 | An editor has performed a search and found that sufficient sources exist to establish the subject's notability. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Find sources: "Meir Feinstein" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (July 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this message) |
 | You can help expand this article with text translated from the corresponding article in Hebrew. (February 2009) Click for important translation instructions.
|
| Meir Feinstein | |
|---|---|
 | |
| Native name | מאיר פיינשטיין |
| Born |
|
| Died | 21 April 1947 (aged 17) Russian Compound, Jerusalem, Mandatory Palestine. |
| Cause of death | Suicide by explosives with Moshe Barazani |
| Buried | Mount of Olives, Jerusalem, next to Moshe Barazani and Menachem Begin. |
| Allegiance | |
| Battles / wars | |
| Website | "Meir Feinstein - A Family Memorial" meirfeinstein |
Meir Feinstein (Hebrew: מאיר פיינשטיין; 30 June 1929 – 21 April 1947) was an Irgun member during the Jewish insurgency in Mandatory Palestine. Feinstein, who was sentenced to death by the British authorities, is remembered for his suicide together with Moshe Barazani, a member of the group Lehi, under sentence of death; the two killed themselves embracing each other with a live grenade lodged between them hours before their scheduled hangings. He is memorialized in Israel today as one of 12 Olei Hagardom.
Early life
Meir Feinstein was born in the Old City of Jerusalem. His parents, Bela and Eliezer, immigrated from Brisk. As a boy, he received a religious education; he studied at the Etz Chaim Yeshiva for ten years, and was a disciple of Aryeh Levin. During his childhood, his father died, and he had to work to help support the family. He worked in a series jobs in Jerusalem, in Ramatayim, and in the kibbutzim of Negba and Givat HaShlosha.
Haganah and British Army service
While at Givat HaShlosha, Feinstein joined the Haganah. During his military training, Feinstein, an aspiring writer, educated himself in secular subjects with books sent to him by his brother from Jerusalem.
In 1944, during World War II, after rumors of the Holocaust began spreading, Feinstein enlisted in the British Army. Although only 16 at the time, he enlisted using a forged birth certificate claiming he was 20. Feinstein was accepted and served for two and a half years in the Royal Engineers, during which he was stationed in Palestine, Alexandria, and Beirut. He was discharged from the British Army in August 1946.
Irgun activities
While still in the British Army, Feinstein had met other Irgun members and began helping them smuggle weapons stolen from British military camps to Mandatory Palestine for Irgun use. Following his discharge, he joined the Irgun's Jerusalem branch. He initially worked in the Irgun's propaganda section, but was eventually promoted to join the Combat Corps.
On October 30, 1946, Feinstein participated in a raid on the Jerusalem railway station. The attack was one of a series of sabotage operations the Irgun carried out against the railways that day, as part of the Irgun's overall efforts to paralyze the British Mandatory government. The British had advance intelligence of the plan, and the operation was further compromised when the Irgun, not wanting to harm civilians in the station, published an advance warning. On the day of the raid, the British were waiting in ambush at the station. The Irgun raiders arrived in two taxis, and Feinstein drove the one carrying the bombs which were to be used - three suitcases filled with explosives. The team then rushed into the station, laid the three suitcase bombs, and put up a sign warning of mines. However, they came under British fire, and four of the attackers were hit, including Feinstein, whose left arm was shattered. Feinstein and some teammates rushed back to his taxi, and managed to escape. Despite his injury, Feinstein managed to drive the taxi, under a hail of British gunfire, away from the station using only one arm. After their escape, the British attempted to remove the suitcase bombs they had abandoned. When a police sapper tried to lift one of the bombs, it exploded, killing him and devastating the interior of the station.
Capture and trial
After escaping, Feinstein drove the taxi to Jerusalem's Yemin Moshe quarter, where the team then scattered, hoping to slip away. Feinstein's arm, however, continued bleeding heavily, and he left a trail of blood behind him. Shortly afterward, the police discovered the abandoned taxi, riddled by bullets and with blood-soaked seats, in the Yemin Moshe quarter. Feinstein was arrested when they followed the trail of blood from the taxi to Feinstein. He was taken to hospital, where his shattered left arm was amputated.
