| Revision as of 15:37, 6 December 2007 editJingiby (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, New page reviewers62,422 edits A new source.← Previous edit | Revision as of 10:50, 30 January 2008 edit undoHegumen (talk | contribs)604 editsNo edit summaryNext edit → | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| {{For|the Byzantine Christian sect|Macedonianism}} | {{For|the Byzantine Christian sect|Macedonianism}} | ||
| '''Macedonism''' (] and ]: Македонизам, ]: Македонизъм, all ]: ''Makedonizam'') is a political term used to refer to a set of ideas |
'''Macedonism''' (] and ]: Македонизам, ]: Македонизъм, all ]: ''Makedonizam'') is a political term used to refer to a set of ideas perceived{{By who?}} as characteristic of ] ]. The term is mostly used in a ] sense by opponents of such views, mainly by ]<ref name=Genov>Nikolaĭ Genov, Anna Krŭsteva, (2001) ''Recent Social Trends in Bulgaria, 1960-1995'', </ref> and sometimes ] authors,<ref name=SMS>, ''Macedonianism FYROM'S Expansionist Designs against Greece, 1944-2006'', Ephesus - Society for Macedonian Studies, 2007 ISBN: 978-960-8326-30-9, Retrieved on ].</ref><ref name=Gillespie>Kentrotis, Kyriakos (1996): "Echoes from the Past: Greece and the Macedonian Controversy", in: Richard Gillespie (ed.) ''Mediterranean Politics'', Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, p. 85–101 </ref><ref>Evangelos Kofos (1994): "Remarks on FYROM 's new school textbooks" </ref> where it has strong ] connotations. It is occasionally also used in international scholarship,<ref name=Bell>John D. Bell, edited by Sabrina P Ramet - (1999) ''The Radical Right in Central and Eastern Europe Since 1989'', </ref> and in a positive sense in isolated examples from Macedonian authors themselves.<ref></ref><ref>The Macedonian (Old-New) Issue. Mirjana Maleska, Institute of Sociological and Political Research, Skopje, Macedonia. New Balkan Politics - Journal of Politics ISSUE 3. | ||
| </ref><ref name=Danforth>Example cited in: ] (1995), ''The Macedonian Conflict: ethnic nationalism in a transnational world'', </ref> | </ref><ref name=Danforth>Example cited in: ] (1995), ''The Macedonian Conflict: ethnic nationalism in a transnational world'', </ref> | ||
| ==Origins== | ==Origins== | ||
| The roots of the concept were first developed in the late 19th century, in the context of Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian initiatives to take control over the region of ], which was |
The roots of the concept were first developed in the late ], in the context of ], ] and ] initiatives to take control over the region of ], which was at that time ruled by the ]. It was originally used to refer to the idea that ] constituted a distinct ], separate from their neighbours. The first to use the term "Macedonist" was the ] author ], who coined the term in his article '']'', published in the newspaper ] in 1871, to criticise those Macedonians espousing such views. An early recorded use of the term "Macedonism" is found in a report by the ] politician ] from 1887. He proposed to employ the Macedonist ideology as a means to counteract the Bulgarian influence in Macedonia, thereby promoting Serbia's interests in the region.<ref>From the report of S. Novakovic to the Minister of Education in Belgrade about 'Macedonism' as a transitional stage in Serbianizing the Macedonian Bulgarians - BULGARIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES - Institute of History - Bulgarian Language Institute, MACEDONIA, DOCUMENTS AND MATERIALS - Sofia 1978. </ref> | ||
| {{cquote2|quotetext=''We have often heard from the Macedonists that they are not Bulgarians but Macedonians, descendants of the ], and have always waited to hear some proof of this, but have never heard it. The Macedonists have never shown us the basis for their beliefs. They insist on their Macedonian origin...''|personquoted=]|quotesource=<ref>]</ref>|quotewidth=##px|quoteheight=##px}} | |||
| ==Ideas== | ==Ideas== | ||
| Among the |
Among the views and opinions that are often perceived{{By who?}} as typical of Macedonian ] and are criticised as parts of "Macedonism" by those who use the term<ref>Representative of the anti-"Macedonist" criticism from the Bulgarian side is the work by ] (2003), '']'', Sofia.</ref> are the following: | ||
| *The idea that there is a fundamental, |
*The idea that there is a fundamental, ] distinction between Macedonians and Bulgarians, going back much further than the political divisions between the two nations during the 20th century; (see ]) | ||
| *The belief that this distinction is related to the inheritance of ethnic elements of the ancient non-Slavic tribe of the ], supposed to form an essential part of modern Bulgarian but not Macedonian heritage; (see ], ]) | *The belief that this distinction is related to the inheritance of ethnic elements of the ancient non-Slavic tribe of the ], supposed to form an essential part of modern Bulgarian but not Macedonian heritage; (see ], ]) | ||
| *The |
*The disputed level of racial continuity between the modern Macedonians and ancient autochthonous peoples of the region (i.e. ]); | ||
| *] political views about the neighbouring regions of ] ''("]")'' and parts of southwest ] ''("]")'' and about |
*] political views about the neighbouring regions of ] ''("]")'' and parts of southwest ] ''("]")'' and about ethnic Macedonian minorities living in these areas, connected to the political idea of a ]. | ||
| Other, related areas of |
Other, related areas of Macedonian–Bulgarian national polemics relate to: | ||
| * The presence of the ] in Medieval Macedonia and their connection |
* The presence of the ] in Medieval Macedonia and their connection to today's Macedonians; (see ]) | ||
| * The ethnic character of various medieval historical figures and entities, including the saints ] and ], the medieval Tsar ] and his kingdom, and the medieval ]; | * The ethnic character of various medieval historical figures and entities, including the saints ] and ], the medieval Tsar ] and his kingdom, and the medieval ]; | ||
| * The historical role of the ] and the ethnic character of ] |
* The historical role of the ] and the ethnic character of the ]; | ||
| *The historical role of various Macedonian insurgent movements during |
*The historical role of various Macedonian insurgent movements during ] rule (see ]) and during the Bulgarian occupation of Macedonia in ] (see ]); | ||
| *The opinion that a separate Macedonian nationhood was |
*The opinion that a separate Macedonian nationhood was the artificial product of a ] ] during the 20th century<ref>Minchev, Dimiter: "Macedonia and Bulgaria". In: B. A. Cook (ed.), ''Europe since 1945: An Encyclopedia'' Taylor and Francis, 2001. ISBN 0815340583, pg. 808.</ref> and the belief of some Bulgarians that Macedonians — for whatever reason — constitute a subgroup of the Bulgarian people. (see ]) | ||
| On the other hand, areas of |
On the other hand, areas of Macedonian–Greek national polemics relate to: | ||
| * The |
* The ] the ancient Macedonians and the ] of the ] and their relation to the contemporary ] and ]s and people. <ref>Tracing the script and the language of the Ancient Macedonian, Professor Tome Boshevski, Aristotel Tentov. </ref><ref>Ancient Macedonian Genes in the the Modern Macedonian Nation not-related to the Greek Nation </ref> (see ], ]) | ||
| ==Notes== | ==Notes== | ||
Revision as of 10:50, 30 January 2008
For the Byzantine Christian sect, see Macedonianism.Macedonism (Macedonian and Serbian: Македонизам, Bulgarian: Македонизъм, all transliterated: Makedonizam) is a political term used to refer to a set of ideas perceived as characteristic of ethnic Macedonian nationalism. The term is mostly used in a polemic sense by opponents of such views, mainly by Bulgarian and sometimes Greek authors, where it has strong pejorative connotations. It is occasionally also used in international scholarship, and in a positive sense in isolated examples from Macedonian authors themselves.
Origins
The roots of the concept were first developed in the late 19th century, in the context of Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian initiatives to take control over the region of Macedonia, which was at that time ruled by the Ottoman Empire. It was originally used to refer to the idea that Macedonians constituted a distinct ethnic group, separate from their neighbours. The first to use the term "Macedonist" was the Bulgarian author Petko Slaveykov, who coined the term in his article The Macedonian Question, published in the newspaper Makedoniya in 1871, to criticise those Macedonians espousing such views. An early recorded use of the term "Macedonism" is found in a report by the Serbian politician Stojan Novaković from 1887. He proposed to employ the Macedonist ideology as a means to counteract the Bulgarian influence in Macedonia, thereby promoting Serbia's interests in the region.
We have often heard from the Macedonists that they are not Bulgarians but Macedonians, descendants of the Ancient Macedonians, and have always waited to hear some proof of this, but have never heard it. The Macedonists have never shown us the basis for their beliefs. They insist on their Macedonian origin...
