| Revision as of 16:04, 17 September 2012 editMystichumwipe (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users2,132 edits →Problems identified in Mr. Avey's different accounts: refs← Previous edit | Revision as of 17:44, 17 September 2012 edit undoLight show (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers30,726 edits Restored to last version by User:86.139.163.210 due to excessive OR, erroneous citations added to statements, and [[WP:Undue|over-reliance and undue weight to Guy Walters essay.Next edit → | ||
| Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
| '''Denis Avey''' (born 1919) fought in the desert during the Second World War and was captured and held as a prisoner of war for two years near Auschwitz III, a concentration camp. He says that during his imprisonment he exchanged uniforms with a Jewish prisoner and smuggled himself into Auschwitz to witness conditions first hand. | '''Denis Avey''' (born 1919) fought in the desert during the Second World War and was captured and held as a prisoner of war for two years near Auschwitz III, a concentration camp. He says that during his imprisonment he exchanged uniforms with a Jewish prisoner and smuggled himself into Auschwitz to witness conditions first hand. | ||
| In 2010 he received a ] award for having saved the life of a Jewish prisoner by smuggling cigarettes to him. <ref> www.ex-bbc.net/Ariel/Arielwk11.2010.pdf </ref> He has written of his accounts, with Rob Broomby, in his book, '']'', published in 2011. A decade earlier, he described his personal life and war experiences in an interview with the ] in London.<ref>, Imperial War Museum, London, UK, July 16, 2001</ref> That interview, Avey states, was the "catalyst" that brought him, after 60 years of silent "anguish," to talk of that experience: "I began to weep - for the first time since the war. From then on, I could remain silent no longer, because I want my story to make a difference."<ref name=Welt2/> |
In 2010 he received a ] award for having saved the life of a Jewish prisoner by smuggling cigarettes to him. <ref> www.ex-bbc.net/Ariel/Arielwk11.2010.pdf </ref> He has written of his accounts, with Rob Broomby, in his book, '']'', published in 2011. A decade earlier, he described his personal life and war experiences in an interview with the ] in London.<ref>, Imperial War Museum, London, UK, July 16, 2001</ref> That interview, Avey states, was the "catalyst" that brought him, after 60 years of silent "anguish," to talk of that experience: "I began to weep - for the first time since the war. From then on, I could remain silent no longer, because I want my story to make a difference."<ref name=Welt2/> | ||
| But problems with the details of his story and differences in his account in the book to those of his interviews and talks have been raised. The whole account has been doubted by among others Piotr Setkiewicz, the head of research at the Auschwitz-Birkenau memorial and museum, who has said: "Theoretically it is possible to do such a thing, but for practical reasons it would be extremely difficult. It is a question of confirmation, and I can't see any way to confirm Mr. Avey's story. Nevertheless, privately, I don't think this (the swap) happened.<ref name=Collett-White>{{cite news|title=Veteran defends disputed story of Auschwitz heroics|first=Mike|last=Collett-White|date=26 April 2011|accessdate=17 September 2012|publisher=]|url=http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/04/26/arts-auschwitz-book-idUSLDE73P12520110426}}</ref>" | |||
| ==Early years and military service== | ==Early years and military service== | ||
| Line 86: | Line 84: | ||
| ==Reactions and questions== | ==Reactions and questions== | ||
| Reaction from the mainstream media to his story 2009 and 2010 was positive. However after publication of the book questions were raised over his account of having entered Auschwitz III and his reasons for keeping silent for so long<ref name=Mail2/><ref>http://www.faz.net/artikel/C30870/umstrittenes-buch-schoa-zum-anfassen-30337614.html</ref><ref>http://www.standaard.be/artikel/detail.aspx?artikelid=6M3ANGGI§ionid=ab8d3fd8-bf2f-487a-818b-9ea546e9a859</ref> One historian states that Avey's story was problematic partly because it was impossible to prove or disprove. "Theoretically it is possible to do such a thing, but for practical reasons it would be extremely difficult," he said. |
Reaction from the mainstream media to his story 2009 and 2010 was positive. However after publication of the book questions were raised over his account of having entered Auschwitz III and his reasons for keeping silent for so long<ref name=Mail2/><ref>http://www.faz.net/artikel/C30870/umstrittenes-buch-schoa-zum-anfassen-30337614.html</ref><ref>http://www.standaard.be/artikel/detail.aspx?artikelid=6M3ANGGI§ionid=ab8d3fd8-bf2f-487a-818b-9ea546e9a859</ref> One historian states that Avey's story was problematic partly because it was impossible to prove or disprove. "Theoretically it is possible to do such a thing, but for practical reasons it would be extremely difficult," he said.<ref> , ''Reuters'', April 26, 2011</ref> The World Jewish Congress has asked his publishers to verify the historical accuracy of the book.<ref name=Welt></ref> Avey has since suggested that those who consider his story too fantastic to be true may have "a bad (or evil) heart." | ||
| <ref name=Welt2> (German-language interview) ''Welt'', May 8, 2011</ref> | <ref name=Welt2> (German-language interview) ''Welt'', May 8, 2011</ref> | ||
| Line 94: | Line 92: | ||
| The BBC, who first broadcast Avey's story, have subsequently produced a programme detailing the controversy. <ref> ''BBC'', radio broadcast</ref><ref> ''BBC'' video documentary, April 2012</ref> | The BBC, who first broadcast Avey's story, have subsequently produced a programme detailing the controversy. <ref> ''BBC'', radio broadcast</ref><ref> ''BBC'' video documentary, April 2012</ref> | ||
| ==Problems identified in Mr. Avey's different accounts== | |||
| Eight differing versions given by Mr. Avery were noted by Guy Walters, Jeremy Duns and Adrian Weale. <ref name=Walters>{{cite news|title=The curious case of the "break into Aushcwitz "|first=Guy|last=Walters|date=17 November 2011|accessdate=17 September 2012|publisher=]|url=http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/guy-walters/2011/11/avey-book-holocaust-auschwitz}}</ref>Nicholas Hellen writing in the Sunday Times also detailed problems of significant differences between versions of Avey's accounts, notably between the five hours of taped Imperial War Museum interviews of July 2001 and the book account first published in March 2011.<ref name=Times/> These include | |||
| * key elements of his story were changed before the book was published.<ref name=Walters/> | |||
| * Mr. Avey's earlier accounts included details of an Australian POW who worked stoking the crematoria in Birkenau yet there is no record of the imprisonment of a British or Australian POW who worked with the Jewish Sonderkommando. An Australian, Donald Watt, had published a book in 1995 claiming to be a stoker at Auschwitz but there is no evidence that Watt had even been in Auschwitz-Birkenau and his account was later exposed as fraudulent and discredited. | |||
| * Mr. Avey’s swap story is very similar to another published account in a book titled "The Password Is Courage" which is accepted as faudulent. That book was written by another former PoW at camp E715, Charles Coward.<ref name=Mail3/> | |||
| * Mr. Avey said when he entered the Monowitz camp he marched under the "Arbeit Macht Frei" sign, yet that sign was not at Auschwitz III but at Auschwitz I, six miles away.<ref name=Collett-White/><ref name=Mail3/> | |||
| * in the taped account, Avey said he swapped with a prisoner in Auschwitz-Birkenau. In the book account he wrote that he swapped with an inmate of the Auschwitz III labour camp (also known as Monowitz).<ref name=Walters/><ref name=Times/> | |||
| * the name of the prisoner with whom he exchanged places differed in the accounts. In the book, he wrote that he swapped with a Dutch Jewish inmate called ‘Hans’ and smuggled himself into Auschwitz III. In a 2009 Daily Mail interview and in a talk to Oxford students he said he swapped with prisoner Ernst Lobethal into Auschwitz II, also known as Birkenau.<ref name=Mail3/><ref name=Times/> | |||
| * criticism has been made and dobts expressed concerning the length of time after the event allowed to pass before Avey first narrated the swap incident. | |||
| * Mr Avey partly explained the delay by claiming that military authorities after the war were not interested in his account. Yet in 1947 he had declined the invitation to make an affidavit of his time as a POW, when contacted by American prosecutors who were documenting camp conditions for war crimes trials.<ref name=Mail3/> | |||
| ==See also== | ==See also== | ||
| Line 121: | Line 108: | ||
| * | * | ||
| * | * | ||
| * The Heretics' Hour 6-27-2011 Denis Avey and other Revisionist News | |||
| {{Persondata | {{Persondata | ||
Revision as of 17:44, 17 September 2012
| Denis Avey | |
|---|---|
 | |
| Born | 1919 (age 105–106) Essex |
| Allegiance |  United Kingdom |
| Service |  British Army |
| Unit | 7th Armoured Division |
| Battles / wars | Second World War |
| Awards | British Hero of the Holocaust |
| Other work | Engineer Author |
Denis Avey (born 1919) fought in the desert during the Second World War and was captured and held as a prisoner of war for two years near Auschwitz III, a concentration camp. He says that during his imprisonment he exchanged uniforms with a Jewish prisoner and smuggled himself into Auschwitz to witness conditions first hand.
In 2010 he received a British Hero of the Holocaust award for having saved the life of a Jewish prisoner by smuggling cigarettes to him. He has written of his accounts, with Rob Broomby, in his book, The Man who Broke into Auschwitz, published in 2011. A decade earlier, he described his personal life and war experiences in an interview with the Imperial War Museum in London. That interview, Avey states, was the "catalyst" that brought him, after 60 years of silent "anguish," to talk of that experience: "I began to weep - for the first time since the war. From then on, I could remain silent no longer, because I want my story to make a difference."
Early years and military service
Avey was born in Essex, outside of London, in 1919. As a boy he learned boxing, was head boy at school and studied at Leyton technical college. He joined the army in 1939 at the age of 20, and fought in the desert campaigns of North Africa in the 7th Armoured Division, known as the "Desert Rats". He was captured by the Germans while attacking Rommel's forces near Tobruk, Libya, and saw his best friend killed next to him. He escaped to Greece by crossing the Mediterranean Sea floating on top of a packing crate, but was recaptured after landing.
After being retaken prisoner, he was moved to a POW labor camp for British soldiers near Auschwitz III, a German concentration camp, where he was kept imprisoned from 1943 until April, 1945. During his time in the camp he managed to befriend a Jewish inmate of Auschwitz III, Ernst Lobethal. He obtained cigarettes from Ernst's sister in Britain, which he secretly passed to Ernst. Avey says that on two separate occasions while at Auschwitz, he exchanged uniforms with another Jewish prisoner and smuggled himself into Auschwitz III in order to witness first hand, conditions inside the prison, with a view to testifying after the war. Avey explains:
I knew I had to bear witness. As Albert Einstein said: the world can be an evil place, not because of those who do evil, but because of those who look on and do nothing. I’ve never been one to do nothing."
When POWs were evacuated from the camp near the end of the war Avey escaped and made his way back to England. He says that he encountered indifference from his commanding officer when he tried to report his experience in Auschwitz III and that when prosecutors sought his testimony for post war trials they were unable to trace him.
After the war he married twice and pursued a career in engineering, which culminated in him building a factory near Newcastle. After retirement he became active amongst ex-POWs seeking compensation for wartime experiences
Autobiographical book
Avey describes the events in detail in the book, The Man Who Broke into Auschwitz (2011)which he co-authored with Rob Broomby and which carried a foreword by Sir Martin Gilbert. The book was promoted by the Holocaust Educational Trust whose support Avey acknowledged, and had been published in 14 countries as of May, 2011.
He first began disclosing these events seven years ago when invited to appear on the BBC to talk about war pensions. "The memories suddenly started tumbling out, and the TV hosts could scarcely believe the extraordinary tale they were hearing. Avey states that "Auschwitz III was like nothing else on earth; it was hell on earth. This is what I had come to witness, but it was a ghastly, terrifying experience." According to Avey's account, "my life depended on 50 cigarettes - 25 in, 25 out. He (the guard) could have shot me easily." His motivation for getting inside the camp was to "put one over on the enemy," and witness the slaughter so that he could tell the world afterwards. As a result, the BBC began production of a documentary about his heroic story, and also discovered the name of the young Jewish prisoner Avey had befriended in Auschwitz, Ernst Lobethal."
Detailing his "break in"
He explains that by exchanging his uniform for the clothing of a Jewish prisoner at Auschwitz, he managed to smuggle himself into the concentration camp in order to document the events there:
- ". . . the then-25-year-old pondered and plotted, soon hatching a plan so audacious that, more than 65 years later, he shakes his head at its absurdity. While so many Jews and others held at the infamous extermination camp were desperate to get out, Avey was actually devising a way to sneak in. . . . 'I shaved my hair completely off,' he recalled. 'And before that, I dirtied my face and my eyes. He also carefully studied and copied "the slouch," the defeated bearing of many of the Jewish prisoners, who were starved of both food and hope.'"
Avey realized at the time that he was risking his life with this audacious scheme:
- "With that simple exchange between the two of us I had given away the protection of the Geneva Convention: I'd given my uniform, my lifeline, my best chance of surviving that dreadful place, to another man. . . If I was caught, the guards would have shot me out of hand as an imposter. No question at all." "We worked alongside the striped Jews and we weren’t allowed to speak to them. If you spoke to them, the bullet."
Avey traded places twice and slept overnight in Auschwitz. He tried a third time but he was almost caught and the plan was aborted. He also made his own estimates of the deaths during his period in prison, which he described at a lecture:
- "I am telling you I know without exaggeration, nearly 200,000 prisoners in Auschwitz were worked to death. Not killed. Were worked to death and they claimed total innocence. They lived for no more than 4 months. They were clubbed and beaten every day without any justification whatsoever."
Avey escaped during the "death marches" in April, 1945, which followed the Nazis' evacuation of Auschwitz. Although suffering from tuberculosis, he "saw a chance to escape and seized it, he states." Avey also estimates that around 15,000 prisoners died on the way. “The road was littered with corpses.” He eventually ran into Americans who helped get him back to England and his family, who thought he was dead.
After being hospitalised for two years after the war, in 1947 he went to his military authorities to give them his first hand account of what he saw taking place at Auschwitz. "Their eyes glazed over," he states "I wasn’t taken seriously. I was shocked, especially after the risks I’d taken. I felt completely disillusioned, and traumatized as well. So from then on I bottled it up, and tried to piece my life back together."
Subsequent years
As a result of the indifference to his breaking into Auschwitz, Avey kept the traumatic events about his wartime past a complete secret from everyone, including his mother, his present wife, and also his step-daughter. In an interview with German newspaper Welt, (translated) he partly explains his decision to keep his experience private: "I did not talk about my captivity, as no one was concerned or asked questions, including my mother. I could tell from just the body language of people in my village that their learning that a British soldier had worked alongside Jewish concentration camp prisoners was too unpleasant to imagine.
Avey explains:
- "The sad irony was that I went in there to find out the truth, so I could tell everybody about the horrors of the Nazi regime. But I was so traumatised at my whole experience of the Auschwitz camps it took me 60 years to be able to recount the horrors I saw."
"I knew there was something," said his wife, Audrey. "Naturally, you ask questions. But I never got an answer." Avey also suffered from symptoms after the war: "I had nightmares for years. I still think of Auschwitz every day. I can't exorcise this. My bed was soaked from sweat for years. I went to doctors, they couldn't help." He suffered from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder when he came back from the war and has only recently been able to speak about what he did and what he saw. He admits some may find it hard to believe and acknowledges it was "foolhardy".
Before he died, Ernst Lobethall recorded his survival story on video for the Shoah Foundation, which video the testimonies of Holocaust survivors and witnesses. In it he spoke of his friendship with a British soldier in Auschwitz who he simply called "Ginger". "It was Denis," notes BBC writer Rob Broomby. Avey also notes that the prisoner he helped to survive by providing him with cigarettes, the 'currency' of the camps, Ernst likewise refused to burden anyone with his own suffering and never talked about Auschwitz until very late in life. But Avey adds:
- "I, too, have left it late. I will always regret not tracking Ernst down while he was alive. If I’d known he was living in America, I would have gone and found him, without doubt. But I am proud to have played a small part in helping one man through the obscenity of Auschwitz."
Recognition
From 2000 onwards he began to share details of his experiences in Auschwitz, with Colin Rushton, BBC local radio, the Imperial War Museum and Diarmuid Jeffries. In 2009 author Rob Broomby and Patrick Howse of the BBC demonstrated that by supplying cigarettes to Ernst Lobethal Avey had saved his life - Lobethal has used the cigarettes as currency to have his boots re-soled, which enabled him to survive the death march when Auschwitz III was evacuated.
Regarding his helping of Ernst Lobethal, a spokesman for the International Raoul Wallenberg Foundation states, "We feel that his story is genuine," noting that a fellow survivor corroborated his account to the foundation's satisfaction. Lobethal himself was interviewed as part of the USC Shoah Foundation Institute for Visual History and Education and spoke about the efforts of a British prisoner of war he called "Ginger" to help him; Avey identifies himself as "Ginger". The BBC filmed an emotional reunion between Avey and Ernst's sister, Susanne. The two had met soon after the war at a time when they both thought Ernst was dead. In 2010, Avey was named a British Hero of the Holocaust by the British Governnment.
Reactions and questions
Reaction from the mainstream media to his story 2009 and 2010 was positive. However after publication of the book questions were raised over his account of having entered Auschwitz III and his reasons for keeping silent for so long One historian states that Avey's story was problematic partly because it was impossible to prove or disprove. "Theoretically it is possible to do such a thing, but for practical reasons it would be extremely difficult," he said. The World Jewish Congress has asked his publishers to verify the historical accuracy of the book. Avey has since suggested that those who consider his story too fantastic to be true may have "a bad (or evil) heart."
In the New Statesman in November 2011, the journalist and historian Guy Walters, in his blog, demanded that Avey's book should be withdrawn from publication and its claims presented to an independent body of historians for assessment. However, Lyn Smith, who interviewed Avey for the Imperial War Museum, states that "he is an utterly reliable witness," and would not be surprised if he made some mistakes in recalling names. She has included Avey in her forthcoming book, Heroes of the Holocaust.
In March 2012, Hodder, the book's publishers, added extended and detailed notes to reprints addressing, clarifying, and expanding details related to specific sections.
The BBC, who first broadcast Avey's story, have subsequently produced a programme detailing the controversy.
See also
References
- www.ex-bbc.net/Ariel/Arielwk11.2010.pdf
- Interview with Denis Avey, Imperial War Museum, London, UK, July 16, 2001
- ^ "The man who broke into Auschwitz" (German-language interview) Welt, May 8, 2011
- ^ Smith, David. Denis Avey, Herald ScotlandMarch 27, 2011
- "The Man Who Broke into Auschwitz: A True Story of World War II", Publishers Weekly review
- ^ Broomby, Rob (29 November 2009). "The man who smuggled himself into Auschwitz". BBC News. Retrieved 1 December 2009., includes video interview with Avey
- ^ "The British PoW who broke into Auschwitz — and survived", The Sunday Times, U.K., Feb. 25, 2010
- All information from Denis Avey's autobiography 'The Man who Broke into Auschwitz.'
- http://www.hodder.co.uk/books/work.aspx?WorkID=172580
- ^ "Denis Avey: 'Auschwitz wasn't inhuman. It was bestial'"
- http://www.hodder.co.uk/books/work.aspx?WorkID=172580
- "Man who broke into death camp" Derbyshire Times, May 6, 2011
- ^ "The British soldier who broke into Auschwitz: Denis Avey swapped uniforms with Jewish pal to witness atrocities", Daily Mail April 1, 2011
- ^ "Bearing Witness to Nazi Horror" Los Angeles Times, April 3, 2010
- Avey, Denis. The Man Who Broke into Auschwitz, Hodder & Stoughton, U.K. (2011) pp. 3-4
- ^ "Avey lecture" Oxford Chabad Society
- "How British PoW Swapped Uniforms to Sneak IN to Auschwitz so his Jewish Pal Could Slip Out" Daily Mail, Dec. 13, 2009
- Rushton, Colin, 'Spectator in Hell', Summersdale, 2007, pp.205-8.
- Avey, p.203.
- Avey/Broomby p.210
- ^ BBC, April 9, 2011
- Diarmuid Jeffries, 'Hell's Cartel' 2008, p.371
- BBC", 2010.pdf p.5
- Simons, Jake Wallis (February 25, 2010). "The British PoW who broke into Auschwitz — and survived". Times Online. Retrieved 26 February 2010.
- "Britons honoured for holocaust heroism". The Telegraph. 9 March 2010. Archived from the original on 9 March 2010. Retrieved 9 March 2010.
- http://www.faz.net/artikel/C30870/umstrittenes-buch-schoa-zum-anfassen-30337614.html
- http://www.standaard.be/artikel/detail.aspx?artikelid=6M3ANGGI§ionid=ab8d3fd8-bf2f-487a-818b-9ea546e9a859
- "Veteran defends disputed story of Auschwitz heroics" , Reuters, April 26, 2011
- "WJC"
- "Holocaust historian defends man who broke into Auschwitz", The Jewish Chronicle, Nov. 17, 2011
- Full text of updated Notes section to Avey's book
- "Witness to Auschwitz" BBC, radio broadcast
- "Witness to Auschwitz" BBC video documentary, April 2012
External links
- Video: 30 minutes, "Witness to Auschwitz" BBC TV documentary, April 2012
- Video: Avey discussing his new book, BBC, April 26, 2011, 4.5 minutes
- Video: Interview with Denis Avey, with Rob Broomby, 4 minutes
- British P.O.W. Tells Oxford Students of Auschwitz Horrors
- Auschwitz hero Denis Avey in line for Israeli honour
- British POW Denis Avey, ‘Why I smuggled myself into Auschwitz’ - Lecture