Year
|
Award
|
Nominated work
|
Result
|
1983
|
New York Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Right Stuff
|
Nominated
|
1984
|
Obie Award for Distinguished Performance by an Actor
|
Fool for Love
|
Won
|
1986
|
Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Actor in a Play
|
Precious Sons
|
Won
|
Theatre World Award
|
Won
|
1989
|
Saturn Award for Best Actor
|
The Abyss
|
Nominated
|
1992
|
Valladolid International Film Festival Award for Best Actor
|
Glengarry Glen Ross
|
Won
|
1995
|
Critics' Choice Movie Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Nixon, Apollo 13, and Just Cause
|
Won
|
Southeastern Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Apollo 13
|
Won
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Runner-up
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Lucille Lortel Award for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play
|
Simpatico
|
Won
|
1996
|
Bronze Wrangler for Television Feature Film
|
Riders of the Purple Sage
|
Won
|
1998
|
Blockbuster Entertainment Award for Favorite Supporting Actor — Drama
|
The Truman Show
|
Won
|
National Board of Review Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
Southeastern Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Saturn Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
2000
|
Toronto Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Pollock
|
Won
|
Satellite Award for Best Actor – Motion Picture Drama
|
Nominated
|
2001
|
Satellite Award for Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture
|
A Beautiful Mind
|
Nominated
|
2002
|
Critics' Choice Movie Award for Best Acting Ensemble
|
The Hours
|
Nominated
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
3rd Place
|
London Film Critics Circle Award for Actor of the Year
|
Nominated
|
Phoenix Film Critics Society Award for Best Cast
|
Nominated
|
Italian Online Movie Award for Best Cast
|
Won
|
Italian Online Movie Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
2005
|
Satellite Award for Best Actor – Miniseries or Television Film
|
Empire Falls
|
Nominated
|
Women's Image Network Award for Best Actor in a Made-for-TV Movie/Miniseries
|
Won
|
National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
A History of Violence
|
Won
|
2007
|
Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Solo Performance
|
Wrecks
|
Nominated
|
Outer Critics Circle Award for Outstanding Solo Performance
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Boston Film Festival Prize for Best Screenplay Adaptation
|
Appaloosa
|
Won
|
Bronze Wrangler for Theatrical Motion Picture
|
Won
|
Critics' Choice Movie Award for Best Acting Ensemble
|
Gone Baby Gone
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Golden Nymph Award for Best Performance by an Actor – Television Film
|
Game Change
|
Nominated
|
2014
|
Women Film Critics Circle - Adrienne Shelly Award
|
Frontera
|
Won
|
2016
|
Lucille Lortel Award for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play
|
Buried Child
|
Nominated
|
2017
|
Saturn Award for Best Supporting Actor on Television
|
Westworld
|
Won
|
2019
|
Saturn Award for Best Supporting Actor on Television
|
Nominated
|