loc=p. 218: "They are Christian and are possibly ] descendants of their ancient namesakes"}} Mohammad Taghi Akbari, Sunder S. Papiha, Derek Frank Roberts and Dariush Farhud.{{Sfn|Akbari|Papiha|Roberts|Farhud|1986|loc=p. 85: "The Assyrians are a group of Christians, also known as Nestorians, with a long history in the Middle East. From historical and archeological evidence, it is thought that their ancestors formed part of the Mesopotamian civilization"}} Numerous scholars who themselves are of Assyrian origin, such as Efrem Yildiz,{{sfn|Yildiz|1999|p=16-19}} Sargon Donabed{{Sfn|Donabed|2019|p=118}} and Odisho Malko Gewargis,{{Sfn|Gewargis|2002|p=89}} have also published ] in support of Assyrian continuity.{{sfn|Yildiz|1999|p=16-19}}{{Sfn|Donabed|2019|p=118}}{{Sfn|Gewargis|2002|p=89}} | |||
Some academics, most notably the historians J.F. Coakley,{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=599}} ], David Wilmshurst and Adam H. Becker, have opposed continuity between modern and ancient Assyrians, typically arguing that modern Assyrian identity only emerged in the middle to late 19th century as a consequence of interactions with foreign missionaries and/or the discovery of ancient Assyrian ruins.{{Sfn|Wilmshurst|2011|pp=413–416}}{{Sfn|Becker|2008|p=396}} Wholesale opposition of Assyrian continuity is not reflected within Assyriology. The Assyriologist Eckart Frahm considers modern Assyrians to be a group of "Arameans" on account of their language, but also the direct cultural heirs of the ancient Assyrians.{{Sfn|Frahm|2017|loc=p. 7: "Many Assyrians adopted the Aramaic language and alphabetic script. After the downfall of the Assyrian state in the late seventh century BCE, cuneiform writing in Assyria came to an end, but key elements of Assyrian culture and religion survived among the Aramaeans. Even today, there are groups of Aramaeans who call themselves Assyrians and consider themselves heirs of the Assyrians of the imperial age"}} ] considers Assyrian continuity to still be a matter of debate, but also opposes the idea that Assyrian identity only emerged in the 19th century, noting that modern Christians in northern Mesopotamia saw themselves as descendants of the ancient Assyrians long before the discovery of ancient sites and visits by foreign missionaries,{{Sfn|Radner|2015|p=7}} as can for instance be gathered from the accounts of Horatio Postgate.{{Sfn|Butts|2017|p=602}} Some opponents to Assyrian continuity, such as Becker, have argued that the rich Christian literature from the Sasanian period connecting with ancient Assyria was simply based on the Bible, rather than actual remembrance of ancient Assyria,{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=208}} despite several figures appearing in the tales, such as Esarhaddon and Sargon II, barely being mentioned in the Bible.{{Efn|Sargon II was for instance due to being mentioned only once in the Bible long forgotten in western scholarship and was only accepted as a real Assyrian king within Assyriology in the 1860s.{{sfn|Holloway|2003|p=71}}}} The texts are also very much a local Assyrian phenomenon, given that the historical accounts presented in them are at odds with those of other historical writings of the Sasanian Empire.{{sfn|Payne|2012|p=215}} | |||
Many Old English personal names, such as Edward and Audrey, remain popular in England.<ref>{{cite web|title=Meaning, origin and history of the name Edward|url=http://www.behindthename.com/name/edward|last=Campbell|first=Mike|website=Behind the Name}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|title=Meaning, origin and history of the name Audrey|url=http://www.behindthename.com/name/audrey|last=Campbell|first=Mike|website=Behind the Name}}</ref> | |||
Modern Assyrians consider opposition to Assyrian continuity to be offensive and associate it with other historical forms of oppression against them. Sargon Donabed, for instance, considers the use of terms such as "Chaldeans", "Syrian", "Syriacs", "Arameans", or more extremely "Arab Christians", "Kurdish Christians" and "Turkish Christians", to be harmful as they add to division and confusion in regard to identity and are "clearly reflective of modern political parlance".{{Sfn|Donabed|2012|p=412}} These views are partly attributable to the actions of the government in ] (1968–2003), which sought to counteract Assyrian demands for autonomy through refusing to recognize Assyrians as a third ethnic minority of the country, instead promoting Assyrians, "Syrians" and Chaldeans as separate peoples, and undercounted Assyrians in censuses; in 1977, it was made impossible to register as Assyrian in the national census and Assyrians were consequently forced to register as Arabs for fear of losing employment and ration cards.{{Sfn|Naby|2006|pp=527–528}} | |||
==Early modern opinions favoring continuity== | |||
Proponents of continuity such as ] point out that as late as the 18th and 19th centuries, the region around Mosul was known as "]" by the native Christian population, which means "Assyria."{{sfn|Dalley|1993|p=134–147}} A number of 19th century ], such as ], the Assyrian archaeologist ] and the Anglican missionary and ] ] supported Assyrian continuity. | |||
Genetic testing of Assyrian populations is a relatively new field of study, but has hitherto supported the notion that Assyrians historically rarely intermarried with surrounding populations.{{sfn|Travis|2010|p=149}} Genetic studies conducted in 2000 and 2008 support Assyrians as genetically distinct from other groups in the Middle East, with high ]; this indicates that the community has historically been relatively closed owing to their religious and cultural traditions, with little intermixture with other groups.{{Sfn|Banoei|Chaleshtori|Sanati|Shariati|2008|p=79}}<!-- This paragraph does not relate directly continuity but it is there since some anti-Assyrian efforts claim that they are just Christianized members of some other group (Arabs/Kurds etc.) --> | |||
Christian missionary ] (d. 1894), who travelled through ] and encountered various groups of indigenous Christians, stated in 1840 that ''Chaldeans'' consider themselves to be descended from ''Assyrians'', but he also recorded that the same ''Chaldeans'' hold that ''Jacobites'' are descended from those ancient ''Syrians'' whose capital city was ]. Referring to ''Chaldean'' views, Southgate stated: | |||
== See also == | |||
{{Blockquote|text="Those of them who profess to have any idea concerning their origin, say, that they are descended from the Assyrians, and the Jacobites from the Syrians, whose chief city was Damascus".{{sfn|Southgate|1840|p=179}}}} | |||
* ] | |||
Rejecting assumptions of ], who claimed (in 1841) that modern ''Nestorians'' and other Christian groups of Mesopotamia are descendants of ancient ] tribes,{{sfn|Grant|1841|p=}} Southgate remarked (in 1842): | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
== Notes == | |||
{{Blockquote|text="The Syrians are remarkably strict in the observance of the Sabbath as a day of rest, and this is one of a multitude of resemblances between them and the Jews. There are some of these resemblances which are more strongly marked among the Syrians than among the Nestorians, and yet the Syrians are undoubtedly descendants of the Assyrians, and not of the Jews".{{sfn|Southgate|1842|p=249}}}} | |||
{{Notelist}} | |||
== References == | |||
Southgate visited Christian communities of the Near East sometime before the ancient Assyrian sites were rediscovered by western archaeologists,{{sfn|Donabed|2012|p=411}} and in 1844 he published additional remarks on local traditions of ancient ancestry: | |||
{{Reflist|20em}} | |||
=== Bibliography === | |||
{{Blockquote|text="At the Armenian village of Arpaout, where I stopped for breakfast, I began to make inquiries for the Syrians. The people informed me that there were about one hundred families of them in the town of Kharpout, and a village inhabited by them on the plain. I observed that the Armenians did not know them under the name which I used, Syriani; but called them Assouri, which struck me the more at the moment from its resemblance to our English name Assyrians, from whom they claim their origin, being sons, as they say, of Assour (Asshur)"{{sfn|Southgate|1844|p=80}}}} | |||
{{refbegin|30em}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Akbari |first=Mohammad Taghi |last2=Papiha |first2=Sunder S. |last3=Roberts |first3=Derek Frank |last4=Farhud |first4=Dariush |date=1986 |title=Genetic differentiation among Iranian Christian communities |url=https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1684716/ |journal=American Journal of Human Genetics |volume=38 |issue=1 |pages=84–98 |pmid=3456196}} | |||
In 1849, British archaeologist ] (d. 1894) noted that among modern inhabitants of the historical region of Assyria there might be those who are descendants of ancient Assyrians: | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Bahrani|first=Zainab|date=2006|title=Race and Ethnicity in Mesopotamian Antiquity|url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/40023594|journal=World Archaeology|volume=38|issue=1|pages=48–59|doi=10.1080/00438240500509843|jstor=40023594|s2cid=144093611}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Banoei |first=Mohammad Mehdi |last2=Chaleshtori |first2=Morteza Hashemzadeh |last3=Sanati |first3=Mohammad Hossein |last4=Shariati |first4=Parvin |last5=Houshmand |first5=Massoud |last6=Majidizadeh |first6=Tayebeh |last7=Soltani |first7=Niloofar Jahangir |last8=Golalipour |first8=Massoud |date=2008 |title=Variation ofDAT1 VNTR Alleles and Genotypes Among Old Ethnic Groups in Mesopotamia to the Oxus Region |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/41465951 |journal=Human Biology |volume=80 |issue=1 |pages=73–81 |jstor=41465951}} | |||
{{Blockquote|text="I have thought that it might not be uninteresting to give such slight sketches of manners and customs, as would convey a knowledge of the condition and history of the present inhabitants of the country, particularly of those who, there is good reason to presume, are descendants of the ancient Assyrians. They are, indeed, as much the remains of Nineveh, and Assyria, as are the rude heaps and ruined palaces."{{sfn|Layard|1849a|p=IX-X}}}} | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Becker |first=Adam H. |title=Antiquity in Antiquity: Jewish and Christian Pasts in the Greco-Roman World |publisher=Mohr Siebeck |year=2008 |isbn=9783161494116 |location=Tübingen |pages=394–415 |chapter=The Ancient Near East in the Late Antique Near East: Syriac Christian Appropriation of the Biblical East |chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=oD2vKMCu_JgC&pg=PA394}} | |||
* {{cite book |last=Becker |first=Adam H. |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=DbTtBgAAQBAJ |title=Revival and Awakening: American Evangelical Missionaries in Iran and the Origins of Assyrian Nationalism |publisher=University of Chicago Press |year=2015 |isbn=978-0226145280 |location=Chicago}} | |||
Elaborating further, Layard also noted that local Christian communities, ''Chaldeans'' and ''Jacobites'', might be the only remaining descendants of ancient Assyrians: | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Bedford |first=Peter R. |title=The Dynamics of Ancient Empires: State Power from Assyria to Byzantium |publisher=Oxford University Press |year=2009 |isbn=978-0-19-537158-1 |editor-last=Morris |editor-first=Ian |location=Oxford |chapter=The Neo-Assyrian Empire |editor-last2=Scheidel |editor-first2=Walter}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Benjamen|first=Alda|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=_IxVEAAAQBAJ|title=Assyrians in Modern Iraq: Negotiating Political and Cultural Space|publisher=Cambridge University Press|year=2022|isbn=978-1108838795|location=Cambridge}} | |||
{{Blockquote|text="A few Chaldaeans and Jacobite Christians, scattered in Mosul and the neighboring villages, or dwelling in the most inaccessible part of the Mountains, their places of refuge from the devastating bands of Tamerlane, are probably the only descendants of that great people which once swayed, from these plains, the half of Asia."{{sfn|Layard|1849a|p=38}}}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Biggs |first=Robert D. |year=2005 |title=My Career in Assyriology and Near Eastern Archaeology |url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v19n1/Biggs-Biography-final.pdf |url-status=dead |journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies |volume=19 |pages=1–23 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080227130515/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v19n1/Biggs-Biography-final.pdf |archive-date=2008-02-27 |number=1}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Butts|first=Aaron Michael|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nhsmDwAAQBAJ|title=A Companion to Assyria|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|year=2017|isbn=978-1118325247|editor=E. Frahm|location=Hoboken|chapter=Assyrian Christians}} | |||
Reflecting on the question of ancient Assyrian heritage in the region, Layard formulated his views on Assyrian continuity: | |||
* {{cite book |last=Cameron |first=Averil |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=59c6PSa5JCAC |title=The Byzantines |publisher=John Wiley and Sons |year=2009 |isbn=978-1-4051-9833-2 |location=Oxford}} | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Cavalli-Sforza |first=Luigi Luca |url=https://books.google.se/books?id=FrwNcwKaUKoC |title=The History and Geography of Human Genes |last2=Menozzi |first2=Paolo |last3=Piazza |first3=Alberto |publisher=Princeton University Press |year=1994 |isbn=0-691-08750-4 |location=Princeton |name-list-style=amp}} | |||
{{Blockquote|text="Still there lingered, in the villages and around the site of the ruined cities, the descendants of those who had formerly possessed the land. They had escaped the devastating sword of the Persians, of the Greeks, and of the Romans. They still spoke the language of their ancestors, and still retained the name of their race."{{sfn|Layard|1849a|p=241}}}} | |||
* {{Cite book |last1=Crone |first1=Patricia |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=Ta08AAAAIAAJ |title=Hagarism: The Making of the Islamic World |last2=Cook |first2=Michael A. |publisher=Cambridge University Press |year=1977 |isbn=9780521211338 |location=Cambridge |author-link1=Patricia Crone |author-link2=Michael Cook (historian)}} | |||
* {{Cite encyclopedia|year=2009|title=Akkadian|encyclopedia=Concise Encyclopedia of Languages of the World|publisher=Elsevier|location=Oxford|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=F2SRqDzB50wC|last=Deutscher|first=G.|isbn=978-0-08-087774-7}} | |||
English priest ], writing in the early 1850s, states that Upper Mesopotamia was known as Assyria/Athura by the Semitic Christian population of the region.<ref>Burgess, Henry. ''The Repentance of Nineveh''. Sampson Low: Son and Co., London, (1853) p.36.</ref> | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Dalley |first=Stephanie |year=1993 |title=Nineveh after 612 BC |url=https://doi.org/10.1524/aofo.1993.20.1.134 |journal=Altorientalische Forschungen |volume=20 |pages=134–147 |doi=10.1524/aofo.1993.20.1.134 |number=1 |s2cid=163383142}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Donabed |first=Sargon |date=2012 |title=Rethinking Nationalism and an Appellative Conundrum: Historiography and Politics in Iraq |url=https://doi.org/10.1080/14608944.2012.733208 |journal=National Identities |volume=14 |issue=4 |pages=407–431 |doi=10.1080/14608944.2012.733208}} | |||
] wrote in 1912, "The ] people, especially the Christians are very proud of their city and the antiquity of its surroundings; the Christians, regard themselves as direct descendants of the great rulers of Assyria."<ref>Soane, E.B. ''To Mesopotamia and Kurdistan in Disguise''. John Murray: London, 1912. p. 92.</ref> | |||
* {{cite book |last=Donabed |first=Sargon |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=taxvDwAAQBAJ |title=Routledge Handbook of Minorities in the Middle East |year=2019 |isbn=978-1138649040 |editor-last=Rowe |editor-first=Paul S. |location=London |chapter=Persistent Perseverence: A Trajectory of Assyrian History in the Modern Age}} | |||
* {{cite book|last=Düring|first=Bleda S.|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=1NLKDwAAQBAJ|title=The Imperialisation of Assyria: An Archaeological Approach|publisher=Cambridge University Press|year=2020|isbn=978-1108478748|location=Cambridge}} | |||
] argued in 1926 that poor communities continued to perpetuate some basic Assyrian identity after the fall of the empire through to the present.{{#tag:ref|"In Achaemenian times there was an Assyrian detachment in the Persian army, but they could only have been a remnant. That remnant persisted through the centuries to the Christian era and beyond, and continued to use in their personal names appellations of their pagan deities. This continuance of an Assyrian tradition is significant for two reasons; the miserable conditions of these late Assyrians is attested to by the excavations at Ashur, and it is clear that they were reduced to extreme poverty by the time of Parthian rule."<ref>S. Smith, "Notes on the Assyrian Tree". ''Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies'' (1926): 69.</ref>|group=Note}} Efrem Yildiz echoes this view also.{{sfn|Yildiz|1999|p=15-30}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Efstathiadou |first=Anna |date=2011 |title=Representing Greekness: French and Greek Lithographs from the Greek War of Independence (1821–1827) and the Greek-Italian War (1940–1941) |url=https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/15136247.pdf |journal=Journal of Modern Greek Studies |volume=29 |issue=2 |pages=191–218 |doi=10.1353/mgs.2011.0023 |s2cid=144506772}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Filoni|first=Fernando|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=Xp8rDwAAQBAJ|title=The Church in Iraq|publisher=The Catholic University of America Press|year=2017|isbn=978-0813229652|location=Washington, D.C.}} | |||
Anglican missionary Rev. ], in his book ''The Assyrians and Their Neighbours'' (1929), writes "The Assyrian stock, still resident in the provinces about the ruins of Nineveh, Mosul, ], and ], and seem to have been left to their own customs in the same way".{{sfn|Wigram|1929|p=}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Frahm|first=Eckart|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nhsmDwAAQBAJ|title=A Companion to Assyria|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|year=2017|isbn=978-1118325247|editor=E. Frahm|location=Hoboken|chapter=Introduction}} | |||
* {{cite book|last=Frahm|first=Eckart|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nhsmDwAAQBAJ|title=A Companion to Assyria|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|year=2017|isbn=978-1118325247|editor=E. Frahm|location=Hoboken|chapter=The Neo-Assyrian Period (ca. 1000–609 BCE)|ref=CITEREFFrahm2017b}} | |||
R. S. Stafford in 1935 describes the Assyrians as descending from the Ancient Assyrians, surviving the various periods of foreign rule intact, and until ] of having worn items of clothing much like the ancient Assyrians.<ref>''The Tragedy of the Assyrians''. Lt. Col. R.S. Stafford D.S.O., M.C.</ref> | |||
* {{cite book|last=Frahm|first=Eckart|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nhsmDwAAQBAJ|title=A Companion to Assyria|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|year=2017|isbn=978-1118325247|editor=E. Frahm|location=Hoboken|chapter=Assyria in the Hebrew Bible|ref=CITEREFFrahm2017c}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Frye |first=Richard N. |author-link=Richard N. Frye |year=1999 |title=Reply to John Joseph |url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v13n1/frye.pdf |journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies |volume=13 |pages=69–70 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200711213743/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v13n1/frye.pdf |archive-date=2020-07-11 |number=1}} | |||
===Modern views=== | |||
* {{Cite book |last1=Gaunt |first1=David |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=F9E9DQAAQBAJ |title=Let Them Not Return: Sayfo – The Genocide Against the Assyrian, Syriac, and Chaldean Christians in the Ottoman Empire |last2=Atto |first2=Naures |last3=Barthoma |first3=Soner O. |publisher=Berghahn |year=2017 |isbn=978-1785334986 |location=New York}} | |||
====Opposition==== | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Gewargis |first=Odisho Malko |year=2002 |title=We Are Assyrians |url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v16n1/WeAreAssyrians.pdf |journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies |volume=16 |pages=77–95 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20030421141243/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v16n1/WeAreAssyrians.pdf |archive-date=2003-04-21 |number=1}} | |||
Some academics, including the Assyrian historian John Joseph, largely reject the modern Assyrian claim of descent from the ancient Assyrians of Mesopotamia, and their succeeding the Sumero-Akkadians and the Babylonians as one continuous civilization.<ref name="refugees"> The rising European missionary presence in the Hakkari region coincided with a number of archeological excavations of the ancient ruins of Nineveh and Babylon, and especially with the discovery of the Nimrud palace of Ashur-nasirpalii in 1848. Missionaries drew on these recent discoveries of pre-Islamic Assyrian greatness to promote the idea of this branch of eastern Christians as direct descendants of this ancient empire. It was during the late nineteenth century that western missionaries also began to popularise the word Assyrian previously the most prominent of a number of mostly religious designations, as a mode of identifying the present-day community with the ancient empires. Originally, this idea may have been suggested by local assistants to the excavations like the Assyrian activist Hormuzd Rassam; certainly it buttressed community ambitions for local autonomy, as well as romantic missionary imaginings of an untouched "original" Christian community.</ref> He criticises modern Assyrian writers who "eager to establish a link between themselves and the ancient Assyrians, conclude that such a link is confirmed whenever they come across a reference to the word Assyrians during the early Christian period, to them it proves that their Christian ancestors always 'remembered' their Assyrian forefathers. Nationalist writers often refer to ]'s statement that he was 'born in the land of the Assyrians,' and note that the Acts of Mar Qardagh trace the martyr's ancestry to Ancient Assyrian kings".<ref>The ancestry of the semi-legendary Mar Qardagh is dubious. (Miller/Joseph)</ref> He claims that while "The name Assyrian was certainly used prior to the nineteenth century . . . was a well known name throughout the centuries and wherever the Bible was held holy, whether in the East or West", due to the Old Testament.{{sfn|Joseph|2003|p=}} However, the terms 'Assyria' and 'Assyrian' were only applied to people living within historical Assyria, and not, for example, to Levantine or Arabian persons or peoples. | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Haider |first=Peter W. |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=KgVD3WL0vAsC |title=The Variety of Local Religious Life in the Near East: In the Hellenistic and Roman Periods |publisher=BRILL |year=2008 |isbn=978-9004167353 |editor-last=Kaizer |editor-first=Ted |location=Leiden |chapter=Tradition and change in the beliefs at Assur, Nineveh and Nisibis between 300 BC and AD 300}} | |||
* {{Cite book |last1=Harper |first1=Prudence O. |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=LSaeT9CloGIC |title=Assyrian Origins: Discoveries at Ashur on the Tigris: Antiquities in the Vorderasiatisches Museum, Berlin |last2=Klengel-Brandt |first2=Evelyn |last3=Aruz |first3=Joan |last4=Benzel |first4=Kim |publisher=Metropolitan Museum of Art |year=1995 |isbn=0-87099-743-2 |location=New York}} | |||
Adam H. Becker, Professor of Classics & Religious Studies at ], disagrees with Assyrian continuity and writes that the special continuity claims "must be understood as a modern invention worthy of the study of a ] or an ] rather than an ancient historian." (Both Anderson and Hobsbawm study the origins of invented traditions in nationalism.) Becker describes Assyrians as "East Syrians" in his writings.{{sfn|Becker|2008|p=396}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Hauser|first=Stefan R.|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nhsmDwAAQBAJ|title=A Companion to Assyria|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|year=2017|isbn=978-1118325247|editor=E. Frahm|location=Hoboken|chapter=Post-Imperial Assyria}} | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Holloway |first=Steven W. |title=Mesopotamia and the Bible |publisher=A&C Black |year=2003 |isbn=978-1-84127-252-8 |editor-last=Chavalas |editor-first=Mark W. |location=Edinburgh |chapter=The Quest for Sargon, Pul and Tiglath-Pileser in the Nineteenth Century |editor-last2=Younger, Jr |editor-first2=K. Lawson |chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=60fmNZQzwjYC&q=Dynasty+of+Tiglath-Pileser&pg=PA68}} | |||
David Wilmshurst, a historian of the Church of the East, believes that Assyrian identity only emerged as a consequence of the earlier archaeological discovery of the ruins of Nineveh in 1845.{{sfn|Wilmshurst|2011|pp=413–416}} Any continuity, he argues, is insignificant, if it exists at all. | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Hitti |first=Philip K. |url=https://archive.org/details/HistoryOfSyria-PhilipK.Hitti/ |title=History of Syria: Including Lebanon and Palestine |publisher=MacMillan |year=1951 |location=London |oclc=5510718}} | |||
* {{cite book |last=Jackson |first=Cailah |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=LngxEAAAQBAJ |title=Islamic Manuscripts of Late Medieval Rum, 1270s-1370s: Production, Patronage and the Arts of the Book |publisher=Edinburgh University Press |year=2020 |isbn=978-1474451505 |location=Edinburgh}} | |||
====Support==== | |||
* {{cite book |last=Jupp |first=James |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=wgoFxfSTfYAC |title=Australian People: An Encyclopedia of the Nation, its People and their Origins |publisher=Cambridge University Press |year=2001 |isbn=0-521-80789-1 |location=Cambridge}} | |||
Another argument is based on the etymology of "Syria." The noted ] ], who supports ethnic continuity from ancient times to the present, argues that the term 'Syrian' originating from 'Assyrian' supports continuity, particularly when applied to the Semites in northern Mesopotamia and its environs. In a response to John Joseph, Frye writes "I do not understand why Joseph and others ignore the evidence of Armenian, Arab and Persian sources in regard to usage with initial a-, including contemporary practice."{{sfn|Frye|1999|p=70}} Historian Robert Rollinger also uses this line of argumentation in support of the notion that "Syria" was derived from "Assyria", pointing to the evidence provided by the newly discovered ].{{sfn|Rollinger|2006a|p=72-82}}{{sfn|Rollinger|2006b|p=283-287}} Joseph was long skeptical about the initial a-theory, using it as a central plank in his argument against continuity, but has since been forced to accept it following the discovery of the Çineköy inscription. | |||
* {{Cite book |last1=Kalimi |first1=Isaac |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=bF_bAgAAQBAJ |title=Sennacherib at the Gates of Jerusalem: Story, History and Historiography |last2=Richardson |first2=Seth |publisher=] |year=2014 |isbn=978-9004265615 |editor-last=Kalimi |editor-first=Isaac |location=Leiden |chapter=Sennacherib at the Gates of Jerusalem: Story, History and Historiography: An Introduction |editor-last2=Richardson |editor-first2=Seth}} | |||
* {{cite book |last=Kaufman |first=Stephen A. |url=https://oi.uchicago.edu/research/publications/as/19-akkadian-influences-aramaic |title=The Akkadian Influences on Aramaic |publisher=University of Chicago Press |year=1974 |isbn=0-226-62281-9 |series=The Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago Assyriological Studies |location=Chicago}} | |||
Prominent Assyriologist ] in his book '']'' points out that the Assyrian population was never wiped out, bred out or deported after the fall of its empire, and that after ] the Assyrians have continued to keep alive their identity and heritage.{{sfn|Saggs|1984|p=290|ps=:"The destruction of the Assyrian Empire did not wipe out its population. They were predominantly peasant farmers, and since Assyria contains some of the best wheat land in the Near East, descendants of the Assyrian peasants would, as opportunity permitted, build new villages over the old cities and carried on with agricultural life, remembering traditions of the former cities. After seven or eight centuries and after various vicissitudes, these people became Christians. These Christians, and the Jewish communities scattered amongst them, not only kept alive the memory of their Assyrian predecessors but also combined them with traditions from the Bible."}} However, Saggs disputes an extreme "racial purity"; he points out that even at its mightiest, Assyria deported populations of ], ]ites, ], ], ] and others into Assyria, and that these peoples became "Assyrianised" and were absorbed into the native population. | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Kuhrt |first=Amélie |date=1995 |title=The Assyrian heartland in the Achaemenid period |url=https://www.persee.fr/doc/palla_0031-0387_1995_num_43_1_1372 |journal=Pallas. Revue d'études antiques |volume=43 |pages=239–254 |jstor=43660582}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Livingstone |first=Alasdair |date=2009 |title=Remembrance at Assur: The Case of the dated Aramaic memorials |url=https://journal.fi/store/article/view/52458 |journal=Studia Orientalia Electronica |volume=106 |pages=151–157}} | |||
Assyriologist John A. Brinkman argues that there is absolutely no historical or archaeological evidence or proof to suggest the population of Assyria was wiped out, bred out of existence or removed at any time following the destruction of its empire. He puts the burden of proof upon those arguing against continuity to prove their case with strong evidence. Brinkman goes on to mention that the gods of the Assyrian Pantheon were certainly still being worshiped even 900 years after the fall of the Assyrian Empire. He also indicated that ] and Calah, among other cities, were prosperous and still occupied by Assyrians, which he claims indicates a continuity of Assyrian identity and culture well into the Syriac Christian period.<ref> - Quote from a lecture held in 1999 by historian John A. Brinkman: "There is no reason to believe that there would be no racial or cultural continuity in Assyria since there is no evidence that the population of Assyria was removed."</ref>{{sfn|Al-Jeloo|1999|p=}}{{sfn|Yildiz|1999|p=22}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last1=Luukko|first1=Mikko|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nhsmDwAAQBAJ|title=A Companion to Assyria|last2=Van Buylaere|first2=Greta|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|year=2017|isbn=978-1118325247|editor=E. Frahm|location=Hoboken|chapter=Languages and Writing Systems in Assyria}} | |||
* {{Cite web |last=Joshua J. |first=Mark |date=2018 |title=Assyria |url=https://www.worldhistory.org/assyria/ |access-date=27 February 2022 |website=]}} | |||
British archeologist John Curtis disputed assumptions based on non historical biblical interpretations that Assyria became an uninhabited wasteland after its fall, pointing out its wealth and influence during the various periods of Persian rule.{{sfn|Curtis|2003|p=157-167}}{{sfn|Curtis|2005|p=175-195}} Modern archeological finds in the Assyrian heartland have indicated that ] was a prosperous region.{{sfn|Kuhrt|1995|p=239-254}} Assyrians soldiers were a remnant of Achaemenid armies, holding important civic positions, with their agriculture providing a ] for the empire. Imperial Aramaic and Assyrian administrative practices were also retained by the Achaemenid kings. In addition, it is known that a number of important Assyrian cities such as ], ] and ] survived intact, and others, such as ] and ], recovered from their previous destruction. For those cities that remained devastated, such as Nineveh and Calah, smaller towns were built nearby, such as Mepsila.<ref>Printed in ''Nabu Magazine'', Vol. 3, Issue 1 (1997).</ref> | |||
* {{cite book|last=Michel|first=Cécile|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nhsmDwAAQBAJ|title=A Companion to Assyria|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|year=2017|isbn=978-1118325247|editor=E. Frahm|location=Hoboken|chapter=Economy, Society, and Daily Life in the Old Assyrian Period}} | |||
* {{cite book |last=Minov |first=Sergey |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=9AsOEAAAQBAJ |title=Memory and Identity in the Syriac ''Cave of Treasures'': Rewriting the Bible in Sasanian Iran |publisher=BRILL |year=2020 |isbn=978-9004445505 |location=Leiden}} | |||
French Assyriologist ] notes that Assyrian culture and national religion were alive into the 3rd and 4th centuries AD, with the city of Assur possibly being independent for some time in the 3rd century AD, and that the Neo-Assyrian kingdom of Adiabene was a virtual resurrection of Assyria, but emphasises that "the revived settlements had very little in common architecturally with their earlier precursors."<ref name="Roux">George Roux. '' Iraq''.</ref> Roux also states that, "After the fall of Assyria, however, its actual name was gradually changed to 'Syria'; thus, in the Babylonian version of Darius I inscriptions, Eber-nari ("across-the-river," i.e. Syria, Palestine and Phoenicia) corresponds to the Persian and Elamite Athura (Assyria); besides, in the Behistun inscription, Izalla, the region of Syria renowned for its wine, is assigned to Athura."{{citation needed|date=April 2021}} Roux, as well as Saggs, note that a time came when Akkadian inscriptions were meaningless to the inhabitants of Assyria, and ceased to be spoken by the common people.<ref>''Ancient Iraq'' (1992 edition), pp.411–412, 419–420, 423–424</ref>{{sfn|Saggs|1984|p=125}}<ref>Toynbee, ''A Study of History'' (1954), viii, pp. 440–442</ref> | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Morrison |first=Susannah |date=2018 |title="A Kindred Sigh for Thee": British Responses to the Greek War for Independence |url=https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/thetean/vol47/iss1/5 |journal=The Thetean: A Student Journal for Scholarly Historical Writing |volume=47 |issue=1 |pages=37–55}} | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Naby |first=Eden |title=]: An Overview of Nationalisms in State-Endowed and Statless Nations, Volume II: the World |publisher=School of Humanities and Journalism |year=2006 |isbn=83-87653-46-2 |editor-last=Burszta |editor-first=Wojciech J. |location=Bygoszcz |chapter=Assyrian Nationalism in Iraq: Survival under Religious and Ethnic Threat |editor-last2=Kamusella |editor-first2=Tomasz |editor-last3=Wojchiechowski |editor-first3=Sebastian |name-list-style=amp}} | |||
The historian ] states also that Assyrians and their culture were still extant well into the Christian period.<ref>''Cambridge Ancient History: The Roman Republic, 133–44 B.C.''</ref><ref>W. W. Tarn; Cambridge University Press; 1985; pp 597.</ref> | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Nisan |first=Mordechai |url=https://books.google.se/books?id=9UmnCgAAQBAJ |title=Minorities in the Middle East: A History of Struggle and Self-Expression |publisher=McFarland |year=2002 |isbn=978-0-7864-1375-1 |edition=2nd |location=Jefferson}} | |||
* {{cite book|last=Novák|first=Mirko|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=WBrfDQAAQBAJ|title=Assyria to Iberia: Art and Culture in the Iron Age|publisher=Metropolitan Museum of Art|year=2016|isbn=978-1588396068|editor-last=Aruz|editor-first=Joan|location=New York|chapter=Assyrians and Arameans: Modes of Cohabitation and Acculuration at Guzana (Tell Halaf)|editor-last2=Seymour|editor-first2=Michael}} | |||
] and ] state that Assyrian consciousness did not die out after the fall of its empire, asserting that a major revival of Assyrian consciousness and culture took place between the 2nd century BC and 4th century AD.<ref>{{harvnb|Crone|Cook|1977|p=55}}</ref> | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Parpola |first=Simo |date=1999 |title=Assyrians after Assyria |url=http://www.nineveh.com/Assyrians%20after%20Assyria.html |journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies |volume=13 |issue=2}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Parpola|first=Simo|date=2004|title=National and Ethnic Identity in the Neo-Assyrian Empire and Assyrian Identity in Post-Empire Times|url=http://media.hujada.nu/2019/03/Parpola-identity_Article_-Final1.pdf|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|volume=18|issue=2|pages=5–22}} | |||
Some supporters of Assyrian continuity, though not all, argue that Assyrian culture as well as ethnicity is continuous from ancient times until today. The Assyriologist ] echoes Saggs, Brinkman and Biggs, saying that there is strong evidence that Assyrian identity and culture continued after the fall of the Assyrian Empire.{{sfn|Parpola|2000|p=1–16}}{{sfn|Parpola|2004|p=5-22}} Parpola asserts that traditional Assyrian religion remained strong until the 3rd and 4th centuries AD, surviving among small communities of Assyrians up to at least the 10th century AD in Upper Mesopotamia, and as late as the 18th century AD in ], based on accounts of ].<ref name="nineveh.com">{{cite web|url=http://www.nineveh.com/parpola_eng.pdf |title=Assyrian Identity In Ancient Times And Today' |access-date=2018-06-16}}</ref> Parpola asserts that the Neo-Assyrian Upper Mesopotamian kingdoms of Adiabene, Assur, Osrhoene, ], ] and to some degree ] which existed between the 1st century BC and 5th century AD in Assyria, were distinctly Assyrian linguistically, as they wrote in the Syriac language, a dialect of Aramaic which began in geographic Assyria . | |||
* {{cite book |last=Payne |first=Richard |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=KteqCwAAQBAJ |title=Visions of Community in the Post-Roman World: The West, Byzantium and the Islamic World, 300–1100 |publisher=Ashgate Publishing |year=2012 |isbn=978-1409427094 |editor-last=Pohl |editor-first=Walter |location=Farnham |chapter=Avoiding Ethnicity: Uses of the Ancient Past in Late Sasanian Northern Mesopotamia |editor-last2=Gantner |editor-first2=Clemens |editor-last3=Payne |editor-first3=Richard}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Petrosian |first=Vahram |date=2006 |title=Assyrians in Iraq |url=https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Assyrians-in-Iraq-Petrosian/b75f4fe51842f350501a17422dbceda82f7beea7 |journal=Iran and the Caucasus |volume=10 |issue=1 |pages=138 |doi=10.1163/157338406777979322 |s2cid=154905506}} | |||
Similarly, British linguist ] pointed to several historical sources from the period of ], containing references to contemporary ''Assyrians'' in various regions, from ] to ]. He noted that Assyrian designations were used by ], and ] in his work "'']''", and also by Christian authors in the later "'']''".{{sfn|Segal|1970|p=47, 51, 68-70}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Radner|first=Karen|title=Ancient Assyria: A Very Short Introduction|publisher=Oxford University Press|year=2015|isbn=978-0198715900|location=Oxford}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Radner|first=Karen|title=Multilingualism in Ancient Contexts: Perspectives from Ancient Near Eastern and Early Christian Contexts|publisher=African Sun Media|year=2021|isbn=978-1991201164|editor-last=Jonker|editor-first=Louis C.|location=Stellenbosch|chapter=Diglossia and the Neo-Assyrian Empire’s Akkadian and Aramaic Text Production|editor-last2=Berlejung|editor-first2=Angelika|editor-last3=Cornelius|editor-first3=Izak|name-list-style=amp}} | |||
] supports genealogical/ethnic continuity without prejudicing cultural continuity, asserting that the modern Assyrians are likely ''ethnic'' descendants of ancient Assyrians but became largely ''culturally'' different from them with the advent of ].{{sfn|Biggs|2005|p=10|ps=:"Especially in view of the very early establishment of Christianity in Assyria and its continuity to the present and the continuity of the population, I think there is every likelihood that ancient Assyrians are among the ancestors of modern Assyrians of the area."}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Reade |first=Julian E. |year=1998 |title=Greco-Parthian Nineveh |url=http://www.jstor.org/stable/4200453 |journal=Iraq |volume=60 |pages=65–83 |doi=10.2307/4200453 |jstor=4200453}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Reade|first=Julian Edgeworth|title=I am Ashurbanipal, king of the World, king of Assyria|publisher=Thames & Hudson|year=2018|isbn=978-0-500-48039-7|editor-last=Brereton|editor-first=Gareth|location=London|chapter=Nineveh Rediscovered}} | |||
British writer ] in an article in '']'' of 2017 clearly links the modern Assyrians to the ancient Assyrians, stating that they are the Christianised ancestors of the ancient Assyrians.<ref>{{cite news|url=https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/islamic-state/11452080/Islamic-States-thugs-are-trying-to-wipe-an-entire-civilisation-from-the-face-of-the-earth.html|title=Islamic State's thugs are trying to wipe an entire civilisation from the face of the earth|first=Tom|last=Holland|date=5 March 2015|work=The Telegraph}}</ref> | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Rollinger|first=Robert|date=2006|title=The Terms "Assyria" and "Syria" Again|url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/511103|journal=Journal of Near Eastern Studies|volume=65|issue=4|pages=283–287|doi=10.1086/511103|jstor=10.1086/511103|s2cid=162760021}} | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Roux |first=Georges |title=Ancient Iraq |publisher=Penguin Books |year=1992 |isbn=978-0140125238}} | |||
] states that "Syrian", "Syriac Christian" and "Nestorian" are simply vague generic terms encompassing a number of different peoples, and that the Semitic Christians of northern Mesopotamia are historically and ethnically most appropriately described as "Assyrians."<ref>Hitti, Philip Khuri (1957). History of Syria, including Lebanon and Palestine. Macmillan; St. Martin's P.: London, New York.</ref> | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Saggs |first=Henry W. F. |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=8MNJGwAACAAJ |title=The Might That Was Assyria |publisher=Sidgwick & Jackson |year=1984 |isbn=9780312035112 |location=London}} | |||
* {{cite news |last=Salem |first=Chris |date=24 December 2020 |title=A Name Chaldeans Forgot: Assyria |work=Medium |url=https://medium.com/@chrissalem/a-name-chaldeans-forgot-assyria-bea23450fa40 |access-date=6 January 2022}} | |||
] asserts that Assyrians have survived as an ethnic, linguistic, religious and political minority from the fall of the Assyrian Empire through to the present day. He points out that maintaining a language, religion, identity and customs distinct from their neighbours has aided their survival.<ref>Based on interviews with community informants, this paper explores socialization for ingroup identity and endogamy among Assyrians in the United States. The Assyrians descent from the population of ancient Assyria (founded in the 24th century BC), and have lived as a linguistic, political, religious, and ethnic minority in Iraq, Iran, Syria and Turkey since the fall of the Assyrian Empire in 608 BC. Practices that maintain ethnic and cultural continuity in the Near East, the United States and elsewhere include language and residential patterns, ethnically based Christian churches characterised by unique holidays and rites, and culturally specific practices related to life-cycle events and food preparation. The interviews probe parental attitudes and practices related to ethnic identity and encouragement of endogamy. Results are being analyzed.</ref><ref>MacDonald, Kevin (2004-07-29). "Socialization for Ingroup Identity among Assyrians in the United States". Paper presented at a symposium on socialization for ingroup identity at the meetings of the International Society for Human Ethology, Ghent, Belgium.</ref> | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Segal |first=Judah B. |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=LziFAAAAIAAJ |title=Edessa: The Blessed City |publisher=Clarendon Press |year=1970 |isbn=978-0-19-821545-5 |location=Oxford |author-link=Judah B. Segal}} | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Shehadeh |first=Lamia Rustum |url=https://books.google.se/books?id=nr9Ivt-pc0IC |title=The Origins of Syrian Nationhood: Histories, pioneers and identity |publisher=Routledge |year=2011 |isbn=978-0-415-61504-4 |editor-last=Beshara |editor-first=Adel |location=Oxford |chapter=The name of Syria in ancient and modern usage}} | |||
], himself an Assyrian writer, also espouses a continuity from the fall of the Assyrian Empire, through the period of Christianisation and into modern times.{{citation needed|date=June 2019}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Smith |first=Sidney |date=1926 |title=Notes on "The Assyrian Tree" |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/607403 |journal=Bulletin of the School of Oriental Studies, University of London |volume=4 |pages=69–76 |jstor=607403}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Tamari|first=Steve|title=Grounded Identities: Territory and Belonging in the Medieval and Early Modern Middle East and Mediterranean|publisher=BRILL|year=2019|isbn=978-9004385337|editor-last=Tamari|editor-first=Steve|location=Leiden|chapter=The Land of Syria in the Late Seventeenth Century: ʿAbd al-Ghani al-Nabulusi and Linking City and Countryside through Study, Travel, and Worship|chapter-url=https://brill.com/view/book/edcoll/9789004385337/BP000006.xml}} | |||
George V. Yana asserts that the Assyrians continue to exist to this day, and shared their culture with Aramaic-speaking populations.{{sfn|Yana|2008|p=111}} | |||
* {{cite book |last=Travis |first=Hannibal |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=kd8lAQAAMAAJ |title=Genocide in the Middle East: The Ottoman Empire, Iraq, and Sudan |publisher=Carolina Academic Press |year=2010 |isbn=978-1594604362 |location=Durham}} | |||
* {{cite book |last=Trolle Larsen |first=Mogens |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nhsmDwAAQBAJ |title=A Companion to Assyria |publisher=John Wiley & Sons |year=2017 |isbn=978-1118325247 |editor=E. Frahm |location=Hoboken |chapter=The Archaeological Exploration of Assyria}} | |||
Professor Joshua J. Mark supports a continuity, stating in the ], "Assyrian history continued on past that point (the fall of its empire); there are still Assyrians living in the regions of Iran and Iraq, and elsewhere, in the present day."<ref></ref> | |||
* {{Cite book |last=Wilmshurst |first=David |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=zfxNtwAACAAJ |title=The martyred Church: A History of the Church of the East |publisher=East & West Publishing Limited |year=2011 |isbn=9781907318047 |location=London}} | |||
* {{Cite journal |last=Yildiz |first=Efrem |year=1999 |title=The Assyrians: A Historical and Current Reality |url=https://www.academia.edu/22095031 |journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies |volume=13 |pages=15–30 |number=1}} | |||
French film maker Robert Alaux produced a documentary film about the Assyrian Christians in 2004, and states they are descendants of the Ancient Assyrians-Mesopotamians, and were among the very earliest people to convert to Christianity.<ref>{{Cite web | url=http://www.africine.org/?menu=film&no=12854 |title = Africiné}}</ref> | |||
===Differences between Assyrians and neighbouring peoples=== | |||
] differentiates between Levantine Aramaean and Mesopotamian ]n populations, stating that; "even if 'Syrian' were derived from 'Assyrian', it does not mean that the people and culture of ''geographical Syria'' are identical to those of ''geographical Assyria''".{{sfn|Heinrichs|1993|p=106-107}} | |||
The ] (]) recognises Assyrians as ] of northern Iraq.<ref>{{Cite web|title=UNPO: Assyria|url=https://unpo.org/members/7859|date=2018-01-19|website=]|access-date=2020-05-14|quote=Assyrians are one of the indigenous populations of modern-day Iraq.}}</ref> | |||
===Genetic continuity=== | |||
A series of modern ] have shown that the modern Assyrians from northern Iraq, southeastern Turkey, northwestern Iran and northeastern Syria are in a genetic sense one homogenous people, regardless of which church they belong to (e.g. Assyrian Church of the East, Chaldean Catholic, Syriac Orthodox, Assyrian Protestant). Their collective genetic profile differs from neighbouring ], Levantine Syriac ], ]/], Arabs, ], Armenians, ], ], ], Greeks, ], ], ], ], ] and ].<ref name="Elias" /><ref name="M.T. Akbari, Sunder S 1986">M.T. Akbari, Sunder S. Papiha, D.F. Roberts, and Daryoush D. Farhud. "Genetic Differentiation among Iranian Christian Communities". ''American Journal of Human Genetics'' '''38''' (1986): 84–98.</ref><ref name="Cavalli-Sforza" /><ref name="Banoei" /><ref name="Yepiskoposian" /> | |||
Late 20th century ] conducted on Assyrian members of the Assyrian Church of the East, Chaldean Catholic Church and Syriac Orthodox Church by ], Paolo Menozzi and ] "shows that Assyrians have a distinct genetic profile that distinguishes their population from any other population."<ref name="Elias">{{cite web |author=Joel J. Elias |title=The Genetics of Modern Assyrians and their Relationship to Other People of the Middle East |url=http://www.atour.com/health/docs/20000720a.html |date=20 July 2000}}</ref><ref></ref> Genetic analysis of the Assyrians of Persia demonstrated that they were ] with the Muslim ] population and that an individual Assyrian's genetic makeup is relatively close to that of the Assyrian population as a whole.<ref name="M.T. Akbari, Sunder S 1986" /> Cavalli-Sforza et al. state in addition, "he Assyrians are a fairly homogeneous group of people, believed to originate from the land of old Assyria in northern Iraq," and "they are Christians and are probably ] descendants of their namesakes."<ref name="Cavalli-Sforza">], </ref> "The genetic data are compatible with historical data that religion played a major role in maintaining the Assyrian population's separate identity during the Christian era."<ref name="Elias" /> | |||
A 2008 study on the genetics of "old ethnic groups in Mesopotamia," including 340 subjects from seven ethnic communities (Assyrian, Jewish, ], Armenian, Turcoman, Kurdish and Arab peoples of Iran, Iraq, and ]) found that Assyrians were homogeneous with respect to all other ethnic groups sampled in the study, regardless of each Assyrians religious affiliation.{{#tag:ref|"The relationship probability was lowest between Assyrians and other communities. ] was found to be high for this population through determination of the heterogeneity coefficient (+0,6867), Our study supports earlier findings indicating the relatively closed nature of the Assyrian community as a whole, which as a result of their religious and cultural traditions, have had little intermixture with other populations."<ref name="Banoei">{{cite journal |author1=Mohammad Medhi Banoei |author2=Morteza Hashemzadeh Chaleshtori |author3=Mohammad Hossein Sanati |author4=Parvin Shariati |year=2008 |title=Variation of DAT1 VNTR alleles and genotypes among old ethnic groups in Mesopotamia to the Oxus region |journal=] |volume=80 |issue=1 |pages=73–81 |pmid=18505046 |url=http://digitalcommons.wayne.edu/humbiol/vol80/iss1/6 |doi=10.3378/1534-6617(2008)802.0.co;2}}</ref>|group=Note}} | |||
A study by Dr Joel J. Elias found that Assyrians of all denominations were a homogenous group, and genetically distinct from all other Near Eastern ethnicities.<ref name="Elias" /> | |||
In a 2006 study of the ] DNA of six regional populations, including, for comparison, Assyrians and Syrians, researchers found that "the Semitic populations (Assyrians and Syrians) are very distinct from each other according to both axes. This difference supported also by other methods of comparison points out the weak genetic affinity between the two populations with different historical destinies."<ref name="Yepiskoposian">{{cite journal |author1=Levon Yepiskoposian |author2=Ashot Harutyunian |author3=Armine Khudoyan |name-list-style=amp |year=2006 |journal=Iran and the Caucasus |volume=10 |issue=2 |pages=191–208 |title=Genetic testing of language replacement hypothesis in southwest Asia |url=http://www.rau.am/downloads/publ.kafedr/episkoposyan_medbiolog/Yepiskoposian_I&C_06.pdf |doi=10.1163/157338406780345899 |access-date=2021-05-10 |archive-date=2015-10-17 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20151017200047/http://www.rau.am/downloads/publ.kafedr/episkoposyan_medbiolog/Yepiskoposian_I%26C_06.pdf |url-status=dead }}</ref> | |||
In 2008, ] in the ] ran a feature called "Know Your Roots." As part of the feature, ] reporter Nineveh Dinha was tested by GeneTree.com. Her DNA profile was traced back to the region of Harran in southeastern Anatolia in 1400 BC, which was a part of ancient Assyria.<ref>{{Cite news|last=Dinha|first=Nineveh|date=2008-11-16|title=Know Your Roots|work=Fox 13 News|location=Salt Lake City|url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptaT0Rmjzeg|access-date=2020-05-14}}</ref> | |||
In a 2011 study focusing on the genetics of ] in Iraq, researchers identified Y chromosome ]s shared by Marsh Arabs, Arabic-speaking Iraqis, Mandaeans and Assyrians, "supporting a common local background."{{#tag:ref|"In the less frequent J1-M267* clade, only marginally affected by events of expansion, Marsh Arabs shared haplotypes with other Iraqi and Assyrian samples, supporting a common local background."<ref name="BMC Evolutionary Biology">{{cite journal |author1=Nadia Al-Zahery |author2=Maria Pala |author3=Vincenza Battaglia |author4=Viola Grugni |author5=Mohammed A. Hamod |author6=Baharak Hooshiar Kashani |author7=Anna Olivieri |author8=Antonio Torroni |author9=Augusta S. Santachiara-Benerecetti |author10=Ornella Semino |year=2011 |title=In search of the genetic footprints of Sumerians: a survey of Y-chromosome and mtDNA variation in the Marsh Arabs of Iraq |journal=] |volume=11 |page=288 |pmid=21970613 |doi=10.1186/1471-2148-11-288 |pmc=3215667}}</ref>|group=Note}} | |||
A 2017 study of the various ethnic groups of Iraq appeared to show that Assyrians (along with Mandaeans and Yazidis) have a stronger genetic connection to the population extant during the period of ] and ] Mesopotamia than their neighbours, the Arabs, Kurds, Turks, Iranians, Armenians and Turcomans.<ref>{{cite journal |last1=Dogan |first1=Serkan |last2=Gurkan |first2=Cemal |last3=Dogan |first3=Mustafa |last4=Balkaya |first4=Hasan Emin |last5=Tunc |first5=Ramazan |last6=Demirdov |first6=Damla Kanliada |last7=Ameen |first7=Nihad Ahmed |last8=Marjanovic |first8=Damir |title=A glimpse at the intricate mosaic of ethnicities from Mesopotamia: Paternal lineages of the Northern Iraqi Arabs, Kurds, Syriacs, Turkmens and Yazidis |journal=PLOS ONE |date=3 November 2017 |volume=12 |issue=11 |pages=e0187408 |doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0187408 |pmid=29099847 |pmc=5669434 |bibcode=2017PLoSO..1287408D |language=en |issn=1932-6203|doi-access=free }}</ref> | |||
A study by Akbari et al supports the genetic distinctiveness of the Assyrian people in relation to their neighbours, and notes their ancient origins in the region | |||
===Linguistic continuity=== | |||
] | |||
Among ], numbers of fluent speakers range from approximately 600,000 to 1,000,000, with the main dialects being Assyrian Neo-Aramaic (250,000 speakers), ] (216,000 speakers) and ] (112,000 to 450,000 speakers), together with a number of smaller, closely related dialects with no more than 10,000 speakers between them. Contrary to what their names suggest, these mutually intelligible dialects are ''not'' divided upon Assyrian Church of the East/Chaldean Catholic Church/Syriac Orthodox Church/Assyrian Protestant/Syriac Catholic Church lines.<ref>Turoyo at ''Ethnologue'' (17th ed., 2013)</ref>{{#tag:ref|"Based on interviews with community informants, this paper explores socialization for ingroup identity and endogamy among Assyrians in the United States.}} | |||
By the 3rd century AD at the very latest, Akkadian was extinct, although significantly, some loaned vocabulary, grammatical features and family names still survives in the Eastern Aramaic dialects of the Assyrians to this day.{{sfn|Kaufman|1974|p=}} | |||
As linguist ] points out that a number of vocabulary and grammatical features in the colloquial modern neo-Aramaic dialects spoken by the Assyrians shows similarities with the ancient Akkadian language, whereas significantly, the now near extinct ] dialects of the Aramaeans, Phoenicians, Nabataeans, Jews and Levantine Syriacs of Syria and the Levant do not.{{sfn|Khan|2007a|p=110}} This indicates that the Assyrian Eastern Aramaic dialects gradually replaced Akkadian among the Assyrian populace, and that they were both influenced by and overlaid the earlier Assyrian Akkadian tongue of the region, unlike Aramaic dialects spoken in the Levant.{{sfn|Khan|2007b|p=6}} | |||
Similarly, linguists Alda Benjamen and Andrew Breiner also note the Akkadian ( also known as Old Assyrian, Old Babylonian) and Sumerian sub stratum and influences on modern Assyrian dialects that are absent from other dialects of Aramaic and other West Asian languages, and indicates the speakers of these dialects are the same people that once spoke Akkadian . | |||
There are a number of Akkadian words mostly connected with ] that have been preserved in modern Syriac vernaculars. One example is the word ''miššara'' 'rice paddy field' which is a direct descendant of the Akkadian ''mušāru''. A number of words in the dialect of ] (Qaraqosh) shows the same origin, e.g. ''baxšimə'' 'storeroom (for grain)' from Akkadian ''bīt ḫašīmi'' 'storehouse' and ''raxiṣa'' 'pile of straw' from ''raḫīṣu'' 'pile of harvest produce'.{{sfn|Khan|2007b|p=5}} | |||
] asserts that Eastern Aramaic had become so entrenched in Assyrian identity that the Greeks regarded the Imperial Aramaic of the Achaemenid Empire during the 5th and 4th centuries BC as "the Assyrian Language."{{#tag:ref|'The Greek historian ] reports that during the Peloponnesian wars (ca. 410 BC) the Athenians intercepted a Persian who was carrying a message from the Great King to Sparta. The man was taken prisoner, brought to Athens, and the letters he was carrying were translated "from the Assyrian language", which of course was Aramaic…'|group=Note}} During the 3rd century BC composition of the ], a translation of the Hebrew Bible into Greek for the ] ], "Aramaic language" was translated into "Syrian tongue," and "Aramaeans" into "Syrians".{{sfn|Joseph|2000|p=9}} | |||
Parpola's assertions are also supported by professor of Semitic languages ] who states "Those (Aramaic texts) engraved on hard surfaces tend to be formal, but the notes scratched on clay tablets and the few ] reveal more cursive forms. From them descended the standard ] (called 'Assyrian writing' in ]) and eventually both the square ] (also known as 'Assyrian writing' in Hebrew), and through ], the ]."<ref>http://www.bisi.ac.uk/sites/bisi.localhost/files/languages_of_iraq.pdf</ref> | |||
It is believed that all extant forms of Aramaic stem from Imperial Aramaic, which itself originated in Assyria.<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.worldhistory.biz/ancient-history/66454-4-the-spread-of-the-aramaic-language.html|title=The spread of the Aramaic language|date=5 June 2015|website=World history|access-date=2019-12-29}}</ref> | |||
Speaking Aramaic long ago ceased to signify an Aramaean ethnic identity, for the language spread among many previously non-Aramaean and non-Aramaic-speaking peoples in the Near East and Asia Minor from the time of the Neo-Assyrian Empire onwards. Korean orientalist Chul-hyun Bae of ] states "The Arameans' political power thus came to an end; however, their language survived, ironically achieving a far wider presence that the people among whom it had originated".{{sfn|Bae|2004|p=1–20}} | |||
==Political issues== | |||
The Israeli orientalist Mordechai Nisan also supports the view that Assyrians should be named specifically as such in an ethnic and national sense, are the descendants of their ancient namesakes, and are denied self-expression for political, ethnic and religious reasons.{{sfn|Nisan|2002|p=}} | |||
Sargon Donabed notes that Assyrians have been downplayed, denied and under represented in studies on modern Iraq and Turkey due to racial and religious prejudice, and also that the confusion of later religious denominational names applied to them has harmed their cause . | |||
Dr Arian Ishaya, an historian and ] from ] states that the confusion of names applied to the Assyrians, and a denial of Assyrian identity and continuity, is on one hand borne out of 19th and early 20th century ], condescending and arrogant meddling by westerners, rather than by historical fact, and on the other hand by long held ]ic, Arab, Kurdish, Turkish and Iranian policies, whose purpose is to divide the Assyrian people along false lines and deny their singular identity, with the aim of preventing the Assyrians having any chance of unity, self-expression and potential statehood.<ref name="Nineveh">"Intellectual Domination and the Assyrians". ''Nineveh Magazine'', Vol. 6 No. 4 (Fourth Quarter 1983), published in Berkeley, California.</ref> | |||
], a 19th century advocate of ] from the Syriac Orthodox Church community in ], encouraged Assyrians to unite regardless of tribal and theological differences.<ref>"Neo-Assyrianism & the End of the Confounded Identity". Zinda. 2006-07-06. "The fact remains that throughout the last seven years and the last 150 years for that matter the name Assyrian has always been attached to our political ambitions in the Middle East. Any time, any one of us from any of our church and tribal groups targets a political goal we present our case as Assyrians, Chaldean-Assyrians, or Syriac-Assyrians – making a connection to our "Assyrian" heritage. This is because our politics have always been Assyrian. Men like Naum Faiq and David Perley emerging from a "Syriac" or "Jacobite" background understood this as well as our Chaldean heroes, General Agha Petros d-Baz and the late Chaldean Patriarch Mar Raphael BiDawid."</ref> ], an Assyrian Protestant from the same region of southeastern Turkey as Faiq, also espoused Assyrian unity during the early 20th century, stating that the Church of the East, Chaldean Catholic and Syriac Orthodox were one people, divided purely upon religious lines.<ref>''"The hindrance before the advancement of the Assyrian people was not so much the attacks from without as it was from within, the doctrinal and sectarian disputes and struggles, like Monophysitism (One nature of Christ) Dyophysitism (Two natures of Christ) is a good example, these caused division, spiritually, and nationally, among the people who quarreled among themselves even to the point of shedding blood. To this very day the Assyrians are still known by various names, such as Nestorians, Jacobites, Chaldeans"''</ref> ] also advocated Assyrian unity and was a staunch supporter of Assyrian identity and nationalism and the formation of an ancestral ] in the wake of the ].<ref>Aprim, Fred. "Dr. Freidoun Atouraya". essay. Zinda Magazine. Retrieved 2000-02-01. "AD (February 1917) Hakim Freidoun Atouraya, Rabbie Benyamin Arsanis and Dr. Baba Bet-Parhad establish the first Assyrian political party, the Assyrian Socialist Party. Two months later, Kakim Atouraya completes his "Urmia Manifesto of the United Free Assyria" which called for self-government in the regions of Urmia, Mosul, Turabdin, Nisibin, Jezira, and Julamaerk."</ref> ], an influential Syrian-born Assyrian nationalist, deeply criticised the leaders of the various churches followed by the Assyrian people, accusing the Syriac Orthodox Church, Church of the East, Chaldean Catholic Church and Syriac Catholic Church of creating divisions among Assyrians, when their joint ethnic and national identity should be paramount.<ref>Farid Nazha tog vid där Naum Faiq slutade, Hujada.com</ref><ref>2.^ Jump up to: a b c d e f Farid Nazha, Bethnahrin.nl</ref> Assyrian doctor George Habash asserts that the Assyrian people have been denied representation due to a betrayal by ] and by policy of deliberately denying their heritage and rights by Muslim Arab, Turkish, Iranian and Kurdish regimes.<ref>{{cite web|title=What do the Assyrian people want?|url=http://www.aina.org/articles/habash.pdf|last=Habash|first=George|date=1999|website=Assyrian International News Agency|access-date=2020-05-15}}</ref> | |||
===Nestorian designations=== | |||
In ] terminology, both medieval and early modern, it was customary to label the ] as the "Nestorian Church", and its adherents, including Assyrians, as "Nestorians". Kelly L. Ross notes that the oldest western reference to the 'Christians' of Iraq is as "Nestorians," a term used by ] in 525 AD, though she acknowledges that this is a 'doctrinal' term and not an ethnic one. Hannibal Travis, in contrast, argues that "Assyrian" is the oldest name for this community, and that the term long predated Nestorian.<ref name=refugees/> ], Fellow at the Center for Non-Territorial Autonomy at the ], echoes Hannibal Travis in arguing that the confusion of later names applied to the Assyrians were introduced by Western theologians and missionaries, and others arose out of doctrinal rather than ethnic divisions.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://conference.osu.eu/globalization/publ/08-bohac.pdf |title=Summary |website=conference.osu.eu }}</ref><ref name="Hitti, Philip Khuri 1957">Hitti, Philip Khuri (1957). ''History of Syria, including Lebanon and Palestine''. Macmillan; St. Martin's P.: London, New York.</ref>{{sfn|Travis|2010|p=237-277}} | |||
Historian ] states that there was no consensus among English-language sources what term to use for the ethnic group in the early twentieth century; the term "Assyrian" had only been accepted for followers of the Assyrian Church of the East, Syriac Orthodox Church and Chaldean Catholic Church who were extant in Iraq, southeast Turkey, northeast Syria and Northwest Iran Furthermore, since the Ottoman Empire was organized by religion, "''Assyrian'' was never used by the Ottomans; rather, government and military documents referred to their targets by their traditional religious sectarian names".{{sfn|Gaunt|2015|p=86}} | |||
All adherents of the ] and it's offshoot, the ], reject the label of "Nestorian" even in a theological sense, since the ancient Church of the East certainly predates ] by centuries, and is ] distinct. Philip Hitti stated that "Nestorian" is an inaccurate term both chronologically and theologically and has no ethnic meaning as it applied to Christians as far afield as China, Central Asia, India and Greece,<ref name="Hitti, Philip Khuri 1957"/> while ] indicated that Nestorian designations were a lamentable misnomer.{{sfn|Brock|1996|p=23-35}} | |||
===Chaldean identity=== | |||
In recent times, a mainly United States-based minority{{Citation needed|date=May 2020}} within the ] has begun to espouse a separate 'Chaldean' ethnic identity. They assert that they are a different and separate ethnicity compared to modern Assyrians, and are the direct descendants of the ancient ]ns of southern Mesopotamia.{{citation needed|date=June 2020}} As a compromise between the two positions, some have chosen to be referred to by the label 'Chaldo-Assyrian' or 'Assyro-Chaldean'.{{sfn|Coakley|2011a|p=45}} | |||
Chaldean Catholics are members of the largest church that traces its origins from the ].<ref>{{cite book|author1=Orlando O. Espín|author2=James B. Nickoloff|title=An Introductory Dictionary of Theology and Religious Studies|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=k85JKr1OXcQC&pg=PA218|year=2007|publisher=Liturgical Press|isbn=978-0-8146-5856-7|page=218}}</ref> For many centuries, the term "Chaldean" indicated the ]. It was so used by ],{{sfn|Gallagher|2012|p=123-141}} and was still the normal terminology in the nineteenth century.{{sfn|Gesenius|Prideaux-Tregelles|1859|p=}}{{sfn|Fürst|1867|p=}}{{sfn|Davies|1872|p=}} Only in 1445 did it begin to be used to mean Aramaic speakers who had entered ] with the ]. This happened at the ],{{sfn|Coakley|2011b|p=93}} which accepted the profession of faith that Timothy, ] of the Chaldeans in ], made in Aramaic, and which decreed that "nobody shall in future dare to call Chaldeans, Nestorians".<ref></ref>{{sfn|Baum|Winkler|2003|p=112}}{{sfn|O’Mahony|2006|p=526-527}} | |||
Previously, when there were as yet no Catholic Aramaic speakers of Mesopotamian origin, the term "Chaldean" was applied with explicit reference to their "]" religion. Thus Jacques de Vitry wrote of them in 1220/1 that "they denied that Mary was the Mother of God and claimed that Christ existed in two persons. They consecrated leavened bread and used the 'Chaldean' (Syriac) language".{{sfn|Baum|Winkler|2003|p=83}} | |||
In an interview published in 2003 with ], head of the Chaldean Catholic Church between 1989 and 2003, he commented on the ] and distinguished between what is the name of a church and an ethnicity: | |||
{{Blockquote|text=I personally think that these different names serve to add confusion. The original name of our Church was the 'Church of the East' ... When a portion of the Church of the East became Catholic, the name given was 'Chaldean' based on the Magi kings who came from the land of the Chaldean, to Bethlehem. The name 'Chaldean' does not represent an ethnicity... We have to separate what is ethnicity and what is religion... I myself, my sect is Chaldean, but ethnically, I am Assyrian.{{sfn|Parpola|2004|p=22}}}} | |||
Proponents of a Chaldean continuity or separateness from Assyrians sometimes claim that they are separate because they speak Chaldean Neo-Aramaic rather than Assyrian Neo-Aramaic.{{citation needed|date=June 2020}} However, both of these appellations are only 20th-century labels applied by some modern linguists to regions where one church was seen to be more prevalent than another for convenience, with no historical continuity or ethnic context implied in either. They are also inaccurate; many speakers of Chaldean Neo-Aramaic are in fact members of the Assyrian Church of the East, Assyrian Pentecostal, Evangelical Churches or Syriac Orthodox Church,<ref>Nordhoff, Sebastian; Hammarström, Harald; Forkel, Robert; Haspelmath, Martin, eds. (2013). "Northeastern Neo-Aramaic". Glottolog 2.2. Leipzig: Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology.</ref> and equally, many speakers of Assyrian Neo-Aramaic are members of the Chaldean Catholic Church, the Syriac Orthodox Church, the Syriac Catholic Church or other confessions. This is also true of the Surayt/Turoyo dialect, and minority dialects such as ], ], ] and ]. Furthermore, each of these dialects originated in Assyria, evolving from the 8th century BC Imperial Aramaic of the Assyrian Empire and 5th century BC Syriac of Achaemenid Assyria. | |||
==See also== | |||
{{div col|colwidth=30em}} | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
{{div col end}} | |||
==Notes== | |||
{{reflist|group=Note}} | |||
==References== | |||
{{reflist}} | |||
==Sources== | |||
{{refbegin|2}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Ainsworth|first=William F.|author-link=William Francis Ainsworth|title=An Account of a Visit to the Chaldeans, Inhabiting Central Kurdistán; And of an Ascent of the Peak of Rowándiz (Ṭúr Sheïkhíwá) in Summer in 1840|journal=The Journal of the Royal Geographical Society of London|year=1841|volume=11|pages=21–76|doi=10.2307/1797632|jstor=1797632|url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/1797632}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Ainsworth|first=William F.|author-link=William Francis Ainsworth|title=Travels and Researches in Asia Minor, Mesopotamia, Chaldea and Armenia|year=1842a|volume=1|location=London|publisher=John W. Parker|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=-IVxAAAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Ainsworth|first=William F.|author-link=William Francis Ainsworth|title=Travels and Researches in Asia Minor, Mesopotamia, Chaldea and Armenia|year=1842b|volume=2|location=London|publisher=John W. Parker|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=895lAAAAcAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Al-Jeloo|first=Nicholas|title=Who are the Assyrians?|journal=The Assyrian Australian Academic Journal|year=1999|volume=4|url=http://www.nestorian.org/who_are_the_assyrians.html}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Andrade|first=Nathanael J.|title=Syrian Identity in the Greco-Roman World|year=2013|location=Cambridge|publisher=Cambridge University Press|isbn=9781107244566|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=4ROhAQAAQBAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Andrade|first=Nathanael J.|title=Framing the Syrian of Late Antiquity: Engagements with Hellenism|journal=Journal of Modern Hellenism|year=2011|volume=28 |pages=1–46|url=https://journals.sfu.ca/jmh/index.php/jmh/article/download/267/270}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Andrade|first=Nathanael J.|title=Assyrians, Syrians and the Greek Language in the late Hellenistic and Roman Imperial Periods|journal=Journal of Near Eastern Studies|year=2014|volume=73|number=2|pages=299–317|doi=10.1086/677249|jstor=10.1086/677249|s2cid=163755644|url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/677249}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Andrade|first=Nathanael J.|chapter=Syriac and Syrians in the Later Roman Empire: Questions of Identity|title=The Syriac World|year=2019|location=London|publisher=Routledge|pages=157–174|chapter-url=https://www.academia.edu/26842432}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Badger|first=George Percy|author-link=George Percy Badger|title=The Nestorians and Their Rituals|year=1852|volume=1|location=London|publisher=Joseph Masters|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=JOPWPqa0aH8C}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Badger|first=George Percy|author-link=George Percy Badger|title=The Nestorians and Their Rituals|year=1852|volume=2|location=London|publisher=Joseph Masters|isbn=9780790544823|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=cnURAAAAYAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Bae|first=Chul-hyun|title=Aramaic as a Lingua Franca During the Persian Empire (538-333 B.C.E.)|journal=Journal of Universal Language|year=2004|volume=5|pages=1–20|doi=10.22425/jul.2004.5.1.1|url=http://www.sejongjul.org/archive/view_article?pid=jul-5-1-1|doi-access=free}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Bagg|first=Ariel M.|chapter=Assyria and the West: Syria and the Levant|title=A Companion to Assyria|year=2017|location=Hoboken|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|pages=268–274|chapter-url=https://www.academia.edu/42720898}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last1=Baum|first1=Wilhelm|author-link1=Wilhelm Baum (historian)|last2=Winkler|first2=Dietmar W.|title=The Church of the East: A Concise History|year=2003|location=London-New York|publisher=Routledge-Curzon|isbn=9781134430192|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=CnSCAgAAQBAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Baumer|first=Christoph|title=The Church of the East: An Illustrated History of Assyrian Christianity|year=2006|location=London-New York|publisher=Tauris|isbn=9781845111151|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=SQ7ZAAAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Becker|first=Adam H.|chapter=The Ancient Near East in the Late Antique Near East: Syriac Christian Appropriation of the Biblical East|title=Antiquity in Antiquity: Jewish and Christian Pasts in the Greco-Roman World|year=2008|location=Tübingen|publisher=Mohr Siebeck|pages=394–415|isbn=9783161494116|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=oD2vKMCu_JgC&pg=PA394}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Becker|first=Adam H.|title=Revival and Awakening: American Evangelical Missionaries in Iran and the Origins of Assyrian Nationalism|year=2015|location=Chicago|publisher=University of Chicago Press|isbn=9780226145310|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=WEGNBgAAQBAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Biggs|first=Robert D.|author-link=Robert D. Biggs|title=My Career in Assyriology and Near Eastern Archaeology|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=2005|volume=19|number=1|pages=1–23|url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v19n1/Biggs-Biography-final.pdf|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080227130515/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v19n1/Biggs-Biography-final.pdf|url-status=dead|archive-date=2008-02-27}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Brock|first=Sebastian P.|author-link=Sebastian P. Brock|title=The 'Nestorian' Church: A Lamentable Misnomer|journal=Bulletin of the John Rylands Library|year=1996|volume=78|number=3|pages=23–35|doi=10.7227/BJRL.78.3.3|url=https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:1m2396&datastreamId=POST-PEER-REVIEW-PUBLISHERS-DOCUMENT.PDF}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Butts|first=Aaron M.|editor1-first=Eckart|editor1-last=Frahm|chapter=Assyrian Christians|title=A Companion to Assyria|year=2017|location=Malden|publisher=John Wiley & Sons|pages=599–612|doi=10.1002/9781118325216|isbn=9781118325216|chapter-url=https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/9781118325216}} | |||
*{{cite book |authors=], Paolo Menozzi & Alberto Piazza |year=1994 |title=The History and Geography of Human Genes |publisher=] |isbn=9780691087504 |ref=Cavalli-Sforza}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Coakley|first=James F.|title=The Church of the East and the Church of England: A History of the Archbishop of Canterbury's Assyrian Mission|year=1992|location=Oxford|publisher=Clarendon Press|isbn=978-0-19-826744-7|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=UHcKAQAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Coakley|first=James F.|chapter=Assyrians|title=Gorgias Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Syriac Heritage|year=2011a|location=Piscataway, NJ|publisher=Gorgias Press|pages=45|chapter-url=https://gedsh.bethmardutho.org/Assyrians}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Coakley|first=James F.|chapter=Chaldeans|title=Gorgias Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Syriac Heritage|year=2011b|location=Piscataway, NJ|publisher=Gorgias Press|pages=93|chapter-url=https://gedsh.bethmardutho.org/Chaldeans}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last1=Crone|first1=Patricia|author-link1=Patricia Crone|last2=Cook|first2=Michael A.|author-link2=Michael Cook (historian)|title=Hagarism: The Making of the Islamic World|year=1977|location=Cambridge|publisher=Cambridge University Press|isbn=9780521211338|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=Ta08AAAAIAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Curtis|first=John|chapter=The Assyrian Heartland in the Period 612-539 BC|title=Continuity of Empire (?): Assyria, Media, Persia|year=2003|location=Padova|publisher=Editrice e Libreria|pages=157–167|chapter-url=https://www.academia.edu/27264358}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Curtis|first=John|chapter=The Achaemenid Period in Northern Iraq|title=L'Archéologie de l'Empire Achéménide: Nouvelles Recherches|year=2005|location=Paris|publisher=De Boccard|pages=175–195|chapter-url=https://www.academia.edu/20558656}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Dalley|first=Stephanie|title=Nineveh after 612 BC|journal=Altorientalische Forschungen|year=1993|volume=20|number=1|pages=134–147|doi=10.1524/aofo.1993.20.1.134|s2cid=163383142|url=https://doi.org/10.1524/aofo.1993.20.1.134}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last1=Dalley|first1=Stephanie|last2=Reyes|first2=Andres T.|chapter=Mesopotamian Contact and Influence in the Greek World: 1. To the Persian Conquest|title=The Legacy of Mesopotamia|year=1998|location=New York|publisher=Oxford University Press|pages=85–106|isbn=978-0-19-814946-0|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=UhVfijsPxOMC&pg=RA2-PA85}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Davies|first=Benjamin|author-link=Benjamin Davies (Hebraist)|title=A Compendious and Complete Hebrew and Chaldee Lexicon to the Old Testament|year=1872|location=London|publisher=Asher|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=THIOAAAAYAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Donabed|first=Sargon G.|title=Remnants of Heroes: The Assyrian Experience: The Continuity of the Assyrian Heritage from Kharput to New England|year=2003|location=Chicago|publisher=Assyrian Academic Society Press|isbn=9780974445076|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=K39tAAAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Donabed|first=Sargon G.|title=Rethinking Nationalism and an Appellative Conundrum: Historiography and Politics in Iraq|journal=National Identities: Critical Inquiry into Nationhood, Politics & Culture|year=2012|volume=14|number=4|pages=407–431|doi=10.1080/14608944.2012.733208|s2cid=145265726|doi-access=free}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Donabed|first=Sargon G.|title=Reforging a Forgotten History: Iraq and the Assyrians in the Twentieth Century|year=2015|location=Edinburgh|publisher=Edinburgh University Press|isbn=9780748686056|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=bwLdCQAAQBAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Donabed|first=Sargon G.|chapter=Neither Syriac-speaking nor Syrian Orthodox Christians: Harput Assyrians in the United States as a Model for Ethnic Self-Categorization and Expression|title=Syriac in its Multi-Cultural Context|year=2017|location=Leuven|publisher=Peeters Publishers|pages=359–369|isbn=9789042931640|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=sxt4rgEACAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Fiey|first=Jean Maurice|author-link=Jean Maurice Fiey|title=Assyriens ou Araméens?|journal=L'Orient Syrien|year=1965|volume=10|pages=141–160|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ZJEWAAAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Frazee|first=Charles A.|title=Catholics and Sultans: The Church and the Ottoman Empire 1453-1923|year=2006|orig-year=1983|location=Cambridge|publisher=Cambridge University Press|isbn=9780521027007|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=X6DM4szwUpEC}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Frye|first=Richard N.|author-link=Richard N. Frye|title=Assyria and Syria: Synonyms|journal=Journal of Near Eastern Studies|year=1992|volume=51|number=4|pages=281–285|doi=10.1086/373570|jstor=545826|s2cid=161323237|url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/545826}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Frye|first=Richard N.