The Thalmann Algorithm (VVAL 18) is a deterministic decompression model originally designed in 1980 to produce a decompression schedule for divers using the US Navy Mk15 rebreather. It was developed by Capt. Edward D. Thalmann, MD, USN, who did research into decompression theory at the Naval Medical Research Institute, Navy Experimental Diving Unit, State University of New York at Buffalo, and Duke University. The algorithm forms the basis for the current US Navy mixed gas and standard air dive tables (from US Navy Diving Manual Revision 6). The decompression model is also referred to as the Linear–Exponential model or the Exponential–Linear model.
History
The Mk15 rebreather supplies a constant partial pressure of oxygen of 0.7 bar (70 kPa) with nitrogen as the inert gas. Prior to 1980 it was operated using schedules from printed tables. It was determined that an algorithm suitable for programming into an underwater decompression monitor (an early dive computer) would offer advantages. This algorithm was initially designated "MK15 (VVAL 18) RTA", a real-time algorithm for use with the Mk15 rebreather.
Description
VVAL 18 is a deterministic model that utilizes the Naval Medical Research Institute Linear Exponential (NMRI LE1 PDA) data set for calculation of decompression schedules. Phase two testing of the US Navy Diving Computer produced an acceptable algorithm with an expected maximum incidence of decompression sickness (DCS) less than 3.5% assuming that occurrence followed the binomial distribution at the 95% confidence level.
The use of simple symmetrical exponential gas kinetics models has shown up the need for a model that would give slower tissue washout. In the early 1980s the US Navy Experimental Diving Unit developed an algorithm using a decompression model with exponential gas absorption as in the usual Haldanian model, but a slower linear release during ascent. The effect of adding linear kinetics to the exponential model is to lengthen the duration of risk accumulation for a given compartment time constant.
The model was originally developed for programming decompression computers for constant oxygen partial pressure closed circuit rebreathers. Initial experimental diving using an exponential-exponential algorithm resulted in an unacceptable incidence of DCS, so a change was made to a model using the linear release model, with a reduction in DCS incidence. The same principles were applied to developing an algorithm and tables for a constant oxygen partial pressure model for Heliox diving
The linear component is active when the tissue pressure exceeds ambient pressure by a given amount specific to the tissue compartment. When the tissue pressure drops below this cross-over criterion the tissue is modelled by exponential kinetics. During gas uptake tissue pressure never exceeds ambient, so it is always modelled by exponential kinetics. This results in a model with the desired asymmetrical characteristics of slower washout than uptake. The linear/exponential transition is smooth. Choice of cross-over pressure determines the slope of the linear region as equal to the slope of the exponential region at the cross-over point.
During the development of these algorithms and tables, it was recognized that a successful algorithm could be used to replace the existing collection of incompatible tables for various air and Nitrox diving modes currently in the US Navy Diving Manual with a set of mutually compatible decompression tables based on a single model, which was proposed by Gerth and Doolette in 2007. This has been done in Revision 6 of the US Navy Diving Manual published in 2008, though some changes were made.
An independent implementation of the EL-Real Time Algorithm was developed by Cochran Consulting, Inc. for the diver-carried Navy Dive Computer under the guidance of E. D. Thalmann.
Physiological interpretation
Computer testing of a theoretical bubble growth model reported by Ball, Himm, Homer and Thalmann produced results which led to the interpretation of the three compartments used in the probabilistic LE model, with fast (1.5min), intermediate (51 min) and slow (488min) time constants, of which only the intermediate compartment uses the linear kinetics modification during decompression, as possibly not representing distinct anatomically identifiable tissues, but three different kinetic processes which relate to different elements of DCS risk.
They conclude that bubble evolution may not be sufficient to explain all aspects of DCS risk, and the relationship between gas phase dynamics and tissue injury requires further investigation.
References
- Thalmann, Edward D; Buckingham, IPB; Spaur, WH (1980). "Testing of decompression algorithms for use in the U.S. Navy underwater decompression computer (Phase I)". Navy Experimental Diving Unit Research Report. 11–80. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Staff (September 2008). "VVAL-18M: New algorithm on deck for Navy divers". Diver Magazine. 33 (7). Archived from the original on July 10, 2011.
- ^ Thalmann 1985a, p. 6
- Thalmann, Edward D (2003). "Suitability of the USN MK15(VVAL18) Decompression Algorithm for Air Diving". Navy Experimental Diving Unit Research Report. 03–12. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Parker et al. 1992, p. 1
- Thalmann 1984, abstract
- Huggins 1992, chpt. 4 page 13
- Parker et al. 1992, p. 3
- Gerth & Doolette 2007, p. 1
- Gerth & Doolette 2007, p. 2
- Ball 1995, p. 272
- Ball 1995, p. 273
Sources
- Thalmann, E. D. (1983). "Computer algorithms used in computing the MK15/16 constant 0.7 ATA oxygen partial pressure decompression tables". Navy Exp. Diving Unit Res. Report. 1–83. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Thalmann, E. D. (1984). "Phase II testing of decompression algorithms for use in the U.S. Navy underwater decompression computer". Navy Exp. Diving Unit Res. Report. 1–84. Archived from the original on January 13, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Thalmann, E. D. (1985a). "Development of a Decompression Algorithm for Constant Oxygen Partial Pressure in Helium Diving" (PDF). Navy Exp. Diving Unit Res. Report. 1–85. Retrieved 13 July 2023.
- Thalmann, E. D. (1985b). "Air-N202 Decompression Computer Algorithm Development" (PDF). Navy Exp. Diving Unit Res. Report. 8–85. Retrieved 13 July 2023.
- Weathersby, P. K.; S.S. Survanshi; R.Y. Nishi; E.D. Thalmann (1992). "Statistically based decompression tables VII: Selection and treatment of primary air and N2O2 data". Joint Report: Naval Submarine Medical Research Laboratory and Naval Medical Research Institute. NSMRL 1182 and NMRI 92-85. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Parker, E. C.; Survanshi, S.S.; Weathersby, P.K.; Thalmann, E.D. (1992). "Statistically Based Decompression Tables VIII: Linear Exponential Kinetics". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 92–73. Archived from the original on January 13, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Huggins, Karl E. (1992). "Dynamics of decompression workshop". Course Taught at the University of Michigan. Archived from the original on 15 April 2013. Retrieved 10 January 2012.
- Ball, R.; Himm, J.; Homer, L.D.; Thalmann, E.D. (1994). "A Model of Bubble Evolution During Decompression Based on a Monte Carlo Simulation of Inert Gas Diffusion". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 94–36.
- Ball, R.; Himm, J.; Homer, L.D.; Thalmann, E.D (1995). "Does the time course of bubble evolution explain decompression sickness risk?". Undersea and Hyperbaric Medicine. 22 (3): 263–280. ISSN 1066-2936. PMID 7580767. Archived from the original on 11 August 2011. Retrieved 14 March 2013.
- Parker, E.C.; Survanshi, S.S.; Thalmann, E.D.; Weathersby, P.K. (1996). "Statistically based decompression tables IX: probabilistic models of the role of oxygen in human decompression sickness". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 96–05. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Survanshi, S.S.; Weathersby, P.K.; Thalmann, E.D. (1996). "Statistically based decompression tables X: Real-time decompression algorithm using a probabilistic model". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 96–06. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Thalmann, E. D.; P. C. Kelleher; S. S. Survanshi; E. C. Parker; P. K. Weathersby (1999). "Statistically Based Decompression Tables XI: Manned Validation of the LE Probabilistic Model for Air and Nitrogen-Oxygen Diving". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 99–01. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Survanshi, S. S.; E. C. Parker; E. D. Thalmann; P. K. Weathersby (1997). "Statistically based decompression tables XII: Volume I. Repetitive decompression tables for air and constant 0.7 ata PO2 in N2 using a probabilistic model". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 97–36.
- Survanshi, S. S.; E. C. Parker; E. D. Thalmann; P. K. Weathersby (1997). "Statistically based decompression tables XII: Volume II. Repetitive dive tables: Air". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 97–36.
- Survanshi, S. S.; E. C. Parker; E. D. Thalmann; P. K. Weathersby (1997). "Statistically based decompression tables XII: Volume III. Exceptional exposure tables: Air". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 97–36.
- Survanshi, S. S.; E. C. Parker; E. D. Thalmann; P. K. Weathersby (1997). "Statistically based decompression tables XII: Volume IV. Repetitive dive tables: 0.7 ATA PO2 in N2". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 97–36.
- Survanshi, S. S.; E. C. Parker; E. D. Thalmann; P. K. Weathersby (1997). "Statistically based decompression tables XII: Volume V. Exceptional exposure tables: 0.7 ATA PO2 in N2". Naval Medical Research Institute Report. 97–36.
- Butler, F. K.; D. G. Southerland (2001). "The U.S. Navy decompression computer". Undersea Hyperb. Med. 28 (4): 213–28. ISSN 1066-2936. OCLC 26915585. PMID 12153150. Archived from the original on August 11, 2011. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Gault, K. A. (2003). "Potential Benefits of Navy Dive Computer Use in Ships Husbandry Diving: Analysis of Dives Conducted on the USS RONALD REAGAN (CVN-76)". Navy Exp. Diving Unit Res. Report. 06–04. Archived from the original on April 16, 2013. Retrieved 2008-03-16.
- Gerth, Wayne A.; Doolette, David J. (2007). "VVal-18 and VVal-18M Thalmann Algorithm – Air Decompression Tables and Procedures". Navy Experimental Diving Unit, TA 01-07, NEDU TR 07-09. Archived from the original on 12 May 2013. Retrieved 27 January 2012.
