| Revision as of 20:32, 21 November 2006 editPatchouli (talk | contribs)7,395 edits →Criticism: According to Benador expert+quote← Previous edit | Revision as of 20:33, 21 November 2006 edit undoPatchouli (talk | contribs)7,395 editsm →Criticism: According to [[BenadorNext edit → | ||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
| Khatami fervently praised the ]<ref name="mullahcracy"> ''Iran Press Service''</ref>. A Paris-based analyst said,{{quotation|When Mr. Khatami joins him, and worse, imitates him (]), he loses his own power base. <ref name="mullahcracy" />}} | Khatami fervently praised the ]<ref name="mullahcracy"> ''Iran Press Service''</ref>. A Paris-based analyst said,{{quotation|When Mr. Khatami joins him, and worse, imitates him (]), he loses his own power base. <ref name="mullahcracy" />}} | ||
| According to ] expert, ], "Khatami is a symptom and not the cause of change in Iran," . | According to ] expert, ], "Khatami is a symptom and not the cause of change in Iran," . | ||
| "Only one problem exists. Khatami is neither a reformer nor a democrat. It is true that Khatami beat three other candidates to win the presidency in 1997. But he emerged to victory only after the mullahs disqualified 234 other challengers whom they felt too reformist or too liberal. Khatami has not retracted his 1980 writings in the Iranian daily Keyhan in which he insisted that government was only for the clergy.<ref> ] ]</ref> | "Only one problem exists. Khatami is neither a reformer nor a democrat. It is true that Khatami beat three other candidates to win the presidency in 1997. But he emerged to victory only after the mullahs disqualified 234 other challengers whom they felt too reformist or too liberal. Khatami has not retracted his 1980 writings in the Iranian daily Keyhan in which he insisted that government was only for the clergy.<ref> ] ]</ref> | ||
Revision as of 20:33, 21 November 2006
 | The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (Learn how and when to remove this message) |
Upon his election in 1997, Mohammad Khatami promised the populace of Iran "reforms". However, after eight years of presidency nothing tangible was accomplished except hundreds of arrests and quashing of real demonstrations in 1999 as opposed to government-organized demonstrations coupled with a spate of imprisoning, torture, and killing associated with the 2nd of Khordad Movement. According to Human Rights Watch, "Torture, Detention, and the Crushing of Dissent in Iran" were present in 2004..
Major events
According to a famous statement made by Khatami, his government survived an average of one national crisis every nine days during his term of office. Highlights of important crises (related to his domestic reform plans) during his presidency include:
- The serial murders of Iranian political dissidents by rogue elements in the Intelligence Ministry.
- The beating of two of his closest allies and key cabinet ministers (Ataollah Mohajerani and Abdollah Noori) by Islamist pressure groups after a Friday prayer in Tehran.
- An unsuccessful attempt to impeach Khatami's culture minister (Ataollah Mohajerani) by the conservative-dominated 5th Majlis.
- The impeachment of Khatami's interior minister (Abdollah Noori) by the 5th Majlis which led to Noori's removal from office.
- Noori's trial and imprisonment on the grounds of insulting Islamic values.
- Iran student riots, July 1999. This was the largest anti-regime street demonstrations in the history of the Islamic Republic. At the time, students were considered to be the most important supporters of Khatami's government.
- The attempted assassination of Saeed Hajjarian, one of Khatami's closest allies and considered by many to be the mastermind strategist of the reform movement.
- The judiciary's verdict resulting in the closure of over 20 reformist newspapers in one day. This was considered by many to be the starting point of the reform movement's demise and was described by some political activists as the silent coup d'état against Khatami's government
- The failure of the "Twin Bills" (لوایح دوقلو in Persian). The bills were presented by Khatami to the 6th Majlis but after a long struggle they were eventually disapproved by the Guardian Council. These two pieces of proposed legislation would have introduced small but key changes to the national election laws of Iran and also presented a clear definition of the president's power to prevent constitutional violations by state institutions. Khatami himself described the "twin bills" as the key to the progress of reforms in Iran
- The imprisonment of many prominent figures of the reform movement and some of Khatami's key allies during his presidency by the judiciary on the grounds of insulting Islamic values. Some of these individuals are: Dr. Mohsen Kadivar, Gholamhossein Karbaschi, Ayatollah Hossein-Ali Montazeri, Mohsen Sazegara, Abbas Abdi, investigative journalists Akbar Ganji and Emadedin Baghi, etc.
- The trial and death sentence of Dr. Hashem Aghajari, a university professor and political activist accused of insulting Islamic values during one of his speeches. The death sentence was reversed after widespread protests by students and reformist parties. Dr. Aghajari was released after a brief stay in prison.
In September 2002 Khatami presented the so-called twin bills to Parliament. The twin bills addresses two issues: the first would curb the powers of the Council of Guardians, while the second would enhance presidential powers. The bills were rejected by Guardian council and Khatami withdrew them from the parliament eventually.
Reform within Islamic framework
Criticism
Khatami's desire to not make extra-Islamic reforms made people question the purpose of his presidency. He has received criticism inside and outside the Islamic Republic and it is not known how a mullah (expert in Islam) can bring freedoms that would, for example, be in discordance with the blasphemy laws of the Islamic Republic of Iran or other Islamic laws.
At Tehran University, his former supporters chanted, " No more lies! No more lies! No more lies! No more lies! No more lies!" Many of them had gotten physically beaten by security forces before the meeting. According to Khatami,"he reforms should come from within the regime. I consider the Islamic Republic to be a great achievement of the most popular revolution in my lifetime." Many of his supporter misunderstood this idea. With regard to those that were disillusioned with the epic of 23 May 1997, Khatami denounced the Iran student riots, July 1999 because of "their envy" and that they "created obstacles," referring to people like Akbar Mohammadi. Additionally, he asserted,
Rest assured that beyond the Islamic Republic there will not be a democratic regime in the true sense of the word.
In the same vein, he has ridiculed the idea of Western-style democracy in the Middle East,
It's a great joke - the greatest joke that Mr Bush said, that he would like to export democracy to the Middle East.
Khatami fervently praised the mullahcracy. A Paris-based analyst said,
When Mr. Khatami joins him, and worse, imitates him (Ali Khamenei), he loses his own power base.
According to Benador expert, Azar Nafisi, "Khatami is a symptom and not the cause of change in Iran," .
"Only one problem exists. Khatami is neither a reformer nor a democrat. It is true that Khatami beat three other candidates to win the presidency in 1997. But he emerged to victory only after the mullahs disqualified 234 other challengers whom they felt too reformist or too liberal. Khatami has not retracted his 1980 writings in the Iranian daily Keyhan in which he insisted that government was only for the clergy.
" refused, for example, to back off a previous comparison between the American leader and Osama bin Laden.Video clip of speech
Khatami has faced criticism for his verbal support of Hezbollah, as well as comments he made on US and Israeli policy. In September 2006, the Simon Wiesenthal Center and Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney objected to the US State Department's decision to grant Khatami a visa for a lecture tour.
In a press release, Romney accused Khatami of being a supporter of "violent jihad" and an advocate of "the destruction of Israel", for comments he made in support of Hezbollah, and the actions of the Iranian government while he was in power. Romney ordered that all Massachusetts state government agencies decline support, if asked, for Khatami's visit to Harvard University on September 10, 2006. Romney also criticised Harvard University for inviting Khatami to speak there. Governor Mitt Romney and others have pointed out what they perceive as the duplicity of Mohammad Khatami who used his "reformist" platform as a ploy. Mitt Romney said,
Khatami relaxed freedom of speech laws giving democracy reformers a false sense of security only to engage in one of the largest crackdowns in the country’s history...e will never make progress in the region if we deal with wolves in sheep’s clothing..
The Simon Wiesenthal Center launched a petition against the decision to grant Khatami a visa to the US. They stated that allowing Khatami into the US will "be viewed by the mullahs as a reward for their policy of confrontation and hatred toward the United States and her allies".
The State Department has defended its decision to grant the visa, insisting Khatami poses no threat to national security. A spokesman stated that the lecture tour was an opportunity for Khatami to address the concerns of the American people.
Despite the fact that President Khatami was supportive of democratic reforms, Defenders of Human Rights Center which is Iran's main human rights organization, did not succeed in official registration and its qualification was not approved after three years of sending requests.
Defense
Khatami is known by most as the first Iranian reformist president since the 1979 Islamic Revolution. After taking office in a landslide victory and having based his campaign on promises of implementing a more tolerant, democratic and open society and the rule of law, Khatami faced fierce opposition from powerful conservatives within the Iranian political establishment.
During his two terms in office, Khatami was able to introduce some reforms to the Iranian political system, however all in all, he is widely considered to have lost the power struggle with his opponents. The root cause for his failures is widely considered to be the limited powers of the President in the Iranian political system. As President, Khatami had little or no authority over many key state institutions such as the judiciary, the state radio and television, the armed forces including the police, the military, etc. (See Politics of Iran).
It seems that Mr. Romney meant to refer to the mass closure of reformist newspapers by the press court during the first term of Mr. Khatami in office, unaware of the fact that not only Khatami had no control over the judiciary as President, but also that the judiciary was widely known to be controled by hardline opponents of Khatami at the time. Ironically, the specific event that Romney refers to, has been described by some political analysts in Iran as the silent coup d'etat against Khatami's reform programs by his opponents.
References and notes
- Khatami: Iran's democratic reforms failed China Daily
- Iranian protesters say student killed, 1,400 detained CNN 17 July 1999
- VOICES OF DISSENT "...angry student demonstrations for the past six days... the rallies...have degenerated into attacks by police and irregular paramilitary forces on the demonstrators." PBS 13 July 1999
- Khatami lecture attracts protesters The Guardian 13 October 2006
- Country Reports on Human Rights Practices - 2001
- “Like the Dead in Their Coffins” Human Rights Watch
- ^ Iranian President Khatami Clashes with Reformist Students at Tehran University MEMRI TV
- [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6108798.stm Khatami labels US policy 'a joke'] BBC News 2 November 2006
- ^ KHATAMI SAYS HE IS FOR VELAYAT FAQIH, URGES STUDENTS KEEP QUIET Iran Press Service
- Iran’s Myth of Moderation 18 March 2002
- SAY NO TO UNITED STATES GRANTING VISA TO MOHAMMAD KHATAMI Simon Wisenthal Center
- Sanctions essential: US; Iran boosts arsenal Arab Times
- ROMNEY DENOUNCES KHATAMI VISIT TO HARVARD The Commonwealth of Massachusetts 5 September 2006