This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Dicklyon (talk | contribs) at 04:20, 21 February 2006. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Revision as of 04:20, 21 February 2006 by Dicklyon (talk | contribs)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
In optics, a circle of confusion, (also known as disk of confusion, circle of indistinctness, blur circle, etc.), is an optical spot caused by a cone of light rays from a lens not coming to a perfect focus when imaging a point source.
Two important uses of this term and concept need to be distinguished:
1. To calculate a camera's depth of field, one needs to know how large a circle of confusion can be considered to be an acceptable focus. The maximum acceptable diameter of such a circle of confusion is known as the maximum permissible circle of confusion, the circle of confusion diameter limit, or the circle of confusion criterion, but is often incorrectly called simply the circle of confusion.
2. Recognizing that real lenses do not focus all rays perfectly under even the best of conditions, the circle of confusion of a lens is a characterization of its optical spot. The term circle of least confusion is often used for the smallest optical spot a lens can make, for example by picking a best focus position that makes a good compromise between the varying effective focal lengths of different lens zones due to spherical or other aberrations. Diffraction effects from wave optics and the finite aperture of a lens can be included in the circle of least confusion, or the term can be applied in pure ray (geometrics) optics.
In idealized ray optics, where rays are assumed to converge to a point when perfectly focused, the shape of a mis-focused spot from a lens with a circular aperture is a hard-edged disk of light (that is, a hockey-puck shape when intensity is plotted as a function of x and y coordinates in the focal plane). A more general circle of confusion has soft edges due to diffraction and aberrations, and may be non-circular due to the aperture (diaphragm) shape. So the diameter concept needs to be carefully defined to be meaningful. The diameter of the smallest circle that can contain 90% of the optical energy is a typical suitable definition for the diameter of a circle of confusion; in the case of the ideal hockey-puck shape, it gives an answer about 5% less than the actual diameter.
The rest of this article is about only the first interpreation, where the circle of confusion diameter limit is a criterion used to describe how out of focus a point is allowed to be on film, on a print, or on an electronic sensor, before the fuzziness becomes unacceptable. In film photography, the circle of confusion criterion is sometimes defined as the largest circle of blur on a film negative that will still be perceived by the human eye as a clean point when printed at 30 cm diagonal size and viewed from a normal viewing distance of 50 cm (and variations thereon).
While this definition has its subjective aspects, photographers still find it very useful because it allows a mathematical treatment of image sharpness when the eye's resolution is specified numerically. It is, for instance, a part of the calculation of depth of field. The circle of confusion can be used to describe blur limitations in both digital and film cameras.
Film size is important because it relates to the amount of enlargement necessary to get to 8x10. The larger the film size, the less enlargement required and the larger the tolerable circle of confusion. A circle that is 0.026 mm on 35mm film when enlarged to the same size as a 6 x 4.5 cm (roughly twice the size of the 35mm) will be about 0.05 mm.
The resolution of the eye is another factor in determining the area of the circle of confusion. A person with good vision can readily distinguish 5 lines per millimeter at a distance of 25 cm. Using this visual acuity, at a normal viewing distance for an 8x10 print the maximum size for a point to still be regarded as a point is 1/5th of a mm, or 0.2 mm. If the film negative was itself 8x10 size film, the enlargement ratio would be 1.0X and the circle of confusion would be 0.2 mm. Using the more common 35mm film size, however, the enlargement is 7.5X and thus the circle of confusion need be 7.5 times, or 0.2 mm / 7.5 = 0.026 mm. Thus the optical sharpness demands on the optical system are more severe for smaller film formats, because the enlargement factor is bigger.
Using the industry-standard "Zeiss formula" the circle of confusion is calculated as d/1730 where "d" is the diagonal measure of the film in millimeters. For 35mm film (43mm diagonal) this comes out to be 0.024 mm. The 1730 figure is derived directly from the diagonal length, in millimeters, of an 8"x10" print, multiplied by 5 because the eye at a standard distance can view 5 lines per millimeter.
The circle of confusion of 0.026 mm is intended to represent "average" photographing, printing, and viewing conditions. If the photograph will be magnified to a larger size, or viewed more closely, or printed on photo printers which introduce additional blur, then a tighter circle of confusion will be required.
Accepted values for circle of confusion
| Film format | Frame sizeTemplate:Fn | CoC |
|---|---|---|
| Small Format | ||
| APS-CTemplate:Fn | 22.5mm x 15.0 mm | 0.016 mm |
| 35mm | 36 mm x 24 mm | 0.026 mm |
| Medium Format | ||
| 645 | 56 mm x 42 mm | 0.043 mm |
| 6x6 | 56 mm x 56 mm | 0.049 mm |
| 6x7 | 56 mm x 69 mm | 0.055 mm |
| 6x9 | 56 mm x 84 mm | 0.062 mm |
| 6x12 | 56 mm x 112 mm | 0.077 mm |
| 6x17 | 56 mm x 168 mm | 0.109 mm |
| Large Format | ||
| 4x5 | 102 mm x 127 mm | 0.100 mm |
| 5x7 | 127 mm x 178 mm | 0.135 mm |
| 8x10 | 203 mm x 254mm | 0.200 mm |
Trivia
The Circle of Confusion is a popular and often appropriate name for photography clubs.
See also
External links
- Depth of field and Circle of Confusion
- About the Circle of Confusion
- Circles of Confusion for digital cameras
Notes
Template:FnbThe frame size is an average of cameras that take photographs of this format. Not all 6x7 cameras (for example) take frames that are exactly 56mm x 69mm. Check with the specifications of a particular camera if this level of exactness is needed.
Template:FnbThis format is commonly found on digital SLRs.
Category: