Revision as of 18:26, 19 May 2024 view sourceDreamy Jazz (talk | contribs)Edit filter managers, Autopatrolled, Checkusers, Administrators105,825 edits →Persistent WP:IDONTLIKEIT behavior in WP:NCROY discussions: Removing request for arbitration: Declined by the committeeTag: Replaced← Previous edit | Revision as of 07:01, 16 June 2024 view source Kaalakaa (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users2,759 editsNo edit summaryNext edit → | ||
Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
{{Misplaced Pages:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Header<noinclude>|width=auto</noinclude>}} | {{Misplaced Pages:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Header<noinclude>|width=auto</noinclude>}} | ||
<noinclude>__TOC__</noinclude> | <noinclude>__TOC__</noinclude> | ||
== Anachronist == | |||
'''Initiated by ''' — ] ] '''at''' 07:01, 16 June 2024 (UTC) | |||
=== Proposed parties === | |||
<!-- Please change "userlinks" to "admin" if the party is an administrator --> | |||
*{{userlinks|Kaalakaa}}, ''filing party'' | |||
*{{admin|Anachronist}} | |||
*{{admin|Cullen328}} | |||
*{{admin|Jayron32}} | |||
*{{userlinks|AndyTheGrump}} | |||
;Confirmation that all parties are aware of the request | |||
<!-- All parties must be notified that the request has been filed, immediately after it is posted, and confirmation posted here. --> | |||
* | |||
* | |||
* | |||
* | |||
;Confirmation that other steps in ] have been tried | |||
<!-- Identify prior attempts at dispute resolution here, with links/diffs to the page where the resolution took place. If prior dispute resolution has not been attempted, the reasons for this should be explained in the request for arbitration --> | |||
*Link 1 | |||
*Link 2 | |||
=== Statement by Kaalakaa === | |||
Anachronist, as an admin, seems to have some chronic issues with understanding our policies and guidelines. | |||
* Previously, on 3 August 2023 , Anachronist, citing ], claimed that you don't need to cite sources for content based on your own observations in a museum . His arguments were refuted by Cullen328 and Jayron32 . Jayron32 particularly told Anachronist, "{{tq|Please stop confusing the new users here, and if you can't speak knowledgeably on this stuff, please stop.}}" | |||
* On 3 September 2033, Anachronist reverted my edit with an edit summary "{{tq|This has nothing to do with censorship, but with WP:BURDEN}}" . So I opened a discussion and provided him with a quote from the source, but Anachronist said, "{{tq|I am not arguing that the statement was unsourced. I am saying that for a biography, we don't need to put undue emphasis on analysis of statements of faith.}}" This reply of his, in my opinion, has no relevancy with ], and displays his misunderstanding of the policy. | |||
* In November 2023, on his talk page, Anachronist was involved in an argument with AndytheGrump about a book published by University Press . AndytheGrump appeared to be planning to take Anachronist to ArbCom to request that he be desysopped, stating: "{{tq|you seem so clearly intent on misinterpreting multiple policies in order to exclude a legitimate academic source from a contentious article on entirely spurious grounds.}}" At the end of the section, Anachronist said, "{{tq|I'm going to sleep now. A dispute over content should be continued on the article talk page. I'll look for it tomorrow.}}" However, Anachronist did not reply again on that article's talk page . | |||
* On 26 February 2024, the arbitrators pointed out that Anachronist's understanding of ] was incorrect. . | |||
* Recently, Anachronist used ] to support his arguments , but it turns out the essay was written only by himself. It contains many extraordinary claims about university presses, but many of them are not supported by reliable sources. The essay also seems to contradict our ] policy, which states that "{{tq|books published by university presses}}" are among "{{tq|the most reliable sources.}}" Within the essay, he also describes Russ Rodgers, a command historian of the US Army and former adjunct professor of history, as a hobbyist historian. | |||
=== Statement by Anachronist === | |||
=== Statement by Cullen328 === | |||
=== Statement by Jayron32 === | |||
=== Statement by AndyTheGrump === | |||
=== Statement by {Non-party} === | |||
Other editors are free to make relevant comments on this request as necessary. Comments here should address why or why not the Committee should accept the case request or provide additional information. | |||
<!-- * Please copy this section for the next person. * --> | |||
=== Anachronist: Clerk notes === | |||
:''This area is used for notes by the clerks (including clerk recusals).'' | |||
* | |||
=== Anachronist: Arbitrators' opinion on hearing this matter <0/0/0> === | |||
{{anchor|1=Anachronist: Arbitrators' opinion on hearing this matter}}<small>Vote key: (Accept/decline/recuse)</small> | |||
* |
Revision as of 07:01, 16 June 2024
"WP:ARC" redirects here. For a guide on talk page archiving, see H:ARC.Shortcut
Requests for arbitration
Arbitration Committee proceedings- recent changes
- purge this page
- view or discuss this template
Request name | Motions | Initiated | Votes |
---|---|---|---|
Anachronist | 16 June 2024 | 0/0/0 |
Case name | Links | Evidence due | Prop. Dec. due |
---|---|---|---|
Palestine-Israel articles 5 | (t) (ev / t) (ws / t) (pd / t) | 21 Dec 2024 | 11 Jan 2025 |
No cases have recently been closed (view all closed cases).