|author-link=Richard N. Frye|title=Assyria and Syria: Synonyms|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=1997|volume=11|number=2|pages=30–36|url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v11n2/frye.pdf|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200713125829/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v11n2/frye.pdf|archive-date=2020-07-13}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Frye|first=Richard N.|author-link=Richard N. Frye|title=Reply to John Joseph|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=1999|volume=13|number=1|pages=69–70|url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v13n1/frye.pdf|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200711213743/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v13n1/frye.pdf|archive-date=2020-07-11}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Frye|first=Richard N.|author-link=Richard N. Frye|chapter=Mapping Assyria|title=Ideologies as Intercultural Phenomena|year=2002|location=Milano|publisher=Università di Bologna|pages=75–78|isbn=9788884831071|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=3LdtAAAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Fürst|first=Julius|author-link=Julius Fürst|title=A Hebrew & Chaldee Lexicon to the Old Testament: With an Introduction Giving a Short History of Hebrew Lexicography|year=1867|location=London|publisher=Williams & Norgate|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ELwsAQAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Gallagher|first=Edmon L.|title=Hebrew Scripture in Patristic Biblical Theory: Canon, Language, Text|year=2012|location=Leiden-Boston|publisher=Brill|isbn=9789004228023|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=aWkyAQAAQBAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Georgis|first=Mariam|chapter=Nation and Identity Construction in Modern Iraq: (Re)Inserting the Assyrians|title=Unsettling Colonial Modernity in Islamicate Contexts|year=2017|location=Newcastle upon Tyne|publisher=Cambridge Scholars Publishing|pages=67–87|isbn=9781443893749|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=WnXXDgAAQBAJ&pg=PA67}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last1=Gesenius|first1=Wilhelm|author-link1=Wilhelm Gesenius|last2=Prideaux-Tregelles|first2=Samuel|author-link2=Samuel Prideaux Tregelles|title=Gesenius's Hebrew and Chaldee Lexicon to the Old Testament Scriptures|year=1859|location=London|publisher=Bagster|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=dOsCrozzTikC}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Gewargis|first=Odisho Malko|title=We Are Assyrians|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=2002|volume=16|number=1|pages=77–95|url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v16n1/WeAreAssyrians.pdf|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20030421141243/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v16n1/WeAreAssyrians.pdf|archive-date=2003-04-21}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Grant|first=Asahel|author-link=Asahel Grant|title=The Nestorians, or the Lost Tribes: Containing Evidence of Their Identity|year=1841|location=London|publisher=John Murray|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=rWFTAAAAcAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Hanish|first=Shak|chapter=Assyrians|title=Native Peoples of the World: An Encyclopedia of Groups, Cultures and Contemporary Issues|year=2015|location=London-New York|publisher=Routledge|pages=517|isbn=9781317464006|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=vf4TBwAAQBAJ&pg=PA517}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Healey|first=John F.|chapter=The Church Across the Border: The Church of the East and its Chaldean Branch|title=Eastern Christianity in the Modern Middle East|year=2010|location=London-New York|publisher=Routledge|pages=41–55|isbn=9781135193713|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=XzOMAgAAQBAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Harrak|first=Amir|title=The Ancient Name of Edessa|journal=Journal of Near Eastern Studies|year=1992|volume=51|issue=3|pages=209–214|doi=10.1086/373553|s2cid=162190342|url=http://www.aramaic-dem.org/English/History/The%20Ancient%20Name%20Of%20Edessa%20Harrak.pdf|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140809084028/http://www.aramaic-dem.org/English/History/The%20Ancient%20Name%20Of%20Edessa%20Harrak.pdf|archive-date=2014-08-09}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Harrak|first=Amir|chapter=Tales about Sennacherib: The Contribution of the Syriac Sources|title=The World of the Aramaeans|volume=3|year=2001|location=Sheffield|publisher=Sheffield Academic Press|pages=168–189|isbn=9780567637376|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=WWyvAwAAQBAJ&pg=PA168}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Harrak|first=Amir|chapter=Ah! The Assyrian is the Rod of My Hand!: Syriac View of History after the Advent of Islam|title=Redefining Christian Identity: Cultural Interaction in the Middle East Since the Rise of Islam|year=2005|location=Leuven|publisher=Peeters Publishers|pages=45–65|isbn=9789042914186|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=u1nM57HD6joC&pg=PA45}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Heinrichs|first=Wolfhart|author-link=Wolfhart Heinrichs|chapter=The Modern Assyrians - Name and Nation|title=Semitica: Serta philologica Constantino Tsereteli dicata|year=1993|location=Torino|publisher=Zamorani|pages=99–114|isbn=9788871580241|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=VMZiAAAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Joseph|first=John B.|author-link=John Joseph (historian)|title=Assyria and Syria: Synonyms?|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=1997|volume=11|number=2|pages=37–43|url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v11n2/JohnJoseph.pdf|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200715002908/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v11n2/JohnJoseph.pdf|archive-date=2020-07-15}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Joseph|first=John B.|author-link=John Joseph (historian)|title=The Bible and the Assyrians: It Kept their Memory Alive|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=1998|volume=12|number=1|pages=70–76|url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v12n1/JohnJoseph.pdf|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200715114112/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v12n1/JohnJoseph.pdf|archive-date=2020-07-15}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Joseph|first=John B.|author-link=John Joseph (historian)|title=The Modern Assyrians of the Middle East: A History of Their Encounter with Western Christian Missions, Archaeologists, and Colonial Powers|year=2000|location=Leiden|publisher=Brill|isbn=9004116419|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=79wj2hj4wKUC}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Joseph|first=John B.|author-link=John Joseph (historian)|title=A Response by John Joseph|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=2003|volume=17|number=1|url=http://insideassyria.com/rkvsf5/wwwboard/msgs/We_are_Assyrians_A_Response_by_John_Joseph-3acl.html}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Kaufman|first=Stephen A.|title=The Akkadian Influences on Aramaic|year=1974|location=Chicago|publisher=University of Chicago Press|isbn=9780226622811|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=lD50vQEACAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Khan|first=Geoffrey|author-link=Geoffrey Khan|chapter=Aramaic in the Medieval and Modern Periods|title=Languages of Iraq: Ancient and Modern|year=2007a|location=Cambridge|publisher=The British School of Archaeology in Iraq|pages=95–114|chapter-url=http://www.bisi.ac.uk/sites/bisi.localhost/files/languages_of_iraq.pdf}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Khan|first=Geoffrey|title=Remarks on the Historical Background of the Modern Assyrian Language|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=2007b|volume=21|issue=2|pages=4–11|url=https://www.academia.edu/37461912}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Khan|first=Geoffrey|author-link=Geoffrey Khan|chapter=The Language of the Modern Assyrians: The North-Eastern Neo-Aramaic Dialect Group|title=The Assyrian Heritage: Threads of Continuity and Influence|year=2012|location=Uppsala|publisher=Uppsala Universitet|pages=173–199|chapter-url=https://www.academia.edu/37462045}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Kuhrt|first=Amélie|title=The Assyrian Heartland in the Achaemenid Period|journal=Pallas: Revue d'études antiques|year=1995|volume=43|pages=239–254|url=https://www.persee.fr/doc/palla_0031-0387_1995_num_43_1_1372}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Layard|first=Austen H.|author-link=Austen Henry Layard|title=Nineveh and its Remains: With an Account of a Visit to the Chaldean Christians of Kurdistan|year=1849a|volume=1|location=London|publisher=John Murray|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=0RXpxc0JWU4C}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Layard|first=Austen H.|author-link=Austen Henry Layard|title=Nineveh and its Remains: With an Account of a Visit to the Chaldean Christians of Kurdistan|year=1849b|volume=2|location=London|publisher=John Murray|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=SxE_WD4OUUQC}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Makko|first=Aryo|title=The Historical Roots of Contemporary Controversies: National Revival and the Assyrian Concept of Unity|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=2010|volume=24|number=1|pages=58–86|url=http://docplayer.net/34418981-The-historical-roots-of-contemporary-controversies-national-revival-and-the-assyrian-concept-of-unity.html}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Makko|first=Aryo|chapter=The Assyrian Concept of Unity after Seyfo|title=The Assyrian Genocide: Cultural and Political Legacies|year=2017|volume=1|location=London|publisher=Routledge|pages=239–253|isbn=9781138284050|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=_8azAQAACAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last1=Mutlu-Numansen|first1=Sofia|last2=Ossewaarde|first2=Marinus|title=A Struggle for Genocide Recognition: How the Aramean, Assyrian, and Chaldean Diasporas Link Past and Present|journal=Holocaust and Genocide Studies|year=2019|volume=33|issue=3|pages=412–428|doi=10.1093/hgs/dcz045|url=https://research.utwente.nl/files/191702532/Mutlu_Numansen2019struggle.pdf}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Nisan|first=Mordechai|title=Minorities in the Middle East: A History of Struggle and Self-Expression|year=2002|edition=2nd|location=Jefferson, NC|publisher=McFarland|isbn=9780786451333|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=keD9z1XWuNwC}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=O’Mahony|first=Anthony|chapter=Syriac Christianity in the modern Middle East|title=The Cambridge History of Christianity: Eastern Christianity|volume=5|year=2006|location=Cambridge|publisher=Cambridge University Press|pages=511–536|isbn=9780521811132|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=1xUV-nMxNGsC}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Parpola|first=Simo|author-link=Simo Parpola|title=Assyrians after Assyria|journal=Journal of the Assyrian Academic Society|year=2000|volume=12|number=2|pages=1–16|url=http://www.betnahrain.net/1History/Parpola1.htm|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080426072232/http://www.betnahrain.net/1History/Parpola1.htm|url-status=dead|archive-date=2008-04-26}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Parpola|first=Simo|author-link=Simo Parpola|title=National and Ethnic Identity in the Neo-Assyrian Empire and Assyrian Identity in Post-Empire Times|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=2004|volume=18|number=2|pages=5–22|url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v18n2/Parpola-identity_Article%20-Final.pdf|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20071128181409/http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v18n2/Parpola-identity_Article%20-Final.pdf|url-status=dead|archive-date=2007-11-28}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Parpola|first=Simo|author-link=Simo Parpola|chapter=Mount Nisir and the Foundations of the Assyrian Church|title=From Source to History: Studies on Ancient Near Eastern Worlds and Beyond|year=2014|location=Münster|publisher=Ugarit-Verlag|pages=469–484|chapter-url=https://www.academia.edu/9468007}} | |||
* {{Cite book|editor-last=Roller|editor-first=Duane W.|editor-link=Duane W. Roller|title=The Geography of Strabo: An English Translation, with Introduction and Notes|year=2014|location=Cambridge|publisher=Cambridge University Press|isbn=9781139952491|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=33GFAwAAQBAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Rollinger|first=Robert|title=Assyrios, Syrios, Syros und Leukosyros|journal=Die Welt des Orients|year=2006a|volume=36|pages=72–82|jstor=25684050|url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/25684050}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Rollinger|first=Robert|title=The Terms Assyria and Syria Again|journal=Journal of Near Eastern Studies|year=2006b|volume=65|number=4|pages=283–287|doi=10.1086/511103|s2cid=162760021|url=http://www.aina.org/articles/ttaasa.pdf}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Saggs|first=Henry W. F.|author-link=Henry W. F. Saggs|title=The Might That Was Assyria|year=1984|location=London|publisher=Sidgwick & Jackson|isbn=9780312035112|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=8MNJGwAACAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Segal|first=Judah B.|author-link=Judah B. Segal|title=Edessa: The Blessed City|year=1970|location=Oxford|publisher=Clarendon Press|isbn=978-0-19-821545-5|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=LziFAAAAIAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Southgate|first=Horatio|author-link=Horatio Southgate|title=Narrative of a Tour Through Armenia, Kurdistan, Persia and Mesopotamia|year=1840|volume=2|location=London|publisher=Tilt and Bogue|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ql5CAAAAcAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Southgate|first=Horatio|author-link=Horatio Southgate|title=Report of a Visit of the Rev. H. Southgate to the Syrian Church of Mesopotamia, 1841|journal=The Spirit of Missions|year=1842|volume=7|pages=163–174, 246–251, 276–280|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=aLbSAAAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Southgate|first=Horatio|author-link=Horatio Southgate|title=Narrative of a Visit to the Syrian (Jacobite) Church of Mesopotamia|year=1844|location=New York|publisher=Appleton|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=TFLMrTAyAQQC}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last1=Tekoğlu|first1=Recai|last2=Lemaire|first2=André|last3=İpek|first3=İsmet|last4=Tosun|first4=Kazım|title=La bilingue royale louvito-phénicienne de Çineköy|journal=Comptes rendus des séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres|year=2000|volume=144|number=3|pages=961–1007|url=https://www.persee.fr/docAsPDF/crai_0065-0536_2000_num_144_3_16174.pdf}} | |||
* {{Cite book|editor-last=Thackeray|editor-first=Henry St. John|editor-link=Henry St. John Thackeray|title=Josephus: Jewish Antiquities, Books I-IV|volume=4|year=1961|orig-year=1930|location=London|publisher=William Heinemann|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=mBKxAAAAIAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Tisserant|first=Eugène|author-link=Eugène Tisserant|chapter=L'Église nestorienne|title=Dictionnaire de théologie catholique|year=1931|volume=11|location=Paris|publisher=Letouzey et Ané|pages=157–323|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=JxhAAQAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Travis|first=Hannibal|title=Genocide in the Middle East: The Ottoman Empire, Iraq, and Sudan|year=2010|location=Durham, NC|publisher=Carolina Academic Press|isbn=9781594604362|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=kd8lAQAAMAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Wigram|first=William Ainger|author-link=William Ainger Wigram|title=The Assyrians and Their Neighbours|year=1929|location=London|publisher=G. Bell & Sons|url=https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.282998}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Wilmshurst|first=David|title=The Ecclesiastical Organisation of the Church of the East, 1318–1913|year=2000|location=Louvain|publisher=Peeters Publishers|isbn=9789042908765|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=jB8ir0ek8bgC}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Wilmshurst|first=David|title=The martyred Church: A History of the Church of the East|year=2011|location=London|publisher=East & West Publishing Limited|isbn=9781907318047|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=zfxNtwAACAAJ}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Wilmshurst|first=David|chapter=The Church of the East in the 'Abbasid Era|title=The Syriac World|year=2019|location=London|publisher=Routledge|pages=189–201|chapter-url=https://www.academia.edu/26842432}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Wolk|first=Daniel P.|chapter=Assyrian Americans|title=Encyclopedia of Race, Ethnicity, and Society|year=2008|volume=1|location=Los Angeles|publisher=SAGE Publications|pages=107–109|isbn=9781412926942|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=YMUola6pDnkC}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Woźniak|first=Marta|title=National and Social Identity Construction among the Modern Assyrians/Syrians|journal=Parole de l'Orient|year=2011|volume=36|pages=569–583|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=8MJ1z_6fhTYC}} | |||
* {{Cite document|last=Woźniak|first=Marta|title=From religious to ethno-religious: Identity change among Assyrians/Syriacs in Sweden|work=Joint Sessions of Workshops organized by the European Consortium for Political Research (ECPR)|publisher=ECPR|year=2015a|url=https://ecpr.eu/Filestore/PaperProposal/7b35bf3b-ddc6-47b6-8bb6-f5bb1a9c236a.pdf}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Yana|first=George V.|title=Myth vs Reality|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=2000|volume=14|issue=1|pages=78–82|url=http://www.jaas.org/edocs/v14n1/e3.pdf)}}{{dead link|date=July 2021|bot=medic}}{{cbignore|bot=medic}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Yana|first=George V.|title=Ancient and Modern Assyrians: A Scientific Analysis|year=2008|location=Philadelphia|publisher=Exlibris Corporation|isbn=9781465316295|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=32HS_jUi4NEC}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Yildiz|first=Efrem|title=The Assyrians: A Historical and Current Reality|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=1999|volume=13|number=1|pages=15–30|url=https://www.academia.edu/22095031}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Yildiz|first=Efrem|title=The Aramaic Language and Its Classification|journal=Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies|year=2000a|volume=14|number=1|pages=23–44|url=https://www.academia.edu/22094684}} | |||
* {{Cite journal|last=Yildiz|first=Efrem|title=Los Asirio-Caldeos, Cristianos orientales arameoparlantes|journal=Dialogo Ecumenico|year=2000b|volume=35|number=112|pages=263–282|url=https://summa.upsa.es/high.raw?id=0000002192&name=00000001.original.pdf}} | |||
* {{Cite book|last=Yildiz|first=Efrem|chapter=The Assyrian Linguistic Heritage and its Survival in Diaspora|title=The Assyrian Heritage: Threads of Continuity and Influence|year=2012|location=Uppsala|publisher=Uppsala Universitet|pages=201–220|chapter-url=https://www.academia.edu/25156354}} | |||
{{refend}} | {{refend}} | ||
{{Assyrian topics}} | {{Assyrian topics}} | ||
] | ] | ||
] | ] |
Revision as of 08:44, 28 February 2022
Continuity between ancient and modern Assyrians File:Ashur5.jpgThe modern Assyrian flag (top) prominently incorporates ancient Assyrian elements, including the god Ashur (bottom left) and the star of the god Shamash (bottom right)Assyrian continuity is the theory of continuity between the modern Assyrian people, an ethnoreligious minority in the Middle East, and the people of ancient Assyria. Assyrian continuity is a key part of the identity of the modern Assyrian people. Given that there is no evidence of the original Assyrian population being replaced in the aftermath of the fall of Assyria, contemporary scholarship generally supports Assyrian continuity, recognizing the modern Assyrians as descendants of the Aramaic-speaking populations of the Neo-Assyrian Empire, which were composed of both the old native Assyrian population and of Aramean settlers in the Assyrian heartland.
Due to a shortage of sources beyond the Bible and works by classical authors, western historians prior to the 19th century believed Assyria to have been completely annihilated. Modern Assyriology has increasingly challenged this perception; today, Assyriologists recognize that Assyrian culture and people clearly survived the violent fall of the Neo-Assyrian Empire. The last period of ancient Assyrian history is now regarded to be the long post-imperial period, during which the Akkadian language went extinct but other aspects of Assyrian culture, such as religion, traditions, and naming patterns, survived in a reduced but highly recognizable form for nearly a millennium.
The extinction of Akkadian and its replacement with Aramaic does not reflect the disappearance of the original Assyrian population; Aramaic was used not only by Aramean settlers but was also adopted by native Assyrians, in time even becoming used by the royal administration itself. Due to assimiliation efforts encouraged by Assyrian kings, Arameans and other groups in the Assyrian heartland are also likely to quickly have self-identified, and been regarded, as Assyrians. The population of northern Mesopotamia was Christianized between the 1st and 4th centuries AD. Aramaic-language sources from the Christian period predominantly use the self-designations ʾārāmāyā ("Aramean") and suryāyā. "Assyrian" (ʾāthorāyā) also continously survived as the designation for a Christian from Mosul (ancient Nineveh) and its vicinity. The reluctance of the overall Christian population to adopt ʾāthorāyā as a self-designation probably derives from Assyria's portrayal in the Bible. The different terms did not refer to different groups, given that some individuals are described as both ʾārāmāyā and suryāyā. Suryāyā, sometimes translated as "Syrian" or "Syriac", is also not technically a different identity than "Assyrian" given that the term is thought to derive from the ancient Akkadian assūrāyu. The academic consensus is that the modern name "Syria" originated as a shortened form of "Assyria".
Assyrian nationalism developed near the end of the 19th century, coinciding with increasing contacts with Europeans and with increased expressions nationalism in other Middle Eastern groups, such as the Armenians, Arabs, Kurds and Turks. Through the large-scale adoption and promotion of identities such as ʾāthorāyā and ʾasurāyā, Assyrian intellectuals and authors hoped to inspire the unification of the Assyrian nation, transcending long-standing denominational divisions. This effort has been met with both support and opposition in various communities; some denominations have rejected unity and promoted alternate identities, such as "Aramean", "Syriac" and "Chaldean". Though some religious officials and activists have promoted such identities as separate ethnic groups rather than simply religious groups, they are not generally treated as such by international organizations.
Assyrians after the Assyrian Empire
Early assumption of Assyrian annihilation
Ancient Assyria fell in the late 7th century BC through the Medo-Babylonian conquest of the Assyrian Empire, with its major population centers violently sacked and most of its territory incorporated into the Neo-Babylonian Empire. In the millennia following the fall of Assyria, knowledge of the ancient empire chiefly survived in western literary tradition through accounts of Assyria in the Hebrew Bible and works by classical authors, both of which described Assyria's fall as violent and comprehensive destruction. Before the 19th century, the prevalent belief in Biblically-influenced western scholarship was that ancient Assyria and Babylonia had been literally annihilated due to provoking divine wrath. This belief was reinforced through archaeologists in the Middle East initially not finding many remains fitting with the conventional European image of ancient cities, with stone columns and great sculptures, beyond those of ancient Persia; Assyria and other Mesopotamian civilizations left no magnificent ruins above ground—all that remained to see were huge grass-covered mounds in the plains which travellers at times believed to simply be natural features of the landscape. Early European archaeologists in the Middle East were also for the most part more interested in confirming Biblical truth through their excavations than to spend time on new interpretations of the evidence they discovered.
Though the Bible and other Hebrew texts describe the destruction of the Assyrian Empire, they do not actually claim that the Assyrian people were destroyed. The 2nd century BC apocryphal Book of Judith states that the Neo-Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar II (r. 605–562 BC) "ruled over the Assyrians in the great city of Nineveh", the Book of Ezra refers to the Persian king Darius I as "king of Assyria", and the Book of Isaiah states that there will come a day when God will proclaim "Blessed be Egypt my people, and Assyria the work of my hands, and Israel my heritage". The idea of Assyrian annihilation, despite increasing evidence to the contrary, proved to be enduring in western academia. As late as 1925, the Assyriologist Sidney Smith wrote that "The disappearance of the Assyrian people will always remain an unique and striking phenomenon in ancient history. Other, similar kingdoms and empires have indeed passed away, but the people have lived on ... No other land seems to have been sacked and pillaged so completely as was Assyria". Just a year later, Smith had abandoned the idea of the Assyrians having been eradicated and recognized the persistence of Assyrians through the Christian period.
Post-imperial Assyria in modern Assyriology
See also: Post-imperial AssyriaModern Assyriology does not support the idea that the fall of Assyria also brought with it a complete eradication of the Assyrian people and their culture. Though in the past regarded as a "post-Assyrian" age, Assyriologists today consider the last period of ancient Assyrian history to be the long post-imperial period, extending from 609 BC to around AD 240. Though the centuries that followed the fall of Assyria are characterized by a distinct lack of surviving sources from the region, the idea that Assyria was rendered uninhabited and desolated stems from the contrast with the richly attested Neo-Assyrian period, not necessarily from the actual sources from the post-imperial period.
Though the Assyrian bureaucracy and governmental institutions disappeared with Assyria's fall, Assyrian population centers and culture did not. At Dur-Katlimmu, one of the largest settlements along the Khabur river, a large Assyrian palace, dubbed the "Red House" by archaeologists, continued to be used in Neo-Babylonian times, with cuneiform records there being written by people with Assyrian names, in Assyrian style, though dated to the reigns of the early Neo-Babylonian kings. These documents mention officials with Assyrian titles and invoke the ancient Assyrian national deity Ashur. Two Neo-Babylonian texts discovered at the city of Sippar in Babylonia attest to there being royally appointed governors at both Assur and Guzana, another Assyrian site in the north. Arbela is attested as a thriving city, but only very late in the Neo-Babylonian period, and there were attempts to revive the city of Arrapha in reign of Neriglissar (r. 560–556 BC), who returned a cult statue to the site. Harran was revitalized, with its great temple dedicated to the lunar god Sîn being rebuilt under Nabonidus (r. 556–539 BC).
Individuals with Assyrian names are attested at multiple sites in Babylonia during the Neo-Babylonian Empire, including Babylon, Nippur, Uruk, Sippar, Dilbat and Borsippa. The Assyrians in Uruk apparently continued to exist as a community until the reign of the Achaemenid king Cambyses II (r. 530–522 BC) and were closely linked to a local cult dedicated to Ashur. Individiuals with clearly Assyrian names are also known from the rule of the Achaemenid Empire, sometimes in high levels of government. A prominent example is Pan-Ashur-lumur, who served as the secretary of Cambyses II. The temple dedicated to Ashur in Assur was rebuilt by local Assyrians in the reign of Cyrus the Great.
Under the Seleucid and Parthian empires, Assyria began to be rebuilt and the ancient population centers began to be resettled, with the predominant portion of the population remaining native Assyrian. The original Assyrian capital of Assur is in particular known to have fluorished under Parthian rule. Continuity from ancient Assyria is clear in Assur during this period, with personal names of the city's denizens greatly reflecting names used in the Neo-Assyrian Empire, such as Qib-Assor ("command of Ashur"), Assor-tares ("Ashur judges") and even Assor-heden ("Ashur has given a brother", a late version of the name Aššur-aḫu-iddina, i.e. Esarhaddon). The Assyrians at Assur continued to follow the traditional ancient Mesopotamian religion, worshipping Ashur (at this time known as Assor) and other gods. Assur may even have been the capital of its own semi-autonomous vassal state, either under the suzerainty of the Kingdom of Hatra, or under direct Parthian suzerainty. Though this golden age of Assur came to an end with the conquest, sack and destruction of the city by the Sasanian Empire c. AD 240, the inscriptions, temples, continued celebration of festivals and the wealth of theophoric elements (divine names) in personal names of the Parthian period illustrate a strong continuity of traditions, and that the most important deities of old Assyria were still worshipped at Assur more than 800 years after the Assyrian Empire had been destroyed.
Identity in ancient Assyria
Development and distinctions
Ethnicity and culture are largely based in self-perception and self-designation. In ancient Assyria, a distinct Assyrian identity appears to have formed already in the Old Assyrian period (c. 2025–1364 BC), when distinctly Assyrian burial practices, foods and dress codes are attested and Assyrian documents appear to consider the inhabitants of Assur to be a distinct cultural group. A wider Assyrian identity appears to have spread across northern Mesopotamia under the Middle Assyrian Empire (c. 1363–912 BC), since later writings concerning the reconquests of the early Neo-Assyrian kings refer to some of their wars as liberating the Assyrian people of the cities they reconquered. Though there for much of ancient Assyria's history existed a distinct Assyrian identity, Assyrian culture and civilization, like any other culture and civilization, did not develop in isolation. As the Assyrian Empire expanded and contracted, elements from regions the Assyrians conquered or traded with culturally influenced the Assyrian heartland and the Assyrians themselves. Early Assyrian culture was greatly influenced by the Hurrians, a people that also lived in northern Mesopotamia, and by the culture of southern Mesopotamia, particularly that of Babylonia.
Surviving evidence suggests that the ancient Assyrians had a relatively open definition of what it meant to be Assyrian. Modern ideas such as a person's ethnic background, or the Roman idea of legal citizenship, do not appear to have been reflected in ancient Assyria. Although Assyrian accounts and artwork of warfare frequently describe and depict foreign enemies, they are not depicted with different physical features, but rather with different clothing and equipment. Assyrian accounts describe enemies as barbaric only in terms of their behavior, as lacking correct religious practices, and as doing wrongdoings against Assyria. All things considered, there does not appear to have been any well-developed concepts of ethnicity or race in ancient Assyria. What mattered for a person to be seen by others as Assyrian was mainly fulfillment of obligations (such as military service), being affiliated with the Assyrian Empire politically, and maintaining loyalty to the Assyrian king; some kings, such as Sargon II (r. 722–705 BC), explicitly encouraged assimilation and mixture of foreign cultures with that of Assyrian.
Arameans and Aramaic
In the wake of the Late Bronze Age collapse around 1200 BC, Aramean tribes began to migrate into Assyrian territory. In the first millennium BC, Aramean influence on Assyria grew greater and greater, owing to further migrations as well as mass deportations enacted by several Assyrian kings. Though the expansion of the Assyrian Empire, in combination with resettlements and deportations, changed the ethno-cultural make-up of the Assyrian heartland, there is no evidence to suggest that the more ancient Assyrian inhabitants of the land ever disappeared or became restricted to a small elite, nor that the ethnic and cultural identity of the new settlers was anything other than "Assyrian" after one or two generations.
Because the Assyrians never imposed their language on foreign peoples whose lands they conquered outside of the Assyrian heartland, there were no mechanisms in place to stop the spread of languages other than Akkadian. Beginning with the migrations of Arameans into Assyrian territory during the Middle Assyrian period, this lack of linguistic policies facilitated the spread of the Aramaic language. As the most widely spoken and mutually understandable of the Semitic languages (the language group containing many of the languages spoken through the empire), Aramaic grew in importance throughout the Neo-Assyrian period and increasingly replaced the Akkadian language even within the Assyrian heartland itself. From the 9th century BC onwards, Aramaic became the de facto lingua franca, with Akkadian becoming relegated to a language of the political elite (i.e. governors and officials).
The widespread adoption of the language does not indicate a wholesale replacement of the original native population; the Aramaic language was used not only by Aramean settlers but also by native Assyrians, who adopted it and its alphabetic script. The Aramaic language had entered the Assyrian royal administration by the reign of Shalmaneser III (r. 859–824 BC), given that Aramaic writings are known from a palace he built in Nimrud. By the time of Tiglath-Pileser III (r. 745–727 BC), the Assyrian kings employed both Akkadian and Aramaic-language royal scribes, confirming the rise of Aramaic to a position of an official language used by the imperial administration. It is clear that Aramaic was spoken by the Assyrian royal family from at least the late 8th century BC onwards, given that Tiglath-Pileser's son Shalmaneser V (r. 727–722 BC) owned a set of lion weights inscribed with text in both Akkadian and Aramaic. A recorded drop in the number of cuneiform documents late in the reign of Ashurbanipal (r. 669–631 BC) could indicate a greater shift to Aramaic, often written on perishable materials like leather scrolls or papyrus, though it could perhaps alternatively be attributed to political instability in the empire. The denizens of Assur and other former Assyrian population centers under Parthian rule, who clearly connected themselves to ancient Assyria, wrote and spoke Aramaic.
Pre-modern self-identities
Though many foreign states ruled over the Assyrian heartland in the millennia following the empire's fall, there is no evidence of any large scale influx of immigrants that replaced the original population, which instead continued to make up a significant portion of the region's people until Mongol and Timurid massacres in the late 14th century. In pre-modern Syriac-language (the type of Aramaic used in Christian Mesopotamian writings) sources, the typical self-designations used are ʾārāmāyā ("Aramean") and suryāyā (as well as the shortened surayā), with the term ʾāthorāyā ("Assyrian") rarely being used as a self-designation. It is clear from the surviving sources that ʾārāmāyā and suryāyā were not distinct and mutually exclusive identities, but rather interchangeable terms used to refer to the same people; the Syriac author Bardaisan (154–222) is for instance referred to in 4th-century Syriac translations of Eusebius's Church History as both ārāmāyā and suryāyā.
Suryāyā, which also occurs in the forms suryāyē and sūrōyē, though sometimes translated to "Syrian", is not technically a different identity than "Assyrian". The term is believed to derive from the ancient Akkadian term assūrāyu ("Assyrian"), which was sometimes even in ancient times rendered in the shorter form sūrāyu. Luwian and Aramaic texts from the time of the Neo-Assyrian Empire, such as the Çineköy inscription, sometimes use the shortened "Syria" for the Assyrian Empire. The consensus in modern academia is thus that "Syria" is simply a shortened form of "Assyria". The modern distinction between "Assyrian" and "Syrian" is the result of ancient Greek historians and cartographers, who designated the Levant as "Syria" and Mesopotamia as "Assyria". By the time the terms are first attested in Greek texts (in the 4th century BC), the local denizens in both the Levant and Mesopotamia had already long used both terms interchangeably for the entire region, and continued to do so well into the later Christian period. Whether the Greeks began referring to Mesopotamia as "Assyria" because they equated the region with the Assyrian Empire, long fallen by the time the term is first attested in Greek, or because they named the region after the people who lived there, the (As)syrians, is not known.
Although suryāyā is thus clearly connected to "Assyrian", the more prevalent term for ancient Assyrians, ʾāthorāyā is not the typical self-designation in pre-modern sources. Syriac sources did however prominently use ʾāthorāyā in other contexts, particularly in relation to ancient Assyria. Ancient Assyria was typically referred to as ʾāthor, which also survived as a designation for the region surrounding its last great capital, Nineveh. The reluctance of Medieval Syriac Christians to use ʾāthorāyā as a self-designation could perhaps be explained by the Assyrians described in the Bible being prominent enemies of Israel; the term ʾāthorāyā was sometimes employed in Syriac writings as a term for enemies of Christians. In this context, the term was sometimes applied to the Persians of the Sasanian Empire; the 4th-century Syriac writer Ephrem the Syrian for instance referred to the Sasanian Empire as "filthy ʾāthor, mother of corruption". In a similar fashion, the term in this context was also sometimes applied to the later Muslim rulers. Though not used by the overall Syriac-speaking community in the Middle Ages, the term ʾāthorāyā did survive as a self-identity throughout the period as it was the typically used designation for a Syriac Christian from Mosul (ancient Nineveh) and its vicinity.
Pre-modern Syriac-language sources at times identified positively with the ancient Assyrians and drew connections between the ancient empire and themselves. Most prominently, ancient Assyrian kings and figures long appeared in local folklore and literary tradition and claims of descent from ancient Assyrian royalty were forwarded both for figures in folklore and by actual living high-ranking members of society in northern Mesopotamia. Figures like Sargon II, Sennacherib (r. 705–681 BC), Esarhaddon (r. 681–669 BC), Ashurbanipal and Shamash-shum-ukin long figured in local folklore and literary tradition. In large part, tales from the Sasanian period and later times were invented narratives, based on ancient Assyrian history but applied to local and current landscapes. Medieval tales written in Syriac, such as that of Behnam, Sarah, and the Forty Martyrs, for instance by and large characterize Sennacherib as an archetypical pagan king assassinated as part of a family feud, whose children convert to Christianity.
The 7th-century Assyrian History of Mar Qardagh made the titular saint, Mar Qardagh, out to be a descendant of the legendary Biblical Mesopotamian king Nimrod and the historical Sennacherib, with his illustrious descent manifesting in Mar Qardagh's mastery of archery, hunting and polo. A sanctuary constructed for Mar Qardagh during this time was built directly on top of the ruins of a Neo-Assyrian temple. The legendary figure Nimrod, otherwise traditionally viewed as simply Mesopotamian, is explicitly referred to as Assyrian in many of the Sasanian-period texts and is inserted into the line of Assyrian kings. Nimrod, as well as other legendary Mesopotamian (though explicitly Assyrian in the texts) rulers, such as Belus and Ninus, sometimes play significant roles in the writings. Certain Christian texts considered the Biblical figure Balaam to have prophesized the Star of Bethlehem; a local Assyrian version of this narrative appears in some Syriac-language writings from the Sasanian period, which allege that Balaam's prophecy was remembered only through being transmitted through the ancient Assyrian kings. In some stories, explicit claims of descent are made. According to the 6th-century History of Karka, twelve of the noble families of Karka (ancient Arrapha) were descendants of ancient Assyrian nobility who lived in the city during the time of Sargon II.
Modern identity and nationalism
See also: Assyrian nationalism19th century identities and developments
Early travellers and missionaries in northern Mesopotamia in the 19th century observed connections between the indigenous Christian population and the ancient Assyrians. The British traveller Claudius Rich (1787–1821) referenced "Assyrian Christians" in Narrative of a Residence in Koordistan and on the site of Ancient Nineveh (published posthumously in 1836, though describing a 1820 journey). It is possible that Rich considered "Assyrian" a geographic, rather than ethnic, term since he in a footnote on the same page also referenced the "Christians of Assyria". More clear-cut evidence of Assyrian self-identity in the 19th century can be seen in the writings of the American missionary Horatio Southgate (1812–1894). In Southgate's Narrative of a Visit to the Syrian Church of Mesopotamia (1844) he remarked with surprise that Armenians referred to the Syriac Christians as Assouri, which Southgate associated with the English "Assyrians", rather than Syriani, which he himself had been using. Armenian sources have since antiquity consistently referred to Assyrians as Assouri or Asori. Southgate also mentioned that the Syriac Christians themselves at this point claimed origin from the ancient Assyrians as "sons of Assour". Southgate's account thus demonstrates that modern Assyrians claimed ancient Assyrian descent already in the middle of the 19th century.
Connections between the modern population and ancient Assyrians were popularized in the west and academia by the archaeologist and traveller Austen Henry Layard (1817–1894), responsible for the early excavations of several major ancient Assyrian sites, such as Nimrud. In Nineveh and its Remains (1849), Layard argued that the Christians he met in northern Mesopotamia were "descendants of the ancient Assyrians". It is possible that Layard's assessment of them as such derived from his partnership with the local Assyrian archaeologist Hormuzd Rassam (1826–1910).
Towards the end of the 19th century, a so-called "religious renaissance" or "awakening" took place in Urmia, Iran. Perhaps partly encouraged by Anglican, Roman Catholic and Russian Orthodox missionary efforts, the concepts of nation and nationalism were introduced to the Assyrians in Urmia, who began to adopt the term ʾāthorāyā as a self-identity, and began building a national ideology more heavily based around ancient Assyria. This was not an isolated phenomenon: Middle Eastern nationalism, probably influenced by developments in Europe, also began to be strongly expressed in other communities during this time, such as among the Armenians, Arabs, Kurds and Turks. This time also saw the development of Literary Urmia Aramaic, a new literary language based on the at the time spoken Neo-Aramaic dialects. Through the promotion of an identity rooted in ancient Assyria, various communities could transcend their denominational differences and unite under one national identity.
Contemporary identities and name debate
See also: Terms for Syriac ChristiansIn the years before World War I, several prominent Aramaic-language authors and intellectuals promoted Assyrian nationalism. Among them were for instance Freydun Atturaya (1891–1926), who in 1911 published an influential article titled Who are the Syrians ? How is Our Nation to Be Raised Up?, in which he pointed out the connection between surayē and "Assyrian" and argued for the adoption of ʾāthorāyā. The early 20th century saw an increase in the use of the term ʾāthorāyā as a self-identity. Also used as the neologism ʾasurāyā, perhaps inspired by the Armenian Asori. The adoption of ʾāthorāyā and a stronger association with ancient Assyria through nationalism is not a unique development in regard to the Assyrians. Greeks, for instance, due to associating the term "Greek" with the ancient pagan Greeks, overwhelmingly self-identified as Romans (Rhōmaîoi) up until nationalism around the time of the Greek War of Independence, when a more strong association with Ancient Greece spread among the populace.
As a consequence of World War I, the Sayfo (Assyrian genocide) and various other massacres, a majority of Assyrians have today been displaced from their homeland, living in diaspora in countries such as Germany, Sweden, Denmark, the United Kingdom, Greece, Australia, New Zealand and the United States. In the aftermath of these events, explicit Assyrian self-identity became even more widespread and established in their communities, not only in order to unify communities in the diaspora (who often originated from different regions) but also because "Syrian" became internationally established as the demonym of the newly created country of Syria. Some from outside the Church of the East also embraced Assyrian nationalism, such as D. B. Perley (1901–1979), who in 1933 helped found the Assyrian National Federation and religiously identified as Syriac Orthodox but ethnically identified as Assyrian. In 1935, Perley wrote that "The Assyrians, although representing but one single nation as the direct heirs of the ancient Assyrian Empire … are now doctrinally divided … No one can coherently understand the Assyrians as a whole until he can distinguish that which is religion or church from that which is nation …" and even proposed uniting all Assyrians under a single patriarch of the Church of the East.
For communities that identify as Assyrian, Assyrian continuity forms a key part of their self-identity. Many modern Assyrians are named after ancient Mesopotamian figures, such as Sargon, Sennacherib and Nebuchadnezzar, and the modern Assyrian flag displays symbolism deriving from ancient Assyria. From the second half of the 20th century to the present, Assyrians, particularly in the diaspora, have continued to promote Assyrian nationalism as a unifying force of their people. Some denominational groups have opposed being lumped in as "Assyrians" and have started counter-movements of their own; the so-called "name debate" is still today a hotly discussed topic within Syriac Christian communities, especially in the diaspora outside the Assyrian homeland. An alternative promoted by some Syriac Orthodox church officials is Aramean (ʾārāmāyā) identity, for instance advocated for by Patriarch Ignatius Aphrem I (patriarch 1933–1957). More recently, Syriac Orthodox adherents have preferred to identify simply as "Syriac", the name of their church and the liturgical language and an alternate transliteration of suryayā. In 1981, Patriarch Ignatius Zakka I advocated for Syriac identity over both Assyrian and Aramean identity. Today, people who identify as Aramean or Syriac typically use those identites interchangeably. Some of the adherents to the Chaldean Catholic Church, "Chaldeans", have also in recent times advocated for recognition as a distinct group. Modern international organizations do not generally recognize Assyrians, Syriacs, Arameans and Chaldeans as different ethnic groups but merely as alternate names and numerous church leaders have also affirmed that they belong to the same ethnic group, albeit to different Christian denominations.
Other forms of continuity
In addition to continuity in self-designation and self-perception, there continued to be important continuities between ancient and contemporary Mesopotamia in terms of religion, literary culture and settlement well after the post-imperial period. Assyrian settlements continued to be occupied into the Christian period. The ancient capital of Nineveh, for instance, became the seat of a bishop, the Bishop of Nineveh, and a church (later converted to a mosque under Islamic rule) was built on top of the ruins of an ancient Assyrian palace. The main population center in the city gradually shifted to the opposite bank of the river, which became the city today known as Mosul; ancient Nineveh only gradually fell into ruin and eventually became open countryside. Though most of the old population centers were similarly gradually abandoned and fell into ruin some also endured. The ancient city of Arbela, today known as Erbil, has been continuously inhabited since the time of the Neo-Assyrian Empire. Although the ancient Mesopotamian pantheon ceased to be worshipped at Assur with the city's destruction in the 3rd century AD, it persisted at other localities, despite the overwhelming conversion of the region to Christianity, for much longer; the old faith persisted at Harran until at least the 10th century and at Mardin until as late as the 18th century.
Names clearly reminiscent of those used by Assyrians in the Neo-Assyrian Empire continued to be used at Assur throughout the post-imperial period, at least until the 3rd century AD. Though some opponents to Assyrian continuity, such as David Wilmshurst, have claimed that Assyrian names ceased being used in the Christian period and that this in turn was evidence of a lack of continuity, ancient names were not wholly abandoned. Arabic-language records from 13th-century Rumkale for instance record a man by the name Nebuchadnezzar (rendered Bukthanaṣar in the Arabic text), a relative of a Patriarch of the Syriac Orthodox Church named Philoxenus Nemrud (also a name with ancient Assyrian connections, deriving either from Nimrud or Nimrod). Modern Assyrian authors, such as Odisho Malko Gewargis, contend that a decrease in ancient pagan names invoking gods such as Ashur, Nabu and Sîn is hardly surprising given the Christianization of the Assyrians; similar cases of native names being increasingly replaced by Biblically-derived names are also known from numerous other Christianized peoples.
Though modern Assyrian languages, most prominently the Suret language, are Neo-Aramaic languages with little resemblance to the old Akkadian language, they are not wholly without Akkadian influence. Most notably there are several examples of Akkadian loanwords in both ancient and modern Aramaic languages. The Syriac language, an Aramaic dialect today mainly used liturgical language, has at least fourteen exclusive (i.e. not attested in other dialects) loanwords from Akkadian, including nine of which are clearly from the ancient Assyrian dialect (six of which are architectural or topographical terms).
Academia and politics
The use of the Assyrian name by modern Assyrians has historically led to controversy and misunderstanding, not only within but also outside the Assyrian community. Discussions on the connection between the modern and ancient Assyrians have also entered into academia. In addition to support by prominent historical Assyriologists, such as Austen Henry Layard and Sidney Smith, Assyrian continuity enjoys wide support within contemporary Assyriology. Among proponents of continuity are prominent Assyriologists such as Simo Parpola, Robert D. Biggs, H. W. F. Saggs, Georges Roux, J. A. Brinkman and Mirko Novák. Historians of other fields have also supported Assyrian continuity, such as Richard Nelson Frye, Philip K. Hitti, Patricia Crone, Michael Cook, Mordechai Nisan and Joshua J. Mark (contributor of the World History Encyclopedia). Other scholars supporting continuity include, among others, the linguist Judah Segal, the political scientist James Jupp, the genocide researcher Hannibal Travis, and the geneticists Luigi Luca Cavalli-Sforza, Paolo Menozzi, Alberto Piazza, Mohammad Taghi Akbari, Sunder S. Papiha, Derek Frank Roberts and Dariush Farhud. Numerous scholars who themselves are of Assyrian origin, such as Efrem Yildiz, Sargon Donabed and Odisho Malko Gewargis, have also published academic works in support of Assyrian continuity.
Some academics, most notably the historians J.F. Coakley, John Joseph, David Wilmshurst and Adam H. Becker, have opposed continuity between modern and ancient Assyrians, typically arguing that modern Assyrian identity only emerged in the middle to late 19th century as a consequence of interactions with foreign missionaries and/or the discovery of ancient Assyrian ruins. Wholesale opposition of Assyrian continuity is not reflected within Assyriology. The Assyriologist Eckart Frahm considers modern Assyrians to be a group of "Arameans" on account of their language, but also the direct cultural heirs of the ancient Assyrians. Karen Radner considers Assyrian continuity to still be a matter of debate, but also opposes the idea that Assyrian identity only emerged in the 19th century, noting that modern Christians in northern Mesopotamia saw themselves as descendants of the ancient Assyrians long before the discovery of ancient sites and visits by foreign missionaries, as can for instance be gathered from the accounts of Horatio Postgate. Some opponents to Assyrian continuity, such as Becker, have argued that the rich Christian literature from the Sasanian period connecting with ancient Assyria was simply based on the Bible, rather than actual remembrance of ancient Assyria, despite several figures appearing in the tales, such as Esarhaddon and Sargon II, barely being mentioned in the Bible. The texts are also very much a local Assyrian phenomenon, given that the historical accounts presented in them are at odds with those of other historical writings of the Sasanian Empire.
Modern Assyrians consider opposition to Assyrian continuity to be offensive and associate it with other historical forms of oppression against them. Sargon Donabed, for instance, considers the use of terms such as "Chaldeans", "Syrian", "Syriacs", "Arameans", or more extremely "Arab Christians", "Kurdish Christians" and "Turkish Christians", to be harmful as they add to division and confusion in regard to identity and are "clearly reflective of modern political parlance". These views are partly attributable to the actions of the government in Ba'athist Iraq (1968–2003), which sought to counteract Assyrian demands for autonomy through refusing to recognize Assyrians as a third ethnic minority of the country, instead promoting Assyrians, "Syrians" and Chaldeans as separate peoples, and undercounted Assyrians in censuses; in 1977, it was made impossible to register as Assyrian in the national census and Assyrians were consequently forced to register as Arabs for fear of losing employment and ration cards.
Genetic testing of Assyrian populations is a relatively new field of study, but has hitherto supported the notion that Assyrians historically rarely intermarried with surrounding populations. Genetic studies conducted in 2000 and 2008 support Assyrians as genetically distinct from other groups in the Middle East, with high endogamy; this indicates that the community has historically been relatively closed owing to their religious and cultural traditions, with little intermixture with other groups.
See also
- History of the Assyrians
- Assyrian culture
- List of ethnic Assyrians, Chaldeans, and Syriacs
- Nationalist historiography
Notes
- At the height of the Neo-Assyrian Empire, there were around 20 million Assyrians. Estimates for the number of people resettled under Neo-Assyrian rule (not all of whom were Arameans and not all of whom were settled in the Assyrian heartland) range from 1.5 million to 4.5 million.
- Sargon II was for instance due to being mentioned only once in the Bible long forgotten in western scholarship and was only accepted as a real Assyrian king within Assyriology in the 1860s.
References
- ^ Butts 2017, p. 605.
- ^ Novák 2016, p. 132.
- ^ Frahm 2017, p. 7.
- Biggs 2005, p. 10.
- ^ Saggs 1984, p. 290.
- Parpola 2004, p. 22.
- Bedford 2009, p. 33.
- ^ Hauser 2017, p. 240.
- ^ Radner 2021, p. 149.
- ^ Luukko & Van Buylaere 2017, p. 319.
- ^ Butts 2017, p. 600.
- ^ Butts 2017, pp. 600–601.
- ^ Benjamen 2022, p. 2.
- ^ Parpola 2004, pp. 16–17.
- ^ Shehadeh 2011, p. 17.
- ^ Butts 2017, p. 603.
- ^ Petrosian 2006, pp. 143–144.
- Frahm 2017b, p. 192.
- ^ Trolle Larsen 2017, pp. 583–584.