— Petko Slaveykov,
Ideas
Among the views and opinions that are often perceived as typical of Macedonian nationalism and are criticised as parts of "Macedonism" by those who use the term are the following:
- The idea that there is a fundamental, ethnogenetic distinction between Macedonians and Bulgarians, going back much further than the political divisions between the two nations during the 20th century; (see Identities of the ethnic Macedonians)
- The belief that this distinction is related to the inheritance of ethnic elements of the ancient non-Slavic tribe of the Bulgars, supposed to form an essential part of modern Bulgarian but not Macedonian heritage; (see Origins of the ethnic Macedonians, Ethnogenesis of the Bulgarians)
- The disputed level of racial continuity between the modern Macedonians and ancient autochthonous peoples of the region (i.e. Ancient Macedonians);
- Irridentist political views about the neighbouring regions of Greek Macedonia ("Aegean Macedonia") and parts of southwest Bulgaria ("Pirin Macedonia") and about ethnic Macedonian minorities living in these areas, connected to the political idea of a United Macedonia.
Other, related areas of Macedonian–Bulgarian national polemics relate to:
- The presence of the Bulgars in Medieval Macedonia and their connection to today's Macedonians; (see Kouber)
- The ethnic character of various medieval historical figures and entities, including the saints Cyril and Methodius, the medieval Tsar Samuil and his kingdom, and the medieval Archbishopric of Ohrid;
- The historical role of the Bulgarian Exarchate and the ethnic character of the Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organization;
- The historical role of various Macedonian insurgent movements during Ottoman rule (see Ilinden Uprising) and during the Bulgarian occupation of Macedonia in World War II (see National Liberation War of Macedonia);
- The opinion that a separate Macedonian nationhood was the artificial product of a Communist plot during the 20th century and the belief of some Bulgarians that Macedonians — for whatever reason — constitute a subgroup of the Bulgarian people. (see Demographic history of Macedonia)
On the other hand, areas of Macedonian–Greek national polemics relate to:
- The cultural identity the ancient Macedonians and the classification of the ancient Macedonian language and their relation to the contemporary Macedonian and Greek languages and people. (see Origins of the Greeks, The Arnaiz-Villena controversy)
Notes
- Nikolaĭ Genov, Anna Krŭsteva, (2001) Recent Social Trends in Bulgaria, 1960-1995, Page 74
- Society for Macedonian Studies, Macedonianism FYROM'S Expansionist Designs against Greece, 1944-2006, Ephesus - Society for Macedonian Studies, 2007 ISBN: 978-960-8326-30-9, Retrieved on 2007-12-05.
- Kentrotis, Kyriakos (1996): "Echoes from the Past: Greece and the Macedonian Controversy", in: Richard Gillespie (ed.) Mediterranean Politics, Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, p. 85–101
- Evangelos Kofos (1994): "Remarks on FYROM 's new school textbooks"
- John D. Bell, edited by Sabrina P Ramet - (1999) The Radical Right in Central and Eastern Europe Since 1989, Page 252
- The "Mi-An" encyclopedia - a great victory for Macedonism
- The Macedonian (Old-New) Issue. Mirjana Maleska, Institute of Sociological and Political Research, Skopje, Macedonia. New Balkan Politics - Journal of Politics ISSUE 3.
- Example cited in: Loring Danforth (1995), The Macedonian Conflict: ethnic nationalism in a transnational world, Page 45
- From the report of S. Novakovic to the Minister of Education in Belgrade about 'Macedonism' as a transitional stage in Serbianizing the Macedonian Bulgarians - BULGARIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES - Institute of History - Bulgarian Language Institute, MACEDONIA, DOCUMENTS AND MATERIALS - Sofia 1978.
- The Macedonian Question
- Representative of the anti-"Macedonist" criticism from the Bulgarian side is the work by Bozhidar Dimitrov (2003), The Ten Lies of Macedonism, Sofia.
- Minchev, Dimiter: "Macedonia and Bulgaria". In: B. A. Cook (ed.), Europe since 1945: An Encyclopedia Taylor and Francis, 2001. ISBN 0815340583, pg. 808.
- Tracing the script and the language of the Ancient Macedonian, Professor Tome Boshevski, Aristotel Tentov.
- Ancient Macedonian Genes in the the Modern Macedonian Nation not-related to the Greek Nation