| Revision as of 16:01, 15 January 2002 view sourceSJK (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers6,145 editsNo edit summary← Previous edit | Revision as of 17:53, 15 January 2002 view source Lee Daniel Crocker (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users4,417 editsNo edit summaryNext edit → | ||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
| I recall reading several works arguing that Nazism was not a form of fascism, due to its emphasis on race, which was largely absent from other forms of fascism (such as the Italian or Spanish). Also, some mention should be made of French fascism (and I mean the native French fascist movement, not the Vichy government), since although it was unsuccessful I believe it is theoretically important. Some discussion is needed of exactly what fascism is -- the present article just defines it as the political systeme existing under Mussolini, and then says the system was exported to Spain and Nazi Germany -- it needs rather to explain what the features of fascism are (such as nationalism, anti-democratic emphasis on leadership, corporatism). Finally, some mention of fascist philosophers such as Gentile, and also Gabrielle D'Annunzio as a precursor in part of fascism (although the political, as opposed to literary, activity of D'Annunzio is an absolutely fascinating topic in himself, on which unfortunately way too information seems to be available in English). -- ] | I recall reading several works arguing that Nazism was not a form of fascism, due to its emphasis on race, which was largely absent from other forms of fascism (such as the Italian or Spanish). Also, some mention should be made of French fascism (and I mean the native French fascist movement, not the Vichy government), since although it was unsuccessful I believe it is theoretically important. Some discussion is needed of exactly what fascism is -- the present article just defines it as the political systeme existing under Mussolini, and then says the system was exported to Spain and Nazi Germany -- it needs rather to explain what the features of fascism are (such as nationalism, anti-democratic emphasis on leadership, corporatism). Finally, some mention of fascist philosophers such as Gentile, and also Gabrielle D'Annunzio as a precursor in part of fascism (although the political, as opposed to literary, activity of D'Annunzio is an absolutely fascinating topic in himself, on which unfortunately way too information seems to be available in English). -- ] | ||
| ---- | |||
| Commentary removed from article and placed here: | |||
| ''The following text is apparently written from a pro-Fascist point of view, and needs re-editing for NPOV:'': | |||
| '' - sorry, my father was one of those soldiers condemned to death by RSI, so you can imagine I can allow myself no identification at all with fascism. | |||
| As anyone who suffered from violence, I am not able to consider sponsoring a political position, whatever it be. | |||
| However, facts are facts, as written in my premise, and understanding this site as more objective rather than ideological, <u>with no sympathy to fascism</u> I felt I had to add some points for a better comprehension of the fenomenon, and I did it, I dared. | |||
| I'm not depositary of any truth, so please take it as a simple adding of single facts, but please, do not call me pro-fascist. THX | |||
| Greetings, Gianfranco, Rome - '' | |||
Revision as of 17:53, 15 January 2002
The governement of Horthy was not fascist!
Fascism was installed by Szálasi government for a short period of time!
http://historicaltextarchive.com/horthy/
Questions that need to be answered by the article
What governments were self-described fascist? Only Mussolini, or did others lay claim?
What are some other specific elements of fascism (especially something specific to fascism and not, say, Nazism, or is Nazism encompassed by fascism)?? The Roman-style stiff-arm salute is engagingly specific.
The latter parts of this article appear startlingly pro-fascist. They appear to be written by 151.24.189.xxx, apparently a non-native English speaker (perhaps Italian?). They are certainly not NPOV! -- The Anome
- Yikes! Where is Fellini (or is it Phellini?) when you need him? I agree that there are serious NPOV issues here. For one thing, many Italians opposed fascism. Moreover, any account of the appeal of fascism in the 1930s has to provide a lot more context. There was indeed a global economic crisis and people in different countries were struggling to find ways out. I have no doubt that fascism benefited some people, but any discussion of Italian fascism has to explore who it did and didn't benefit, and explore its limitations. Was fascism just about getting the trains to run on time, or was it also about bombing Ethiopia? Should this new section be removed to the talk section until it is rewritten? SR
I recall reading several works arguing that Nazism was not a form of fascism, due to its emphasis on race, which was largely absent from other forms of fascism (such as the Italian or Spanish). Also, some mention should be made of French fascism (and I mean the native French fascist movement, not the Vichy government), since although it was unsuccessful I believe it is theoretically important. Some discussion is needed of exactly what fascism is -- the present article just defines it as the political systeme existing under Mussolini, and then says the system was exported to Spain and Nazi Germany -- it needs rather to explain what the features of fascism are (such as nationalism, anti-democratic emphasis on leadership, corporatism). Finally, some mention of fascist philosophers such as Gentile, and also Gabrielle D'Annunzio as a precursor in part of fascism (although the political, as opposed to literary, activity of D'Annunzio is an absolutely fascinating topic in himself, on which unfortunately way too information seems to be available in English). -- SJK
Commentary removed from article and placed here:
The following text is apparently written from a pro-Fascist point of view, and needs re-editing for NPOV::
- sorry, my father was one of those soldiers condemned to death by RSI, so you can imagine I can allow myself no identification at all with fascism.
As anyone who suffered from violence, I am not able to consider sponsoring a political position, whatever it be.
However, facts are facts, as written in my premise, and understanding this site as more objective rather than ideological, with no sympathy to fascism I felt I had to add some points for a better comprehension of the fenomenon, and I did it, I dared.
I'm not depositary of any truth, so please take it as a simple adding of single facts, but please, do not call me pro-fascist. THX
Greetings, Gianfranco, Rome -