- Frahm 2017c, p. 560.
- Kuhrt 1995, p. 239.
- ^ Reade 2018, p. 286.
- Dalley 1993, p. 134.
- Frahm 2017c, pp. 560–561.
- Dalley 1993, pp. 135–136.
- ^ Smith 1926, p. 69.
- Radner 2015, p. 20.
- ^ Hauser 2017, p. 229.
- Frahm 2017, p. 5.
- ^ Kuhrt 1995, p. 240.
- ^ Hauser 2017, p. 230.
- Frahm 2017b, p. 194.
- Parpola 1999.
- Radner 2015, p. 6.
- Hauser 2017, p. 238.
- ^ Reade 1998, p. 71.
- Haider 2008, p. 193.
- ^ Livingstone 2009, p. 154.
- Haider 2008, p. 197.
- Radner 2015, p. 19.
- Harper et al. 1995, p. 18.
- ^ Radner 2015, p. 7.
- Düring 2020, p. 39.
- Michel 2017, p. 81.
- Düring 2020, p. 145.
- Bahrani 2006, pp. 56–57.
- ^ Luukko & Van Buylaere 2017, p. 318.
- Radner 2021, p. 147.
- Frahm 2017b, p. 180.
- Frahm 2017b, p. 190.
- Filoni 2017, p. 37.
- ^ Butts 2017, p. 601.
- Rollinger 2006, pp. 285–287.
- Tamari 2019, p. 113.
- Rollinger 2006, p. 284.
- Hauser 2017, p. 241.
- ^ Kalimi & Richardson 2014, p. 5.
- Payne 2012, pp. 205, 217.
- ^ Payne 2012, p. 214.
- Payne 2012, p. 209.
- Payne 2012, p. 205.
- ^ Payne 2012, p. 208.
- Minov 2020, pp. 187, 191.
- Minov 2020, p. 203.
- Payne 2012, p. 217.
- ^ Butts 2017, p. 602.
- Becker 2015, p. 328.
- Cameron 2009, p. 7.
- Efstathiadou 2011, p. 191.
- Morrison 2018, p. 39.
- Butts 2017, p. 604.
- ^ Butts 2017, p. 599.
- Gaunt, Atto & Barthoma 2017, p. ix.
- Salem 2020.
- Trolle Larsen 2017, p. 584.
- Parpola 2004, p. 21.
- Wilmshurst 2011, p. 415.
- Jackson 2020, Chapter 1.
- ^ Gewargis 2002, p. 89.
- Luukko & Van Buylaere 2017, p. 314.
- Kaufman 1974, p. 164.
- Parpola 2004, p. 5–22.
- Biggs 2005, p. 10: "Especially in view of the very early establishment of Christianity in Assyria and its continuity to the present and the continuity of the population, I think there is every likelihood that ancient Assyrians are among the ancestors of modern Assyrians of the area".
- Saggs 1984, p. 290: "The destruction of the Assyrian Empire did not wipe out its population. They were predominantly peasant farmers, and since Assyria contains some of the best wheat land in the Near East, descendants of the Assyrian peasants would, as opportunity permitted, build new villages over the old cities and carried on with agricultural life, remembering traditions of the former cities. After seven or eight centuries and after various vicissitudes, these people became Christians. These Christians, and the Jewish communities scattered amongst them, not only kept alive the memory of their Assyrian predecessors but also combined them with traditions from the Bible".
- Roux 1992, pp. 276–277, 419–420.
- Assyrian Academic Society: Summary of the Lecture "There is no reason to believe that there would be no racial or cultural continuity in Assyria since there is no evidence that the population of Assyria was removed".
- Frye 1999, pp. 69–70.
- Hitti 1951, p. 519.
- ^ Crone & Cook 1977, p. 55.
- Nisan 2002, p. 181.
- Mark 2018, "there are still Assyrians living in the regions of Iran and northern Iraq, and elsewhere, in the present day". sfn error: no target: CITEREFMark2018 (help)
- Segal 1970, pp. 47, 51, 68–70.
- Jupp 2001, p. 174: "The Assyrians are the descendants of the once mighty Assyrian nation which inhabited the northern part of the country known as Iraq", "The Assyrians, who were Christians, managed to survive in the lands of their forefathers until the outbreak of the First World War".
- Travis 2010, pp. 148–151.
- Travis 2010, p. 148: "Although some authors doubt that Assyrian people could have survived from 600 BCE to the nineteenth century, many of the factors that justify recognizing Armenians, Jews, or other groups as continuously existing since ancient times also apply to the Assyrians, namely common patterns of worship, consistent self-identification, and genetic continuity".
- Cavalli-Sforza et al. 1994, p. 218: "They are Christian and are possibly bona fide descendants of their ancient namesakes".
- Akbari et al. 1986, p. 85: "The Assyrians are a group of Christians, also known as Nestorians, with a long history in the Middle East. From historical and archeological evidence, it is thought that their ancestors formed part of the Mesopotamian civilization".
- ^ Yildiz 1999, p. 16-19.
- ^ Donabed 2019, p. 118.
- Wilmshurst 2011, pp. 413–416.
- Becker 2008, p. 396.
- Frahm 2017, p. 7: "Many Assyrians adopted the Aramaic language and alphabetic script. After the downfall of the Assyrian state in the late seventh century BCE, cuneiform writing in Assyria came to an end, but key elements of Assyrian culture and religion survived among the Aramaeans. Even today, there are groups of Aramaeans who call themselves Assyrians and consider themselves heirs of the Assyrians of the imperial age".
- Holloway 2003, p. 71.
- Payne 2012, p. 215.
- Donabed 2012, p. 412.
- Naby 2006, pp. 527–528.
- Travis 2010, p. 149.
- Banoei et al. 2008, p. 79.
Bibliography
- Akbari, Mohammad Taghi; Papiha, Sunder S.; Roberts, Derek Frank; Farhud, Dariush (1986). "Genetic differentiation among Iranian Christian communities". American Journal of Human Genetics. 38 (1): 84–98. PMID 3456196.
- Bahrani, Zainab (2006). "Race and Ethnicity in Mesopotamian Antiquity". World Archaeology. 38 (1): 48–59. doi:10.1080/00438240500509843. JSTOR 40023594. S2CID 144093611.
- Banoei, Mohammad Mehdi; Chaleshtori, Morteza Hashemzadeh; Sanati, Mohammad Hossein; Shariati, Parvin; Houshmand, Massoud; Majidizadeh, Tayebeh; Soltani, Niloofar Jahangir; Golalipour, Massoud (2008). "Variation ofDAT1 VNTR Alleles and Genotypes Among Old Ethnic Groups in Mesopotamia to the Oxus Region". Human Biology. 80 (1): 73–81. JSTOR 41465951.
- Becker, Adam H. (2008). "The Ancient Near East in the Late Antique Near East: Syriac Christian Appropriation of the Biblical East". Antiquity in Antiquity: Jewish and Christian Pasts in the Greco-Roman World. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck. pp. 394–415. ISBN 9783161494116.
- Becker, Adam H. (2015). Revival and Awakening: American Evangelical Missionaries in Iran and the Origins of Assyrian Nationalism. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. ISBN 978-0226145280.
- Bedford, Peter R. (2009). "The Neo-Assyrian Empire". In Morris, Ian; Scheidel, Walter (eds.). The Dynamics of Ancient Empires: State Power from Assyria to Byzantium. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-537158-1.
- Benjamen, Alda (2022). Assyrians in Modern Iraq: Negotiating Political and Cultural Space. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1108838795.
- Biggs, Robert D. (2005). "My Career in Assyriology and Near Eastern Archaeology" (PDF). Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies. 19 (1): 1–23. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2008-02-27.
- Butts, Aaron Michael (2017). "Assyrian Christians". In E. Frahm (ed.). A Companion to Assyria. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118325247.
- Cameron, Averil (2009). The Byzantines. Oxford: John Wiley and Sons. ISBN 978-1-4051-9833-2.
- Cavalli-Sforza, Luigi Luca; Menozzi, Paolo & Piazza, Alberto (1994). The History and Geography of Human Genes. Princeton: Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-08750-4.
- Crone, Patricia; Cook, Michael A. (1977). Hagarism: The Making of the Islamic World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521211338.
- Deutscher, G. (2009). "Akkadian". Concise Encyclopedia of Languages of the World. Oxford: Elsevier. ISBN 978-0-08-087774-7.
- Dalley, Stephanie (1993). "Nineveh after 612 BC". Altorientalische Forschungen. 20 (1): 134–147. doi:10.1524/aofo.1993.20.1.134. S2CID 163383142.
- Donabed, Sargon (2012). "Rethinking Nationalism and an Appellative Conundrum: Historiography and Politics in Iraq". National Identities. 14 (4): 407–431. doi:10.1080/14608944.2012.733208.
- Donabed, Sargon (2019). "Persistent Perseverence: A Trajectory of Assyrian History in the Modern Age". In Rowe, Paul S. (ed.). Routledge Handbook of Minorities in the Middle East. London. ISBN 978-1138649040.
{{cite book}}
: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) - Düring, Bleda S. (2020). The Imperialisation of Assyria: An Archaeological Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1108478748.
- Efstathiadou, Anna (2011). "Representing Greekness: French and Greek Lithographs from the Greek War of Independence (1821–1827) and the Greek-Italian War (1940–1941)" (PDF). Journal of Modern Greek Studies. 29 (2): 191–218. doi:10.1353/mgs.2011.0023. S2CID 144506772.
- Filoni, Fernando (2017). The Church in Iraq. Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press. ISBN 978-0813229652.
- Frahm, Eckart (2017). "Introduction". In E. Frahm (ed.). A Companion to Assyria. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118325247.
- Frahm, Eckart (2017). "The Neo-Assyrian Period (ca. 1000–609 BCE)". In E. Frahm (ed.). A Companion to Assyria. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118325247.
- Frahm, Eckart (2017). "Assyria in the Hebrew Bible". In E. Frahm (ed.). A Companion to Assyria. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118325247.
- Frye, Richard N. (1999). "Reply to John Joseph" (PDF). Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies. 13 (1): 69–70. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2020-07-11.
- Gaunt, David; Atto, Naures; Barthoma, Soner O. (2017). Let Them Not Return: Sayfo – The Genocide Against the Assyrian, Syriac, and Chaldean Christians in the Ottoman Empire. New York: Berghahn. ISBN 978-1785334986.
- Gewargis, Odisho Malko (2002). "We Are Assyrians" (PDF). Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies. 16 (1): 77–95. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2003-04-21.
- Haider, Peter W. (2008). "Tradition and change in the beliefs at Assur, Nineveh and Nisibis between 300 BC and AD 300". In Kaizer, Ted (ed.). The Variety of Local Religious Life in the Near East: In the Hellenistic and Roman Periods. Leiden: BRILL. ISBN 978-9004167353.
- Harper, Prudence O.; Klengel-Brandt, Evelyn; Aruz, Joan; Benzel, Kim (1995). Assyrian Origins: Discoveries at Ashur on the Tigris: Antiquities in the Vorderasiatisches Museum, Berlin. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art. ISBN 0-87099-743-2.
- Hauser, Stefan R. (2017). "Post-Imperial Assyria". In E. Frahm (ed.). A Companion to Assyria. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118325247.
- Holloway, Steven W. (2003). "The Quest for Sargon, Pul and Tiglath-Pileser in the Nineteenth Century". In Chavalas, Mark W.; Younger, Jr, K. Lawson (eds.). Mesopotamia and the Bible. Edinburgh: A&C Black. ISBN 978-1-84127-252-8.
- Hitti, Philip K. (1951). History of Syria: Including Lebanon and Palestine. London: MacMillan. OCLC 5510718.
- Jackson, Cailah (2020). Islamic Manuscripts of Late Medieval Rum, 1270s-1370s: Production, Patronage and the Arts of the Book. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 978-1474451505.
- Jupp, James (2001). Australian People: An Encyclopedia of the Nation, its People and their Origins. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-80789-1.
- Kalimi, Isaac; Richardson, Seth (2014). "Sennacherib at the Gates of Jerusalem: Story, History and Historiography: An Introduction". In Kalimi, Isaac; Richardson, Seth (eds.). Sennacherib at the Gates of Jerusalem: Story, History and Historiography. Leiden: Brill Publishers. ISBN 978-9004265615.
- Kaufman, Stephen A. (1974). The Akkadian Influences on Aramaic. The Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago Assyriological Studies. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. ISBN 0-226-62281-9.
- Kuhrt, Amélie (1995). "The Assyrian heartland in the Achaemenid period". Pallas. Revue d'études antiques. 43: 239–254. JSTOR 43660582.
- Livingstone, Alasdair (2009). "Remembrance at Assur: The Case of the dated Aramaic memorials". Studia Orientalia Electronica. 106: 151–157.
- Luukko, Mikko; Van Buylaere, Greta (2017). "Languages and Writing Systems in Assyria". In E. Frahm (ed.). A Companion to Assyria. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118325247.
- Joshua J., Mark (2018). "Assyria". World History Encyclopedia. Retrieved 27 February 2022.
- Michel, Cécile (2017). "Economy, Society, and Daily Life in the Old Assyrian Period". In E. Frahm (ed.). A Companion to Assyria. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118325247.
- Minov, Sergey (2020). Memory and Identity in the Syriac Cave of Treasures: Rewriting the Bible in Sasanian Iran. Leiden: BRILL. ISBN 978-9004445505.
- Morrison, Susannah (2018). ""A Kindred Sigh for Thee": British Responses to the Greek War for Independence". The Thetean: A Student Journal for Scholarly Historical Writing. 47 (1): 37–55.
- Naby, Eden (2006). "Assyrian Nationalism in Iraq: Survival under Religious and Ethnic Threat". In Burszta, Wojciech J.; Kamusella, Tomasz & Wojchiechowski, Sebastian (eds.). Nationalisms Across the Globe: An Overview of Nationalisms in State-Endowed and Statless Nations, Volume II: the World. Bygoszcz: School of Humanities and Journalism. ISBN 83-87653-46-2.
- Nisan, Mordechai (2002). Minorities in the Middle East: A History of Struggle and Self-Expression (2nd ed.). Jefferson: McFarland. ISBN 978-0-7864-1375-1.
- Novák, Mirko (2016). "Assyrians and Arameans: Modes of Cohabitation and Acculuration at Guzana (Tell Halaf)". In Aruz, Joan; Seymour, Michael (eds.). Assyria to Iberia: Art and Culture in the Iron Age. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art. ISBN 978-1588396068.
- Parpola, Simo (1999). "Assyrians after Assyria". Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies. 13 (2).
- Parpola, Simo (2004). "National and Ethnic Identity in the Neo-Assyrian Empire and Assyrian Identity in Post-Empire Times" (PDF). Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies. 18 (2): 5–22.
- Payne, Richard (2012). "Avoiding Ethnicity: Uses of the Ancient Past in Late Sasanian Northern Mesopotamia". In Pohl, Walter; Gantner, Clemens; Payne, Richard (eds.). Visions of Community in the Post-Roman World: The West, Byzantium and the Islamic World, 300–1100. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing. ISBN 978-1409427094.
- Petrosian, Vahram (2006). "Assyrians in Iraq". Iran and the Caucasus. 10 (1): 138. doi:10.1163/157338406777979322. S2CID 154905506.
- Radner, Karen (2015). Ancient Assyria: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0198715900.
- Radner, Karen (2021). "Diglossia and the Neo-Assyrian Empire's Akkadian and Aramaic Text Production". In Jonker, Louis C.; Berlejung, Angelika & Cornelius, Izak (eds.). Multilingualism in Ancient Contexts: Perspectives from Ancient Near Eastern and Early Christian Contexts. Stellenbosch: African Sun Media. ISBN 978-1991201164.
- Reade, Julian E. (1998). "Greco-Parthian Nineveh". Iraq. 60: 65–83. doi:10.2307/4200453. JSTOR 4200453.
- Reade, Julian Edgeworth (2018). "Nineveh Rediscovered". In Brereton, Gareth (ed.). I am Ashurbanipal, king of the World, king of Assyria. London: Thames & Hudson. ISBN 978-0-500-48039-7.
- Rollinger, Robert (2006). "The Terms "Assyria" and "Syria" Again". Journal of Near Eastern Studies. 65 (4): 283–287. doi:10.1086/511103. JSTOR 10.1086/511103. S2CID 162760021.
- Roux, Georges (1992). Ancient Iraq. Penguin Books. ISBN 978-0140125238.
- Saggs, Henry W. F. (1984). The Might That Was Assyria. London: Sidgwick & Jackson. ISBN 9780312035112.
- Salem, Chris (24 December 2020). "A Name Chaldeans Forgot: Assyria". Medium. Retrieved 6 January 2022.
- Segal, Judah B. (1970). Edessa: The Blessed City. Oxford: Clarendon Press. ISBN 978-0-19-821545-5.
- Shehadeh, Lamia Rustum (2011). "The name of Syria in ancient and modern usage". In Beshara, Adel (ed.). The Origins of Syrian Nationhood: Histories, pioneers and identity. Oxford: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-61504-4.
- Smith, Sidney (1926). "Notes on "The Assyrian Tree"". Bulletin of the School of Oriental Studies, University of London. 4: 69–76. JSTOR 607403.
- Tamari, Steve (2019). "The Land of Syria in the Late Seventeenth Century: ʿAbd al-Ghani al-Nabulusi and Linking City and Countryside through Study, Travel, and Worship". In Tamari, Steve (ed.). Grounded Identities: Territory and Belonging in the Medieval and Early Modern Middle East and Mediterranean. Leiden: BRILL. ISBN 978-9004385337.
- Travis, Hannibal (2010). Genocide in the Middle East: The Ottoman Empire, Iraq, and Sudan. Durham: Carolina Academic Press. ISBN 978-1594604362.
- Trolle Larsen, Mogens (2017). "The Archaeological Exploration of Assyria". In E. Frahm (ed.). A Companion to Assyria. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118325247.
- Wilmshurst, David (2011). The martyred Church: A History of the Church of the East. London: East & West Publishing Limited. ISBN 9781907318047.
- Yildiz, Efrem (1999). "The Assyrians: A Historical and Current Reality". Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies. 13 (1): 15–30.