Misplaced Pages

Steven Plaut

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Truthprofessor (talk | contribs) at 13:29, 26 April 2007 (rv: I did discuss it in Talk and you didn't reply. If you want to reply I'm happy to discuss it with you.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Revision as of 13:29, 26 April 2007 by Truthprofessor (talk | contribs) (rv: I did discuss it in Talk and you didn't reply. If you want to reply I'm happy to discuss it with you.)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Steven Plaut (born in 1951) is a Professor on the faculty of the Graduate School of Business Administration at the University of Haifa and a writer.

His editorials are often published in The Jewish Press, Front Page Magazine and other periodicals. In 2002 he authored the book The Scout. He is also a member of the editorial board of the Middle East Quarterly, a publication of the Middle East Forum think tank.

Biography

Steven Plaut was born in Philadelphia into a Jewish family. In the 1930s, his father had been in Hachshara training camp set up in Europe for young Jews who intended to make aliyah, but the British White Paper of 1939 foreclosed his plans. He managed to escape from Nazi Germany to the United States and during World War II served under General Patton.

Steven Plaut grew up in a religiously Conservative Zionist home. In 1981, the Plaut family (including his parents) immigrated to Israel.

Plaut received his undergraduate degree from Temple University in Philadelphia, his MA from Hebrew University of Jerusalem and his Ph.D in economics from Princeton University, specializing in international and urban economics and later in finance and worked at the Federal Reserve Bank. Before his professorship at the Haifa University, he taught at Oberlin College, the Technion, UC Berkeley, UC Irvine, Central European University, Tel Aviv University, University of Nantes, and Athens Laboratory for Business Administration.

In his 2002 book The Scout Steven Plaut describes his near-death experience as a kidney cancer patient at an intensive care ward (he has recovered from the illness). The historical novel is a series of life stories exchanged between him and his neighbor at the ward, an Israeli bedouin scout.

Political views

File:Harovbomb33jy.jpg
Steven Plaut's "slight alteration of the peace plan". Blue is Israel and green is Palestine.

Steven Plaut has been one of the most persistent and outspoken Israeli critics of the Israeli-Palestinian peace process and of Israel's unilateral withdrawal policy. Ever since the Oslo Accords were signed, he has argued that Palestinian and other Arab leaders would continue to seek the destruction of Israel through violence and terrorism. For much of the 1990s, he was an isolated voice in Israeli opinion, but he believes that his views have been vindicated by outbreak of the Al-Aqsa Intifada and the campaign of suicide bombing.

In addition, Plaut has strongly attacked Israeli and Jewish leftists such as Neve Gordon, Michael Lerner and Norman Finkelstein. He claims that such figures are self-hating Jews and apologists for terrorism who promote the destruction of Israel ; he calls them "Israel's Academic Fifth Column". Plaut is particularly opposed to what he sees as left-wing extremism in Israeli universities, and is actively involved in Israel Academia Monitor, a website monitoring such alleged extremism. .

Neve Gordon civil suit

In 2006, Steven Plaut lost a civil suit in an Israeli court in which he was accused of libeling Neve Gordon, a faculty member at the Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Department of Politics and Government. He was ordered to pay Gordon about $18,600 in compensation plus $3,500 in legal fees. He is now appealing this decision.

Emphasizing that the court's role was not to adjudicate opposing political views, Judge Rim Naddaf ruled that Plaut crossed a line between legitimate criticism and unlawful defamation of character. Judge Naddaf came to this decision after reading several articles written by Plaut, where he described Neve Gordon as a "fanatic anti-Semite" and a "Judenrat wannabe." Other supposed cases of defamation of Gordon included a message forwarded by Plaut, but not composed by him, urging readers to write an "Israeli Leftist" a mock-condolence letter for the death of a Hamas member killed by the IDF. Neve Gordon's e-mail address was one of about 30 included in this request.

Commenting on the verdict, Plaut said:

Because it will go to appeal, I prefer not to go into detail about it. I will just say that the judgment amounts to selective protection of freedom of speech in Israel, under which the most outrageous and even illegal behavior and statements made by anti-Israel extremists is always protected speech while denunciation of the public political activities and behavior of such people is deemed "libel."

According to Gordon, Plaut was orchestrating a campaign - including letters to donors and members of the university's appointments committee - aimed at blacklisting him and denying him tenure. The use of the Holocaust motif against him was a decisive factor in Gordon's decision to litigate. "Once someone is labeled as a Holocaust denier that person becomes illegitimate, and rightly so," he explained. "Israeli society tolerates a relatively wide range of political views and that is why Plaut had to resort to this Holocaust mechanism to try to shut me down," Gordon said.

Plaut argued that Gordon's articles had been posted on the website of Holocaust denier Ernst Zundel and had been "published and cited with favor in many other anti-Semitic and anti-Israel printed and online newspapers and magazines, ranging from Al-Ahram, to the Radio Islam web site, to David Irving's web site." While Plaut never claimed Gordon himself was a Holocaust denier, merely a fan of Holocaust deniers, a Jewish newspaper reporting the case claimed that Gordon is indeed a Holocaust denier.

Judge Naddaf commented in her ruling:

At times we are witness to the phenomenon in which some people “dare” to re-examine the Holocaust and its dimensions, from various aspects, whether it be the human, historic, scientific, political, etc., and where such people automatically are turned into objects for attack and accusations of being anti-Semites and Holocaust deniers, deserving of being called Judenrat or Jews for Hitler... It is impossible and improper to turn the Holocaust into some sort of “taboo” subject, about which people may not comment, think beyond, investigate, or analyze unless it is within the framework of the consensus and the “permissible,” as the defendant claims.

Harvard professor Alan Dershowitz defended Plaut and denounced Gordon as a friend of neo-Nazis and anti-Semites, and also denounced Gordon's judge and her verdict , adding "if Finkelstein and Gordon aren't themselves explicitly neo-Nazi, they're at least very highly regarded by those who are - and for good reason." Gordon responded to Dershowitz's charges in an article titled "Anti-Semitism? Mr. Dershowitz, You Just Don't Like What I Say", stating, "Unlike Dershowitz, however, when choosing between truth or dare I always side with truth."

Besides Dershowitz, other publicists criticized the decision. Caroline Glick argued that this was one of a growing number of attempts by anti-democratic judges in Israel to suppress freedom of speech . The Jerusalem Post's Jonathan Rosenblum also criticized the verdict as interfering with the freedom of speech.

External links

Categories: