Misplaced Pages

Classification of Southeast Asian languages

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
(Redirected from Classification schemes for Southeast Asian languages) Overview of Southeast Asian languages

There have been various classification schemes for Southeast Asian languages (see the articles for the respective language families).

Language families

The five established major language families are:

Isolates and small families

A number of language groups in Arunachal Pradesh traditionally considered to be Sino-Tibetan (Tibeto-Burman) may in fact constitute independent language families or isolates (Roger Blench 2011). (See Language isolates and independent language families in Arunachal.)

Macrofamilies

The Dené–Caucasian proposal

Several macrofamily schemes have been proposed for linking multiple language families of Southeast Asia. None of these proposals have been accepted by mainstream comparative linguistics, though research into higher-level relationships among these languages has gained some renewed scholarly interest over the last three decades; the various hypotheses are still under investigation, and the validity of each has yet to be resolved.

  • Austro-Tai links the Austronesian and Kra–Dai languages. Several linguists, including Laurent Sagart, Stanley Starosta, Weera Ostapirat and Lawrence Reid, accept or theorize a close relationship between these families, but the specifics of the relationship remain unclear. Multiple models of the internal branching of Austro-Tai have been put forward, and Austro-Tai has been incorporated as a subgroup within some larger macrofamily schemes, e.g. in Starosta's East Asian as well as in Sagart's model of Austronesian (see below), both of which regard Kra–Dai as a subfamily within Austronesian. A few versions of Austro-Tai have included Japonic and/or the isolate Ainu as well, though these have not been met with as much acceptance.
  • Miao–Dai (Kosaka 2002) is a hypothesis for a family including Miao–Yao (Hmong–Mien) and Kra–Dai.
  • Sino-Austronesian (Sagart 2004, 2005) links Austro-Tai (Austronesian) with Sino-Tibetan (Tibeto-Burman).
  • Austric links all of the major language families of Southeast Asia apart from Sino-Tibetan. Several variants of the Austric hypothesis have been proposed since it took shape with Paul K. Benedict's proposal (1942). Some of these also incorporate Japonic, Korean and/or Ainu. One version called the "Greater Austric" hypothesis (Bengtson 1996) includes Ainu as well as Nihali, a language isolate of India.
  • The "Proto-Asian hypothesis" or "Austro-Asian" (Larish 2006) argues for lexical evidence of relationship among all of the languages typically included in Austric as well as Japanese–Korean and Sino-Tibetan.
  • East Asian (Starosta 2005) covers all of these families (except Japonic, Koreanic, Ainu and Nihali) as well as Sino-Tibetan. It posits Austronesian (including Kra–Dai) as the most divergent branch, coordinate with a primary branch Sino-Tibetan–Yangzian which links Sino-Tibetan with a clade called Yangzian (or Yangtzean), named for the Yangtze river, which includes Austroasiatic and Hmong–Mien.
  • In a different direction, the Dené–Caucasian or Sino-Caucasian hypothesis links Sino-Tibetan to Yeniseian and North Caucasian, the proposal later expanded to include Na-Dene, Burushaski and Basque. On the basis of lexicostatistics, Sergei Starostin additionally hypothesized an even larger Dené–Daic macrofamily which incorporates both Dené–Caucasian and Austric as primary branches.

Genetic similarities between the peoples of East and Southeast Asia have led some scholars such as George van Driem to speculate about "Haplogroup O languages".

Proto-languages

Main article: List of proto-languages

Comparison

The following table compares the phonemic inventories of various recently reconstructed proto-languages of Southeast Asia.

Comparison of Proto-languages
Proto-language Proto-Kra Proto-Tai Proto-Hlai Proto-S. Kra–Dai Proto-Austronesian Proto-Tibeto-Burman Proto-Mon–Khmer
Source Ostapirat (2000) Pittayaporn (2009) Norquest (2007) Norquest (2007) Blust (2009) Matisoff (2003) Shorto (2006)
Consonants 32 33–36 32 28–29 25 23 21
Vowels 6 7 4–5 5–7 4 5–6 7
Diphthongs 4 5 1+ 4 2+ 3
Consonantal finals 7 10–11 6
Vowel length
contrast
No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes

Maps of language families

See also

References

  1. Blench, Roger. 2015. The Mijiic languages: distribution, dialects, wordlist and classification. m.s.
  2. van Driem, George (2008). "To which language family does Chinese belong, or what's in a name?" (PDF). In Sanchez-Mazas, Alicia; Blench, Roger; Ross, Malcolm D.; Peiros, Ilia and Marie Lin [zh], Eds. Past Human Migrations in East Asia: Matching Archaeology, Linguistics and Genetics. London and New York: Routledge: 219–253.
  3. Reid, Lawrence A. (2006). "Austro-Tai Hypotheses". pp. 609–610 in Keith Brown (editor in chief), The Encyclopedia of Language and Linguistics, 2nd edition.
  4. Kosaka, Ryuichi (2002). "On the affiliation of Miao-Yao and Kadai: Can we posit the Miao-Dai family?" (PDF). Mon-Khmer Studies. 32: 71–100.
  5. Bengtson, John (2010). "The "Greater Austric" Hypothesis" (PDF).
  6. Larish, Michael D. 2006. Possible Proto-Asian Archaic Residue and the Statigraphy of Diffusional Cumulation in Austro-Asian Languages. Paper presented at the Tenth International Conference on Austronesian Linguistics, 17–20 January 2006, Puerto Princesa City, Palawan, Philippines.
  7. Pittayaporn, Pittayawat. 2009. The Phonology of Proto-Tai. Ph.D. dissertation. Department of Linguistics, Cornell University.
  8. ^ Norquest, Peter K. 2007. A Phonological Reconstruction of Proto-Hlai. Ph.D. dissertation. Tucson: Department of Anthropology, University of Arizona.
  9. Blust, Robert A. 2009. The Austronesian Languages. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University. ISBN 0-85883-602-5, ISBN 978-0-85883-602-0.
  10. Matisoff, James. 2003. Handbook of Proto-Tibeto-Burman: System and Philosophy of Sino-Tibetan Reconstruction. University of California publications in linguistics, v. 135. Berkeley: University of California Press.
  11. Shorto, Harry L., et al. 2006. A Mon–Khmer Comparative Dictionary. Canberra: Australian National University. Pacific Linguistics. ISBN 0-85883-570-3.

Further reading

External links

Language families of Eurasia
Europe
West Asia
Caucasus
South Asia
East Asia
Indian Ocean rim
North Asia
"Paleosiberian"
Other North Asia
Proposed groupings
Arunachal
East and Southeast Asia
Substrata
  • Families in italics have no living members.
  • Families with more than 30 languages are in bold.
Links to related articles
Austroasiatic languages
Bahnaric
North
West
Central
South
Others
Katuic
West
Katu
Others
Vietic
Viet-Muong
Chut
Kri
Phong–Liha
Others
Khmuic
Phay-Pram
Others
Pearic
Western
(Chong)
Central
Southern
Others
Khasi–
Palaungic
Khasic
Khasi-Pnar-Lyngngam
Others
Palaungic
West
East
Angkuic
Waic
Bit-Khang
Lamet
Others
Munda
North
Kherwarian
Mundaric
Santalic
South
Sora-Gorum
Gutob-Remo
Others
Nicobarese
Chaura-Teresa
Central
Southern
Aslian
Jahaic (Northern)
Senoic (Central)
Semelaic (Southern)
Others
Others
Proto-
languages
Kra–Dai languages
Kra
Gelao
Kam–Sui
Biao
Lakkia
Hlai
Jiamao
BeJizhao
Tai
(Zhuang, etc.)
Northern
Central
Southwestern
(Thai)
Northwestern
Lao–Phutai
Chiang Saen
Southern
(other)
(mixed)
(mixed origins)
proposed groupings
Proto-languages
Italics indicate extinct languages
Hmong–Mien languages
Hmongic
Bahengic
Sheic
West Hmongic
Bu–Nao
Xong
Hmuic
Mienic
Mixed languages
(Proto-languages)
Arunachal languages
Greater Siangic
Tani
Eastern
Western
Digaro (Northern Mishmi)
Siangic
Hrusish
Kho-Bwa
Puroik
Bugun
Western
Miju–Meyor
Sino-Tibetan branches
Western Himalayas (Himachal,
Uttarakhand, Nepal, Sikkim)
Greater Magaric
Map of Sino-Tibetan languages
Eastern Himalayas
(Tibet, Bhutan, Arunachal)
Myanmar and Indo-
Burmese border
"Naga"
Sal
East and Southeast Asia
Burmo-Qiangic
Dubious (possible
isolates) (Arunachal)
Greater Siangic
Proposed groupings
Proto-languages
Italics indicates single languages that are also considered to be separate branches.
Bodic (Tibeto-Kanauri) languages
West Himalayish
(Kanauric)
Western
Kinnauric
Lahaulic
Eastern
Central
Almora
Bodish
Tibetic
Central Tibetan
Amdo
Kham (Eastern)
Southern
Western
Ladakhi–Balti (Western Archaic)
Lahuli–Spiti (Western Innovative)
Sherpa-Jirel
Kyirong–Kagate
Tshangla-East Bodish
Tshangla
East Bodish
Basum
Tamangic
TGTM
Ghale
Kaike
Greater Magaric languages
Magaric
Chepangic
Raji-Raute
Dura
Kiranti languages
Limbu
Western
Central
Eastern
Dhimalish
see also: Mahakiranti languages
Tani languages
Eastern
Western
Kuki-Chin–Naga languages
Kuki-Chin
Southern Naga
(Northwestern)
Northern
Central
Maraic
Khomic
Southern
Naga
Ao (Central Naga)
Angami–Pochuri
Tangkhulic
Zemeic (Western Naga)
Meitei
Karbic
Sal (Brahmaputran) languages
Boro–Garo
Boroic
Garo
Kochic
Deori
Konyak
(Northern Naga)
Konyak
Tangsa–Nocte
Jingpho–Luish
Jingpho
Luish (Asakian)
Karenic languages
Northern
Central
Kayah
Kayan
Kayaw
Western Bwe
Southern
S'gaw
Pwo
Proto-language
Na-Qiangic languages
Naic
Namuyi
Shixing
Naish
Ersuic
Qiangic
Qiang
Gyalrongic
East Gyalrongic
West Gyalrongic
Chamdo
Choyo
Muya
Pumi
Zhaba
Cross (†) and italics indicate extinct languages.
Lolo-Burmese languages
Mondzish
Kathu
Nuclear Mondzish
Loloish
(Yi)
(Ngwi)
Southern Loloish
(Southern Ngwi)
(Hanoish)
Hanoid
Akha
Hani
Haoni
Bisoid
Siloid
Bi-Ka
Mpi
Jino
Central Loloish
(Central Ngwi)
Lawoish
Lahoish
Nusoish
Lisoish
Laloid
Taloid
Kazhuoish
  • Katso
  • Samu
  • Sanie
  • Sadu
  • Meuma
  • Nisoish
    Northern Loloish
    (Northern Ngwi)
    (Nisoid)
    Nosoid
    Nasoid
    Southeastern Loloish
    (Southeastern Ngwi)
    (Axi-Puoid)
    Nisu
    Sani–Azha
    Highland Phula
    Riverine Phula
    others
    Burmish
    Northern
    High Northern
    Hpon
    Mid Northern
    Southern
    Intha-Danu
    Nuclear Southern
    Pai-lang
    (Proto-languages)
    • Italics indicate extinct languages.
    Chinese language
    Sinitic languages
    Major groups
    Mandarin
    Northeastern
    Beijing
    Jilu
    Jiaoliao
    Central Plains
    Southwestern
    Jianghuai
    Lanyin
    Other
    Jin
    Wu
    Taihu
    Taizhou Wu
    Oujiang
    Wuzhou
    Chu–Qu
    Xuanzhou
    Huizhou
    Gan
    Xiang
    Min
    Eastern
    Houguan
    Fu–Ning
    Other
    Southern
    Hokkien
    Teochew
    Zhongshan
    Other
    Other
    Hakka
    Yue
    Yuehai
    Siyi
    Other
    Pinghua
    Unclassified
    Standard
    forms
    Phonology
    Grammar
    Idioms
    Input
    History
    Literary
    forms
    Official
    Scripts
    Logographic
    Script styles
  • Oracle bone
  • Bronze
  • Seal
  • Clerical
  • Semi-cursive
  • Cursive
  • Braille
  • Cantonese
  • Mainland Chinese
  • Taiwanese
  • Two-cell
  • Phonetic
    List of varieties of Chinese
    Austronesian languages
    Formosan
    Malayo-Polynesian
    Western
    Philippine
    Greater Barito*
    Greater North Borneo*
    Celebic
    South Sulawesi
    Central
    Eastern
    SHWNG
    Oceanic
    Western
    Southern
    • * indicates proposed status
    • ? indicates classification dispute
    • † indicates extinct status
    Formosan languages
    East
    Ami
    Kavalanic
    Sirayaic
    Northern
    Atayalic
    Northwest
    Tsouic
    Others
    • Bold indicates languages with more than 1 million speakers
    • ? indicates classification dispute
    • † indicates extinct status
    Micronesian languages
    Nauruan
    Nuclear
    Micronesian
    Chuukic–
    Pohnpeic
    Chuukic
    Pohnpeic
    • * indicates proposed status
    • ? indicates classification dispute
    • † indicates extinct status
    Central Pacific languages
    West
    East
    Polynesian
    Nuclear
    Polynesian
    Samoic
    Eastern
    Futunic
    Tongic
    • * indicates proposed status
    • ? indicates classification dispute
    • † indicates extinct status
    Languages of Asia
    Sovereign states
    States with
    limited recognition
    Dependencies and
    other territories
    Categories: