Misplaced Pages

Misplaced Pages has been criticized for the inequality in the distribution of its volunteer created content with respect to the geographical association of article subjects. The research shows that despite considerable differences of this distribution depending on the language of Misplaced Pages, there is a common trend towards more content related to the United States and Western Europe coupled with the scarcity of information about certain regions in the rest of the world.

Analysis

Several studies on internet geography and Misplaced Pages were published by the members of the Oxford Internet Institute (OII).

A 2009 article by Mark Graham of OII in The Guardian presented a color-coded map of the world that illustrated the disparity between the numbers of geotagged Misplaced Pages articles (in all languages) for countries from the Global North and from the Global South. Graham wrote:

Almost the entire continent of Africa is geographically poorly represented in Misplaced Pages. Remarkably, there are more Misplaced Pages articles written about Antarctica than all but one of the 53 countries in Africa (or perhaps more amazingly, there are more Misplaced Pages articles written about the fictional places of Middle Earth and Discworld than about many countries in Africa, Asia, and the Americas).

A 2010 analysis of Misplaced Pages people edits revealed that Asia, as the most populous continent, was represented in only 16.67% of edits. Africa (6.35%) and South America (2.58%) were equally underrepresented. A 2011 study by OII found that 84 percent of articles tagged with a location were in Europe or North America, and that Antarctica had more entries than any African or South American nation. According to Adama Sanneh, the founder of the WikiAfrica Education initiative, as of 2021 there are more articles on the English Misplaced Pages about Paris than Africa.

In 2011 a breakdown by languages (Arabic, Egyptian Arabic, English, French, Hebrew, Persian, Swahili) was reported by OII. Graham reported some unexpected patterns in distributions. For example, Swahili Misplaced Pages has unusually many articles geotagged in Turkey. Graham explains this and similar artifacts by dedicated editors creating numerous stub articles in the areas of their interest.

A 2015 OII paper reported on a highly uneven geography of participation in editing Misplaced Pages. In particular, it found that contributors from low-income countries contribute to geographical imbalance by writing more about high-income countries than about their own.

A 2016 study by David Laniado and Marc Miquel Ribé empirically confirmed that cultural identity is a significant unconscious motivator for Misplaced Pages editors affecting their works in areas which may be associated with their identity, in particular, in Misplaced Pages categories "Culture" and "Geography". A similar conclusion was drawn in 2010 by Hecht and Gergle: Wikipedians tend to work on topics related to the nearby locations. Laniado and Ribé suggest that in order to overcome the imbalance stemming from cultural identities, Misplaced Pages has to promote editors from different language Wikipedias to propagate their cultural identities into other Wikipedias. To this end the translator and article recommendation tools developed by the Wikimedia Foundation may be of use by providing options to select preferential content based on the keywords related to cultural identity.

See also

• List of countries by number of Internet users

References

1. Pablo Beytía, "The Positioning Matters. Estimating Geographical Bias in the Multilingual Record of Biographies on Misplaced Pages", SSRN Electronic Journal, 2020
2. Mark Graham (2 December 2009). "Misplaced Pages's known unknowns". The Guardian.co.uk. Retrieved 12 June 2020.
3. Livingstone, Randall M. (2010-11-23). "Let's Leave the Bias to the Mainstream Media: A Misplaced Pages Community Fighting for Information Neutrality". M/C Journal. 13 (6). doi:10.5204/mcj.315.
4. Simonite, Tom (22 October 2013). "The Decline of Misplaced Pages". MIT Technology Review. Retrieved 26 May 2021.
5. Greig, Jonathan (16 April 2021). "For Misplaced Pages's 20th anniversary, students across Africa add vital information to site". TechRepublic. Archived from the original on April 19, 2021. Retrieved 11 May 2021.
6. Rogers, Simon (11 November 2011). "The world of Misplaced Pages's languages mapped". The Guardian.
7. Graham, M., Straumann, R., Hogan, B. 2015. "Digital Divisions of Labour and Informational Magnetism: Mapping Participation in Misplaced Pages". Annals of the Association of American Geographers. 105(6) 1158-1178. doi:10.1080/00045608.2015.1072791 (free pre-publication version)
8. James Temperton "Misplaced Pages's world view is skewed by rich, western voices", Wired, September 15, 2015
9. "Misplaced Pages's view of the world is written by the west". the Guardian. 2015-09-15. Retrieved 2022-04-06.
10. ^ David Laniado, Marc Miquel Ribé, "Cultural Identities in Wikipedias", SMSociety '16, July 11 - 13, 2016, London, United Kingdom, doi:10.1145/2930971.2930996
11. Hecht, B.J. and Gergle, D. 2010. "On the localness of user-generated content." Proc. CSCW

Further reading

• The following references are found in Beytía's article:
  • Graham, M., Hogan, B., Straumann, R. K. & Medhat, A. Uneven geographies of user-generated information: patterns of increasing informational poverty. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 104, 746–764 (2014).
    • It was summarized in an article by Joseph Stromberg "Misplaced Pages's geography problem: There are more articles about Antarctica than Egypt", Vox.com September 14, 2014
  • Graham, M. Information geographies and geographies of information. New geographies (2015).
  • Roll, U. et al. Using Misplaced Pages page views to explore the cultural importance of global reptiles. Biological conservation, 204, 42–50 (2016).
  • Overell, S. E. & Rüger, S. View of the world according to Misplaced Pages: Are we all little Steinbergs? Journal of Computational Science, 2, 193–197 (2011).
  • Graham, M., Hale, S. A. & Stephens, M. Geographies of the World's Knowledge. (2011).
  • Graham, M., De Sabbata, S. & Zook, M. A. Towards a study of information geographies:(im) mutable augmentations and a mapping of the geographies of information. Geo: Geography and environment, 2, 88–105 (2015).

• Criticism of Misplaced Pages
• Bias