Feinstein's trial in a Jerusalem military court opened on March 25, 1947. He did not participate in the proceedings, refused legal counsel, and refused to recognize the authority of the British court to try him, other than to speak at the summation. Before the reading of the verdict, Feinstein gave a defiant speech against British rule, saying:
Officers of the army of conquest! A regime of hanging trees is the regime you wish to impose on this land, which was destined to be a lighthouse for all of humanity, and in your foolish wickedness, you presumed that by this regime you will break our people's spirit, the people to whom this whole country had been a gallows. You were wrong. You will learn that you have encountered steel, steel forged in the fire of love and hatred - love for the homeland and freedom, hatred for enslavement and invader. Burning steel it is. You will not break it. You will burn your hands.
How great is your blindness, British tyrants? Did you not notice who stands against you in this campaign, unexampled in the history of mankind? Shall you scare us with death? We, who have listened for years to the rattling of the wheels of them Railroad cars, who led our brothers, our parents, the best of our nation - to slaughter, which too had no precedent in human history? We, who asked, and ask ourselves everyday: in what are we better than them? From the millions of our brothers? What have we won? For we could have been among them and with them in the days of fear and in the moments of dying.
And to these recurring questions, there is in our conscience but one answer: we remained alive not to live and await in conditions of slavery and oppression, a new Treblinka. We remained alive, to ensure life, freedom and dignity for us, for our nation, for our children and their children for generations to come. We remained alive so that it wouldn't matter anymore that which happened there and might happen under your rule, the rule of treason, the rule of blood.
Therefore we shall not be frightened, for we have learned and by countless of victims for nothing we have learned - that there is life worse than death, and there is death greater than life…
Suicide
On 21 April 1947, a few hours before their scheduled execution by hanging in the Jerusalem Central Prison in the Russian Compound, now the Museum of the Underground Prisoners, could be carried out, he and his friend and fellow prisoner Moshe Barazani blew themselves up in their cells with an improvised grenade which had been smuggled to them in a hollowed-out oranges. They lit the grenade and then stood embracing each other, with the grenade lodged between them.
Legacy
The story of Feinstein and Barazani became one of the most famous tales in the history of Zionism. The suicide plan was the idea of the Lehi militant who built the bombs. Before carrying out the operation, the Lehi waited for the approval of Irgun commander Menachem Begin, because Feinstein was from the rival group. Menachem Begin was so moved by the deeds of the two men that he requested in his will that he be buried next to them on the Mount of Olives, which he was.
Just before his death, Feinstein gave to British prison guard Thomas Henry Goodwin, whom he and Barazani had nicknamed "the good jailer", a copy of the Bible, inscribed in Hebrew and English, "In the shadow of the gallows, 21.4.47. To the British soldier as you stand guard. Before we go to the gallows, accept this Bible as a memento and remember that we stood in dignity and marched in dignity. It is better to die with a weapon in your hands than to live with hands raised. Meir Feinstein". He then requested a moment of privacy for prayer, which prevented Goodwin from being able to stop the grenade being detonated (saving Goodwin from being injured by the grenade). In 2007, Goodwin's son Dennis donated the Bible to Feinstein's nephew Eliezer, who received it on behalf of the Museum of Underground Prisoners in Jerusalem at a commemorative state ceremony.
Menachem Begin brought up the story during a speech in 1981:
"Our Mizrahim were courageous fighters – already in the underground. Feinstein was from European origins, What's it called? Ashkenazi. Moshe Barazani was a Sephardic Jew from Iraq. In the night, after they were sentenced to death, they were due to be taken to the gallows in the early morning, the Rabbi insisted that he would come to accompany them and they didn't want to harm the Rabbi. They held close to their hearts a hand grenade – they pulled the trigger... Ashkenazi? Iraqi? Jews! Brothers! Fighters!"
