Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 03:16, 5 November 2006

This article is about the philosophical concept and literary form. For the Half-Life 2 mod, see Dystopia (computer game). For the Crust Punk band, see Dystopia (band)

You must add a |reason= parameter to this Cleanup template – replace it with {{Cleanup|September 2006|reason=<Fill reason here>}}, or remove the Cleanup template.
A dystopia (alternatively, cacotopia, kakotopia or anti-utopia) is a fictional society that is the antithesis of utopia.

A dystopia is usually characterized by an authoritarian or totalitarian form of government, or some other kind of oppressive social control.

In some academic circles, anti-utopia and dystopia have subtly different meanings. A dystopia is an utterly bad place with no pretense of being good. An anti-utopia is a place that seems to be utopian or which was originally intended to be utopian but has a fatal flaw or has been perverted to be the opposite.

Origin of the word

The use of the word has been credited to John Stuart Mill in 1868, whose knowledge of Greek would suggest that he meant it as a place where things are bad, rather than simply the opposite of Utopia. Dystopia is from the Greek prefix "dys" ("δυσ-") prefix signifying "ill", "bad" or "abnormal" and Greek "topos" ("τόπος") which means "place". The Greek "ou-" ("ου") means "not". So, Utopia means "nowhere", and is a pun on "Eutopia" meaning "happy place" - the prefix "eu" means "well".

Common traits of a dystopian society

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Find sources: "Dystopia" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (Learn how and when to remove this message)

The overwhelming majority of dystopias have some connection to our world, but often in an imagined future or an alternate history. Furthermore, the dystopia was brought about as a result of human action or inaction, whether stemming from human evil or mere stupidity. A far distant future where the heat death of the universe makes human life difficult is not dystopian, as human beings are not responsible for entropy.

Dystopian societies usually exhibit one or more of the traits on the following list:

• A Utopian society with at least one fatal flaw.
• An apparently Utopian society, free of poverty, disease, conflict, and even unhappiness. Scratching the surface of the society, however, reveals exactly the opposite. The exact problem, the way the problem is suppressed, and the chronology of the problem form the central conflict of the story.
• Social stratification, where social class is strictly defined and enforced, and social mobility is non-existent (see caste system). See, for example, Brave New World's prenatally designated Alphas, Betas, Gammas, Deltas, and Epsilons.
• A nation-state ruled by an upper class with few, or no, democratic ideals. Note that non-democractic societies are commonplace in historical fiction, fantasies taking place in historical settings or fantasy worlds, and in science fiction, particularly in planetary romance and galactic empires, but few of these societies are regarded as dystopian. In these cases, the hierarchical structure is a result of economic and social forces implicit in the society. The lack of democracy becomes a dystopian feature when the government is clearly imposed by force on a citizenry capable of self-government, particularly when the government hold some pretense of democratic ideals, as when children of the Party members in 1984 are admitted to the Party based on a test, while non-Party members' children simply vanish if it appears they would pass the test.
• Conversely, a ruthlessly egalitarian society, in which ability and accomplishment, or even competence, are suppressed or stigmatized as forms of inequality, as in Kurt Vonnegut's "Harrison Bergeron".
• A bloated welfare state, in which total freedom from responsibility has encouraged an underclass prone to any form of antisocial behavior, and productive contributors to society, particularly those trying to escape the underclass, are burdened with taxes punitive in effect, if not intent.
• Total control by the state of all economic activity. Private ownership may still exist, but the owners are controlled by the state. Black markets may exist, or not, but on the whole, freedom to engage in economic activities is severely limited in these dystopias, which may suppress any form of innovation as disruption, as in Ayn Rand's Anthem.
• A totally or near-totally socially privatized world without a democratic republican state or with a state that only serves the business sector - business and private contractors own and control all of society and social organization, as in the movie Blade Runner, the novel Snow Crash and other Cyberpunk literature, and the Judge Dredd series. There are usually many "small dictators" - essentially competing corporations and robber barons instead of one leader, with either a single police force that makes sure the system runs smoothly, or many small police forces hired by each corporation. Individuals with no wealth or social power are suppressed and miserable.
• State propaganda programs and educational systems that scare most citizens into worshipping the state and its government, in an attempt to convince them to believe that life under the regime is good and just, e.g. Alan Moore's V for Vendetta.
• Strict conformity among citizens and a general assumption that dissent and individuality are bad, as in We, where people are permitted to live out of public view for only an hour a day, and are not only referred to by numbers instead of names, but are neither "citizens" nor "people", but "numbers."
• A state figurehead that people worship fanatically through a vast personality cult, such as Nineteen Eighty-Four's Big Brother, We's The Benefactor, or Equilibrium's Father.
• Deliberately engineered break-down of family ties, as in 1984, where children are organized to spy on their parents and Brave New World where children are reproduced artificially and "mother" is obscene.
• Promiscious sexuality and lack of ideals of romantic love, as in Brave New World where Lenina Crowne confesses to having sexual intercourse with only one man and is encouraged by her friend to be more promiscious, and We, where "numbers" (people) are allowed sexual intercourse with any other number by registering for access.
• Fear of, or disgust at, the world outside the state.
• A common view of traditional life as primitive and nonsensical.
• Alternatively, complete domination by a state religion, e.g., The Republic of Gilead in The Handmaid's Tale, the Sisterhood of Metacontrol in FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions, the Technopriests in The Incal or fundamentalist Christianity (with elements of reconstructionism) in Escape from L.A..
• The "memory" of institutions overriding, or taking precedence over, human memory.
• A penal system that lacks due process laws and often employs psychological and/or physical torture, e.g. Alan Moore's V for Vendetta.
• A lack of the key essentials of life for many citizens, as with food shortages, e.g. Soylent Green. If the cause of this is clear, it is not natural disaster or crop failure, but deliberate engineering.
• Constant surveillance by governments or other agencies.
• Absence, or total co-option, of an educated middle class (such as teachers, journalists, and scientists) who might criticize the regime's leadership.
• Militarized police forces and private security forces.
• The banishment of the natural world from daily life, as when walks are regarded as dangerously anti-social in Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451.
• Construction of fictional views of reality that the populace is coerced into believing.
• Corruption, impotence, or other usurpation of democratic institutions.
• Conversely, a strict majoritarian democracy, which tramples on the rights of minorities, or continually sacrifices the well-being of society to maintain the majority rule, or both.
• Fictional rivalries between groups that actually operate as a cartel.
• Insistence by the establishment that:
  • It provides the best of all possible worlds, e.g. Voltaire's Candide;
  • All problems are due to the action of its enemies and their dupes.
• An overall slow decay of all systems (political, economic, religion, infrastructure. . .), resulting from people being alienated from nature, the State, society, family, and themselves. Yesterday was better, tomorrow will be worse.
• A figurehead or puppet which may be non-existent. This figurehead is either a crowd-pleaser who is sympathetic to the working man, or a patriotic figure who hawks the virtues of the State or the ruling class, and riles up the people by reminding them that their enemies will kill them in their sleep and destroy their home, unless every citizen gives 110%.