Clarification and Amendment requestsCurrently, no requests for clarification or amendment are open.
Arbitrator motionsMotion name | Date posted |
---|---|
Arbitrator workflow motions | 1 December 2024 |
Shortcuts
About this page Use this page to request the committee open an arbitration case. To be accepted, an arbitration request needs 4 net votes to "accept" (or a majority). Arbitration is a last resort. WP:DR lists the other, escalating processes that should be used before arbitration. The committee will decline premature requests. Requests may be referred to as "case requests" or "RFARs"; once opened, they become "cases". Before requesting arbitration, read the arbitration guide to case requests. Then click the button below. Complete the instructions quickly; requests incomplete for over an hour may be removed. Consider preparing the request in your userspace. To request enforcement of an existing arbitration ruling, see Misplaced Pages:Arbitration/Requests/Enforcement. To clarify or change an existing arbitration ruling, see Misplaced Pages:Arbitration/Requests/Clarification and Amendment.
Guidance on participation and word limits Unlike many venues on Misplaced Pages, ArbCom imposes word limits. Please observe the below notes on complying with word limits.
General guidance
|
Anachronist
Initiated by — Kaalakaa at 07:01, 16 June 2024 (UTC)
Proposed parties
- Kaalakaa (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log), filing party
- Anachronist (talk · contribs · blocks · protections · deletions · page moves · rights · RfA)
- Cullen328 (talk · contribs · blocks · protections · deletions · page moves · rights · RfA)
- Jayron32 (talk · contribs · blocks · protections · deletions · page moves · rights · RfA)
- AndyTheGrump (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log)
- Confirmation that all parties are aware of the request
- Confirmation that other steps in dispute resolution have been tried
- Link 1
- Link 2
Statement by Kaalakaa
Anachronist, as an admin, seems to have some chronic issues with understanding our policies and guidelines.
- Previously, on 3 August 2023 , Anachronist, citing WP:BLUESKY, claimed that you don't need to cite sources for content based on your own observations in a museum . His arguments were refuted by Cullen328 and Jayron32 . Jayron32 particularly told Anachronist, "
Please stop confusing the new users here, and if you can't speak knowledgeably on this stuff, please stop.
"
- On 3 September 2033, Anachronist reverted my edit with an edit summary "
This has nothing to do with censorship, but with WP:BURDEN
" . So I opened a discussion and provided him with a quote from the source, but Anachronist said, "I am not arguing that the statement was unsourced. I am saying that for a biography, we don't need to put undue emphasis on analysis of statements of faith.
" This reply of his, in my opinion, has no relevancy with WP:BURDEN, and displays his misunderstanding of the policy.
- In November 2023, on his talk page, Anachronist was involved in an argument with AndytheGrump about a book published by University Press . AndytheGrump appeared to be planning to take Anachronist to ArbCom to request that he be desysopped, stating: "
you seem so clearly intent on misinterpreting multiple policies in order to exclude a legitimate academic source from a contentious article on entirely spurious grounds.
" At the end of the section, Anachronist said, "I'm going to sleep now. A dispute over content should be continued on the article talk page. I'll look for it tomorrow.
" However, Anachronist did not reply again on that article's talk page .
- On 26 February 2024, the arbitrators pointed out that Anachronist's understanding of WP:ARBECR was incorrect. .
- Recently, Anachronist used this essay to support his arguments , but it turns out the essay was written only by himself. It contains many extraordinary claims about university presses, but many of them are not supported by reliable sources. The essay also seems to contradict our WP:OR policy, which states that "
books published by university presses
" are among "the most reliable sources.
" Within the essay, he also describes Russ Rodgers, a command historian of the US Army and former adjunct professor of history, as a hobbyist historian.
Statement by Anachronist
Statement by Cullen328
Statement by Jayron32
Statement by AndyTheGrump
Statement by {Non-party}
Other editors are free to make relevant comments on this request as necessary. Comments here should address why or why not the Committee should accept the case request or provide additional information.
Anachronist: Clerk notes
- This area is used for notes by the clerks (including clerk recusals).
Anachronist: Arbitrators' opinion on hearing this matter <0/0/0>-Anachronist">
Vote key: (Accept/decline/recuse)