References
- "טוראי מאיר פיינשטיין". www.izkor.gov.il.
- ^ כל הדרך לגרדום: ימיו האחרונים של מאיר פיינשטיין [All the way to the gallows: The last days of Meir Feinstein]. www.makorrishon.co.il (in Hebrew). 27 July 2017. Archived from the original on 31 December 2024.
מאיר פיינשטיין נולד וגדל בירושלים. אם שואלים את אתר הזיכרון הרשמי של חללי צה"ל או את ויקיפדיה, תאריך הלידה שלו הוא 5 באוקטובר 1927. לדברי אחיינו, המועד הנכון הוא יולי 1929.
[Meir Feinstein was born and raised in Jerusalem. If you ask the official IDF memorial website or Misplaced Pages, his date of birth is 5 October 1927. According to his nephew, the correct date is July 1929.] - "Two More Palestinian Jews Sentenced to Death; Seven Now Stand in Shadow of Gallows". Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 4 April 1947. (archive published: 20 March 2015)
- "Palestine Military Commander Orders Two More Jews to Hang; Commutes Sentence of Third". Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 18 April 1947. (archive published: 20 March 2015)
- "Feinstein, Meir". Honor Israel's Fallen. Retrieved 19 October 2024.
- Staff, C. I. E. (21 April 2024). "2 Jewish Militants Kill Themselves Before Hanging". CIE. Retrieved 19 October 2024.
- Staff, C. I. E. (21 April 2021). "2 Jewish Militants Kill Themselves Before Hanging". CIE. Retrieved 5 March 2024.
- ^ "אתר ההנצחה לחללי מערכות ישראל".
- Bell, Bowyer J.: Terror out of Zion (1976), p. 182
- "ALMA : Information". www.alma-mahler.at. Retrieved 19 October 2024.
- "Meir Feinstein-A Family Memorial". www.meirfeinstein.org. Retrieved 19 October 2024.
- "Meir Feinstein". daat.ac.il. Retrieved 19 October 2024.
- Yair Sheleg (12 April 2007). "The Good Jailer". Haaretz. Archived from the original on 26 March 2009.
Moshe agreed right away, but since there was an Irgun man with him we had to request their approval, too. We asked the person responsible for Irgun prisoners in the jail, Yehoshua Tamler, what he thought, and he said they needed the consent of the top command. We had to wait a few days, despite fearing that they would be taken to the gallows in the meantime, until approval arrived from the commander of the Irgun, Menachem Begin.
- Sheleg, Yair (7 April 2007). "The good jailer". Haaretz.com.
Moshe agreed right away, but since there was an Irgun man with him we had to request their approval, too. We asked the person responsible for Irgun prisoners in the jail, Yehoshua Tamler, what he thought, and he said they needed the consent of the top command. We had to wait a few days, despite fearing that they would be taken to the gallows in the meantime, until approval arrived from the commander of the Irgun, Menachem Begin.
- ^ 60 Years Later: Feinstein's Bible Returned to Family Begin Center Diary
- 'The good jailer' returns Irgun hero's Bible 60 years later, Jerusalem Post, April 19, 2007
- "Begin Speech 1981". Youtube. 26 January 2016. Archived from the original on 14 December 2021.
| Olei Hagardom | |
|---|---|
- 1927 births
- 1929 births
- 1947 deaths
- 1947 suicides
- Youth suicides
- Ashkenazi Jews in Mandatory Palestine
- British Army personnel of World War II
- Irgun members
- People from Jerusalem
- Royal Engineers soldiers
- Burials at the Jewish cemetery on the Mount of Olives
- Haganah members
- Olei Hagardom
- Suicides in Mandatory Palestine
- Mandatory Palestine military personnel of World War II
- People who died by suicide in prison custody
- People of Belarusian-Jewish descent
- Palestinian amputees
- Palestinian murderers
- Palestinian prisoners sentenced to death
- Prisoners sentenced to death by the British military
- Prisoners who died in British military detention
- People of the Jewish insurgency in Mandatory Palestine