In dystopian societies, the economic system centers on stability and is structured so that the government or the economic system is immune to change or disruption. Usually, the industries operate at maximum efficiency and capacity, and then the excess products or currency is absorbed in some way by the state. In Nineteen Eighty-Four, people are put on rations, and excess production is absorbed in the "war" that is always occurring with either Eurasia or Eastasia. In Brave New World, excess production is sucked by extreme consumerism, encouraged by the government. In the One State depicted in We, there is no currency or exchange whatsoever, either inside or outside the walls of the society, but everything is provided to the people.

Traits of dystopian fiction

Many films and literature featuring dystopian societies exhibit at least a few of the following traits: Template:Spoiler

• A selectively-told back story of a war, revolution, uprising, spike in overpopulation, natural disaster or some other climactic event which resulted in dramatic changes to society
• A standard of living among the lower and middle class that is generally poorer than in contemporary society. This is not always the case, however — in Brave New World and Equilibrium, people enjoy much higher material living standards in exchange for the loss of other qualities in their lives, such as independent thought and emotional depth.
• A protagonist who questions the society, often feeling intuitively that something is terribly wrong, such as Winston Smith in Nineteen Eighty-Four, or V from Alan Moore's V for Vendetta.
  • This knowledge must play into the story's chief conflict being the protagonist with the society. When the society, however bad, is the background against which the protagonist's drama is played, or where the protagonist, though aware the society is bad, regards other individuals in the society as his opponents, the work is generally not dystopian fiction. The character must realize, however vaguely, that their problems are not individual but part of the social structure they are in, and attempt to engage that source of their difficulties.
  • Unlike utopian fiction, which often features an outsider to have the world shown him, dystopias seldom feature an outsider as the protagonist. While such a character would more clearly understand the nature of the society, based on comparison with his own, the knowledge of the outside culture subverts the power of the dystopia. When such outsiders are major characters -- such as John the Savage in Brave New World, their societies are not such as can assist them against the dystopia.
• Necessarily, if it is based on our world, a shift in emphasis of control, e.g. to corporations, autocratic cliques or bureaucracies.
• Because dystopian literature typically depicts events that take place in the future, it often features technology more advanced than that of contemporary society. Usually, the advanced technology is controlled exclusively by the group in power, while the oppressed population is limited to technology comparable to or more primitive than what we have today.
• For the reader to engage with it, dystopian fiction typically has one other trait: familiarity. It is not enough to show people living in a society that seems unpleasant. The society must have echoes of today, of the reader's own experience. If the reader can identify the patterns or trends that would lead to the dystopia, it becomes a more involving and effective experience. Authors can use a dystopia effectively to highlight their own concerns about societal trends. For example, Ayn Rand wrote Anthem as a warning against what she saw as the subordination of individual human beings to the state or "the We." Margaret Atwood wrote The Handmaid's Tale as a warning against the rise of religious fundamentalist totalitarianism in the United States and the hypocrisy of 1970s feminism actually aiding the cause of their worst enemies.

• Dystopian fiction is often (but not always) unresolved. That is, the narrative may deal with individuals in a dystopian society who are unsatisfied, and may rebel, but ultimately fail to change anything. Sometimes they themselves end up changed to conform to the society's norms. This narrative arc to a sense of hopelessness in such classic dystopian works as Nineteen Eighty-Four. It contrasts with much fiction of the future, in which a hero succeeds in resolving conflicts or otherwise changing things for the better.

• There is usually a group of people somewhere in the society who are not under the complete control of the state, and in whom the hero of the novel usually puts his or her hope, although he or she still fails to change anything. In Nineteen Eighty-Four by George Orwell they are the "proles" (short for "proletariat"), in Brave New World by Aldous Huxley they are the people on the reservation, and in We by Zamyatin they are the people outside the walls of the One State. In Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury, they are the "book people" past the river and outside the city.

• The destruction of dystopia is frequently a very different sort of work than one in which is it preserved. Poul Anderson's short story "Sam Hall" depicts the subversion of a dystopia heavily dependent on surveillance. Robert A. Heinlein's "If This Goes On—" liberates the United States from a fundamentalist theocracy, where the underground rebellion is organized by the Freemasons. Cordwainer Smith's The Rediscovery of Man series depicts a society recovering from its dystopian period, beginning in "The Dead Lady of Clown Town" with the discovery that its utopia was impossible to maintain. Although these and other societies are typical of dystopias in many ways, they all have not only flaws but exploitable flaws. The ability of the protagonists to subvert the society also subverts the monolithic power typical of a dystopia.

• If destruction is not possible, escape may be, if the dystopia does not control the world. In Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451, the main character succeeds in fleeing and finding tramps who have dedicated themselves to memorizing books to preserve them. In the book Logan's Run, the main characters make their way to an escape from the otherwise inevitable euthanasia on their 21st birthday (30th in the later film version). Because such dystopias must necessarily control less of the world than the protagonist can reach, and the protagonist can elude capture, this motif also subverts the dystopia's power. In Lois Lowry's The Giver the main character Jonas is able to run away from 'The Community' and escapes to 'Elsewhere' where people have memories.

• Sometimes, this escape leads to the inevitable: The protagonist making a mistake that usually brings about the end of a/n rebel society, usually living where people think is a story. This concept is brought to life in Scott Westerfeld's novel Uglies. The main character accidentally brings the government into the secret settlement of the Smoke. She then infiltrates the government to escape, but chooses to join the society for the greater good.

• Occasionally, the escape from dystopia is made possible by time travel and changing history. Marge Piercy's Woman on the Edge of Time, though chiefly concerned with the protagonist's time-travel to a future utopia, also has her travel to a dystopia, and in the current time, stymies the efforts that will lead to that future. Poul Anderson's The Corridors of Time has a protagonist recruited by one future society to fight another, dystopian one; learning that both societies are dystopian (in very different ways), he acts to prevent either one gaining the upper hand in their time-traveling wars, enabling the future emergence of a utopian state. In its time, such a dystopia can be quite as powerful as any other. However, the time travel necessarily moves portions of the story, and usually quite large portions, out of the time of the dystopia, making it less an overwhelming presence in the novel.

Template:Endspoiler

Criticism of the concept of dystopias

Just as some modern philosophers, political theorists, and writers have dismissed ideas of perfect societies or "utopias", many have also expressed skepticism regarding the likelihood of a real-life dystopia of the kind described by Orwell and others. Although there have been many absolutist states in human history, Gregg Easterbrook and others have argued that such societies tend to rapidly self-destruct or be destroyed by neighbors. Dictatorships and similar regimes tend to be short-lived, as their policies and actions are almost continually leading to the creation of new potential opponents. For example, the killing or "disappearance" of critics and activists only serves to anger their family or friends, who in turn continue the struggle against the regime.

Depictions of dystopias in various media

Dystopias are a common theme in many kinds of fiction. The lists linked below contain extensive lists of works with dystopian themes.

• List of dystopian comics
• List of dystopian literature
• List of dystopian films
• List of dystopian music, TV programs, and games

See also

• Utopia
• Utopian and dystopian fiction
• Social science fiction
• Apocalyptic and post-apocalyptic science fiction
• Soft science fiction
• Fable
• Cyberpunk

References

1. Cacotopia (caco = bad) was the term used by Jeremy Bentham in his 19th century works (, , )
2. Random House's Word of the Day clarifies the technical differences between dystopia and anti-utopia.
3. John Stuart Mill uses the term dystopia in a parliamentary speech, possibly the first recorded use of the term. Exploring Dystopia, last accessed on 19th March 2006, see also

• Dystopian fiction
• Literary concepts
• Postmodernism
• Social philosophy
• Science fiction themes